High CourtsSingle Bench(2016) 11 P&H CK 0093

Vinod vs Pardeep

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 8 November 2016 · Citation: (2016) 4 LawHerald 3558

HON’BLE JUDGES
Mr. Surinder Gupta, J.
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
FAO No. 2471 of 2016 (O&M)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

26 paragraphs · 558 words

Surinder Gupta, J. - This is appeal against award dated 29.01.2016 passed by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Narnaul (later referred to as "the Tribunal") allowing compensation of Rs. 3,71,200/- to claimant-Pardeep for the injuries suffered by him in a motor vehicle accident with Bolero vehicle bearing registration no. HR-35-D-5596 (later referred to as "the offending vehicle").

2.

Compensation of Rs. 3,71,200/- was computed as follows:-

Sr.No.

Heads

Calculation

(i)

Hospital and medicines charges

Rs. 336197

(ii)

Compensation towards 5% temporary disability

Rs. 10000

(iii)

Pain and suffering, special diet, loss of income and attendant charges

Rs. 25000

Total

Rs. 371197 (rounded off to Rs. 371200)

3.

The offending vehicle was not insured, as such, appellants were held liable to pay compensation amount jointly and severally.

4.

Learned counsel for appellants has assailed the award on two counts. Firstly, that the hospital bill produced by claimant is highly inflated; and secondly, the Tribunal has allowed compensation of Rs. 10,000/- towards temporary disability of 5% only, which is also inflated. He has argued that claimant suffered only three injuries and there is no evidence that he was referred from Government Hospital, Narnaul to PGIMS, Rohtak. No doctor from Medanta Hospital was examined by claimant to prove as to what type of treatment was given to him to justify bill of Rs. 3,12,707.87 ps. towards hospital expenses.

5.

Claimant examined Dr. Jagmohan Yadav, Medical Officer, Government Hospital, Narnaul as PW-1, who deposed that claimant was brought to Government Hospital on 15.10.2014 at 03.00 p.m. and on examination he found following injuries on his person:-

(i) A (5x3 cm) lacerated wound on left leg. On examination crepts and active bleed present.

(ii) A (3x2 cm) red bruise on right elbow. On examination tenderness present.

(iii) A (1x5 cm) lacerated wound on right temporal region. On examination no tenderness.

6.

While appearing as PW-2 Pankaj has stated that after the accident claimant was taken to Civil Hospital, Narnaul from where he was referred to PGIMS Rohtak but was taken to Medanta Hospital, Gurgaon for treatment, where he remained admitted upto 19.11.2014. Claimant also remained admitted in Pooja Hospital, Narnaul from 24.11.2014 to 28.11.2014, where he was operated and the hospital charged bill of Rs. 20,830/- from him, which has been proved by examining PW-4 Girdhari Sharma, Record Keeper, Pooja Hospital, Narnaul. Hospital bill of Medanta Hospital, Gurgaon amounting to Rs. 3,12,707.87 ps. was proved by PW-5 Ramesh Kumar, Billing Executive, Medanta Hospital, Gurgaon. It is not proved on file that Medanta Hospital, Gurgaon has prepared a false bill to help the claimant. All the details of treatment and the charges find mention in the medical bill (Ex. PW-5/A). Mere assertion of appellants that this is a fake bill, carries no weight.

7.

The Tribunal has been very moderate while allowing total amount of compensation. Besides hospital and medicines expenses, Tribunal allowed only a sum of Rs. 35,000/- for other conventional heads despite the fact that claimant was hospitalized twice. He was operated in Medanta Hospital as well as in Pooja Hospital. Amount of Rs. 10,000/- awarded as compensation towards temporary disability of 5% cannot be termed as inflated amount of compensation.

8.

In view of my above discussion, I find no legal or factual infirmity in the award calling for any interference.

9.

This appeal has no merit and the same is dismissed.