High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 11 KL CK 1863

Venugopalan Nair vs VK Sreenivasan

High Court Of Kerala, Ernakulam · Decided on 13 November 2026

CASE NUMBER
RCREV. NO. 246 OF 2026

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

10 paragraphs · 592 words

Sathish Ninan, J.

The concurrent orders of eviction passed under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, (for short “the Act”) is under challenge by the tenant.

2.

Eviction was sought for the occupation of the landlord's daughter, to start a dialysis clinic in the petition schedule building. The landlord was examined as PW1. His daughter, for whom eviction is sought, was examined as PW4. She is a Doctor by profession. Though she is presently at United Kingdom, she has sworn to of her intention to come down to the native place and to establish the proposed dialysis clinic.

3.

The Courts, on appreciation of the evidence of PWs.1 and 4 found the claim to be bonafide. It could not be established before us that the appreciation of evidence by the Authorities was perverse or that any material evidence which would have titled the conclusion, was ignored.

4.

The argument of the learned counsel for the revision petitioner is that, there is no plea in the Rent Control Petition that the daughter is dependent on the landlord for the building. The absence of such plea is fatal, is the contention.

5.

In the Rent Control Petition, at paragraphs 8 and 10 it has been pleaded thus:-

“ഹർജജികക്കാരനന്റെ മകൾ അലലക്കാപ്പതജി ലഡക്കാകകക്ടറക്കായ ശശൈലജ ശശൈശ്രീനക്കാഥജിനക സസ്വന്തമക്കായജി കജിനജികക തതുക്ടങതുന്നതജിലലയകകക ഹർജജിപ്പടജികകക്ടമതുറജികൾ അതത്യന്തന്തം ഉത്തമവജിശൈസ്വക്കാസപപൂർവന്തം ആവശൈത്യമക്കായജി തശ്രീർന്നജിടട്ടുള്ളതക്കാണക . കജിനജികക തതുക്ടങതുന്നതജിലലയകകക സസൗകരത്യശപദമക്കായ മറക ഒഴജിഞ്ഞ കക്ടമതുറജികൾ ഹർജജികക്കാരനക ശകവശൈമതുള്ളതല . കപൂക്ടക്കാനത എതതൃഹർജജികക്കാരനന്റെ ശകവശൈമജിരജികതുന്ന ഹർജജിപ്പടജിക കക്ടമതുറജികളക്കാണക കജിനജികക തതുക്ടങതുന്നതജിനക ഏറവതുന്തം അഭജികക്കാമത്യമക്കായജിടട്ടുള്ളതക . …

ഹർജജിപ്പടജിക കക്ടമതുറജികൾ ഹർജജികക്കാരനന്റെ മകൾ അലലക്കാപ്പതജി ലഡക്കാകകക്ടറക്കായ ശശൈലജ ശശൈശ്രീനക്കാഥജിനക സസ്വന്തമക്കായജി കജിനജികക തതുക്ടങതുന്നതജിലലയകകക ഹർജജിപ്പടജിക കക്ടമതുറജികൾ അതത്യന്തന്തം ഉത്തമവജിശൈസ്വക്കാസപപൂർവന്തം ആവശൈത്യമക്കായജിതശ്രീർന്നജിടട്ടുള്ളതക്കാണക .” While the word “dependent” has not been used, there are sufficient indications regarding the same. We find that, the question of “dependency” was urged before the Rent Control Court as well as the Appellate Authority and was considered elaborately by the authorities. The Authorities noted that there is no case for the respondent that PW4 has a building of her own. The contention has been urged and considered. It could not be demonstrated before us that any prejudice has resulted to the tenant consequent to the absence of a specific plea in the Rent Control Petition with regard to the dependency. We find that the argument has no merit.

6.

The learned counsel for the revision petitioner argued that there were vacant rooms in the possession of the landlord and hence the first proviso to Section 11(3) is attracted. It is to be noted that, it is the definite case of the landlord that when the Rent Control petition was filed there was no vacant room available with him. A commission was taken out by him. The Commissioner's reports reveal that there were no vacant rooms available with the landlord. The landlord as PW1 has deposed that after the filing of the petition two rooms fell vacant which were subsequently let out. The Authorities rightly found that the first proviso to Section 11(3) is not attracted.

There is no reason to entertain the revision petition and the same is accordingly dismissed. However, we grant three months time for the revision petitioner-tenant to vacate the petition schedule building. This shall be subject to the condition that the tenant files an affidavit within a period of two weeks from today, undertaking to unconditionally surrender the premises within a period of three months, and pays the monthly rent without default. In case of failure to comply with any of the conditions as above, the revision petitioner will lose the benefit granted under this judgment and shall be liable to be evicted forthwith.