High CourtsSINGLE BENCH(2017) 08 KL CK 0011

VALIYACHALIL GOPALAN vs THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 11 August 2017

HON’BLE JUDGES
P.Ubaid
CASE NUMBER
1614 of 2004 (C)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

24 paragraphs · 1,448 words
1.

The appellant herein is the 1st accused in S.C No.197/2002 of the Court of Session, Kasaragod. He and the 2nd accused faced trial in the court below under Section 55 (a) of the Kerala Abkari Act ("the Act" for short) on the allegation that at about 00.30 hrs on 12.12.2000, at the premises of the Cheruvathur Railway Station, they were found carrying huge quantity of Karnataka arrack contained in 300 packets each. The offence was detected by the Sub Inspector of Police, Chandera on the basis of secret reliable information. The Police version is that on seeing the Police party, the two accused ran off and escaped by abandoning the arrack packets. Though the Police party chased them, they could not be caught. The huge quantity of arrack contained in 600 packets was seized as per a mahazar, and on the basis of the said seizure, a crime was registered against the two accused. The Sub Inspector of Police, Neeleswaram investigated the case and the Sub Inspector of Police, Chandera submitted final report in court. On

committal, the case came up before the Court of Session, from where it was made over to the learned Additional Sessions Judge (Adhoc) I, Kasaragod for trial and disposal.

2.

The two accused appeared before the trial court and pleaded not guilty to the charge framed against them.

The prosecution examined eight witnesses and proved Exts.P1 to P9 documents in the trial court. The MO1 and MO2 properties were also identified during trial. The arrack packets identified as MO2 series in court are 607 in number, whereas, the prosecution case is that 600 packets of arrack were seized. There is no explanation how 607 packets of arrack were happened to be produced and identified during trial.

3.

When examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C, both the accused denied the incriminating circumstances and projected a defence that they had not possessed or carried any quantity or any packet of arrack, and that they have nothing to do with the packets of arrack seized by the Police in this case. The accused did not adduce any evidence in defence.

4.

On an appreciation of the evidence, the trial court found both the accused guilty. On conviction, they were sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year each and to pay a fine of 1 lakh each by judgment dated

31.8.2004. Aggrieved by the judgment of conviction, the 1st accused has come up in appeal. It is not known whether the 2nd accused has preferred appeal against the conviction.

5.

When this appeal came up for hearing, I noticed, on a perusal of the entire materials that there are some serious infirmities in this case, the benefit of which must go to the accused. Even according to the prosecution, the two persons, who were found carrying huge quantity of arrack in packets, ran off and escaped on seeing the Police party, after abandoning the arrack packets. The seizure mahazar or the F.I.R will not show that the Sub Inspector or any member of his party had seen the accused face to face or that they had noticed anything or any identification feature to identify the persons later. During trial, the Sub Inspector stated that he had prior acquaintance with the accused. But he does not explain how he had such prior acquaintance

with the two accused. PW7 is the Sub Inspector, who detected the offence. PW2 is the Police Constable who assisted the Sub Inspector in the process of detection. PW4 and PW5 examined as independent witnesses turned hostile.

PW1 is the Sub Inspector, who initially investigated the case, but effective investigation was made later by PW8, the Sub Inspector of another Police Station. PW3 is the Village Officer who prepared the Ext.P2 scene plan.

6.

The evidence given by PW7 and PW2 will not convince the court as to how exactly they could identify the persons who ran off and escaped from the spot of detection in the night. On an examination of the evidence given by the Sub Inspector, it would appear that he saw the two persons from a distance while standing at the Cheruvathur railway station, whereas during cross-examination, he stated that he and his team members concealed themselves behind the bush at the railway station premises. A perusal of the mahazar will show that the name and other details of the persons who ran off and escaped were given by some witnesses. No such independent witness was cited for

proving the details. PW7 would say that he arrested the two accused later and produced them in court. He does not explain how he identified the persons for arrest. I find that there is no satisfactory evidence in this case to prove that the two accused are the persons who ran off and escaped on seeing the Police party.

7.

The detection in this case was made on 12.12.2000, where as the properties were produced in court only on 15.12.2000. PW7 or PW8 has no explanation for the delay in producing the properties in court. There is no evidence to show that the properties were in the safe custody of PW7 or PW8 till produced in court on 15.12.2000.

In such a circumstance, the possibility of tampering with the properties cannot be ruled out. When the prosecution is consistent that only 600 packets of arrack were seized, 607 packets were produced in court. It is not known from where the Police got seven packets, or who must be responsible or liable for the possession of those 7 packets. It appears that the trial court also did not notice this aspect.

8.

Ext.P7 is the copy of the forwarding note in this

case. It does not contain the copy of the specimen seal affixed on the samples. There is seal in the covering letter addressed to the court. This Court has settled that in cases like this, the specimen of the seal must be affixed on the copy of the forwarding note, and in the absence of such specimen, the accused cannot be connected with the property analysed at the laboratory. This is also an infirmity in the prosecution case.

9.

There is yet another very serious infirmity in this

case. The detection was made by the Sub Inspector of Police, Chandera, but effective investigation was made by the Sub Inspector of Police, Neeleswram as authorised by the Circle Inspector of Police, Neeleswaram. PW8 is the Sub Inspector who investigated the case. Initial investigation was made by PW1.

10.

This Court has consistently held in so many decisions that only the Abkari Officials specifically authorised and appointed by the Government under Section 4 of the Act can discharge the various functions under the Act including investigation. In terms of Section 4 of the Act,

the Government of Kerala issued a notification in 1967 as SR.O 234/1967 by which various powers were conferred on different categories of Excise Officials of the regular Excise Wing function-wise and territory-wise. Excise Officials belonging to one territory or territorial jurisdiction cannot exercise the functions under the Act beyond the territorial limits prescribed. Of course, there is a proviso to the Government Order that the limits of territory shall not apply in the case of detection made under Section 31 or 34 of the

Act. But there is no such proviso authorising investigation by officials beyond territorial limits. On this aspect, this Court has settled the position that in a case where an investigation is made by an incompetent person or a person beyond his territorial limits, the whole prosecution will have to be treated as nonest. In this case, PW8 had no authority to conduct investigation in a crime of the Chandera Police Station. He cannot claim authority on the ground of the authorisation made by the superior officer. The superior officers cannot assume the role of the Government and authorise the subordinates to discharge functions under the

Act. Only the Government can make such authorisation, and only those officers who are specifically authorised by the Government can discharge the functions. I find that investigation was made by an incompetent Police officer and on this legal infirmity, the accused is entitled for acquittal.

In the result, this appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentence against the appellant (1st accused) in S.C No.197/2002 of the court below will stand set aside on the finding that the appellant is not guilty of the offence under Section 55(a) of the Kerala Abkari Act, and accordingly he is acquitted of the said offence in appeal under Section 386(b)

(i) of the Cr.P.C . The appellant is released from prosecution, and the bail bond, if any, executed by him will stand discharged.