AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI, J.(ORAL)
In the present petition, the challenge is to the order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal dated 23.04.2026 in OA No.060/528/2022 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Tribunal’), by which the reversion order passed against the respondent 4 days before his superannuation, has been set aside on the ground that the same was passed without issuing any show cause notice thereby violating the rules of the principles of natural justice.
It may be noticed that the respondent herein was appointed as a Scientific Officer-B in the pay-scale of Rs.2000-3500 w.e.f. 20.04.1988 at National Informatics Center, Bhiwani. He was subsequently promoted while working as Scientific Officer-B w.e.f. 01.01.1992 in the pay-scale of Rs.2200-4000 under the then prevailing recruitment Rules i.e. prior to the introduction of the Flexible Complementing Scheme (FCS). In the year 1998, the respondent was promoted to the post of Scientific Officer-C in the pay-scale of Rs.10000-15200. The respondent continued working on the said post and subsequently, department of Personnel and Training introduced the Flexible Complementing Scheme (FCS) for Scientific Department on dated 09.11.1998 making scientists eligible for promotions upon completion of prescribed eligible residency period and in terms of (FCS) the respondent was assessed and promoted to the post of Scientific Officer-D in the pay-scale of Rs.12000-16500 w.e.f. 20.09.2004.
Thereafter, the respondent department issued a new personnel policy for Group ‘‘A’ S & T Officers vide dated 19.09.2016. The policy prescribed eligibility conditions for respondents to Scientist-E.
Thereafter, the respondent was found prima facie eligible and further promoted as Scientific Officer-E, vide notification dated 29.03.2017. It may be noticed that said promotion was granted with retrospective effect w.e.f. 29.10.2012.
The respondent continued working on the post of Scientific Officer-E satisfactorily without any adverse remarks or complaints. However, shortly before his superannuation scheduled on 31.05.2022, suddenly without giving any show cause notice, an order was passed on 27.05.2022 i.e. 4 days before the date of superannuation, cancelling the promotion of the respondent to the post of Scientific Officer-E so as to direct the respondent to be reverted to the post of Scientific Officer-D with lesser pay-scale. Such reversion order passed by the petitioner was made the subject matter before the Tribunal and the Tribunal by detailed judgment dated 23.04.2026 set aside the said reversion order not only on the ground of the violation of the principles of natural justice but held that the reasons given for reversion that only three promotions can be given to an employee and thereafter, only the ACP benefit can be granted, was not found to be in accordance with the policy guidelines issued on 19.09.2016 qua the eligibility conditions for promotion to the post of Scientist Officer-E, which were made the basis of passing the order of reversion dated 27.05.2022. The said order dated 23.04.2026 passed by the Tribunal in the present petition is under challenge.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argues that though, the promotion qua the post of Scientist Officer-E was withdrawn on 27.05.2022 but, the same was only done to rectify a mistake which came into being while granting the promotion to the respondent to the post of Scientific Officer-E in the year 2017, w.e.f. the year 2012. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that when there is a rectification of a mistake, even if the same incurs reversion to a lower pay-scale, no show cause notice was required to be given. Hence, the order passed by the Tribunal is incorrect.
We have heard learned counsel for the petitioner and have gone through the record with his able assistance.
From the facts depicted hereinbefore, it is clear that the respondent worked on the post of Scientific Officer-E with retrospective effect from 29.10.2012 onwards actually till 27.05.2022 i.e. upto 4 days before his date of superannuation. Further, such promotion was granted with retrospective effect from the year 2012 as per the order passed in the year 2017. Hence, on the post of Scientific Officer-E, the respondent had worked for approximately a period of 10 years when he was reverted to the post of Scientist-D. The question which arise whether under the garb of ‘correcting a mistake’ can an employee be reverted to a lower post having lower pay-scale just 4 days before the date of his superannuation and that too without giving any show cause notice.
As per the settled principles of law as settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India passed in Civil Appeal No.2265 of 2011 titled ‘Chamoli District Co-operative Bank Ltd through its Secretary/Mahaprandhak and another vs. Raghunath Singh Rana and others’, 2016(12) SCC 204, decided on 17.05.2016 and in Civil Appeal No. 9417 of 2019 titled M/s Daffodills Pharmaceuticals Ltd. and another vs. State of U.P. and another 2019 (12) JT 283, decided on 13.12.2019, no order causing prejudice to an employee be passed without grant of opportunity of being heard. The relevant para of Daffodills Pharmaceuticals's case (supra) is as under:-
“15.In the present case, even if one assumes that Surender Chaudhary, the accused in the pending criminal case was involved and had sought to indulge in objectionable activities, that ipso facto could not have resulted in unilateral action of the kind which the State resorted to- against Daffodils, which was never granted any opportunity of hearing or a chance to represent against the impugned order. If there is one constant lodestar that lights the judicial horizon in this country, it is this: that no one can be inflicted with an adverse order, without being afforded a minimum opportunity of hearing, and prior intimation of such a move. This principle is too well entrenched in the legal ethos of this country to be ignored, as the state did, in this case.
16.The High Court, in the opinion of this court, fell into error in holding that in matters of award of public contracts, the scope of inquiry in judicial review is limited. Granted, such jurisdiction is extremely circumscribed; no doubt the court had refused to grant relief to Daffodils against its plea of wrongful rejection of its tender. However, what the impugned judgment clearly overlooks is that the action of the state, not to procure indefinitely, on an assumption of complicity by Daffodils, was in flagrant violation of principles of natural justice.”
The relevant paragraph of the Chamoli's case (supra) is as under:-
“19.The compliance of natural justice in domestic/disciplinary inquiry is necessary has long been established. This Court has held that even there are no specific statutory rule requiring observance of natural justice, the compliance of natural justice is necessary. Certain ingredients have been held to be constituting integral part of holding of an inquiry. The Apex Court in Sur Enamel and Stamping Works Pvt. Ltd. v. Their Workmen reported in (1964) 3 SCR 616 has laid down following:-
“... An enquiry cannot be said to have been properly held unless, (i) the employee proceeded against has been informed clearly of the charges levelled against him, (ii) the witnesses are examined – ordinarily in the presence of the employee – in respect of the charges, (iii) the employee is given a fair opportunity to cross-examine witnesses, (iv) he is given a fair opportunity to examine witnesses including himself in his defence if he so wishes on any relevant matter, and (v) the inquiry officer records his findings with reasons for the same in his report.”
A bare perusal of the above would show that in the present case, without granting any opportunity of being heard to the respondent so as to allow him to satisfy the petitioner that even under the New Personnel Policy for Group ‘A’ S & T Officers vide OM dated 19.09.2016, the claim of the respondent is covered for promotion to the post of Scientific Officer-E, the benefit of promotion has been withdrawn unilaterally. The rules of natural justice has been violated. Even if, any mistake is to be corrected, but such correction of mistake results into reversion to a lower post or withdrawal of a particular pay-scale which causes prejudice to the employee concerned, the rules of natural justice had to be made applicable before any decision is to be taken. In the present case, with a unilateral decision, the promotion granted and availed and duties performed by the respondent on the post of Scientific Officer-E have been nullified, without even giving an opportunity of hearing to the respondent. Hence, keeping in view the totality of the facts and circumstances, the order passed by the Tribunal is perfectly valid and legal.
Though, under circumstances where an order is set aside due to the violation of the principles of natural justice, opportunity needs to be given to the employer to pass a fresh order but in the present case, immediately after passing of the order, the respondent had already retired and there is no mater and servant relationship existing between them so as to grant such liberty to the petitioner in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case and therefore, the order passed by the Tribunal treating the respondent having retired from the post of Scientific Officer-E, needs no interference at the hands of this Court.
Keeping in view the above, no ground is made out for any interference by this Court in the present petition and accordingly, the same is dismissed.
Pending misc. application, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
