AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
SIDDHARTH MRIDUL, J (OPEN COURT)
The present petition under Article 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, essentially assails the impugned Order dated 24th April, 2019, rendered by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi, in OA No.100/2537/2015, whereby, the penalty imposed upon the respondent by the Department of Defence Production, Ministry of Defence, Under Secretary to the Government of India, vide Order dated 18th September, 2014; imposing upon the latter the penalty of withholding of 10% of the monthly pension otherwise admissible to him for a period of one year, has been reduced to withholding of 5% of pension for a period of six months, in the facts and circumstances of the case.
Having heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner and examined in particular, paragraphs 8 and 9 of the impugned judgment, we are of the view that, no interference is called for, in the present petition.
In this regard, we must observe that the only lapse attributable to the respondent was that, he had forwarded the subject file to the Controller, though it was required to be sent through the Joint Controller concerned. In this behalf, we note that, it was observed by the Tribunal that, it is an admitted position that the Joint Controller –I was not present on the 26th February, 2008, the relevant day on which the subject decision taken by the respondent was rendered. It is further recorded by the Tribunal in this regard that, subsequent upon the taking of the subject decision by the respondent, the Controller approved the proposal and furthermore, that neither any material was in fact purchased by the Department consequent upon said decision, nor was any financial loss occasioned to the State. In fact, it is categorically recorded in the impugned order that the relevant file was unavailable during the pendency of the enquiry, thereby unequivocally indicating that the State did not consider the action of the respondent as a serious infringement of the rules.
Having said that however, the impugned order proceeded to find that the respondent ought to have exercised more restraint and waited for the return of the Joint Controller instead of proceeding in the matter in haste. It is in these circumstances, that the penalty of withholding of pension was reduced from 10% of the monthly pension otherwise admissible to the respondent for a period of one year, to one of withholding of 5% of pension for a period of six months; since the same was felt adequate and reasonable. As stated herein above, we do not find any reason to interfere with the conclusion arrived at by the Central Administrative Tribunal particularly from the standpoint of the proportionality of the penalty imposed, in the backdrop in the facts and circumstances, elaborated hereinbefore.
The petition is accordingly dismissed and disposed of. Pending applications also stand disposed of.
