AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
LAPITA BANERJI, J. (Oral)
By this common judgment, FAO-2137 of 2016 (Union of India and another Vs. Jagjit Singh and others) and FAO-1641 of 2016 (Union of India and another Vs. Gurdeep Singh and others) are being disposed of, as common questions of fact and law arise therein. For the sake of brevity, the facts of FAO No.2137-2016 are being taken into consideration.
Under challenge in the present appeal is an award dated December 16, 2012 passed by the learned Arbitrator and a judgment dated September 25, 2015 passed by the Additional District Judge, Jalandhar. Vide the impugned judgment, the learned ADJ rejected the application under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1996 Act”) filed by the appellant-NHAI.
The land in question is situatedd in village Bhangala, Tehsil Mukerian District Hoshiarpur. By the impugned award, the learned Arbitrator enhanced the market value of the land from Rs.7562/- per marla as awarded by the CALA (Competent Authority) to Rs.1,45,000/- per marla. Solatium was granted under Section 23(2) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1894 Act”) along with 12% interest under Section 23(1A) of the 1894 Act. Furthermore, the interest was also granted under Section 28 of the 1894 Act.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant-NHAI submits that there is no evidence at all on record to enhance the market value of the land from from Rs.7,562/- per marla to Rs.1,45,000/- per marla. The learned Arbitrator misdirected himself by relying upon sale deeds of the years 2008 and 2010 to determine the market value of the land whereas under the provisions of the National Highways Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1956 Act”), the market value of the land on the date of Notification under Section 3-A of the 1956 Act had to be considered. The Notification under Section 3-A of the 1956 Act was issued on December 24, 2004 which was much prior to the date of sale deeds relied upon by the learned Arbitrator. Furthermore, it is submitted that after holding that the ‘agricultural’ land in rural areas was awarded compensation at the rate of Rs.62,500/- per marla and in Municipal areas Rs.1,00,000/- per marla was awarded in 629 cases, the learned Arbitrator could not have awarded Rs.1,45,000/- per marla for ‘agricultural’ land situated in a rural area.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent No.1-land owner submits that there was no infirmity committed by the learned Arbitrator by enhancing the market value of the land. He submits that the land in question was situated along with the GT Road and Rs.44,000/- was the collector rate for the same. Therefore, relying on the orders passed by the Coordinate Benches in respect of other villages, the impugned award has been passed. There was no arbitrariness or perversity in passing of the said award.
Learned counsel for the respondents has relied on the judgment of the Apex Court passed in civil Appeal No.6483 of 2019 dated March 04, 2021 ‘NTPC Ltd. Vs. M/s Deconar Services Pvt. Ltd.’. However, the same is not applicable since it arises out of an award passed under The Arbitration Act, 1940. Moreover the said case relates to construction contract and factually has no connection with the compensation payable to the land owners in land acquisition cases.
The interest awarded under Section 23(1A) of the 1894 Act has not been seriously contested by learned counsel for the respondent-landowner.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the material on record.
The evidence relied upon by the learned Arbitrator for the purpose of determining the enhanced market value is as follows:-
Copy of APR
Copy of Collector rates for the year 2004
Copy of Jamabandi for the year 2002-03
Aks Shajra/Site plan
5.Copy of collector rate (year 2004) @ Rs.7532/- per marla for Nehri Land.
6.Copies of letter from Competent Authority-cum-SDM Mukerian, to the petitioner informing them reg. acquisition of their land and to hand over the possession.
7.A copy of cheque No.0000118 dated 25.04.2008 for Rs.5, 52,026/- in the name of Sh. Jagjit Singh Sardool Singh being the amount of compensation for the acquisition of land.
8.Arbitrator order dated 28.01.2009 for 629 cases of Dasuya Sub Division where minimum price of land in rural area was paid by NHAI @ Rs.62,500/- per marla.
9.A copy of award of the Arbitrator in case No.622 of 2008 of village Bhangala in which land rate of 80,000/- per marla has been awarded.
10.A copy of award of the Arbitrator in case No.624 of 2008 of village Bhangala in which land rate for commercial land has been awarded @ Rs.1.50 lac per marla and Rs.75,000/-for all other types of land.”
From serial No.8 of the evidence, it becomes clear that the learned Arbitrator took into consideration the award dated January 28, 2009 passed in 629 cases whereby compensation at the rate of Rs.62,500/- per marla was awarded for agricultural land in rural areas. The land in question is ‘nehri’ (irrigated) land and is situated in aa rural area. The next piece of evidence considered by the learned Arbitrator was the award in Case No.622 of 2008 concerning the same village, wherein compensation @ Rs.80,000/- per marla was awarded. Furthermore, the award taken into consideration by the learned Arbitrator was passed in case No.624 of 2008 for the land situated in the same village where rate for commercial land was determined Rs.1.50 lakhs per marla and for all other types of lands Rs.75,000/- per marla was determined. Thereafter, the learned Arbitrator referred to certain additional documents whereby registered sale deeds of the years 2008 and 2010 (much after the 3A Notification) for the same village that were produced on behalf of the land owners. As per the sale deeds, the land was valued between Rs.1 lakh per marla to Rs.1.44 lakh per marla. However, the nature of the land in question that was subject matter of those sale deeds, has not been discussed by the learned Arbitrator.
The evidence relied upon by the land owner also includes a sale deed dated July 24, 2007 of village Kureshian whereby instead of Rs.7562/- per marla (Collector rate), Rs.31,250/- per marla was taken to be the actual market value, for ‘agricultural’ land. The said sale deed was also of a date much later than the issuance of 3A Notification.
The learned Arbitrator observed that he had visited the spot to ascertain the true nature of the property and found that the land had commercial potential. For the year 2004-05, the Collector rate for ‘nehri’/ ‘chahi’ land, was Rs.12,09,000/- per acre i.e. Rs.7562/- per marla whereas the Collector rate for ‘gair mumkin abadi’ land was Rs.33,000/- per marla. The learned Arbitrator recorded that the collector rate for the land situated along with the GT road was Rs.44,000/- per marla but did not record whether that was the case for all types of land and whether the acquired land in question was situated along the highway.
The learned Arbitrator relied on the fact that compensation @ five times the Collector rate was paid in all cases of Kapurthala District which ranged from Rs.62,500/- per marla (‘agricultural’ land) to Rs.2.5 lakh per marla (‘commercial’ land) in 629 cases relating to Dasuya Sub-division. He also relied on a comparative chart to come to the finding that the ‘agricultural land/rastas’ were to be paid for at the rate of Rs.1 lakh per marla in Municipal areas and ‘agricultural land/rastas’ were to be acquired at the rate of Rs.62,500/- per marla, in rural areas. After observing the same, the learned Arbitrator went on to discuss the sale deeds of years 2008-2010 which were produced by the land owners at a subsequent stage. On what basis sale deeds subsequent to the date of the 3A Notification published in 2004 were relied upon by the learned Arbitrator is beyond the comprehension of this Court.
Just on the ground that in Kapurthala District, NHAI had paid five times the Collector rate, the learned Arbitrator came to the finding that five times of Rs.44,000/- per marla should be taken as the enhanced market value of the land in question and failed to take into account the nature of the land as reflected in the jamabandi for the year 2004-05. As per the said jamabandi, the nature of the land was ‘nehri’. The Collector rate for the same has been reproduced in the award itself. Therefore, on what basis the learned Arbitrator held that the Collector rate for the land in question was Rs.44,000/- per marla also beyond cannot be fathomed.
Accordingly, this Court finds no evidence at all for increasing the market value of the ‘nehri’ land from Rs.7562/- per marla to Rs.1,45,000/- per marla. The best evidence produced by the land owner is the award passed in case No.624 of 2008 for the same village where Rs.75,000/- per marla was granted for all types of lands apart from commercial land. Since the land in question is not ‘commercial’ in nature, at best the learned Arbitrator could have relied on the aforesaid award for determination of the market value and on the basis of parity the compensation could have been enhanced from Rs.7562/- per marla to Rs.75,000/- per marla for ‘nehri’ land. As almost 14 years have passed since the passing of the award dated December 16, 2012 enhancing the compensation, this Court finds that no useful purpose will be served by setting aside the determination of the enhanced market value and relegating the proceedings back to the learned Arbitrator for fresh evaluation/determination.
Accordingly, the enhanced market value of the land in question is set aside. The enhanced market value payable to the land owner is determined Rs.75,000/- per marla as in award Case No.624 of 2008.
The solatium will be awarded as per Section 23(2) of the 1894 Act. The additional interest @ 12% per annum under Section 23(1A) of the 1894 Act will not be payable to the land owner as clarified in the judgment of the Apex Court passed in Civil Appeal No.7086 of 2019 dated September 19, 2019 ‘National Highways Authority of India & Anr. v. Tehal Singh & Ors.’
Furthermore, interest will be paid to the land owner @ 9% per annum from the date of taking possession of the land till the date of payment/deposit of the entire enhanced amount. In case, the enhanced compensation has not been deposited within a period of one year from the date of taking possession, interest @ 15% per annum will be paid on balance part of the enhanced compensation after expiry of one year till the same is deposited, in accordance under Section 28 of the 1894 Act.
In view of the directions issued hereinabove, the impugned award dated December 16, 2012 is modified and the impugned judgment dated September 25, 2015 passed by the learned ADJ to that limited extent is also consequently modified.
Consequently, the instant appeals being FAO-2137-2016 and FAO-1641-2016 are disposed of.
Connected application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
