High CourtsSINGLE BENCH(2017) 05 KL CK 0025

THOMAS JOSEPH vs STATE OF KERALA

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 25 May 2017

HON’BLE JUDGES
P.Ubaid
CASE NUMBER
1059 of 2011

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

12 paragraphs · 1,427 words
1.

The appellant herein faced prosecution before the Court of Session, Wayanad in S.C 347/2006 on the allegation that when the Excise Party led by the Circle Inspector of Excise, Sulthan Bathery Circle inspected the Mini Bus No.KL-12B 3499 on the public road in front of the Perikalloor High School, the appellant, who was a passenger therein, was found possessing huge quantity of arrack imported from the State of Karnataka, contained in 250 packets of 100ml capacity and carried in a big shopper placed between his legs while sitting on a seat. In the presence of the Driver and the Conductor of the said bus, the Excise Circle Inspector arrested the accused and seized 250 packets of arrack as per a seizure mahazar. The accused and the properties were produced by the Circle Inspector before the Sulthan Bathery Excise Range Office where an Excise Inspector registered the crime and occurrence report. He took over the investigation and also submitted final report before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Sulthan Bathery under Sections 55 (a) and 8 (2) of the Kerala Abkari Act. After complying with the procedure prescribed under the law, the learned Magistrate committed the case to the Court of Session, from where it was made over to the learned Additional Sessions Judge

(Adhoc) I, Kalpetta for trial and disposal.

2.

The accused appeared before the trial court and pleaded not guilty to the charge framed against him under Sections 8(2) and 55 (a) of the Act. The prosecution examined five witnesses in the trial court, and proved Exts.P1 to P7 documents. The MO1 to MO3 properties were also identified during trial.

3.

When examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C, the accused denied the incriminating circumstances and submitted that a false case was foisted against him to help the Driver and the Conductor of the bus, who actually illegally transported huge quantity of arrack. No evidence was adduced in defence by the accused.

4.

On an appreciation of the evidence, the trial court found the accused guilty under Section 55 (a) of the Act. In view the conviction on the finding that arrack was illicitly imported from another State, no separate conviction was made by the court below under Section 8 (2) of the Act. On conviction, the accused was sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for four years, and to pay a fine of 1,00,000/- by judgment dated 17.6.2011. Aggrieved by the judgment of conviction, the accused has come up in appeal.

5.

When this appeal came up for hearing, the learned counsel for the appellant submitted that there is no material at all to connect the accused with the contraband articles seized by the Excise party, and that he was only a passenger in the bus. It was also submitted that a big shopper containing packets of arrack abandoned by somebody at the bus was used by the Excise Party to foist a case against him. This was controverted by the learned Public Prosecutor, who submitted that there is clear and convincing evidence including that of the Driver and the Conductor of the bus, to prove the prosecution case.

6.

Of the five witnesses examined in the trial court, PW4 is the Excise Sub Inspector who detected the offence, PW3 is the Excise Inspector who registered the crime and occurrence report and investigated the case, and PW5 is the Excise Preventive Officer who assisted the Circle Inspector in the process of detection. PW1 and PW2 are respectively the Conductor and the Driver of the Bus. These two witnesses supported the prosecution. Though the evidence of the driver does not fully support the prosecution, his evidence shows that PW4 had seized a big shopper containing 250 packets of arrack. To that extent of proving the fact of seizure, his evidence supports the prosecution, but the evidence given by the conductor is fully in support of the prosecution.

7.

PW4 and PW5 have given definite evidence that when the Excise Party led by PW4 inspected the bus, they saw the accused in this case sitting on a seat with a big shopper in between his legs. When PW4 opened the big shopper and examined it, he found 250 packets of arrack illicitly imported from the State of Karnataka. All the packets had identical label details showing that it is arrack manufactured in the State of Karnataka. The arrack contained in two packets was collected in a bottle as sample, and the sample was well packed and sealed at the spot of detection itself. The remaining packets were also well packed and sealed at the spot of detection, and the accused was arrested on the spot. The contraband articles including the samples were seized as per the Ext.P2 seizure mahazar. The Driver and the Conductor identified their signature in the seizure mahazar. I find nothing to disbelieve the evidence given by PW4 and PW5 regarding the detection. There is absolutely no reason to reject their evidence when the prosecution case is fully supported by the Bus Conductor. In cross-examination, the Bus Conductor stated that the accused had a big shopper in his possession, and when the Excise party opened it and examined it, they saw 250 packets of arrack therein. The accused was arrested on the spot and the packets of arrack were seized as per mahazar. The Bus conductor has no reason to give any false evidence against the accused. A suggestion was put to the witnesses that the big shopper was in fact carried by the Cleaner of the bus and on seeing the Excise party, he just ran off and escaped. There is no evidence to probabilse such a case. It is not known who the Cleaner of the bus

was. PW4 and PW5 are definite that the MO3 big shopper containing 250 packets of arrack was seized from the hands of the accused in this case while travelling as passenger in the bus inspected by them. MO2 series are the empty packets from which sample was taken and MO1 series are the remaining 248 packets of arrack manufactured in the State of Karnataka. The accused has no explanation for the possession of huge quantity of arrack manufactured in the State of Karnataka. A clear case of illicit import of arrack manufactured in the State of Karnataka is well proved in this case by the evidence of PW4 and PW5, fully corroborate by that of the Bus Conductor (PW1). The Ext.P7 report of analysis shows that the liquid contained in the sample was identified as arrack at the laboratory. The evidence well convinces the court that the sample was collected from two packets carried in the MO3 big shopper seized from the possession of the accused. Thus, I find that the prosecution has convincingly proved the offence punishable under Section 55(a) of the Act that the accused was found in possession of 250 packets of arrack illicitly imported from the State of Karnataka. In view of the clear evidence proving the offence punishable under Section 55 (a) of the Act, no separate conviction was made by the court below under Section 8 (2) of the Act. I find no reason for interference in appeal in this case.

8.

Now the question of sentence. The accused was aged 55 years on the date of detection. The offence was detected on 21.3.2005. Now we are in 2017 and the appellant must be now aged about 67 years. No previous case of similar nature is seen reported against him. He is said to be an Ex-service man. The substantive sentence imposed by the court below is simple imprisonment for four years, and the fine sentence is the minimum possible under the law. On a consideration of all the relevant aspects including the present age and circumstances of the accused, I feel that imprisonment for one year will be the adequate sentence in this case. The default sentence also can be reasonably reduced. Though interference in the matter of fine is not possible, the default sentence can be appropriately reduced and modified by the court.

In the result, the conviction against the appellant under Section 55 (a) of the Act in S.C 347/2006 of the court below is confirmed and the appeal is disposed of accordingly.

However, the jail sentence imposed by the court below will stand reduced to simple imprisonment for one year. The fine sentence is maintained, subject to the modification that the default sentence shall be simple imprisonment for two months. The accused will get the benefit of set off as already ordered by the trial court.