High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 10 BOM CK 5384

The State Of Maharashtra vs Sanjay @ Jagdev Namdev Pimpalkar

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 15 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Rohit W. Joshi, J · Shivkumar Dige, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Criminal Appeal No. 237/2012

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

26 paragraphs · 2,058 words

(PER: SHIVKUKAR DIGE, J.)

(1)

This appeal is preferred by the State challenging the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned Ad-Hoc District Judge-1 and Assistant Sessions Judge, Akola, whereby the respondent has been acquitted for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, 'IPC'), by extending the benefit of Section 84 of the IPC.

(2)

The prosecution case is that on 29/03/2008, at about 08:40 p.m., the respondent assaulted his wife, Sangita, by means of an axe, inflicting multiple injuries on her head and other parts of her body, including injuries resulting in the amputation of her legs and limbs. She died on the spot. After the incident, the respondent came out of house, where he met his cousin brother, Arun Pimpalkar (PW-1) and disclosed that he had killed his wife because she had called him a mad person. On the report lodged by PW-1, crime came to be registered against the respondent. The prosecution examined eight witnesses to establish its case, whereas the respondent examined DW-1, Dr. Pramod Thakare, a psychiatrist, in support of his defence that he had committed the act while suffering from unsoundness of mind. Upon appreciation of the evidence, the learned Sessions Judge accepted the defence and acquitted the respondent by extending the benefit of Section 84 of the IPC. Being aggrieved, the State has preferred the present appeal.

(3)

It is contention of the learned APP that prosecution evidence establishes that the respondent assaulted his wife with an axe and caused her death. According to the learned APP, the deposition of PW-1 and PW-2 establishes the respondent's conduct and his statements immediately following the occurrence. It was not proved before the learned Sessions Judge that the respondent was insane at the time of the incident. It is further submitted that the respondent's mental illness was not sufficient to establish that he was incapable of understanding the nature of his act or that it was wrong or contrary to law at the time of the incident. It was argued that the respondent could behave normally between episodes of mental illness and that the medical examination conducted subsequently did not establish his mental condition on the date of the occurrence. The burden was on the respondent to prove the said fact, which was not discharged. It was, therefore, argued that the learned Sessions Judge had erroneously extended the benefit of Section 84 of the IPC without sufficient evidence concerning the respondent's mental condition at the time of the incident. The State accordingly prayed that the acquittal be set aside. Learned APP relied on following case laws.

1)

Lakshmi Singh & Ors. v. State of Bihar, (1976) 4 SCC 394.

2)

Jafarudheen & Ors. v. State of Kerala, (2022) 8 SCC

3)

Rajesh Prasad v. State of Bihar & Anr, (2022) 3 SCC 471.

4)

Constable 907 Surendra Singh & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand (with Ashad Singh Negi v. State of Uttarakhand), (2025) 5 SCC 433.

5)

State of Maharashtra v. WalmikUndraji Gawande & ors, Criminal Appeal No. 558 of 2006.

6)

NandLal and Ors V. State of Chhattisgarh, (2023) 10 SCC 470

(4)

It is the contention of the learned counsel for respondent that it has come on record that respondent had been suffering from mental illness since childhood and his father had also suffered from mental illness. It was further submitted that the respondent had left the village for about two months to undergo treatment and returned only a day before the incident. Learned counsel further submitted that the testimony of DW-1, who diagnosed the respondent as suffering from psychosis, corroborated the respondent's history of psychiatric illness and prior treatment. DW-1 also explained that a person suffering from a serious mental disorder may pose a danger to himself or others during certain periods, while appearing to behave normally at other times. He specifically stated that the respondent's mental condition was not good and that he committed the murder in an unsound mental state. It is contended that the deposition of the prosecution witnesses, along with the medical evidence adduced by the defence, supports the plea of unsoundness of mind raised by the respondent. The learned Sessions Judge has passed a well-reasoned order, and no interference is required.

(5)

Heard rival submissions, perused the impugned judgment and order and documents produced on record.

(6)

To prove its case, the prosecution examined PW-1 Arun Pimpalkar (cousin brother of the respondent) has stated that on 29/03/2008, at about 08:30 p.m. to 09:00 p.m., while he was returning home, he saw the respondent standing on the road in front of his house with his clothes smeared with blood. When He asked him what had happened, the respondent stated that he had killed his wife with an axe because she had called him mad. He further stated that when he looked inside the house, he saw the respondent's wife lying in a pool of blood, with her hand severed and an axe lying nearby. He thereafter informed his family members and the Police Patil, Nathu Kale (PW-2), who then informed the police. PW-1 lodged the report, it is at Exhibit 27.

(7)

During his cross-examination, PW-1 admitted that the respondent’s father was mentally ill and used to remain in a state of mental disturbance. He further admitted that the respondent had also been suffering from mental illness since childhood. According to PW-1, about two months before the incident, the respondent had been taken to his wife’s parental home for treatment, as his mental condition had deteriorated. He also stated that whenever the respondent suffered from mental disturbance, he would not perform any work and the respondent had never quarreled with his wife. The respondent had returned home from his wife’s parental place one day before the incident.

(8)

PW-2, Nathu Kale, the Police Patil, stated that PW-1 informed him about the incident on 29/03/2008. Upon reaching the spot, he saw the respondent’s wife lying in a pool of blood, with injuries on her head, legs and hand. He also noticed that her legs had been severed. The respondent was standing near his house and stated that he had assaulted his wife because she had called him mad. During cross-examination, he admitted that the respondent's father had suffered from mental illness and the respondent himself had been suffering from mental illness since childhood and experienced episodes of mental disturbance. He further admitted that the respondent had returned to the village one day before the incident after undergoing treatment for about two months.

(9)

PW-5, Dr. Bhavna (Medical Officer) conducted the post-mortem and opined that the deceased died due to injury to vital organs, shock, and injury to major neck vessels. She found a severe open skull fracture with visible brain matter and brain haematoma, along with incised wounds around the neck. She opined that the injuries were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death and were possible by assault with the axe sent by police. However, in cross-examination, she admitted that the post-mortem report did not specifically record the "sufficient cause of death", the axe was not sealed after examination, no receipt was taken on its return, the axe was not described in her opinion, and the Civil Surgeon’s signature was absent from the post-mortem report. She further admitted that, she did not give any opinion connecting with the offence. The witness further admitted that injuries caused by insane persons are generally spontaneous and not pre-planned, but she stated that the mental condition of an assailant cannot be ascertained from the nature of injuries on the deceased. She also stated that she could not speak authoritatively on psychosis or the classification of abnormal mental states.

(10)

PW-3, Sk. Hassan and PW-4 – Shrikrishna Bhawane, panchas of spot panchanama did not support prosecution case. Nothing elicited in their cross-examination by learned APP. PW-6, Chandrasingh Chavan, (Investigating Officer), carried out the investigation, prepared the spot and inquest panchanamas, recorded the statements of witnesses and seized the axe.

(11)

The respondent examined DW-1, Dr. Pramod Thakare (Psychiatrist), as a defence witness. He has stated that he had examined prisoners referred by the jail authorities. He deposed that the jail medical officer had reported that the respondent was mentally affected and had attempted to commit suicide in jail. DW-1 examined the respondent on 03/03/2009 and stated that he had previously been treated by various doctors and administered anti-psychotic medicines. He diagnosed the respondent as suffering from psychosis on the basis of the available medical history and repeated examinations. He admitted that hereditary factors may play a role in certain mental illnesses, though no history of mental illness in the respondent’s father was recorded. He further stated that a person suffering from an abnormal mental condition may be injurious to himself or others and may behave normally at other times. He proved the issuance of Certificate Exhibit 9, under which the respondent was diagnosed with psychosis and referred to the Mental Hospital, Nagpur, for final assessment. In cross-examination, he admitted that, at the time of his examination on 03/03/2009, the respondent was mentally fit. He also stated that the earlier treatment records were not available for his perusal before the respondent’s admission to jail and that his diagnosis was based on the history provided and repeated examinations by his fellow doctors.

(12)

The evidence of PW-1 and PW-2 shows that the respondent had been suffering from mental illness since childhood. His father was also suffering from mental illness. These witnesses have stated that the respondent had undergone treatment for about two months and had returned to the village just one day before the incident. These facts are relevant to determine his mental condition at the time of the occurrence. These circumstances are not isolated or incidental facts; they constitute relevant evidence of the respondent’s antecedent mental condition and assume importance when considered in conjunction with the medical evidence adduced by the defence.

(13)

The question is whether the respondent committed the act while suffering from unsoundness of mind. The respondent told PW-1 that he killed his wife because she had called him mad. In normal circumstances, no prudent man would murder his wife merely upon being called mad. The post-mortem report reveals multiple severe injuries caused by an axe, resulting in the severing of her limbs. No normal person would assault anyone with such extreme force unless under severe mental disturbance. Though the nature of the assault alone cannot prove insanity, when considered along with the respondent’s history of mental illness and recent treatment, it supports his defence that he was suffering from serious mental disturbance at the time of the incident.

(14)

In the present case, the evidence of PW-1 and PW-2 regarding the respondent’s longstanding mental illness and recent treatment is corroborated by DW-1, Dr. Pramod Thakare, who diagnosed him with psychosis. Though the doctor found him mentally fit during a subsequent examination, this alone does not rule out the possibility of unsoundness of mind at the time of the incident.

(15)

The learned APP contended that the respondent’s extra-judicial confession to PW-1 and PW-2 establishes his guilt. However, the said statement, by itself, cannot determine his criminal responsibility. When the evidence of mental illness is considered along with the surrounding circumstances, the confession does not disentitle the respondent to the benefit of Section 84 of the IPC, provided the required legal incapacity at the time of the incident is established.

(16)

Section 84 of the IPC provides protection to a person who, due to unsoundness of mind, is incapable of knowing the nature of his act or that it is wrong or contrary to law at the time of its commission. In the present case, the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, read with the medical evidence and the respondent's history of mental illness, supports his defence. On an overall assessment of the evidence, we find that the learned Sessions Judge has rightly extended the benefit of Section 84 of the IPC. We have gone through the case laws cited by learned APP, Facts of the cited cases are distinguishable from those of the present case, therefore, will not be applicable to the present case. The learned Sessions Judge has passed a well reasoned order. No interference is warranted.

(17)

Hence, we pass following order:-

ORDER

(i)

Criminal Appeal stands dismissed.