AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Background:
‘Heard’ the Learned Counsel for the ‘Appellant’/ ‘Respondent’, Mr. Pradeep Joy, at the ‘Admission’ stage, itself. To avoid an avoidable delay, ‘Notice’ to the ‘Respondent’, is dispensed with, in the interest of Justice.
According to the Learned Counsel for the ‘Appellant’, the impugned Order, dated 25/01/2023, passed by the ‘Adjudicating Authority’/ ‘National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench’, in IA(IBC)/207/KOB/2022, in C.P.(IB)/25/KOB/2021, (Filed by the Respondent/ Petitioner, under Section 50 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016), is an erroneous one and based on wrong appreciation’ of the ‘Facts’ and ‘Circumstances’ of the instant Case, on hand.
Appellant’s Contentions:
According to the Learned Counsel for the ‘Petitioner’/ ‘Appellant’, the ‘Adjudicating Authority’/ ‘National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench’, had failed to take into account, that the ‘Forensic Audit Report’, had not dealt with extensively or elaborately on the ‘Extortionate Credit Transactions’, with the assistance of ‘Books of Accounts’/ ‘Financial Statements’, and further, it had not provided any ‘formula’, on the basis on which the ‘Forensic Auditor’, came to the certain Conclusion.
The Learned Counsel for the ‘Appellant’, proceeds to point out that during the ‘review period’, the Corporate Debtor, had borrowed from several ‘Non Banking Financing Corporations’, when prescribed much higher rate of interest and so ‘Loans’, ‘Advances’, to the ‘Respondent’, were at much lower interest rates, if calculated, on the basis of the ‘internal rate of return’.
The other ‘Contention’, projected on the side of the ‘Appellant’, is that the ‘Adjudicating Authority’/ ‘National Company Law Tribunal’, Kochi Bench’, is that the ‘Adjudicating Authority’/ ‘National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench’, should have looked into an important fact, that the ‘Respondent’, must have produced ‘material and documentary evidence(s)’, in respect of the ‘purported transactions’, to substantiate the allegations, instead of solely relying upon the ‘Forensic Report’.
It is represented on behalf of the ‘Appellant’, in an emphatic and forceful manner that there is no ‘element of extortion’ in the ‘Alleged Transaction’, as per the ingredients of Section 50 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
A plea is advanced on behalf of the ‘Appellant’ that, before the ‘Adjudicating Authority’/ ‘Tribunal’, that, the ‘Application’/ ‘Petition’, is barred by ‘Laches’ and ‘Delay’ and hence, the same is ‘per se’, not maintainable.
Appraisal:
At this Juncture, this ‘Tribunal’, makes a useful reference to the ‘Impugned Order’, dated 25/01/2023, in IA/IBC/207/KOB/2022, in C.P.(IB)/25/KOB/2021 (Filed under Section 50 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016), whereby and whereunder, at Para 9, it is observed as follows:
Para 9: “On the Respondent side admitted the fact that the Loan was given to Corporate Debtor but stated that the said loan was not Interest free loan. In the application itself Applicant admitted that for the Loan interests were paid for the Financial Years 2016-2017 and 2017-2018. The Loan was extended for further period but no interest was drawn for the year 2018-2019, but interest was drawn for the year 2019-2020 and 2020-2021.”
As a matter of fact, the very apt and tacit ‘Admission’, made by the ‘Appellant’, is exhibited in the ‘Impugned Order’, at Paragraph 9 , whereby and whereunder, it is observed as under:
Para 9: ….“Even though there is no mentioning of Principal loan amount lent to the Corporate Debtor, both sides admitted Respondent withdrawn interest for the year 2019-2020 RS. 12.39 Lakhs and Interest from 1st January 2020 to 30th November 2020-2021 at Rs. 16.39. According to the Petitioner on calculation the interest drawn by the Respondent comes at 26.50% interest which is exorbitant and usurious, taking advantage of his dominant position over the Corporate Debtor the Respondent acted arbitrarily. The transactions within a period of two years preceding the date of commencement of insolvency alone comes under section 50 of IBC 2016. The date of commencement of CIRP in this case is 21.12.2021, the transaction taken after 21.12.2019 are to be considered”.
In view of the unambiguity, as made mention of Supra, the ‘Appellant’, cannot, by any means, ‘wriggle out’, of the predicament, that he is in. At this juncture, it is suffice, for this Tribunal, to make a pertinent mention that this ‘Tribunal’, on going through the ‘Impugned Order’, dated 25/01/2023 in IA(IBC)/207/KOB/2022 in C.P.(IB)/25/KOB/2021, is of the considered view that, even in the ‘Forensic Report’ , it was made mentioned that on numerous occasions, ‘negative balance’, was shown in the ‘Loan Account’, received from the Respondent, but interest was not collected from the Respondent for those periods and the ‘Interest’ collected was at 26.50 % and the same being on the higher side. However, the ‘Adjudicating Authority’/ ‘National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench’, in the ‘Impugned Order’, had opined that 12% interest, per ‘Annum’ was a reasonable interest and accordingly, it had mentioned that the ‘Interest withdrawn’ by the ‘Respondent’, viz; Rs.12,39,000 + Rs. 16,39,000 = Rs. 28,78,000/-, represents 26.50 % interest, out of which after deducting Rs. 13,03,245/-, representing 12 % interest for which the ‘Respondent’ is entitled; then, the ‘Respondent’ was required to repay the remaining sum of Rs.15,74,755/-, to the ‘Applicant’/ ‘Petitioner’, as per Section 51(d), of the ‘Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016’.
As far as, the present case is concerned, this ‘Tribunal’, is in ‘Complete Agreement’ with the view arrived at, by the ‘Adjudicating Authority’/ ‘National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench’, in the ‘Impugned Order’, dated 25/01/2023, in IA (IBC) 207/KOB/2023 in C.P./IB/25/KOB/2021, wherein a direction was issued to the ‘Respondent’ (‘Appellant’ in ‘Appeal’), to pay a sum of Rs.15,74,755/-, with Simple Interest at 12 % per Annum, from the date of passing of the ‘Order’, till the date of ‘Realisation’, of the same, but, without ‘Costs’. Looking at, from any angle, the instant ‘Appeal’, is devoid of merits and it fails.
Result:
In fine, the instant Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 97/2023, is ‘Dismissed’. ‘No Costs’. Connected Pending IA No. 336/2023 (For ‘Stay’) & IA No. 337/2023(For ‘Condone Delay’), are ‘Closed’.
