High CourtsSingle Bench(2022) 11 KL CK 0240

T P Abraham vs Lissy

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 21 November 2022

HON’BLE JUDGES
M.R.Anitha, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Regular Second Appeal No. 312 Of 2022

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

12 paragraphs · 868 words

M.R.Anitha, J

1.

This appeal has been filed against the judgment and decree in A.S. No.7/2021 on the file of Sub Court, Perumbavoor which in turn arose out of the supplementary preliminary decree in I.A. No.1912/2019 in O.S. No.125/2004 on the file of Munsiff's Court, Perumbavoor.

2.

I.A. No.1912/2019 has been filed by the respondents/petitioners who are the 2nd and 3rd petitioners in the above I.A. The appellant herein is the sole respondent in the appeal and I.A. No.1912/2019. The 1st plaintiff the mother died on 23.05.2015. As per the decree passed by the 1st appellate court which though challenged in second appeal was dismissed confirming the order of the 1st appellate court. The 1st appellate court divided the plaint schedule properties to nine equal shares and 3/9 shares was allotted to the 1st plaintiff deceased mother and 2/9 shares each were allotted to the respondent herein and the appellant.

3.

After  the death of  the mother, respondents  and appellant are entitled to get the share of the mother equally. Hence, the respondents filed I.A. No.1912/2019 for passing supplementary preliminary decree. The appellant herein filed objection contending that partition of 5 items by metes and bounds will not be beneficial to any one and sought for directions of allotment of shares on the basis of equity.

4.

Appellant was examined as RW1 and commission report and sketch were marked as Ext.C1 and C1(a) and supplementary preliminary decree was passed by the learned Munsiff ordering to partition, the plaint schedule property into equal 9 shares and supplementary preliminary decree was passed ordering that respondents are entitled to get 1/3 share each out of 3/9 share of the 1st plaintiff the mother and appellant is also entitled to get 1/3 share out of 3/9 share of the deceased 1st plaintiff. The prayer of appellant to allot his 1/3rd share from plaint 'A' schedule property was not considered.

5.

Against which appellant filed  first appeal and 1st appellate court on re-appreciating the facts and circumstances, found that objection and suggestion regarding the allotment of property ordered to partition could be raised in final decree proceedings and it could not be decided in this proceedings. It is also found that the contentions raised by the appellant are for challenging the decree which has become final and accordingly the order passed by the trial court was confirmed. Against which appellant approaches this Court in 2nd appeal.

6.

Notice was issued to the respondents and both sides were heard.

7.

According to the leaned counsel for the appellant, he is the only son residing in a house near to plaint 'A' schedule property. His only request is to allot his share from plaint 'A' schedule property. It is contended that there are 5 items of properties. Plaint 'A' schedule property consists of 2 acres 46 cents, 'B' schedule consists 40 cents, 'C' schedule is a paddy land extending to 99.8 cents, 'D' schedule is 1.93 acres and 'E' schedule is 30 cents.

8.

The contention of the learned counsel is that if 3 sharers are allotted properties from all the items, it will not be just and equitable and his request is that since he is residing near by plaint A schedule property, his share should be alloted from plaint A schedule property.

9.

The learned counsel for the respondents (plaintiffs 2 and 3) vehemently objects in entertaining the prayer of the appellant. According to him, equity and reservation can be determined only in the final decree proceedings after ascertaining the value and importance of the properties. It is also contended by him that except 'A' schedule property all other properties and not having road excess and are situated in unimportant localities. It is further contended that appellant forged a Will and attempted to grab the entire properties and has been in possession of all the properties and hence he does not deserve any equitable treatment. Appellant is the only male child and respondents are the female children of the deceased 1st plaintiff.

10.

Admittedly, preliminary decree has already been passed and it has become final and the supplementary preliminary decree happened to be passed, since the mother 1st plaintiff died pending the proceedings. So, while passing a supplementary preliminary decree with respect to the partition of the share allotted to the deceased mother, it may not be proper to give any such direction for allotting the plaint 'A' schedule property to the appellant. Of course, at the time of passing of final decree, if at all the appellant is residing near by the plaint A schedule property, it is open for the appellant to make such request, even without a direction by this Court. The court passing the final decree can consider equity and reservation while passing the final decree. Without proper evaluation of lie of the properties, importance of the locality value of the property etc, it would not be proper to give any such direction for reservation by this Court to the appellant while sitting in 2nd appeal from a supplementary preliminary decree passed, in the absence of any substantial question of law.

In the result, appeal stands dismissed. In the facts and circumstance, there is no order as to costs.