Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2026) 09 NCDRC CK 7040

T.G Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. vs Darshan Kumar Ahuja & Anr.

National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi · Decided on 21 September 2026

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
NC/FA/487/2021

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

38 paragraphs · 1,942 words
1.

Heard learned counsel for both the parties in detail.

2.

This common order will also dispose of FA/488/2021, FA/489/2021, FA/490/2021, FA/491/2021, FA/492/2021, FA/636/2021, FA/637/2021, FA/638/2021, FA/639/2021, FA/640/2021 & FA/641/2021 as the facts in these First Appeals are similar. For reasons of convenience, FA No.487 of 2021 is taken as the lead case.

3.

These Appeals arise out of the Order dated 06.10.2020, which are subsequently modified vide orders dated 11.01.2021 and 05.03.2021 by the learned State Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission, Delhi ('State Commission') in Complaint Case No.119 of 2017 titled as Mr. Darshan Kumar Ahuja & Anr. Vs. T.G. Buildwell Pvt. Ltd.

4.

Brief facts of the case are that on 08.04.2011, the Respondents applied for booking a Studio Apartment in the project of Appellant named "Tivoli Holiday Village" situated in the village, Dharuhera, Tehsil and Dist. Rewari, Haryana and paid booking amount of Rs.4,00,000/- vide two cheques of Rs.2,00,000 each to the Opposite Party (OP). On 25.04.2011, Studio Apartment No. SA- 1102 in Tower No.TG-II admeasuring super area of 645 sq feet was allotted to him by the OP vide Allotment Letter dated 25.04.2011. On 25.04.2011, the parties had entered into an MOU dated 25.04.2011 and the said MOU was valid for 3 years i.e. till 30.04.2014. In pursuance of the same, the OP paid Rs.8,72,134 to the Complainant as assured return after deducting TDS. On 28.04.2011, the Builder Buyer Agreement (BBA) with detailed terms and conditions was executed between the parties and parties agreed to abide by all the terms and conditions but failed to adhere to the same and committed default in complete payment of instalment of Down Payment Plan, which was payable within 45 days of booking. On 30.04.2011, the Respondents paid only Rs.9,00,000 vide two cheques amounting to Rs.4,50,000/- each towards the cost of the apartment and after that no further payments were made and till today, only Rs.13,00,000 was paid by them to the Appellant towards the apartment in question. On 25.01.2017 the Complainants filed Complaint No. 2084 of 2017 before the State Commission, Delhi seeking refund with compensation.

5.

The dispute, therefore, pertains to having failed contract between the parties wherein it is a specific contention of the Complainants that they entered into agreement with OP as follows:

NAME OF THE COMPLAINANTSDATE
Darshan Kumar Ahuja28.04.2011
Aarti Kamra01.07.2011
Ankit Kamra & Anr.10.06.2011
Jitender Bajaj & Ors.05.12.2011
Krishna Devi & Anr.25.11.2011
Mohan Arora & Anr.28.04.2011
6.

As per the terms of the said agreements, the OP was liable to hand over the possession of the unit within a period of 30 days. It is undisputed position that contract failed and the project remained incomplete till date. On the Complainants filing Complaint No.119 of 2017 before the State Commission, the same was disposed as below:

27.

Keeping in view the principles as discussed above, we direct the OP to refund the entire amount paid by the complainants i.e. Rs.13,00,000/- along with interest as per the following arrangement:

A. An interest @ 7% p.a. calculated from 30.04.2014 being the expiry date of MOU till 06.10.2020 being the date of order (both the dates being inclusive), in case the amount is paid by 05.01.2020;

B. In case the OP fails to refund the amount as per clause (A), an interest @ 7.5% p.a. calculated from 30.04.2014 till the actual realization of the amount.

28.

In addition to the aforesaid and taking into consideration the facts of the present case, the OP is directed to pay a sum of:

A. Rs.2,50,000/- as damages for mental harassment and torture caused to the complainants; and

B. Rs.50,000/- as litigation costs to the complainants.

7.

As against which the present Appeals as well as cross Appeals have been filed wherein the OP raised objections with respect to order of the State Commission and on the other hand in the cross Appeals filed by Complainants, they sought enhancement of compensation.

8.

The learned counsel for OP argued that, in compliance of the order of this Commission dated 21.05.2025 towards grant of ex-parte stay, the decretal amount has already been deposited before the State Commission. She states that the contract had failed on account of non-payment balance due by the Complainants and that the OP had suffered adversely in the transactions and, therefore, the amount already deposited before the State Commission be released to the Complainants as full and final settlement of the claim. On the other hand, the learned counsel for Complainants argued that the OP has put the Complainants into financial crisis of liability to pay penal interests on the loans obtained for housing and seeks this amount to be compensated. On this regard, the learned counsel also relies on the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Rajnish Sharma v. M/s. Business Park Town Planners Ltd., 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 951, decided on 24.09.2025 and seeks that similar liability be passed to the OP.

9.

Heard learned counsels for both the parties in detail. As per the terms of the Agreements, the OP was liable to hand over the possession of the unit within a period of 30 days from the date of the Agreement. It is undisputed that contract failed and the project remained incomplete till date. Therefore, the OP is bound to refund the payments made along with compensation in the form of interest. In this regard the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Rajnish Sharma v. M/s. Business Park Town Planners Ltd., 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 951, decided on 24.09.2025 has held that where a builder has levied an exorbitant rate of interest upon a consumer for delayed payment, principles of equity and fairness mandate that the same standard be applied against the builder for its own default in handing over possession. The Court clarified that there is no rigid principle of law that the rate of interest charged by the builder must always be granted to the buyer, as the reasonableness of interest varies from case to case and depends upon the facts and circumstances involved. Relevant paras of the said judgement are reproduced as under:

"4.7

Thus, the conduct of the respondent has been full of blemishes throughout.

4.8

Finally, the respondent charged the appellant interest @ 18% p.a. whereas agreed to give back to the appellant the principal amount with 9% interest, which is in defiance of logic and reason. Respondent, for its default, should have been judged by the same standard and made to pay back 18% interest.

7.

We start by analyzing the arguments raised by the respondent.

8.

It was argued that this Court has consistently rejected the claim of parity raised by buyers. Various judgments of this Court, which were cited, have been noted. On perusal thereof, we find that in all such cases this Court did not give elaborate reasons for rejecting the claim for parity but reduced/increased the rate of interest based on other factors peculiar to the facts and circumstances of each case, such as the prevailing market conditions, lockdown due to COVID, et cetera.

11.

Suffice it to say, there is no principle of law that interest in default charged by the builder can never be granted to the buyer.

12.

Law is well settled that the amount of interest should be reasonable. What is reasonable varies from case to case. The same is to be granted considering the facts and circumstances of each case. The series of judgments cited by the respondent to buttress its argument that this Court has consistently granted interest @ 9% p.a. will make no difference to the decision in this lis, as all the said cases were decided in light of the peculiar facts of each case.

14.

As per clause 22 of the AGREEMENT, possession of the plot was to be handed over within 24 months of sanction of service plans of the entire colony. Admittedly, no offer for possession was made until the year 2018. The conduct of the respondent in the interregnum is also worthy of a discussion.

18.

Having noted thus, we agree with Mr. Nayyar that before compensation can be granted by the NCDRC, actual loss must be proved to have been suffered by the consumer. The objective of granting compensation cannot be altered such that it amounts to a windfall gain to the other party. Proof of actual loss would require evidence to be tendered, for, it is a guiding lamp for grant of compensation. Be that as it may, in this case, we are not deciding the actual loss suffered by the appellant. We are only concerned with deciding the rate of interest to be awarded to the appellant on the principal amount paid by him to the respondent.

19.

Keeping in mind the overall conduct of the respondent: the delay caused by it in offering the plot, the fact that the respondent charged the appellant delay compensation @ 18% p.a. on the due amount, and the long wait that the appellant had to endure over a period of a decade, causing harassment and anxiety, which are writ large, we find that this is an appropriate case where refund of the principal amount with interest @ 9% p.a., as awarded by the NCDRC, will not serve the ends of justice.

20.

In view of the conduct of the respondent, it cannot be permitted to escape with a nominal liability for its default, while it charged interest @ 18% on default committed by the appellant. Although, the rate of interest charged by the builder cannot be granted to the buyer as a rule of thumb, however, in the present case, equity and fairness demands that the respondent be put to the same rigours for charging 18% interest and face consequences similar to those imposed on the appellant for default committed by him. If we hold otherwise, we will be perpetuating a manifestly wrong bargain.

21.

We, therefore, substitute the rate of interest awarded by the NCDRC and increase it from 9% to 18% per annum, while keeping the other terms intact. Respondent shall refund the requisite amount within a period of two months from date."

10.

Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Experion Developers Private Limited Vs. Sushma Ashok Shiroor, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 416 wherein it was held as follows:-

"We are of the opinion that for the interest payable on the amount deposited to be restitutionary and also compensatory, interest has to be paid from the date of the deposit of the amounts. The Commission in the Order impugned has granted interest from the date of last deposit. We find that this does not amount to restitution. Following the decision in DLF Homes Panchkula Pvt. Ltd. Vs. DS Dhanda and in modification of the direction issued by the Commission, we direct that the interest on the refund shall be payable from the dates of deposit. Therefore, the Appeal filed by purchaser deserves to be partly allowed. The interest shall be payable from the dates of such deposits. At the same time, we are of the opinion that the interest of 9% granted by the Commission is fair and just and we find no reason to interfere in the appeal filed by the consumer for enhancement of interest."

11.

Considering the nature of the case and submissions made, we consider it appropriate that the orders of the learned State Commission towards grant of refund as well as compensation in the given circumstance are appropriate and, therefore, all the Appeals i.e. FA/487/2021, FA/488/2021, FA/489/2021, FA/490/2021, FA/491/2021, FA/492/2021, FA/636/2021, FA/637/2021, FA/638/2021, FA/639/2021, FA/640/2021 and FA/641/2021 are dismissed.

12.

There shall be no order as to costs.

13.

All the pending IAs, if any, are also disposed of accordingly.