AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Manisha Batra, J.
Prayer in this second petition, filed under Section 483 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, is for grant of regular bail to the petitioner in cross version recorded vide DDR No. 26 dated 12.12.2014 in case bearing FIR No. 261 dated 12.12.2014, registered under Sections 302, 307, 324, 427, 506, 148 and 149 of IPC and Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act, 1959 (Section 201 of IPC added later on) at Police Station Lopoke, District Amritsar (Rural). His previous petition for grant of regular bail was dismissed by this Court on 18.03.2026 (Annexure P-13).
Brief facts of the case relevant for the purpose of disposal of this petition are that the aforementioned FIR was registered on the statement of Muktul Singh in respect of a land dispute. He alleged that the members of the opposite group had fired gunshots at him and his companions, resulting in the death of his brother Narinder Singh and injuries to others. During investigation, an information was received that two persons, namely Nawab Singh and Jagtar Singh, had also died in the same occurrence at village Lodhi Gujjar. The Investigating Officer recorded the statement of injured Jatinder Singh at EMC Hospital, Amritsar. He alleged that on 12.12.2014, at about 12:00 noon, when his cousin Nawab Singh started cultivating the land purchased by him from Ajit Singh, the petitioner and his co-accused, armed with firearms and other weapons, were already present there. Sahib Singh raised a lalkara and his companions opened fire. The petitioner fired a shot with his 315 bore rifle, which hit Jagtar Singh in his abdomen and he died at the spot. On this statement, a cross version was recorded vide DDR No. 26 dated 12.12.2014 (Annexure P-2). The petitioner was declared a proclaimed offender vide order dated 20.02.2016 and was arrested on 30.07.2023. Since the weapon was not recovered from him, offence under Section 201 of IPC was added vide GD No. 39 dated 17.10.2023. Supplementary challan against him was presented on 26.10.2023 (Annexure P-3) and charges were framed on 06.12.2023.
It is argued by learned counsel for the petitioner that he has been falsely implicated in this case. This is a case of version and cross version and the members of the petitioner’s side had only acted in exercise of their right of private defence, since Narinder Singh from their side was shot dead by the complainant party. The petitioner was wrongly declared a proclaimed offender without following the due procedure and he himself surrendered on 30.07.2023. No recovery has been effected from him. There is a material contradiction regarding the weapon attributed to him, as he is shown armed with a 12 bore gun at one place and with a 315 bore rifle at another. The co-accused named in the cross version have already been granted regular bail by this Court (Annexures P-4 to P-7). Learned counsel has further argued that the petitioner has now been in custody for more than 03 years and 03 months. The trial is moving at a very slow pace, as summons issued to the prosecution witnesses are being received back unserved on one date after another (Annexures P-9 to P-11). The complainant of the cross version has not been examined so far, as he himself has been declared a proclaimed offender in two other cases (Annexure P-8). The petitioner is not a previous convict and he undertakes to appear before the trial Court on each date of hearing. It is, thus, urged that the petition deserves to be allowed and the petitioner deserves to be released on bail.
Per contra, learned State counsel, assisted by learned counsel for the complainant, has vehemently opposed the petition by referring to the short reply filed by way of affidavit of the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Sub-Division Rajasansi, Amritsar (Rural). It is argued that there are specific allegations against the petitioner of having fired a shot which hit Jagtar Singh in his abdomen and caused his death. As per the post-mortem report, the cause of death was haemorrhage and shock as a result of laceration of right lung and liver due to firearm injury. The petitioner had absconded after the occurrence and was declared a proclaimed offender on 20.02.2016. He could be arrested only on 30.07.2023. Some of his co-accused in the cross version have already been convicted by the learned trial Court vide judgment dated 28.01.2026. Out of 44 prosecution witnesses cited in the supplementary challan, 06 have been examined so far. Learned State counsel has further argued that the petitioner, if released on bail, may abscond again or may intimidate and influence the prosecution witnesses. Hence, it is urged that the petition is liable to be dismissed.
This Court has heard the rival submissions at considerable length, besides going through the material placed on record.
The petitioner is alleged to have been a member of an unlawful assembly and, in prosecution of its common object, to have fired a shot with his rifle, which hit Jagtar Singh in his abdomen and resulted in his death. Though the allegations make out a prima facie case for commission of the subject offences against the petitioner, the plea of private defence raised on his behalf and the alleged contradiction regarding the weapon are matters to be examined by the learned trial Court on appreciation of evidence. It is true that the previous petition of the petitioner was dismissed by this Court on 18.03.2026. That petition was dismissed keeping in view the specific allegations, his abscondence for a long period and the settled position that the period of custody alone is not sufficient for grant of bail in a serious offence. However, the circumstances have materially changed since then. At that time, the petitioner had been in custody for about 02 years and 07 months, whereas he has now remained in custody for about 03 years and 03 months. The charges were framed against him on 06.12.2023, but only 06 out of 44 prosecution witnesses have been examined in a period of almost three years. The zimni orders dated 15.04.2026, 11.05.2026 and 27.05.2026 (Annexures P-9 to P-11) show that summons issued to the prosecution witnesses were being received back unserved. It is, therefore, obvious that the chances of conclusion of trial in near future are bleak. Obviously, the trial has been unduly prolonged. There is nothing on record to suggest that the delay in conclusion of trial in any manner is attributable to the present petitioner.
So far as the apprehension of the petitioner’s absconding again is concerned, the same can be adequately taken care of by imposing suitable conditions. The conviction of some of the co-accused in the trial held separately against them also cannot be a ground to keep the petitioner behind bars for an indefinite period, since his case is to be decided on the basis of evidence to be led in his own trial. Further incarceration of the petitioner would serve no useful purpose when the trial is not likely to conclude in near future.
It is well settled proposition of law that deprivation of the personal liberty without ensuring speedy trial is not in consonance with the right guaranteed by Article 21 of Constitution of India. Even in cases of serious offences, where some amount of deprivation of personal liberty cannot be avoided, if such period becomes unduly long, the same is against the fairness assured by Article 21 of the Constitution. In Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh vs The State of Maharashtra and another, 2024 (3) RCR (Criminal) 494, it has been observed by Hon’ble Supreme Court that, howsoever, serious a crime may be, an accused has a right to speedy trial as enshrined under the Constitution of India. Bail is not to be withheld as punishment. It was also observed that if the State or any prosecuting agency including the Court concerned has no wherewithal to provide or protect the fundamental right of an accused to have a speedy trial as enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution, then the State or any other prosecuting agency should not oppose the plea for bail on the ground that the crime committed, is serious. Article 21 of the Constitution applies irrespective of the nature of the crime. The Hon’ble Supreme Court had further observed that the over-arching postulates of criminal jurisprudence that an accused is presumed to be innocent unless proven guilty, cannot be brushed aside lightly, howsoever stringent the penal law may be and direction was given for release of appellant on bail.
Reliance can also be placed upon the observations made by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 565 to the effect that the object of bail is to secure the attendance of the accused at the trial and the proper test to be applied in the solution of the question whether the bail should be granted or refused is whether it is probable that the party will appear to take its trial and it is indisputable that the bail is not to be withheld as a punishment.
The question of prolonged incarceration and inordinate delay engaged the attention of Hon’ble Supreme Court in another case cited as Satender Kumar Antil v. Central Bureau of Investigation, (2022) 10 SCC 51, wherein while considering the correct approach towards bail, with respect to several enactments, it was observed that the provisions contained in Section 436-A of Criminal Procedure Code which requires inter alia, the accused to be enlarged on bail if the trial is not concluded within specified periods, would apply to Special Acts also in the absence of specific provisions.
In view of the discussion as made above with regard to the position of law and applying the same to the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case, this Court is of the considered opinion that the petitioner has made out a case for release on bail since his incarceration has been prolonged and there are no chances of conclusion of trial in near future. As such, the petition is allowed and the petitioner is ordered to be admitted to bail subject to his furnishing personal bonds as well as surety bonds by two sureties in the like amount each to the satisfaction of learned trial Court/CJM/Duty Magistrate concerned. The petitioner shall appear before the learned trial Court on each and every date of hearing and shall not leave the country without prior permission of the learned trial Court. In case of violation of any of these conditions, it shall be open to the prosecution to apply for cancellation of his bail.
It is made clear that any observation made herein above is only for the purpose of deciding the present petition and the same shall have no bearing on the merits of the case.
