AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
L.N. Mittal, J.—Plaintiff Surinder Kumar @ Nathu Ram has filed this revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India assailing order dated 30.04.2011 (Annexure P-1) passed by learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Yamunanagar at Jagadhari thereby dismissing plaintiff's application for impounding writing dated 01.06.2005 being unstamped and for permitting the plaintiff-petitioner to pay necessary stamp duty along with penalty.
None is appearing for the petitioner in spite of pass-over.
I have heard learned counsel for the respondent and perused the case file.
Learned trial Court dismissed the application of plaintiff-petitioner on two grounds namely that the plaintiff-petitioner has not proved the said writing and that the original writing has not been placed on record and only photostat copy is there.
The aforesaid approach of the trial Court is patently perverse, illegal and also factually incorrect. On the preceding date of hearing, counsel for the petitioner stated that original writing dated 01.06.2005 had been placed on record of the trial Court and was still available there. Learned counsel for the respondent sought adjournment to verify the same. Having verified it, counsel for the respondent today states that the original writing is available on the records of the trial Court. Accordingly the second ground advanced by the trial Court to dismiss the application of plaintiff-petitioner is factually incorrect.
As regards first ground, the impounding of the unstamped document and payment of stamp duty and penalty for the same has no link with the formal proof of the document. Even after payment of stamp duty and penalty, the plaintiff-petitioner would be required to prove the document in accordance with law. However, plaintiff's application for payment of stamp duty and penalty could not be dismissed by observing that the document has not been proved. Thus entire approach of the trial Court is erroneous, perverse and illegal. The impugned order also suffers from jurisdictional error as the trial Court failed to exercise jurisdiction which vested in it.
For the reasons aforesaid, the instant revision petition is allowed. Impugned order Annexure P-1 passed by the trial Court is set aside. Application moved by the plaintiff-petitioner in the trial Court is allowed and the trial court is directed to impound the writing dated 01.06.2005 and to receive stamp duty and penalty for the same from the plaintiff-petitioner in accordance with law. It is again expressly made clear that this order shall have nothing to do with the formal proof of the writing in question.
