AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
A complaint was filed in FORM ‘M’ on 09.12.2020 by Ms. Suman Yadav (hereinafter referred as “Complainant”) stating that he took membership in the Revanta Multi State CGHS Society (hereinafter referred as “Respondents”) on 12.01.2016 (Application Form dated 12.01.2016) and booked a 3 BHK + SQ Flat (1675 sq. ft.) under their project “Revanta Heights”.
In the complaint, it is submitted by the Complainant that Payment Plan –II 1/3rd of Land cost is to be paid at the time of becoming housing member, 1/3rd of land Cost is to be paid within 45 days of becoming member and 1/3rd of land cost is to be paid at the time of Land Transfer Certificate (LTC).
The Complainant states that a sum of Rs. 15,07,500/- (Rupees Fifteen Lakhs Seven Thousand Five Hundred Only) have been paid to the Respondents till now out of tal consideration of Rs. 22,61,250/- (Rupees Twenty Two Lakhs Sixty One Thousand Two Hundred and Fifty only) for the flat. As he realized later that the Respondents don’t have the authority to construct the flats and they are also not registered with RERA, NCT of Delhi, he has approached the Authority seeking refund of paid amount of Rs. 15,07,500/- (Rupees Fifteen Lakhs Seven Thousand Five Hundred Only).
Preliminary hearing in the case was done on 28.01.2021 and a notice to the Respondents was issued on 25.03.2021.
Shri Shanti Prakash, Advocate for the Complainant and Shri Jatin S. Sethi, Advocate appeared on behalf of the Respondents.
The Respondents filed their Reply on 18.08.2021. The rejoinder was filed by the Complainant on 30.12.2021. The final written submissions were filed on behalf of the Complainant on 03.01.2022 and on behalf of Respondents on 05.01.2022.
For the sake of convenience, the arguments and submission made on behalf of both the parties are summarized as under:
A. Summary of Pleadings by the Complainant
Complainant had applied for the Respondents Society scheme on 12.01.2016 and hence RERA norms which are effective from 2016 are applicable. In “Declaration cum Expression of Interest” form the Respondents have mentioned the applicability of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 to its project.
FIR bearing No. 292 was registered with EOW under sections 406,420,120B of Indian Penal Code, 1860 on 26.12.2019 against the Respondents.
B. Summary of Pleadings by the Respondents
The Respondents is a society registered under the Multi State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002 and Authority lacks jurisdiction to entertain the present complaint as it is hit by Sections 84 and 115 of Multi State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002. Section 84 of Multi State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002 makes it abundantly clear that the dispute between the parties is to be settled before the Arbitrator appointed by the Central Registrar and the decision of the said arbitrator shall be final and cannot not be called in question by any authority.
The complaint is in Form – M for refund, the plea for compensation or interest made by Complainant is not maintainable before this Authority as per the Rule 33 of NCT of Delhi RERA (General) Rules 2016.
The Rule 33 has limited jurisdiction and no compensation, interest, refund can be asked by making an application in Form M before the Authority. Applicant should make an application in Form N before Adjudicating Officer for the purpose, under Rule 34 of the NCT of Delhi RERA (General) Rules 2016.
The Complainant became a member of Respondent Society on 03.07.2015 and the provisions of RE (RD) Act, 2016 cannot be applied retrospectively. Complainant has invested money in the Respondents Society which is formed under the Land Pooling Policy MPD-2021 and the obligations of both the parties are defined under the Multi State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002. Moreover, since the land has not been returned by the appropriate authority to the Respondents, the adjudication of any dispute lies with the Central Registrar of Cooperative Society.
The Complainant has not been able to pin point the date on which cause of action arose. The Authority has to first decide the date when the cause of action arose and under which provision of law the relief can be given.
The Complainant has made payment only towards cost of land and not the flat. The Multi State Cooperative Societies Act 2002 and the bylaws of the Society govern the agreement between the parties and not the RE (RD) Act, 2016. The present complaint is liable to be rejected as the same is misconceived and not tenable as there is no cause of action in favor of Complainant and against the Respondents. The Respondents also pleaded that the complaint need to be dismissed on the grounds of jurisdiction of this Authority as Respondents are a society and have not been registered with Real Estate Regulatory Authority, NCT of Delhi and hence, the Authority lacks jurisdiction to entertain the present complaint.
Considering judgment in case Neelkamal Suburban Realtors Vs. Union of India, 2017 SCC Online Bom 9302, the Respondents claimed that the RE(RD) Act, 2016 is not applicable in this case.
RERA, Punjab in case Bikramjit Singh & ors. Vs. State of Punjab & ors.,by majority has observed that the complaints with respect to unregistered projects would not be maintainable, as the Authority does not have jurisdiction to adjudicate upon such complaints.
The complaint should be resolved as per Section 84(1) of the Multi State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002 which makes it abundantly clear that the dispute between the parties is to be settled before the Arbitrator appointed by the Central Registrar of Co-operative Societies.
As Complaint relate to the acts touching the constitution, management or the business of Respondents, therefore, by virtue of Section 115 of Multistate Cooperative Societies Act 2002, there is an embargo on filling the present application by the Complainant. As per Section 85 of the Multi State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002 the complaint is defective and is liable to be dismissed for being time barred.
C. Analysis and Consideration:
Having considered the arguments and submissions made by both the parties, our observations are as follows.
The clause (iv) of Section 2(zk) of the RE (RD), Act 2016 defines promoter as “an apex State level co-operative housing finance society and a primary co-operative housing society which constructs apartments or buildings for its Members or in respect of the allottees of such apartments or buildings;” and Section 89 gives overriding effect to anything inconsistent with the provisions of RE (RD) Act, 2016. On a plain reading of these two provisions we are unable to agree with the contention of the Respondents that the RE (RD) Act, 2016 is not applicable to co-operative housing societies.
It is evident from the records that the Respondents have received a payment of Rs. 15,07,500/- (Rupees Fifteen Lakhs Seven Thousand Five Hundred Only) from the Complainant under their Housing Scheme.
The Respondents Society has a common membership application form for seeking membership. The Complainant has submitted such a form bearing the stamp and signature on behalf of the Respondents Society. This confirms the details of the unit booked by the Complainant along with other details such as the payment schedule and annual maintenance charges etc.
The contention of the Respondents Society, that the complaint in Form M is not maintainable is not acceptable as the Respondents Society has placed a condition upon the members in the “Declaration cum Expression of Interest” that the project is subject to the provisions of the RE (RD) Act, 2016.
Rule 33(1) of RERD, Rules, 2016 provides inter alia, that an aggrieved person may file a complaint with Authority for any violation under the RERD Act, 2016, “save as those provided to be adjudicated by Adjudicating Officers.” Complaint under Section 31 read with Rule 33(1) has to be filed in FORM M. Section 71 of the RERD Act, 2016 provides inter alia, that for the purpose of adjudging “Compensation” under Section 12, 14, 18 and 19, the Authority shall appoint an adjudicating officer. For seeking “compensation” an aggrieved person has, than, to approach adjudicating officer before whom complaint is to be filed in Form N as provided in Rule 34(1) of RERD, Rules, 2016. In the case of Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of UP And Ors., Civil Appeal Nos.745-6749 of 2019 (DoJ 11.11.2021) the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the scope and functions of adjudicating officer are only for “adjudging compensation”. It is also held in Para 86 of the said judgment that “when it comes to refund of the amount, and interest on the refund amount, or directing payment of interest for delayed delivery of possession, or penalty and interest thereon, it is the regulatory authority which has the power to examine and determine the outcome of a complaint.” Thus, it is clear beyond doubt that complaint in Form N is to be filed only when an aggrieved person is claiming “compensation” under Sections 12,14,16 and 19 before adjudicating officer. The Complainant herein is claiming “refund” with interest; therefore, complaint in Form M is maintainable.
The Respondents has contended that Society is not registered with RERA therefore the Authority has no jurisdiction. We are of the view that registration of society/promoter with RERA is not a sine qua non for exercise of jurisdiction. Section 3 of RERD Act, 2016 reads as under:
“3.(1) No promoter shall advertise, market, book, sell or offer for sale, or invite persons to purchase in any manner any plot, apartment or building, as the case may be, in any real estate project or part of it, in any planning area, without registering the real estate project with the Real Estate Regulatory Authority established under this Act: Provided that projects that are ongoing on the date of commencement of this Act and for which the completion certificate has not been issued, the promoter shall make an application to the Authority for registration of the said project within a period of three months from the date of commencement of this Act: Provided further that if the Authority thinks necessary, in the interest of allottees, for projects which are developed beyond the planning area but with the requisite permission of the local authority, it may, by order, direct the promoter of such project to register with the Authority, and the provisions of this Act or the rules and regulations made thereunder, shall apply to such projects from that stage of registration. (2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), no registration of the real estate project shall be required— (a) where the area of land proposed to be developed does not exceed five hundred square meters or the number of apartments proposed to be developed does not exceed eight inclusive of all phases: Provided that, if the appropriate Government considers it necessary, it may, reduce the threshold below five hundred square meters or eight apartments, as the case may be, inclusive of all phases, for exemption from registration under this Act; (b) where the promoter has received completion certificate for a real estate project prior to commencement of this Act; (c) for the purpose of renovation or repair or re-development which does not involve marketing, advertising selling or new allotment of any apartment, plot or building, as the case may be, under the real estate project. Explanation.—For the purpose of this section, where the real estate project is to be developed in phases, every such phase shall be considered a standalone real estate project, and the promoter shall obtain registration under this Act for each phase separately.”
The first proviso to Section 3 makes it mandatory for “on-going projects” to register with RERA. Section 3(2) (b) however excludes only those projects from this Act, where promoter has received completion certificate. Admittedly, the Respondents Society has not obtained any “completion certificate” so this Authority has jurisdiction because it is “on-going project”.
Section 12 of the RE (RD) Act, 2016 casts a duty upon the promoters to provide any correct and updated information to its members regarding the current status of the project and the likely date by which the project will be completed. Evidently, in complete disregard to its duties, the Respondents have failed to furnish such information to the members.
The law is well settled that the allottees/homebuyers hold an unqualified right to seek refund of the amount with interest at such rate as may be prescribed in this behalf. A conscious decision has been taken by the legislature to cast an obligation upon the promoter to refund the amount on demand along with interest at rate prescribed. It has also been held through the recent judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court that the Regulatory Authority has exclusive jurisdiction to direct refund of the amount, and interest on the refund amount to the allottees. (Vide: Imperia Structures Ltd. Vs. Anil Patni and Another, 2020 (10) SCC 783, and Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of UP And Ors. LL 2021 SC 641).
There is no denying the fact that a statute is the edict of the Legislature and the intention of the legislature is best evidenced by the text of the statute itself. A plain reading of the provisions of the RE (RD) Act 2016 clearly shows that the legislative intent was to protect the affected allottees/homebuyers by incorrect or false statements made by the promoter.
Admitted fact that Complainant became member of Society on 12.01.2016 and booked flat for Rs 22,61,250/- (Rupees Twenty Two Lakhs Sixty One Thousand Two Hundred and Fifty only), he has paid 15,07,500/- (Rupees Fifteen Lakhs Seven Thousand Five Hundred Only) to the Respondents Society.
Thus, in the light of the aforesaid, we consider it appropriate to direct the Respondents M/s Revanta Multistate Co-operative Group Housing Society to refund the entire amount of Rs 15,07,500/- (Rupees Fifteen Lakhs Seven Thousand Five Hundred Only) to the Complainant within 45 days of issuance of this order along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum (MCLR+2%) from the date of payment of each sum until the date of its actual return.
The case is disposed of accordingly.
No orders as to costs.
