High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 11 BOM CK 1073

Sudhir Chakre vs Rajesh Ramdas Wankhade & Anr.

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 2 November 2026

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.600/2013

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

26 paragraphs · 2,682 words

(PER: SHIVKUMAR DIGE, J.)

1.

This appeal is preferred by the son of the deceased (who was allegedly murdered by respondent no.1), challenging the judgment and order passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Amravati, whereby respondent no.1 charged with Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, “IPC”) has been acquitted.

2.

It is prosecution’s case that there was dispute between respondent no.1 and the deceased Niranjan on the ground of construction of `Samaj Mandir’ situated in the Vyankaiyapura area of Amravati. It is alleged that on 31st December 2007, at about 8:30 p.m., when the deceased Niranjan was standing in front of the shop of one Mr.Jaiswal, respondent no.1, Rajesh Wankhade came there and picked up a quarrel with him over an old dispute. Thereafter, respondent no.1 got an axe and assaulted Niranjan on his head and right leg. As a result of the assault, Niranjan sustained injuries and fell on the ground. Respondent no.1 thereafter fled from the spot. At relevant time, PW-8 Police Constable Sanjay Wankhade was on patrolling duty. He received a message from the police station informing that one person was lying in an injured condition in the Vyankaiyapura area. Accordingly, he, along with another police constable, proceeded to the spot and found Niranjan lying in an injured condition. They immediately shifted him to the General Hospital, Amravati, where he was admitted for treatment. Thereafter, PW-8 informed the family members of Niranjan about the incident. As Niranjan was not in a position to speak during that night, his statement could not be recorded. On the next day, the then in-charge of Police Station, Frazerpura directed PW-7 A.S.I. Dhandge to visit the General Hospital, Amravati, and record the statement of Niranjan. Accordingly, PW-7 visited the hospital and gave a letter to the Medical Officer seeking permission to record the statement of the injured Niranjan. He disclosed that he had been assaulted by respondent no.1, Rajesh. On the basis of the said statement, Crime No.2 of 2008 came to be registered against respondent no.1 for the offence punishable under Section 324 of the IPC. Initially, the investigation was carried out by PW-8. During the course of the investigation, respondent no.1 was arrested and the axe used in the crime was recovered under memo of attachment. On 4th January 2008, Niranjan died while undergoing treatment. Hence, Section 302 of the IPC came to be added, and subsequent investigation was taken up by PW-9 Police Inspector Shivshankar Thakur. After completion of the investigation, the charge-sheet came to be filed against respondent no.1. Considering the evidence brought on record, the learned Sessions Judge acquitted respondent no.1.

3.

It is contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that the judgment passed by the learned Sessions Court suffers from several infirmities. The learned Judge has not considered the evidence of PW-1 Dr. Niraj Murke properly and neglected the fact which was certainly established in his evidence. The learned counsel further submits that Dr. Murke in his deposition has specifically stated that injuries at Column nos.17 and 19 are sufficient to cause death in ordinary course. This part of evidence of PW-1 has been completely ignored by the learned Sessions Judge. The learned counsel further submitted that the learned Sessions Judge has disbelieved the dying declaration of the deceased at Exh.46 recorded by PW-7. The learned Judge failed to see that dying declaration can be the sole basis of conviction and unless exceptional circumstances exist, the same may not be disbelieved.

4.

The learned counsel further submitted that the learned Sessions Judge has not considered the oral dying declaration made by the deceased to PW-2 and PW-3, which reveals that respondent no.1/accused assaulted the deceased. The learned counsel further submitted that the axe used in the crime is recovered at the instance of respondent no.1. The learned Sessions Judge has not considered the evidence produced by the prosecution on record properly. The evidence on record points out guilt of respondent no.1. He had motive to kill the deceased as there was a dispute between them regarding construction of `Samaj Mandir’ and requested to allow the appeal. Learned APP adopted the submissions of learned counsel for the appellant.

5.

It is the contention of the learned counsel for respondent no.1 that as per the prosecution case, the incident was witnessed by two eye witnesses – PW-4 Ambadas Bodhankar and PW-5 Sachin Karwade. They have turned hostile and nothing is elicited in their cross-examination. The learned counsel further submitted that the dying declaration recorded by PW-7 was without the requisite medical certificate. PW-6 Sushil Bhasme, the panch witness in whose presence, the axe allegedly used in the crime was attached has turned hostile. The learned counsel further submitted that PW-2 and PW-3, who are sons of deceased, did not go to the hospital to meet their injured father immediately after coming to know about the assault. The Medical Officer, who examined the deceased initially and issued a medical certificate was not examined. The dying declaration of the deceased was recorded by the PW-7 ASI Dhandge. There is no explanation as to why the dying declaration was recorded by a Police Officer and not a Magistrate or a doctor. The learned Sessions Judge has passed a well-reasoned order. No interference is required in it and requested to dismiss the appeal.

6.

We have heard rival submissions of respective parties. Perused the impugned judgment and order and evidence produced on record.

7.

The eye witnesses to the incident, PW-4 Ambadas Bodhankar and PW-5 Sachin Karwade have turned hostile, nothing elicited in their cross-examination. Hence, it is necessary to see other evidence produced on record. As per the prosecution case, on 31st December, 2007 when the deceased was lying injured on the road, he was taken to the hospital by PW-8 Police Head Constable Sanjay Wankhade. He deposed that he received a message from the police station that a quarrel was going on in Vyankaiyapura area. Hence, he along with one constable went to the said area and found a person lying on the ground near electricity distribution pole. He called a jeep from the police station and took the injured person to General Hospital, Amravati. He gave a request letter to the Medical Officer for recording the statement of that person. The Medical Officer examined injured person and told him that the said person was not in a position to give the statement. So, statement of the injured person could not be recorded. During the same night, he went to the house of injured person and informed his family members about his condition. On the next day, based on the statement of the injured person, crime under Section 324 of the IPC came to be registered against respondent no.1. After registering the crime, respondent no.1 was arrested and on the same day, the axe used in the crime was recovered from him under the memo of attachment in the presence of two panchas. The seizure panchanama is at Exh.51. He prepared spot panchanama in presence of panchas. The injured died on 4th January, 2008 while undergoing treatment. Hence, offence under Section 302 of the IPC came to be added. Thereafter, he handed over the investigation to PW-9 Shivshankar Thakur.

During cross-examination, he admitted that when Niranjan was being admitted in the hospital, he was under the influence of alcohol and after recovery of axe, the axe was not sealed.

8.

As per the prosecution’s case, dying declaration of the deceased was recorded by PW-7 A.S.I. Patwardhan Dhandge. He deposed that P.I. Sheikh directed him to go to General Hospital, Amravati and record the statement of Niranjan. He went to the General Hospital, Amravati and requested the Medical Officer for permission to record the statement of injured Niranjan. Thereafter, he recorded the statement of Niranjan. As per the statement of Niranjan, respondent no.1 had assaulted him with an axe on his head and legs due to an old dispute. The dying declaration is at Exh.46 and offence under Section 324 of the IPC was registered against respondent no.1. During cross-examination, he admitted that on 31st December, 2007 i.e. day of incident, the police from Frazerpura Police Station had been to the General Hospital, Amravati for recording the statement of Niranjan but, due to his physical condition on that day, the statement was not recorded. He further admitted that the request letter (Exh.45) given by him to the Medical Officer does not indicate any time as to when it was given or when the Medical Officer put his endorsement on it. He further admitted that before recording of dying declaration, he had not tried to record the statement of Niranjan through the Executive Magistrate or any other authority. Exh.46 does not indicate as to when he started recording the statement of Niranjan and when it was completed. He further admits that the dying declaration does not have any endorsement of the Medical Officer or endorsement of this witness stating about the physical condition of the injured. Though the prosecution is emphasizing on the dying declaration of the deceased but the evidence of this witness, who recorded dying declaration shows that there is no endorsement of the Medical Officer on the said declaration or request letter to show that the deceased was in a fit condition to give the dying declaration. Moreover, on the previous day i.e. 31st December, 2007, when the police team had gone to record the dying declaration of the deceased, it could not be recorded because he was not in the fit physical condition to give the statement. So, it was incumbent on PW-7, who recorded dying declaration of the deceased to take the endorsement of the Medical Officer about his physical condition, but it was not taken. It casts doubt on the prosecution case about the physical and mental fitness of the deceased while giving the dying declaration. It is significant to note that after recording dying declaration, though injured was admitted in the hospital, offence under Section 324 of the IPC was registered against respondent no.1 and not under Section 307 of the IPC. It is the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that the deceased had given oral dying declarations to PW-2 Sudhir Chakre and PW-3 Ratnapal Chakre, sons of the deceased. According to the evidence of PW-2, his father Niranjan told him that respondent no.1 assaulted him with axe due to dispute over Buddha Vihar, whereas according to PW-3 Ratnapal, his father told him that respondent no.1 assaulted him with axe on his legs and head. So, the deposition of both these witnesses about oral dying declaration is not consistent. It appears from the record that though PW-2 and PW-3 learnt about assault on their father, they did not approach the police station immediately and their statements came to be recorded on 6.1.2008 and 7.1.2008. PW-3, in his deposition claimed that his statement was recorded by Frazerpura Police Station on 1.01.2008, however, that statement was not produced on record.

9.

It is contended that the death of deceased was homicidal and it is proved by the evidence of PW-1 Dr, Niraj Murke, who conducted post-mortem of the deceased. He found the following injuries :-

(a)

There was a sutured wound over the parieto occipital region in the center which was sutured with linen. There were two sutures in center and the injury is vertical. He removed the sutures. He found the edges of the injury were irregular having size of 2 cm x ½ cm x muscle deep.

(b)

2nd wound was sutured wound in the right para umbilical region para hyedian incision surgical, vertical with ten stitches with linen. On removal of sutures he found that the would was with clear and regular edges. It was vertical having size of 11 cm long x 2 cm wide and cavity deep. There was evidence of intestinal perforation which was sutured with vicryl seen in ileum region.

(c)

3rd injury which was horizontal having size of 1 inch x 1 cm with regular edges in right hypochondriac region.

(d)

4th injury was a plaster of paris (POP) cast on the left leg starting from thigh to ankle. I removed the POP casting. I have seen there was an oblique sutured wound with three linen sutured on lateral two fingers below the left knee.

(e)

5th injury was compound fracture of left tibia, upper end was seen.

(f)

6th injury was horizontal abrasion having size of 2 cm x 1 cm on medial aspect of right knee.

(g)

7th injury abrasion vertical 2 cm x 1 cm on lateral aspect of right knee.

All the above injuries were ante-mortem. He opened the skull of dead body and found that there were minimal hemorrhagic patches over the dura. There was no evidence of fracture. The brain was edematous and congested. The above internal injury was corresponding to external injury no.1 stated above. The small intestine was distended with gases, mucosa was pale. There was evidence of closure of intestinal perforation. There was yellowish discoloration along the sutures.

PW-1 opined that the death of Niranjan was caused due to intestinal perforation, closure done with compound fracture of left tibia with septicemia and shock. The injuries mentioned in column Nos. 17 & 19 at Exh.30 are sufficient to cause death in ordinary course. All the external injuries mentioned in Column No.17 at Sr. No.1 to 7 are possible due to sharp weapon, axe.

During cross-examination, he admitted that septicemia is always a secondary cause of death. The external injury nos.2 and 3 as stated in Column no.17 are operational injuries. Abrasion is caused if the body of person comes in contact of hard or rough surface. It may be caused due to a fall as well and the external injury nos. 6 and 7 are abrasions. He further admitted that cause of injury no.1, there was no internal damage and injury no.4 i.e. fracture below the left knee was already treated and also plastered and the death may not be caused due to shock of injury no.4. He further admitted that ulcer was one of the causes of perforation in the intestine and sometimes, natural death may occur due to perforation by ulcer. Consuming alcohol is one of the causes of ulcer. It depends upon the quantity of alcohol that is consumed. He admitted that septic condition had developed in the small intestine only. He further admitted that if the injury is caused with a sharp weapon, the edges of the injury should be sharp too. The edges of the injury no.1 in column no.17 were found to be irregular. There is no mention as to what type of edges were of injury no.4 i.e. fracture below the left knee. He further admitted that in Exh.31, he has not specifically opined that injuries found on the person of the deceased Niranjan were caused by blade of the axe. He further admitted that death of Niranjan might have been caused due to post operational intestine septicemia.

10.

As per the prosecution case, respondent no.1 had assaulted on the head and legs of the deceased and as per the testimony of PW-1, death of deceased was caused due to intestinal perforation, closure done with compound fracture of left tibia with septicemia and shock. PW-1 admitted that ulcer is one of the causes of intestinal perforation and due to perforation by ulcer, natural death may occur.

11.

Thus, it appears that death of deceased was due to perforation in the intestine. It has come on record that the deceased was under the influence of the liquor at the time of incident and consumption of alcohol may cause ulcer. The prosecution has not examined the doctor, who treated the deceased initially, while he was admitted in the hospital.

12.

From the evidence produced on record, the prosecution failed to prove the case against respondent no.1 beyond doubt. The learned Sessions Judge has passed a well-reasoned order. No interference is required in it and we pass following order:-

ORDER

Criminal Appeal is dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.