AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Nevaskar, J.—Accused Bhogiram S/o Daryab Prasad Brahmin of Lashkar was prosecuted for (he murder of his wife Vidhya before the Sessions Judge Gwalior, who found him guilty and sentenced him to death.
The accused has preferred an appeal against his conviction.
This appeal and the proceedings for confirmation of the sentence of death have been placed before us for consideration.
Facts as alleged by the prosecution are as follows: Accused Bhogiram was married to deceased Vidhya about three years prior to the incident. The accused was a police-constable and was posted at Lashkar, It is said that the accused ill-treated his wife and for that reason the relations between him on the one hand and those of deceased Vidhya and her parents Shyamlal and Lexmibai on the lather, had got strained. Since about four months prior to the incident the relations had considerably got worse. The accused attributed misappropriation of his ornaments and cash through his wife to Shyamlal while the deceased as well as her parents attributed brutality in his treatment to the deceased. Some time in June 1955, when the accused was away on duty to Nagpur, Vidhya went away to stay with her parents. The accused filed complaint of theft against his wife and her parents. In connection with this complaint, the deceased and her parents were detained in police custody for over 12 hours on 27-7-1955. The deceased on the other hand filed a suit for judicial separation under Hindu Marriage Act No. 25 of 1955 on 29-7-1955. The notice of this suit was served upon the accused and he was required to file written statement to the Plaintiff's allegations of cruelty and the acts of adultery attributed to the accused Defendant on 3-10-1955. However before this, on 11-9-1955 an agreement was executed through the Intervention of Panchas by the accused, admitting his error in securing the detention of the deceased and her parents and further admitting that the allegations made by him in his complaint regarding the ornaments were untrue and that he would thereafter treat her well and live with her amicably. On the faith of this agreement the deceased was sent by her parents to the house of the accused. Both the accused and Shyamlal lived close by in Pan Patte-ki-Got, Lashkar.
The accused however is said to have persisted in his acts of cruelty. Thereupon the deceased Vidhya addressed a letter through registered post to Superintendent of Police requesting him to make a provision for her maintenance by deducting half the salary of the accused or to find a suitable service for her as she did not hope to Jive in peace with the accused for life. This was on 11-10-1955. It is said the acknowledgment receipt of this letter was received back in the same house and got into the hands of the accused at about 10 A.M. This completely put out the accused. It is said that he at once got determined to kill her. With this object, be sent away his aunt and his younger brother some time in the noon and thereafter at about 2 or 2-30 commenced stabbing Vidya with a knife. The unhappy girl began to run about on the roof of the house with the accused chasing her. He gave her several stab wounds. The girl fell down senseless. The accused then got out into the lane in which his house stood. There Vidya's younger brother, Prem was found playing. He seized him and began to stab him too. The mother of the two unhappy victims of his wrath, on seeing that her son was being stabbed, rushed to save him. She too was stabbed when she pushed him aside and wrested away her son from his clutches. Persons in the neighbourhood rushed. One Kamala Kachhi, who resided in the neighbourhood, brought down the accused on the ground. The knife in his hand got bent in this act of felling him down and slipped from his hand. Shankar, Narayansingh and several others, who bad by that time reached the place, took the accused to the Police Station along with the knife.
Laxmibai the mother of the deceased lodged a report at Madhoganj Police Station at 3 P.M., that is within half an hour of the incident, stating therein that when she snatched away her son from his clutches, the accused stabbed her saying that he had killed Vidhya and that be would wipe out her family. It was further stated in the report that Vidhya was killed by the accused.
The accused was thereupon put under formal arrest and Panchnama of seizure of knife and the shirt of the accused was made.
The dead body of deceased Vidhya was sent for post-mortem-examination. Her mother Laxmibai and brother Prem too ware sent for medical examination.
The post-mortem-report indicated 26 injuries in neck, chest, hands, legs all caused by a sharpedged and pointed weapon. According to the opinion of the doctor the death was caused due to shock as a result of haemorrhage due to multiple injuries and particularly due to injuries No. 9 and 10 described in his report which cut pleura, pericardium and right auricle, the cut in the last organ vig. enough to admit one finger. Aorta was also reported to have been cut. The police after investigation put up a Challan u/s 302 I.P.C. against the accused.
In the Committing Magistrate's Court the accused engaged counsel, one Mr. Omprakash Saxena and gave complete instruction to him to cross-examine the prosecution witnesses.
There in his statement, which was taken on record of Sessions Court u/s 287 Criminal Procedure Code, the accused denied the commission of the offence and the statements and circumstances relied upon by the prosecution in support of it. He admitted the fact that Vidhya was his wife and that be was absent from duty after 12 noon on the date of the incident. According to him, his father-in-law had taken Rs. 1000- from him for giving his daughter in marriage to him and that later on he had misappropriated his ornaments worth Rs. 11500- and that when he had demanded the same back from him he was about to abscond when be was called at the Thana through Station Officer Dixit and that for that reason they were putting up false ease against him due to ill-will.
The learned Magistrate committed the accused to stand his trial before the Court of Sessions.
The trial opened on 23-3-1956. Mr. Hamid Ali Shah appeared as a counsel on his behalf. The counsel probably must have bees engaged by his father. The accused at the commencement of the trial objected to his being represented by him and wanted one of the two leading criminal lawyers at Gwalior, Mr. Dey and Anand to appear for him.
Accordingly the cross-examination of the first witness was postponed to enable Mr. Dey, who was hurriedly called to secure instructions from the accused. The case was fixed for 25-5-1956. On this day Mr. Dey appeared for him and submitted a petition requesting for consolidation of this case with another case u/s 307 I.P.C. in respect of assault upon Prem and Laxmibai. This prayer was rejected and the trial was ordered to proceed At that stage Mr. Dey withdrew and Mr. Anand appeared for the accused. At first he too tried to get the case adjourned but later agreed to continue and admitted that he had full instructions in the case from the accused.
The trial accordingly proceeded from 25-5-1956 to 1-6-1956 and all the prosecution witnesses were completely examined and cross-examined.
Thereafter when the learned Sessions Judge proceeded to examine the accused u/s 342 Criminal Procedure Code, the accused refused to give reply. Mr. Anand was asked by the Court to persuade him to give reply. Mr. Anand stated that accused would be amenable to pursuations of Mr. Saxena who had appeared for him in the Committing Magistrate's Court. Thereupon Mr. Saxena was called but the latter did not appear. The accused in spite of persuasions by the Court was stubborn in his refusal. Thereafter Mr. Anand was asked to state which of the defence witnesses he wanted to examine. The case was fixed for the following day. On 2-6-1956 Mr. Om Prakash Saxena appeared and put in an application suggesting for the first time, the insanity of the accused on the ground that when he triad to speak to him, there appeared an incoherence in his replies. The learned Counsel suggested that the brain of the accused might have been affected due to the circumstance that when P.W. 11 Shyamlal was being examined, the accused was required not to interrupt his statement. A prayer was made in the application that the accused be sent for examination to the Mental Hospital. This application was rejected. Mr. Saxena was asked to submit the list of the defence witnesses which the accused wanted to examine. Mr. Saxena gave the list and the case was fixed on 4-6-1956 and later on to 9-6-1956 and 24-8-1956 for examination of the defence witnesses. On the last mentioned date, the accused was not produced from jail and the Jail Superintendent wrote to say that he had been sent to the Mental Hospital Gwalior for observation under the orders of the Court of Municipal Magistrate where the proceedings of commitment in connection with the sister case u/s 307 I.P.C. was going on. The Superintendent Mental Hospital after eight weeks of observation informed the Magistrate on 6-9-1956 that he was of the opinion that there is an element of feigning but that close observations revealed that there is some unsoundness of mind and needs treatment.
The Court of Session however did not take notice of this and fixed the date for bearing on 24-9-1956. On this day while the learned Sessions Judge was in Bhamber, he was informed about the Coming of the accused undressed in Court. It was at this stage that the learned Judge referred back the accused to the Superintendent Mental Hospital again asking him to give his considered opinion about the mental condition of the accused and informing him that he would be examined in Court In respect of his opinion. Accordingly the Superintendent sent in his report on 17-11-1956. In this report the Superintendent again stated that "the accused is of unsound mind though there is element of feigning". On 23-11-1956 the Superintendent who gave the opinion was cross-examined by the public prosecutor in respect of the opinion. In view of the statement of Dr. Kale thus recorded and the personal observation of the accused by him with regard to the behaviour of the accused in Court, the learned Sessions Judge found the accused to be not of unsound mind and held him to be fully able to make his defence. He accordingly proceeded to examine the defence witnesses. After the close of the case, on such examination he heard arguments and found the accused guilty u/s 302 I.P.C. and sentenced him to death.
The learned Sessions Judge relied upon the statements of the three eye-witnesses P.W. 13 Indira, P.W. 14 Sushila and P.W. 15 Nalini. He further relied upon the circumstantial evidence consisting of the statement of Laxmibai, the mother of the deceased, Kamala Kachhi who arrived on the scene soon after and fell the accused down. Dr. Shridharrao Dubey who examined the dead body and also the accused and the recovery of blood stained shirt and the recovery of knife as well as oral and documentary evidence regarding the strained relations between the deceased and her husband. As a result he found the accused guilty. He therefore convicted the accused u/s 302 I.P.C. as he found that it was the accused who caused the death of his wife with a knife.
In this case learned Counsel Mr. J.P. Gupta who appeared for him raised the following contentions:
(1) The accused was of unsound mind when the trial took place.
(2) The learned Sessions Judge having decided to hold Inquiry did not comply with the provisions of Section 468 Criminal Procedure Code. The trial was therefore illegal and the decision ought to be quashed and the accused retried in respect of his alleged insanity.
(3) Assuming that the finding of the learned Sessions Judge dated 27-11-1956, that the accused was not of unsound mind, be correct, the Court ought to have held the trial de novo from the commencement.
(4) 1 he decision upon merits was incorrect.
The learned Counsel relied upon the decisions reported in Shib Das Kundu Vs. King-Emperor, Shib Das Kundu v. King Emperor, and AIR 1954 TK 435, State v. Kochin Chellayyan for his contention No. (2) and (3) noted above.
I shall proceed to consider each of the aforesaid four contentions.
As regards the first, there is a clear finding of the learned Sessions Judge dated 27-11-1956 that the accused was not of unsound mind and was quite capable of making his defence.
According to the learned Judge's view, the insanity put forward at a late stage of the trial was feigned. In arriving at his decision the learned Sessions Judge sent the accused to the mental hospital for observation and after receipt of his report he examined the Superintendent of Mental Hospital before him. The learned Sessions Judge as a result of his conduct and behaviour in Court, absence of any such plea at an earlier stage and the statement of the Superintendent taken before him with opportunity to cross-examine him held the accused not insane. The procedure followed by the Judge was legal, No attempt was made on behalf of the accused who was represented by senior lawyers to give other evidence.
The finding thus arrived at cannot be said to be Incorrect. I have detailed out circumstances in the foregoing part of the judgment to indicate how the accused was perfectly competent to look after his defence, bow he changed counsel from time to time after attempting to secure adjournment. The learned Judge also noted in the judgment that to him too the madness appeared to be patently feigned.
The above discussion will also show that the trial with respect to his suspected insanity was regularly made.
Even if there had been some irregularity in failure to comply with a certain rule the trial cannot be held to be illegal or bad. This appears plain from the decision of Assam High Court in AIR 1953 Ass 1 , Asha Das and Ors. v. The State, which relied inter alia upon the decision of Nagpur High Court in AIR 1940 375 (Nagpur) Emperor v. Mehtar Dhanwa Satnami and others.
The next question to be considered is whether the learned Sessions Judge should have recommenced the trial de novo from the very start and ought not have taken up the thread from where it was broken.
In my opinion under the circumstances of this case where the suggestion for insanity for the first time was made after the whole of prosecution case was over and what was left to be done was to examine the three defence witnesses in accordance with the instructions of the accused, this is by no means necessary.
Section 465 Code of Criminal Procedure is as follows:
(1) In any person committed for trial before a Court of Sections or a High Court appears to the Court at his trial to be of unsound mind and consequently incapable of making his defence, the jury, or the Court with the aid of assessors, shall, in the first instance, try the fact of such unsoundness and incapacity, and if the jury or Court, as the case may be, is satisfied of the fact the Indge shall record a finding to that effect and shall postpone further proceedings in the case and the jury, if any, shall be discharged.
(2) The trial of the fact of the unsoundness of mind and incapacity of the accused shall be deemed to be part of his trial before the Court.
It is clear from this provision that the trial of the fact of unsoundness of mind and Incapacity of the accused is to be deemed to be part of his trial. Therefore where in the midst of trial the fact of the unsoundness of his mind was raised and decided against the accused and the trial is then proceeded with, there is no break in the trial. Section 467 moreover justifies the resumption of the trial. There is nothing in Section 467 to justify the view that the trial has to be held de novo. In the absence of anything specific to that effect it will be a question of propriety whether the trial should begin from the start. If, as in this case, the question of insanity at the trial, was for the first time raised after the entire prosecution evidence was over and it was found that the insanity was feigned and the trial resumed soon after there is no illegality as regards the mode of trial and the trial Is not vitiated (A.I.R. 1947 PC 67, Pulukuri Kottaya and Ors. v. Emperor). The decision relied upon on behalf of the accused does not give reasons for the view that it should begin again from the start.
The last question to be considered is as regards the correctness of the view of the learned Sessions Judge on merits. The evidence against the accused is both direct and circumstantial. Direct evidence consists of the statements of the three eye-witnesses Indira, Sushila and Nalini.
His Lordshipthen discussed the evidence and came to the conclusion that:
In view of the statements of the eye-witnesses, the circumstantial evidence regarding the strained relations between Vidhya and her parents on the one band and the accused on the other, the conduct of the accused after the incident in injuring Prem and Laxmibai and his confessional statement to Laxmibai, the condition of the knife which got bent and broken doe to his being thrown down by Kamla Kachhi, his blood-stained shirt and finally his immediate arrest corroborated by the medical evidence regarding Injuries to the deceased, Prem, Laxmibai and scratches to the accused, there remains not an iota of doubt that it was the accused who caused the death of his wife Vidhya by using a knife.
Some point was sought to be made on behalf of the accused regarding absence of human blood upon the knife as appeared from the report of Imperial Serologist. But explanation for this absence is available from the fact that the scrapings from the knife were not received by the Imperial Serologist, Calcutta till 16-1-1956 i.e. for over three months and he reported that the blood-stains had been disintegrated and their origin could not be determined. However the direct evidence of eye-witnesses and the condition of the knife which fully corroborated their statements clearly establish the fact that it was this knife which was used by the accused.
The conclusions arrived at by the learned Sessions Judge appear to be fully justified in view of the evidence discussed above.
I am further of the view that the accused was not of unsound mind at the time of the trial and that there was neither any Illegality as to the mode of trial nor any prejudice caused to the accused. It may be mentioned in passing that on the first day when the hearing began in this Court, the accused tried to show that be was of unsound mind by blutting out when his name was uttered by the counsel saying why his name was being mentioned. But on the 2nd day when the arguments on the question of unsoundness were over he submitted a petition saying that he was of unsound mind at the time of trial but that he is now perfectly sound and that for that reason the case might be sent back for retrial. This conduct of the accused is significant.
The conviction of the accused was therefore proper.
The last thing to be considered is as regards the sentence.
The relations between the accused and his wife were not cordial. It appears that at one stage there was settlement but the accused persisted in his behaviour with his wife and the wife therefore complained to his superior. This brought the accused in temper. He therefore took a knife and caused as many as 26 injuries with a knife. The unfortunate and helpness girl was running about on the roof calling for help to save her and the accused persisted in his attack. His conduct in sending away his aunt and her son indicated a certain amount of deliberation. There was motive. In view of this the sentence awarded was the only proper sentence.
The appeal therefore, filed by the accused is dismissed and the sentence of death passed by the learned Sessions Judge against the accused is hereby confirmed.
Khan, J.
I agree with my learned brother that the appeal of the accused be dismissed and that the sentence of death passed against him by the Sessions Judge should be confirmed. I would, however, briefly refer to two facts. First, is the plea taken by the counsel of the accused that since he developed insanity, the trial in the lower Court should have been stayed according to Section 465 of the Code of the Criminal Procedure, But the trial is to be postponed only if the Judge after making an enquiry (which was made in this case by the Sessions Judge) comes to the conclusion that the accused is of unsound mind and consequently incapable of making his defence. But where the Judge does not consider the accused to be of unsound mind, as in this case, then the question of postponement does not at all arise. The statement of Dr. Kale about the mental condition of the accused is not convincing. He has stated that "there is an element of feigning in his behaviour and there is some unsoundness of the mind also." But there is one thing very significant In the cross-examination of the doctor and It is that when the accused was observed (he being aware of observation) he acts in a way which inclines one to his being somewhat unbalanced, but the moment he is observed without knowing that he is being observed, he acts in a normal way and even reads a newspaper and talks to other patients. This attitude of the accused or rather this behaviour of the accused is a positive indication of the fact that he is merely feigning insanity. One possible explanation of this assumed Insanity can be that he and his counsel both tried that his trial for the murder of his wife should be postponed till the other case, in which be is accused of making a murderous assault on his brother-in-law Prem and mother in law Laxmibai is committed to the Sessions, and that both the cases should be tried together. But they failed in their attempt to have this case postponed and so In order to achieve that end, the accused has been feigning insanity.
The evidence in this case apart from the proof of motive of the accused, mainly consists of three eye-witnesses, Indira P.W. 13, Sushila P.W. 14 and Nalini P.W. 15 and the statement of Laxmibai P.W. 1, to whom he gave the news that he had killed her daughter and whom he further threatened by saying that he would wipe off the entire family.
The only criticism worth referring to about the eye-witnesses is that their statements were not recorded soon after the incident. It is true, but there is a good reason for it. The husband of Sushila was out and without consulting him as to the propriety of their act, Sushila his wife, Indira, his daughter and Naiini his tenant (all ladies), were averse to making a statement to Police. It is common knowledge that in India, ladies feel shy of coming to court and giving evidence. And the difference of young ladies (Sushila is 35, Indira is 16 and Nalini is 24 years old) to appear before the Sub-Inspector Vishnu Kumar Gupta, who is himself about 40 years of age, is quite understandable. Therefore if in these circumstances their statements were recorded rather late in the Police, the delay can be appreciated. But their statements in the Court when read carefully do not support the suggestion that these witnesses were in any way tutored. The trial Court, which had the opportunity to observe their demeanour has placed reliance in them and to me also there appears to be no smell of any cooking about them.
The manner in which the accused dealt blows after blows, causing no less then 26 stab-wounds on a defenceless woman, calls forth for a deterrant sentence. There is not a single extenuating circumstance and the sentence of death is the only punishment, which the accused deserves.
