AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
THIS complaint has been filed on behalf of Dr. (Mrs.) Medha Karnik, a dental surgeon at Tiruchirapalli for damages for the mental and physical agony suffered by her on account of the negligence of the opposite party.
DR. (Mrs.) Karnik reserved a II Class ticket in April'' 90 for her journey from Trichy to Bombay where her parents are living commencing on 15.5.90 from Trichy by Rockfort Express (Train No. 6178) to Madras and on 16.5.90 by Chennai Express (Train No. 6064) from Madras to Bombay. She was issued a confirmed ticket by Rock Fort Express (S 4/28) and a few days later after getting confirmation from Madras, the Trichy reservation office noted down on the ticket the reservation number for Chennai Express (Train No. 6064) as S/44/6064/16.5.90. Assured of her reservation in both the segments, DR. (Mrs.) Karnik left Trichy with her 1 year old child and a large luggage on 15.5.90 by Rock Fort Express at 10.00 P.M. and arrived in Egmore, Madras early in the morning on 16.5.90. She rushed to Central Station to catch the Chennai Express scheduled to leave at about 7.30 A.M. only to find that Chennai Express did not ply on 16.5.90 being Wednesday. She learnt that this Express ran from Madras only on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, Saturdays and Sundays. Mrs. Karnik tried her best to get a reserved accommodation in Dadar Express which was leaving for Bombay at 9.30 A.M. but in vain. She had perforce to travel in an unreserved compartment in Dadar Express which was over-crowded and after experiencing untold hardship she reached Bombay by 1.00 P.M. on 17.5.90. Hence this complaint. The Opposite Parties have filed a counter through the Deputy Chief Commercial Superintendent. Mrs. Karnik was reserved a seat in Chennai Express only on 15.5.90 (Tuesday) and information to that effect was given to the Trichy reservation counter. On 16.5.90, Chennai Express did not run being Wednesday and as Dadar Express reservation was full and there was no cancellation, Dr. Karnik could not be helped. It is further averred that the information that Chennai Express leaves Madras only on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, Saturdays and Sundays is readily available in the Railway time table and Dr. (Mrs.) Karnik, as a prudent passenger ought to have verified whether this train was running on 16.5.90. The trouble was due to her "inadequacy of knowledge" and she was also guilty of "contributory misrepresentation". Dr. (Mrs.) Karnik is not therefore entitled to allege deficiency of service or negligence on the part of the Railway. She did not suffer any injury and cannot claim any compensation and the compensation claimed is excessive and exaggerated.
Dr. (Mrs.) Karnik has examined herself as P.W.I, and through her is marked the railway ticket issued to her as Ex. P. 1. Her evidence is that in the middle of April 1990, she through her husband and a travel agency purchased Ex. PI, II class ticket for her annual journey to Bombay where her parents and parents-in-law reside by Rock Fort Express on 15.5.90 to Madras and from there to Bombay on 16.5.90 by Chennai Express. At the time of the purchase of the ticket itself she got confirmed reservation for travel on 15.5.90 by Rockfort Express from Trichy to Madras and the endorsement therefor is made on the reverse of the ticket as "S4/28. 6178/15.5.90" (6178 is the number given to Rock Fort Express) a few days later after getting confirmation from Madras Central, the reservation clerk at Trichy made the endorsement MMe/S/44/6064/16.5.90 denoting confirmed reservation for travel by Chennai Express (Train No. 6064) on 16.5.90 on which day the said Express did not ply from Madras, being a Wednesday. This is a clear case of patent error and palpable negligence on the part of the railway staff who made the endorsement of confirmation. According to the opposite parties, the confirmation for P.W.I. for her onward journey from Madras had really been made in Chennai Express leaving Madras on 15.5.90 and a message to this effect has been given to the Trichy reservation office. If this is true, the negligence on the part of the reservation staff at Trichy is still more serious. The Railway administration is vicariously responsible for this act of gross negligence.
IT is urged on behalf of the Railway, that the information pertaining to the running of Chennai Express from Madras only on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, Saturdays and Sundays is given in the Railway time-table and P. W. I. as a prudent passenger ought to have verified the same and the error was due to her inadequacy of knowledge of the schedule of service and she was guilty of contributory misrepresentation. This is really adding insult to injury. Every passenger cannot be expected to purchase a time table and scan through it before booking a ticket. If "want of prudence" or "inadequacy of knowledge" of the service schedule of the Railways is attributed to P.W.I, what about the railway staff who issued the confirmation of reservation? Rule 1.1 of the Rules for advance reservation found in the Southern Railway Time Table issued on 1.5.90 reads: "The Railway Administration may reserve a Seat, Berth or Compartment of a carriage, as the case may be in accordance with the rules and conditions published in the coaching Tariff and Time Table (emphasis ours) should not the Railway reservation clerk have read the time table before making the confirmation? In the matter of confirmation of reservation, the ultimate responsibility rests with the Railway and no question of "Contributory misrepresentation" on the part of the passenger arises. The fault is entirely with the concerned member of the Railway staff and Railway Administration cannot try to escape liability therefor. We have no hesitation in holding the Railway responsible for the gross negligence and deficiency of service.
Now to the question of compensation. P.W.I. commenced her journey to Bombay with her 13 months old child and 30 kilo luggage on the assurance of confirmation of reservation in both the segments on the 15th and 16th of May 1990. She arrived at Egmore Station early in the morning on 16.5.90 and rushed to the Central Station to board the non- starting Chennai Express scheduled to leave at about 7.00 A.M. On coming to know of this distressing fact, she was stupefied and her tale of woe started. She say she went to the Assistant Station Master's office and was guided to the office of the Reservation Suprein- tendent in the erstwhile Moore Market Complex across the "sweet smelling" Coovum. It was closed, she went to the T.T.E''s office, went back to the Reservation Supreindendent's office, met the Reservation Supervisor who was a lady, who finally expressed her helpness to get a reservation in the Dadar Express which was to leave for Bombay at about 9.00 A.M. She then decided to go in an unreserved compartment in Dadar Express. She was literally pushed into the compartment by the surging crowd and managed to get a seat by the window. The compartment was overfull, passengers were sitting and standing all around, she could not feed her crying child and she went up and travelled in the luggage left without food or water. She had even to drug her child with phenargan to make it drowsy. She reached Bombay at about 1.00 P.M. on 17.5.90 after 27 hours of journey, nay or trial and tripulation. Her testimoney makes a dismal reading and she claims compensation in the sum of Rs. 2,25,000/- for the mental and physical agony undergone by her. It is admitted by her in cross-examination that her engagements in and beyond Bombay were not affected and it is therefore urged on behalf of the opposite parties, that P.W.I, has not suffered any loss or damage. This is missing the essential P.W.I, claims compensation not for reaching Bombay late or for loss of engagement thereafter, but for the sufferings mental and physical undergone by her at the Central Station at Madras and during her arduous and hazarduous journey to Bombay, for which she is entitled to claim compensation.
MUCH as we sympathise with her, we cannot help feeling that the amount of compensation claimed by her is arbitrary and exorbitant. This is not a case for awarding punitive or exemplary damages, for the hardship caused to P.W.I, was due to the negligence of the Reservation Clerk and not due to any deliberate, wilful or intentional act or omission. Nor is the fact that the Southern Railway is a big undertaking a ground for awarding disproportionate compensation as claimed by the complaint. In our considered view, a compensation of Rs. 7,500/- will be sufficient to meet the ends of justice. In the result we order the opposite parties (a) to pay a sum of Rs. 7,500/- as compensation to P.W.I, and (b) to pay Rs. 500/- as costs to the complainant The payments shall be made within 30 days of the receipt of the copy of this judgement. Complaint allowed with cost.
