AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Jaswant Singh, J.—Plaintiff/appellant is in second appeal against the judgements and decrees of the courts below, whereby her suit for permanent and mandatory injunction was dismissed by the trial court and in appeal the findings of the trial court were upheld.
Briefly noticed the facts of the case are that plaintiff filed a suit alleging therein that she entered into an agreement to sell dated 7.10.1997 with the defendant/respondent in respect of a plot measuring 100 sq. yards for total sale consideration of Rs.50,000/-out of which Rs.40,000/-were paid to the defendant/respondent and the remaining amount of Rs.10,000/-was to be paid at the time of execution and registration of the sale deed. It was further agreed between the parties that defendant would get necessary corrections in the revenue record in respect of the suit property and would thereafter intimate the plaintiff and it was thereafter that the sale deed was to be executed. It was alleged that though the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform her part of the contract but defendant failed to perform his part of contract and instead was bent upon to alienate the suit property to some other person. Accordingly it was prayed that a decree of mandatory injunction be passed directing the defendant to execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff as also to deliver the vacant possession of the suit property to the plaintiff.
Upon notice defendant filed written statement denying the execution of the agreement to sell dated 7.10.1997. It was specific case of the defendant/respondent that the alleged agreement to sell was a forged and fabricated document. Further the receipt of Rs.40,000/-as part payment was also denied.
On the pleadings of the parties issues were framed. Both sides lead evidence in support of their respective pleas and after appreciating the oral/documentary evidence learned trial Court dismissed the suit which was further upheld by the learned Appellate Court. Hence the present second appeal.
It is submitted by learned Counsel for the appellant that both the Courts below while dismissing the suit of the plaintiff have based their findings on misreading of evidence and as such the impugned judgments and decrees are liable to be set aside.
After hearing learned Counsel I find no merit in the submission made on behalf of the appellant.
The learned Trial Court while dismissing the suit of the plaintiff has observed that during her cross examination plaintiff Vimlesh(PW-1) stated that she had no knowledge whether any target date for execution of the sale deed was fixed or not rather it was her stand that sale deed was to be executed after the marriage of the daughter. It was further admitted by PW-1 that though the marriage of the daughter was solemnized in the year 1997, however, no notice was given to the defendant by the plaintiff. With regard to the alleged payment of Rs.40,000/-it was stated by the plaintiff that a receipt was executed but the same was lost and a report to this effect was lodged. PW-2 Fatey Lal in whose presence the alleged agreement to sell was executed stated that a period of 2 months was fixed for execution of the sale deed and that after the expiry of said period he never met anybody. Thus it was found by the trial Court that testimony of these two witnesses was contradictory to each other since plaintiff had stated that the sale deed was to be executed after the marriage of daughter in 1997 whereas according to PW-2 Fatey Lal a period of two months was fixed for execution of the sale deed. During her evidence plaintiff failed to place on record the original agreement to sell dated 7.10.1997 and instead placed on record a photocopy thereof. PW-3 Raj Kumar another witness to the alleged agreement to sell in his cross examination clearly stated that the original agreement was kept by plaintiff Vimlesh with her. In these circumstances it was rightly held by the trial Court that having failed to produce the primary evidence i.e. the original agreement to sell and receipt it was incumbent upon the plaintiff to lead secondary evidence, however, she failed to do so and instead tendered photocopies thereof as mark-A and mark-B which are inadmissible and cannot be looked into for any purpose. Thus it was rightly held by the trial Court that plaintiff had failed to discharge the onus cast upon her and as such she was not entitled to a decree of permanent or mandatory injunction against the defendant.
As regards the maintainability of the suit it has rightly been held by the appellate Court that when relief of specific performance was available to the plaintiff then the suit for permanent and mandatory injunction was not maintainable. It has further been found by the learned Appellate Court that plaintiff herself had sought change of the relief clause to the one for specific performance but that request was declined by the Court. The learned Counsel for the appellant during the course of arguments has not been able to dispute that the order declining the prayer of the plaintiff to amend the prayer clause was never challenged by her.
In view of the above no question of law much less substantial question of law arises for determination in this appeal which is hereby dismissed.
