High CourtsSingle Bench(2018) 04 CHH CK 0097

Smt. Priyanka Sharma vs Devendra

Chhattisgarh High Court · Decided on 9 April 2018

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
ACQA No. 231 of 2010

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

12 paragraphs · 450 words
1.

This appeal is preferred against the judgment dated 26.04.1999 passed by the 2nd Additional Sessions Judge, Bastar, Jagdalpur in ST No.175/1998,

wherein the said Court acquitted all the respondents for the charges under Sections 302, 120-B and 201 of IPC for committing murder of one Salim and causing disappearance of evidence of the said offence and for conspiracy of the said offence on or before 22.02.1998 at Village Ghamri, Police

Station Kondagaon, District Bastar.

2.

In the present case, the name of the deceased is Salim. In the FIR lodged on 22.02.1998, no one was named as culprit. Surprisingly, on the next day

i.e. on 23.02.1998, two persons namely, Ankaluram (PW-4) and Akturam (PW-5) came forward claiming themselves to be the eye witness of the incident of assault on the deceased Salim. Though, they had stated that the respondents have assaulted the deceased and dragged him, but they did not inform anyone about the said incident for 3 days. They have not explained as to why the incident was not informed to anyone. The trial Court after close scrutiny of the evidence opined that both the witnesses are got up witnesses and their evidence cannot be acted upon. Apart from these two

witnesses, other witnesses are corroborating in nature and it was not safe for the trial Court to act on statement of so called eye witnesses.

3.

As per the opinion of Dr. U. S. Navratan (PW-1) who conducted autopsy in the case, the body was found beheaded and cause of death is

excessive bleeding due to cut of vessels of throat, but from the evidence, it is not established that as to how the vessels were cut and there is nothing incriminating against any of the respondents for what is mentioned in the postmortem report. The view taken by the trial Court is one of the plausible view and it is settled law that if two views are plausible, the view favourable to the accused should be accepted.

4.

On an overall assessment of the evidence, we are satisfied that the infirmity pointed out by the trial Court in the evidence of so called eye witnesses

and other corroborating piece of the evidence is based on proper marshaling of evidence and the same is also based on legally admissible evidence.

5.

We do not find any infirmity in the finding recorded by the trial Court leading to acquittal of all the 7 respondents, in which two respondents namely,

Siyaram and Lakhna died during the pendency of this appeal. In this view of the matter, we do not find any scope for interference in the present appeal and the same is liable to be and is hereby dismissed.