Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2026) 11 ITAT CK 3625

Silverglades Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. vs PCIT

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi · Decided on 20 November 2026

RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
ITA No.3810/DEL/2026

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

56 paragraphs · 5,579 words

PER S. RIFAUR RAHMAN, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :

1.

This appeal is filed by the assessee against the order of ld. Pr. Commissioner of Income-tax (PCIT, Delhi – 7 [“ld. PCIT”, for short] dated 26.03.2026 for the Assessment Year 2022-23.

2.

Brief facts of the case are, this appeal by the assessee is directed against the order dated 26.03.2026 passed by the ld. PCIT under section 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short “the Act”), whereby the assessment order dated 22.03.2024 passed by the Assessing Officer u/s 143(3) read with section 144B of the Act for Assessment Year 2022-23 has been set aside for fresh examination of issues relating to revenue recognition under the Percentage of Completion Method (POCM), valuation of work-in-progress, allocation of construction expenditure, creditors and liabilities, and computation of loss.

3.

Aggrieved with the above order, the assessee is in appeal before us raising following grounds of appeal :-

“1.1

That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Ld. PCIT erred in invoking jurisdiction under section 263 of the Act in total disregard to the fact that the assessment order u/s 143(3) was neither erroneous nor prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue and as such the impugned order is illegal and bad in law.

1.2

That the assessment order having been passed after detailed scrutiny and proper verification of material facts, the allegation of lack of enquiry is arbitrary, factually incorrect and totally untenable thus vitiating the very basis of the impugned order.

2.1

That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the direction of Ld. PCIT regarding the Percentage of Completion Method is unjust and misconceived as the appellant has been consistently following the POCM for revenue recognition over the years and there has been no change in the method of accounting during the year under consideration.

2.2

The Ld. PCIT has failed to appreciate that the issue of revenue recognition under POCM was duly examined by the Assessing Officer during the course of assessment proceedings as well as in earlier years and the method having been consistently followed accepted in past assessment years, there is no case of any error in the assessment order.

2.3

That the overall profit or loss based on POCM being not in dispute and in the absence of any finding or allegation that POCM will result in loss to revenue, the assumption of jurisdiction u/s 263 is devoid of merits and not sustainable.

3.1

That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the appellant having recognized revenue based on POCM as prescribed under accounting standard and the assessing officer having accepted the same based on verification, consistency and past accepted history, the impugned revision proceedings have been initiated merely on account of a change of opinion on the same set of facts and thus beyond the scope of section 263.

3.2

That the POCM is relevant to each year of execution of the project wherein revenue and cost are spread over and recognized in phased manner throughout different years, the direction given in the impugned order for one particular year in isolation is inconsistent, arbitrary and bereft of merits.

4.1

That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the impugned revision order has been passed without issuing any specific show cause notice identifying the alleged error, without conducting any independent inquiry, and without recording any clear finding demonstrating how the method followed by the appellant is erroneous, the assumption of jurisdiction is thus arbitrary and in violation of principles of natural justice.

4.2

That in any case, the observation of Ld.. PCIT being of general nature and in absence of pointing out of any credible defect, inconsistency, or discrepancy in the POCM followed by the appellant, the impugned order is arbitrary and contrary to law.

5.

That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the direction of the Ld. PCIT regarding fresh verification of Creditors and Liabilities and loss computation for FY 2022-23 is without application of mind and specific finding, the same is arbitrary and sans any cogent basis or reasoning and thus without jurisdiction.

6.

That the order passed u/s 263 is not justified in facts and same is bad in law.”

4.

At the time of hearing, Ld AR of the assessee made detailed submissions and he submitted that the assessee had filed detailed reply in response to show cause notice u/s 263 and all the issues raised in the notice were duly clarified. The ld. AR drew our attention to notices and replies filed during the course of assessment proceedings placed at Paperbook Pages 14 to 44 in support of the fact that the AO had duly examined the creditors and liabilities and also took note of the facts relating to revenue recognition under POCM and as such there is no case of any lack of enquiry or inadequate enquiry. It was further submitted that the issue of loss as pointed out by ld. PCIT is factually incorrect and even otherwise relates to Assessment Year 2023-24 which is extraneous to the year under reference. With regard to the issue of recognition of revenue under Percentage of completion method (POCM), the ld. AR made reference to POCM chart placed at Paper book Pages 80 to 81 in support of the contention that assessee has been following the very same method for recognizing revenue year after year on consistent basis and ld. PCIT has given no valid basis for disturbing the method in one particular year. It was further argued that the revenue recognition under POCM was examined in detail by the AO while framing assessment u/s 143(3) for AY 2017-18 and AY 2021-22 and as such the dispute raised by PCIT is arbitrary and unfounded. Further, in subsequent years, there is no dispute raised regarding POCM. The ld. AR made specific reference to the decision of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT v. A2Z Maintenance & Engineering Services Ltd. [2017] 392 ITR 273 (Delhi) in support of the proposition that jurisdiction u/s 263 cannot be exercised to disturb the profits of one year where assessee is following revenue recognition method consistently.

5.

In addition to above, the ld. AR vehemently contended that the impugned order of ld. PCIT lacks substance as there is no conclusive finding whatsoever in respect of the issues on which the assessment order has been set-aside and the exercise of revisionary power u/s 263 is mechanical and contrary to judicial requirement. It was argued that the assessment order was passed after conducting proper enquiry and ld. PCIT has made an attempt to substitute the view of the AO without recording any finding and in total disregard to the scope and purpose of section 263 of the Act. The ld. AR had made reference to various judicial pronouncements and specifically relied upon the following:

i.

Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. v. CIT [2000] 243 ITR 83 (SC)

ii.

PCIT v. Cartier Leaflin (P.) Ltd [2023] 452 ITR 242 (SC)

iii.

Pr.CIT v. Shreeji Paints P. Ltd. [2021] 130 taxmann.com 294 (SC)

iv.

DIT v. Jyoti Foundation (2013) 357 ITR 388 (Delhi) (HC)

6.

On the other hand, ld. DR for the Revenue brought to our notice pages 2 to 10 of impugned order and heavily supported the order passed by the ld. PCIT and contended that the assessment order was passed without making enquiry and as such ld. PCIT was justified in invoking provisions of section 263 of the Act.

7.

Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed that the principal grievance of the assessee is that ld. PCIT has invoked the revisionary jurisdiction conferred u/s 263 of the Act without establishing that the assessment order was erroneous insofar as it was prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. It is contended that the original assessment was completed after scrutiny of the issues for which the case was selected, that the Assessing Officer had specifically called for and examined the relevant information concerning the assessee’s accounting method, work-in-progress, creditors, liabilities, security deposits and retention money, and ld. PCIT has merely substituted his own view regarding the extent of enquiry considered necessary. The assessee accordingly seeks quashing of the impugned revision order and restoration of the original assessment.

8.

We observed that after considering the rival submissions and examining the material available on record, including the assessment order, the impugned order passed u/s 263 of the Act and the paper book and synopsis filed by the assessee, the issues raised before us is essentially whether, on the facts and circumstances of the present case, ld. PCIT was legally justified in holding that the assessment order suffered from a lack of enquiry and was consequently erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue, thereby warranting its cancellation and a direction for fresh assessment.

9.

The material facts are, the assessee is a company engaged in the business of real estate development and related engineering and technical services. For the year under consideration, the assessee filed its return of income on 06.11.2022 declaring total income of Rs.65,28,710/-. The case was selected for scrutiny under the CASS mechanism, inter alia, to examine high creditors and liabilities, stock valuation and a legacy issue. The assessment was completed u/s 143(3) read with section 144B of the Act on 22.03.2024, accepting the returned income of Rs.65,28,710/-.

10.

The assessment record demonstrates that the Assessing Officer issued notices u/s 142(1) of the Act on 08.06.2023 and 11.01.2024, calling for information and supporting documents concerning the issues selected for scrutiny. In response to the initial notice, the assessee furnished details of its business activities, places of business, sources of income and bank accounts. Subsequently, on 19.01.2024, the assessee furnished clarifications and supporting information concerning closing stock, sundry creditors, expenses payable, current liabilities and other relevant particulars. The material placed before us further indicates that the Assessing Officer examined the assessee’s explanation regarding the accounting treatment of construction expenditure and work-in-progress under the Percentage of Completion Method.

11.

It is further noted that the Assessing officer did not conclude only upon the filing of general information and had issued a specific show-cause notice dated 14.03.2024 proposing to treat an amount of Rs.20,59,92,438/- relating to security deposits and retention money as unexplained cash credit u/s 68 read with section 115BBE of the Act. The assessee furnished its response on 19.03.2024 along with confirmations of the relevant parties and upon considering the explanation and the material furnished, the Assessing Officer recorded in the assessment order that the assessee’s reply had been considered and found acceptable, that the details and evidence furnished had been perused and verified, and that no variation was required to be made. The assessment was accordingly completed without making any addition on this issue. Thus, it can be concluded that the assessing officer conducted proper enquiry while framing assessment.

12.

Subsequently, ld. PCIT initiated proceedings u/s 263 of the Act by notice dated 16.02.2026. The principal allegation was that the Assessing Officer had accepted the assessee’s explanation regarding revenue recognition under POCM and valuation of work-in-progress without conducting meaningful verification or recording adequate reasons. Ld. PCIT also questioned the pattern of revenue, construction expenditure, work-in-progress and profitability reflected in the financial statements over several financial years. In relation to creditors and liabilities, ld. PCIT considered that the assessment lacked adequate verification concerning the identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of creditors, age-wise analysis of outstanding liabilities and other aspects bearing upon the correctness of the reported liabilities.

13.

We further noticed that the assessee responded to the revision notice by submitting, inter alia, that it had consistently followed POCM in accordance with the applicable accounting framework and the relevant guidance issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India; that the accounting method had been accepted in preceding and succeeding assessment years; that the Assessing Officer had specifically examined the relevant issues during the original assessment proceedings; and further ld. PCIT had not identified any particular error in the application of the accounting method or established any actual prejudice to the interests of the Revenue. The submissions of the assessee, however, did not find favour with ld. PCIT, he set aside the assessment order and directed the Assessing Officer to undertake fresh verification of revenue recognition, work-in-progress valuation, cost allocation, creditors and liabilities, and computation of loss. Ld. PCIT has made only general observations and did not record any finding as to how the assessment order u/s 143(3) is erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of the revenue.

14.

In the above factual background, the first and foremost question requiring consideration is whether the conditions prescribed u/s 263 of the Act for assumption of revisionary jurisdiction were satisfied in the present case or not.

15.

It is a settled proposition of law that the jurisdiction u/s 263 is not an unrestricted power of review. The provision can be invoked only where the order passed by the Assessing Officer is both erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. The existence of these two conditions is cumulative and indispensable. An order cannot be revised merely because ld. PCIT considers that a different approach ought to have been adopted by the Assessing Officer or that the assessment should have been supported by a more elaborate discussion of the material on record. The governing principles stand authoritatively explained by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. v. CIT [2000] 243 ITR 83 (SC) wherein the Hon’ble Court held that an incorrect assumption of facts or an incorrect application of law may render an order erroneous. Equally, an order passed without application of mind or without following the principles of natural justice may also fall within the ambit of an erroneous order. However, every loss of revenue cannot be treated as prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. Where the Assessing Officer adopts one of the courses permissible in law or takes a view with which the Commissioner does not agree, the order cannot be revised merely on that account unless the statutory requirements are otherwise fulfilled.

16.

The aforesaid principle is fundamental to the exercise of revisionary jurisdiction. Section 263 does not authorise ld. PCIT to cancel every assessment in which he considers the enquiry insufficient or the discussion inadequate. The authority must first establish, on the basis of the assessment record and relevant material, the particular error committed by the Assessing Officer and demonstrate how that error renders the order prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. A general assertion that further verification was desirable cannot, by itself, substitute for the statutory satisfaction required u/s 263.

17.

We notice the same principle finds support in CIT v. Max India Ltd. [2007] 295 ITR 282 (SC), wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated that revisionary jurisdiction cannot be exercised merely because the Commissioner does not agree with a view adopted by the Assessing Officer, particularly where the issue is capable of more than one legally permissible view. The existence of a possible alternative view does not render the assessment order erroneous. The relevant consideration is whether the view adopted by the Assessing Officer is legally sustainable and whether the statutory conditions for revision have been established.

18.

We find that the impugned order proceeds substantially on the premise that the Assessing Officer did not undertake adequate verification of the assessee’s accounting method, work-in-progress and liabilities. Ld. PCIT has placed considerable emphasis upon the fact that the assessment order does not contain a detailed project-wise analysis, a discussion of completion certificates, an elaborate reconciliation of work-in-progress or an independent examination of every component of the construction expenditure. Ld. PCIT has also considered the movement of work-in-progress and profitability across different financial years to be indicative of possible deferral of taxable income.

19.

However, by applying the principles governing the exercise of power u/s 263, as discussed above, we find that the observations of PCIT are not sufficient to sustain the exercise of jurisdiction u/s 263. The assessment order must be examined in conjunction with the notices issued during the assessment proceedings, the information called for, the replies furnished by the assessee and the manner in which the Assessing Officer dealt with the issues raised. The legality of the assessment cannot be determined solely by asking whether the final order contains a separate paragraph dealing with each query or reproduces the entire verification undertaken during the proceedings. It is noticed, law as laid down by Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of CIT v. Eicher Ltd. [2007] 294 ITR 310 (Delhi) that absence of a detailed discussion in the assessment order does not invariably establish that no enquiry was undertaken without taking into account the notices issued and replies furnished by the assessee.

20.

In the present case, the assessment record demonstrates that the Assessing Officer called for details relating to the very issues subsequently questioned by ld. PCIT. The information was furnished concerning the assessee’s business, accounting treatment, stock and work-in-progress, sundry creditors, expenses payable and current liabilities. It is relevant to note, the Assessing Officer issued a specific show-cause notice proposing a substantial addition of Rs.20,59,92,438/- u/s 68 of the Act in respect of security deposits and retention money. The assessee furnished confirmations in response, and the Assessing Officer expressly recorded that the explanation and evidence had been considered, perused and verified and were found acceptable. Thus, the present case is not one in which the assessment record, as placed before us, demonstrates absence of enquiry into the relevant issues and instead the record establishes that the Assessing Officer called for information, examined the explanation furnished by the assessee and completed the assessment after proper verification. Where ld. PCIT would have preferred a more extensive enquiry or a more elaborate discussion, ld. PCIT has to record a specific finding to this effect to support his observation and the requirement cannot be bypassed by making sweeping observation as same would be against the object, purpose and spirit of section 263.

21.

It is pertinent to note that the impugned order does not identify an established error in the computation of taxable income and instead, it sets aside the assessment for an extensive exercise involving project-wise cost sheets, completion certificates, reconciliation of work-in-progress across several years, revenue recognition workings, allocation of indirect expenditure, borrowing costs, vendor-wise construction expenditure and other matters. Ld. PCIT has directed the Assessing Officer to undertake these enquiries afresh without first demonstrating, with reference to any specific project, transaction or accounting entry, that the conclusion reached in the original assessment was erroneous. It is well settled that the jurisdiction u/s 263 cannot be exercised on the assumption that an assessment is erroneous because a further enquiry might disclose an error. The statutory requirement operates in the opposite direction: the revisional authority must establish the requisite error and prejudice on the basis of material available to it before setting aside the assessment. The power to revise an assessment is not intended to provide another opportunity to the Revenue to reopen completed scrutiny proceedings in the hope of discovering a possible basis for an addition. The legal position to this effect is supported from the decision of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of DIT v. Jyoti Foundation [2013] 357 ITR 388 (Delhi) wherein it was explained that where the revisional authority considers an enquiry inadequate, it must itself undertake the necessary enquiry and demonstrate how the assessment order is erroneous. The revisional authority cannot merely remand the matter to the Assessing Officer with a direction to conduct further enquiry. The principle is that the statutory power cannot be exercised mechanically by setting aside an assessment on the general allegation that the enquiry was insufficient.

22.

We may now examine the principal issue concerning revenue recognition under the Percentage of Completion Method. The assessee has consistently followed POCM for recognising revenue from its real estate development activities. Under this method, revenue and the corresponding costs are recognised with reference to the stage of completion of the relevant project, in accordance with the applicable accounting framework and the method regularly employed by the assessee. Expenditure attributable to the project which is not chargeable to the profit and loss account in the relevant period remains reflected in work-in-progress, subject to the applicable accounting principles. The assessee’s explanation, as recorded in the original assessment proceedings, was that construction expenditure was accounted for in accordance with POCM and that the balance expenditure not recognised in the profit and loss account was carried forward as work-in-progress. The assessee also furnished details concerning the opening work-in-progress, expenditure incurred during the year, expenditure charged to the profit and loss account and closing work-in-progress. The assessment record further indicates that the assessee explained the accounting treatment with reference to its nature of business and the guidance applicable to real estate transactions.

23.

Ld. PCIT has questioned the correctness of the accounting treatment primarily by comparing revenue, expenditure, work-in-progress and profit margins over a series of financial years. The revision order refers to the increase in work-in-progress, fluctuations in revenue and variations in reported margins and considers these features indicative of possible deferral of income. It has also questioned whether the percentage of completion was correctly determined whether the cost incurred corresponded with the physical progress of the projects and whether the expenditure allocated to the profit and loss account was commensurate with the revenue recognised. It is not the case of ld. PCIT that overall, there is any mistake in recording of financials relating to revenue and expenses based on POCM.

24.

We are of the considered view that such matters may, in an appropriate case, warrant examination during assessment proceedings. However, the existence of questions which ld. PCIT considers worthy of further examination is not, by itself, sufficient to establish that the assessment order is erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. Ld. PCIT was required to go beyond general observations and demonstrate how the accounting treatment adopted by the assessee was incorrect, which relevant facts had been overlooked by the Assessing Officer, or how the assessment resulted in an erroneous determination of taxable income.

25.

We further find that the financial pattern of a real estate developer cannot be evaluated by applying an inflexible assumption that an increase in work-in-progress must necessarily be accompanied by a corresponding increase in revenue or that closing work-in-progress must invariably decline whenever revenue increases. The relationship between revenue, expenditure and work-in-progress depends upon the nature and stage of the projects undertaken, the timing of expenditure, the stage at which revenue is recognised, change of circumstances and the accounting treatment applicable to the relevant transactions. An increase in work-in-progress may warrant an enquiry in an appropriate case, but it does not, by itself, establish understatement of revenue or inflation of expenditure.

26.

Similarly, fluctuations in gross profit or net profit margins across different years cannot, in isolation, establish any mistake in accounting method. A conclusion that expenditure has been artificially synchronised with revenue, that indirect expenditure has been improperly capitalised, or that the percentage of completion has been understated must be supported by relevant facts and material. Such conclusions cannot be presumed merely from variations in financial ratios or from the fact that work-in-progress has accumulated over several years.

27.

We also find merit in the assessee’s contention concerning consistency in the method of accounting. The assessee has submitted that it followed POCM in preceding as well as subsequent years and that the method had been examined and accepted during scrutiny proceedings for Assessment Years 2017-18 and 2021-22 or even in subsequent years. The assessee has also referred to the corresponding notices, replies and assessment orders placed in the paper book. The principle of consistency does not mean that an accounting method, once accepted, becomes immune from examination in subsequent years. However, where the assessee has consistently followed a recognised method of accounting and the Department has accepted the same in preceding years after examination, a departure from the accepted treatment must be supported by a legally sustainable basis. The revisional authority cannot disregard the established accounting treatment merely because it considers a different approach preferable in the year under consideration particularly when the overall net revenue and profit from the project would ultimately get recognized under POCM and dispute, if any, would only be of timing difference causing no prejudice to the revenue. In any case, a revenue recognition method consistently followed cannot be disturbed in isolation without recording conclusive finding showing patent error in its application, which clearly has not been done in the present case.

28.

We observed that in PCIT v. A2Z Maintenance & Engineering Services Ltd. [2017] 392 ITR 273 (Delhi), the Hon’ble Delhi High Court considered the question of revenue recognition under the applicable accounting standard (AS-7) in the context of revisionary proceedings u/s 263. The decision recognised the significance of a consistently followed and recognised method of accounting and the fact that the issue had received scrutiny during the original assessment proceedings. The Court declined to interfere with the Tribunal’s decision setting aside the revisional order in the facts of that case. The assessee has also relied upon PCIT v. Aditya Builders [2015] 378 ITR 75 (Bom), M/s. Soham Buildcon v. PCIT [2024] 160 taxmann.com 1250 (Ahmedabad - Trib.) and RDC Ventures v. PCIT [2024] 159 taxmann.com 395 (Mumbai - Trib.) in support of its contention that revisionary jurisdiction cannot be exercised to disturb an accepted method of revenue recognition without establishing an error in its application. We find that the decisions relied upon by the assessee are relevant and fully applicable to the present controversy.

29.

The principle emerging from the aforesaid decisions supports the proposition that the acceptance of a recognised accounting method cannot be displaced through revisionary proceedings without establishing the requisite error in its application. In the present case, ld. PCIT has not identified any change in the assessee’s method of accounting during the year under consideration or demonstrated that the method itself was impermissible under the applicable accounting framework. Nor has ld. PCIT established, by reference to a specific project or transaction, that the method was incorrectly applied during the relevant year. Before invoking section 263, it was necessary to establish that the assessee had, in fact, adopted an incorrect basis of revenue recognition or that the Assessing Officer had accepted a computation resulting in an erroneous determination of income. The impugned order does not establish such a defect.

30.

We accordingly hold that, on the facts and material placed before us, ld. PCIT has not demonstrated that the assessment order was erroneous in its acceptance of the assessee’s method of revenue recognition under POCM.

31.

We now turn to the second issue concerning creditors and liabilities. Ld. PCIT has questioned whether the Assessing Officer adequately examined the identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of the creditors and whether an age-wise analysis of outstanding liabilities was undertaken. The revision proceedings also referred to the possibility of unexplained credits u/s 68 of the Act and cessation of liabilities attracting section 41(1).

32.

On examination of the relevant record submitted before us, we find that the issue of creditors and liabilities is directly arising from the assessment proceedings as the case was selected for scrutiny, inter alia, on account of high creditors and liabilities. The Assessing Officer specifically called for details concerning sundry creditors, expenses payable, current liabilities and related particulars. The assessee furnished the information sought, including details concerning trade payables and other liabilities.

33.

As noted elsewhere, the assessment order records that the Assessing Officer raised a specific query concerning security deposits and retention money aggregating to Rs.20,59,92,438/-. A show-cause notice was issued proposing to treat the amount as unexplained cash credit u/s 68 read with section 115BBE of the Act. The assessee furnished confirmations and its explanation vide reply dated 19.03.2024 placed at Paper book Pages 40 to 44. After considering the response, the Assessing Officer expressly recorded that the explanation and evidence were found acceptable and that no variation was required. This sequence of events is significant and demonstrates that the Assessing Officer did not merely accept the balance-sheet figures without raising any query. The Assessing Officer specifically questioned the nature of the relevant liabilities, proposed a substantial addition and considered the assessee’s response before completing the assessment. The subsequent decision not to make an addition was a conscious conclusion recorded in the assessment order after the assessee furnished the relevant confirmations and supporting material.

34.

Further, ld. PCIT has not identified any specific creditor whose identity was found to be doubtful, any confirmation shown to be false, any transaction established to be non-genuine, or any particular liability demonstrated to have ceased during the relevant previous year. Nor has ld. PCIT established that any specific credit was incorrectly accepted as explained u/s 68 of the Act. The direction for fresh verification is founded substantially on the proposition that the Assessing Officer ought to have conducted further enquiries and recorded more detailed findings.

35.

We are unable to sustain the revisionary order on this basis. Where the Assessing Officer has raised specific queries, received supporting documents and accepted the explanation after examination, the revisional authority must identify the defect in the enquiry or the conclusion reached. The mere fact that the assessment order does not reproduce every confirmation or set out a creditor-wise analysis does not establish that the assessment was erroneous. The adequacy of an enquiry must be judged in the context of the material called for, the explanation furnished and the conclusion reached, rather than solely by the length or detail of the assessment order.

36.

We also find that the reference to sections 68 and 41(1) of the Act does not help the case of ld. PCIT. The impugned order does not establish the factual ingredients necessary to show that a particular credit remained unexplained or that a particular liability had ceased to exist during the relevant year. A general direction to examine whether section 68 or section 41(1) might apply cannot take the place of a finding that the original assessment suffered from a specific error warranting revision. Moreover, the majority of the creditors represent customer bookings which are eventually accounted for as income and as such the provisions of section 68 or 41(1) has no application to the facts of the case. In respect of the other loans/liabilities, we find that same either secured loans/debentures being carried forward from earlier year or simply in the nature of statutory/routine liabilities not warranting any adverse inference and as such we fail to see any valid reasoning behind the direction issued by ld. PCIT.

37.

In overall consideration of the issue, we find that ld. PCIT has set aside the assessment with directions to verify the project-wise cost, completion certificates, work-in-progress reconciliation, revenue recognition workings, construction expenditure, creditors and liabilities, and computation of loss in AY 2023-24, which does even not relate the year under reference. Ld. PCIT has not shown that the assessee’s explanations were contradicted by any specific material available on record or that the Assessing Officer’s conclusions were demonstrably unsustainable.

38.

The distinction between an assessment which is erroneous and one which the revisional authority considers insufficiently reasoned cannot be ignored. Section 263 read with Explanation 2 does not permit ld. PCIT to set aside an assessment merely to ensure that the Assessing Officer records a more elaborate discussion or undertakes every enquiry that ld. PCIT might consider useful. Ld. PCIT has not demonstrated that the enquiries actually conducted were so deficient, having regard to the material on record, that the assessment order was rendered erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. The power u/s 263 cannot be exercised merely to facilitate a second round of scrutiny in the absence of the statutory conditions. Moreover, ld. PCIT cannot be permitted to treat every assessment in which the Assessing Officer accepts an explanation without making an addition as erroneous merely because the revisional authority subsequently considers the explanation insufficient. The statutory safeguard u/s 263 would become ineffective if the existence of a possible alternative view or the desirability of additional verification were sufficient to justify cancellation of an assessment. The revisional authority must demonstrate an actual error in the assessment order, not merely a possibility that further enquiries might lead to a different result. The legal position to this effect is supported from following judicial precedents as relied upon by the assessee :- PCIT v. Cartier Leaflin (P.) Ltd [2023] 452 ITR 242 (SC)  Pr.CIT v. Shreeji Paints P. Ltd. [2021] 130 taxmann.com 294 (SC)  CIT v. Max India Ltd. [2007] 295 ITR 282 (SC)

39.

In view of the aforesaid, we accordingly hold that ld. PCIT was not justified in invoking section 263 of the Act and setting aside the assessment order dated 22.03.2024. The impugned revision order is unsustainable in law because ld. PCIT has failed to establish, on the basis of the material available on record, that the assessment order was erroneous insofar as it is prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. In the result, the order dated 26.03.2026 passed by ld. PCIT u/s 263 of the Act is hereby quashed. The original assessment order dated 22.03.2024 passed u/s 143(3) read with section 144B of the Act for Assessment Year 2022-23 is restored.

40.

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed.