Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2025) 09 ITAT CK 2455

Shri Balaji Metal Tech Pvt. Ltd. vs DCIT

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi · Decided on 29 September 2025

RESULT
Partly Allowed
CASE NUMBER
ITA No. 1287/Del/2024 and 2168 to 2171/Del/2024

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

36 paragraphs · 1,325 words

PER ANUBHAV SHARMA, JM:

These are appeals preferred by the Assessee as well as the Revenue against the orders of the Ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) (hereinafter referred to as the First Appellate Authority or ‘the ld. FAA’ for short) in appeals filed before him against the orders of the ld. Assessing Officer (hereinafter referred to as the Ld. AO, for short) passed u/s 143(3) (assessee’s appeal) and 143(3) r.w.s. 153C (Revenue’s appeal) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereafter referred to as ‘the Act’). Further details of the orders of the lower authorities are as under:-

ITA No. & Assessment YearLd. CIT(A)/FAA who passed the appellate orderAppeal No. & Date of order of the Ld. FAAAO who passed the assessment order & Date of order
1287/Del/2024 2018-19CIT(A)-29, New DelhiCIT(A), Delhi-29, 10416/2017-18, dated 08.02.2024DCIT, CC-25, New Delhi, dated 27.02.2021
2168/Del/2024, 2014-15CIT(A)-29, New DelhiCIT(A), Delhi-29, 10397/2013-14, dated 07.02.2024DCIT, CC-25, New Delhi, dated 27.02.2021
2169/Del/2024, 2015-16-DO-CIT(A), Delhi-29, 10566/2013-14, dated 07.02.2024DCIT, CC-25, New Delhi, dated 27.02.2021
2170/Del/2024, 2016-17-DO-CIT(A), Delhi-29, order dated 07.02.2024DCIT, CC-25, New Delhi, dated 27.02.2021
2171/Del/2024, 2017-18-DO-CIT(A), Delhi-29, order dated 07.02.2024DCIT, CC-25, New Delhi, dated 27.02.2021
2.

On hearing both the sides, we find that in ITA No.1287/Del/2024 for AY 2018-19, the assessee has raised the additional grounds of appeal as follows:-

“Additional Ground No.1: The ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has erred both in law and on facts in sustaining the assessment so framed by AO u/s 143(3) of the Act, whereas the assessment for the impugned year should have been framed u/s 153C/143(3) of the Act.

Additional Ground No.1.1: The ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has erred both in law and on facts in sustaining the assessment so framed by AO u/s 143(3) of the Act, whereas the assessment for the impugned year should have been framed u/s 153C/143(3) of the Act and further admittedly, no notice came to be issued u/s 153C of the Act by the AO for the instant year.

Additional Ground No.2: That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the impugned assessment order so passed u/s 143(3) of the Act is null and void, and is also in complete violation of CBDT Circular No.19/2019, since no DIN is mentioned in the entire body of assessment order.”

3.

Further, in the appeals filed by the Revenue, the assessee has raised the same ground by way of an application moved under Rule 27 of the Income-tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963. The ld. AR has relied a catena of decisions including the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case PCIT vs. Shiv Kumar Nayyar, ITA No.285/2024 [TS-343-HC-2024-Delhi and of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case ACIT vs. Serajuddin & Co. (2023) 150 taxmann.com 146, to submit that approval granted in the case of the assessee is without any application of mind.

4.

We have taken into consideration the approval, copy of which is made available at page 11 of the paper book and for convenience, we reproduce the scanned copy of the same below:-

Office of the Additional Commissioner of Income Tax Central Range-7, Room No. 329 E-2, Jhandewalan Extension New Delhi

F. No. Addl. CIT/CR-7/2020-21/790 Dated: 26.02.2021

To The Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax Central Circle – 25, New Delhi

Sub: Approval u/s 153D of the I. T. Act, 1961 in the case of M/s Shri Balaji Metaltech Pvt. Ltd., (JBM Group) (DOS: 5.10.2017) for Block Period A. Y. 2012-13 to 2018-19- reg.

Please refer to your letter F. No. DCIT/CC-25/2020-21/468 dated 25.2.2021 on the above subject.

2.

Approval is hereby accorded u/s 153D of the Income Tax Act, 1961 to the draft assessment order as amended in the following case, on the basis of the detailed discussion with you time to time, information available on record, facts mentioned in the Appraisal Report and relevant seized documents perused by you & brought to the notice of undersigned.

S. NO.Name of the AssesseePANSectionAsstt. YearsReturned Income (Rs.)Assessed Income (Rs.)
1.Shri Balaji Metaltech Pvt. LtdAAQCS0136E153C2012-132,47,790/-1,11,96,309/-
2.Shri Balaji Metaltech Pvt. LtdAAQCS0136E153C2013-147,17,393/-6,90,53,936/-
3.Shri Balaji Metaltech Pvt. LtdAAQCS0136E153C2014-156,60,640/-5,20,83,103/-
4.Shri Balaji Metaltech Pvt. LtdAAQCS0136E153C2015-165,50,210/-5,14,55,326/-
5.Shri Balaji Metaltech Pvt. LtdAAQCS0136E153C2016-176,34,018/-1,95,31,597/-
6.Shri Balaji Metaltech Pvt. LtdAAQCS0136E153C2017-188,39,526/-1,48,99,625/-
7.Shri Balaji Metaltech Pvt. LtdAAQCS0136E153C2018-194,56,099/-2,35,22,903/-
3.

Copies of the final assessment orders should be forwarded to this office immediately after passing the orders. Proposal for retention of seized material should also be forwarded to this office within time as per IT Act, 1961. Before passing the final order, in case, there is requirement of protecting the interest of revenue, permission u/s 281B from Pr. CIT(C)-3, New Delhi should be taken. Office note indicating additions in relevant assessment years should be indicated in all Assessment Years. You have certified about perusal and verification of data seized in electronic format through working copies having certified hash values as that of original hard drives/CDs/ pen drives/mobile data & any other electronic data. You have also certified to the undersigned that all information available in AIR/CIB/from other Law Enforcement Agencies have been properly scrutinized by you before finalizing the draft assessment order. Please ensure that penalty is levied under proper section of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

4.

Wherever the reply of the assessee is reproduced verbatim, it should be within inverted commas and italicized. Numbering of page and paras should be clearly visible.

(Vijay Gupta) Additional Commissioner of Income Tax Central Range – 7, New Delhi Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax Central Circle-25 New Delhi

26 FEB 2021

RECEIVED Dy

5.

The ld. DR has defended the approval primarily submitting that the approval is merely an administrative act and there is no format to exhibit application of mind and, specifically with regard to AY 2018-19, it was submitted that may be out of mistake in the approval under section 153C has been mentioned.

6.

After taking into consideration the material on record, it comes up that while recording the satisfaction note u/s 153C of the Act dated 26.09.2019, copy of which is available at pages 1-10 of the paper book, the AO mentions that notices are issued u/s 153A r.w.s. 153C of the Act for AY 2012-13 to 2017-18. However, in case of the assessee for AY 2018-19, also the approval was sought by the letter dated 26.02.2021 for concluding the assessment u/s 153C of the Act and the same was granted. At the same time, it transpires from the copy of assessment order in regard to AY 2018-19 that the assessment is shown to be completed u/s 143(3) of the Act and at the same time the AO mentions in para 20 that the assessment is completed as per prior approval u/s 153D of the Act as granted by the Addl. Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Range-7, New Delhi, vide letter dated 26.02.2021. The aforesaid discussion leaves no doubt in the minds of this Bench that certainly, there was routine exercise of powers and, therefore, the competent authority did not even enter into the question as to if at all for AY 2018-19, the provisions of section 153C of the Act or 143(3) of the Act were applicable. The manner in which the approval has been granted shows that the approving authority has mentioned of electronic evidences for digital evidences being considered by the AO and were considered admitted. However, when we go through the assessment order, we find that as such, no electronic evidences were found relied in the assessment order. This indicates that the competent authority has not examined the assessment records or gone through the incriminating materials and merely endorsed the draft assessment orders as put across which is not the mandate of law for which reliance is rightly placed by the ld. Sr. Counsel on the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Shiv Kumar Nayyar (supra).

7.

In the light of the aforesaid, the additional grounds raised are sustained. The impugned assessments being vitiated are quashed. The appeal of the assessee is allowed and those of the Revenue are dismissed.