High CourtsSingle Bench(2021) 11 KL CK 0205

Shine S.S vs Mini V

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 29 November 2021

HON’BLE JUDGES
Basant Balaji, J
RESULT
Partly Allowed
CASE NUMBER
RPFC NO. 243 Of 2016

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

12 paragraphs · 1,054 words

Basant Balaji, J

1.

The respondent in M.C. No.279 of 2015 on the files of the Family Court, Nedumangad is the revision petitioner before this court. He is challenging the order of the Family Court whereby the court has allowed maintenance to the wife and minor child at the rate of Rs.6,000/- and Rs.4,000/- respectively from 23.7.2015 onwards.

2.

The petitioner herein and the first respondent got married on 19.5.2005 and out of the wedlock the 2nd respondent was born on 27.3.2007. According to the first respondent, she has no job and source of income whereas the revision petitioner is a driver by profession owning an auto-rikshaw and a car and his monthly income is Rs.35,000/- and moreover, he is getting Rs.10,000/- from agriculture. She further alleges that they were deserted by the petitioner from 10.2.2015 onwards and they are not paid any maintenance.

3.

The revision petitioner filed an objection admitting the marriage and the paternity of the child. He contended that there is no desertion on his part and it was the first respondent who deserted him. He admits that he is auto-rikshaw driver but denied the fact that he is owning an auto and that his monthly income is Rs.4,000/-. He submitted before the Family Court that his wife is employed in Penpol Company, drawing a monthly salary of Rs.10,000/-.

4.

Before the Family Court, the first respondent was examined as PW1 and revision petitioner got examined himself as CPW1.

5.

The Family Court, on an appreciation of the oral and as well as the documentary evidence, came to the firm conclusion that there is wilful neglect and refusal on the part of the husband in maintaining them and that the first respondent is living separately with the minor child with justifiable reasons. The petitioner submitted before the court that he is prepared to pay Rs.3,000/- to 2nd respondent but he contended that since the first respondent is employed in a private firm and earning Rs.10,000/- she is not entitled to claim maintenance. But the Family Court found that there is no evidence to show that the first respondent is employed and earning an income for her livelihood. The Family Court, thereafter, went on to hold that respondent Nos.1 and 2 are entitled to Rs.6,000/- and Rs.4,000/- respectively as monthly maintenance.

6.

Heard the learned counsel for the revision petitioner Sri.A.S. Shammy Raj. Even though notice was issued to the respondents and the said notice has been duly served on the respondents, none appeared for the respondents.

7.

Counsel for the revision petitioner submitted that in order to prove that the first respondent is employed he has filed CMP No.26 of 2016 for issuing summons to the witness in the witness list and to examine him with the records stated in the witness schedule. The first respondent strongly opposed the said prayer and the learned Judge after hearing both parties, dismissed CMP No.26 of 2016 on 16.1.2016. The reason stated in the order is that according to the husband, the wife is employed in Aditya company, but in the objection in paragraph 12 he contends that the wife is working in Penpol company and therefore, by examining the Manager of Aditya company, no purpose would be served. On a perusal of the petition filed for issuing summons, it can be seen that the specific case of the petitioner is that though the first respondent is working in Penpol company, she is recruited to that company by Aditya company and by examining the Manager of Aditya company and on production of the records relating to the recruitment, it can be proved that the first respondent is employed in Penpol company. The learned Family Court understood the prayer in the petition as one filed for proving the fact that the first respondent is employed in Aditya company, but his specific case was that first respondent is working in Penpol company and recruited by Aditya company. By dismissing the said C.M.P., the revision petitioner was denied an opportunity to prove before the Family Court his contention that first respondent is gainfully employed in a private company. The counsel for the petitioner prayed for remanding the matter back to the Family Court and giving him an opportunity to examine the witness stated in C.M.P. No.26 of 2016.

8.

I have gone through the petition as well as the order in C.M.P.No.26 of 2016. When the petitioner has a contention that the first respondent is employed in a company and earning Rs.10,000/- per month, definitely, an opportunity should be given to him to prove the said fact and for that, the witness who was sought to be examined should have been brought before that court and allowed to be examined. The Family Court failed in this aspect.

9.

The learned Family Court has granted Rs.6,000/- to first respondent and Rs.4,000/- to the 2nd  respondent.  Since the main grievance of the revision petitioner is regarding the fixation of monthly maintenance at Rs.6,000/- and since an opportunity was not given to prove his contention that the first respondent is employed, I am of the opinion that the order in M.C.No.279 of 2015 requires interference to the extent that it grants maintenance to the first respondent but at the same time, I am of the considered opinion that no interference is warranted with regard to the maintenance awarded by Family Court in respect of the minor child at the rate of Rs.4,000/- pm.

In the result, this revision is allowed in part, setting aside the order in M.C.No.279 of 2015 of the Family Court, Nedumangadu, to the extent that it grants maintenance to first respondent at the rate of Rs.6,000/- and remanded back for giving an opportunity to the revision petitioner to examine the person mentioned in the witness list in C.M.P. No.26 of 2016. The respondent should also be given an opportunity to cross examine the witness sought to be examined and to pass final orders within a period of six months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of the order. I make it clear that the maintenance granted to 2nd respondent is kept in tact. The Family Court is also directed to issue notice to the petitioner in M.C. No.279 of 2015 before proceedings with the case further.

Transmit the lower court records immediately.