High Courts(1999) 09 AHC CK 0107

Shahmal vs Dharamwati

Allahabad High Court · Decided on 30 September 1999

HON’BLE JUDGES
Ram Janam Singh, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Revision No. 31 of 1996-97

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

6 paragraphs · 327 words

Ram Janam Singh, Member.

1.

This revision has been filed by Shahmal, son of Indraj against the order dated 24121996 passed by learned Additional Commissioner, Meerut with the allegation that the learned Court below has substituted the daughter of the deceased Phulwati in her place against the fact and legal provisions.

2.

Revisionist alleged that the deceased Smt. Phulwati has executed a Will deed in her favour and on the basis of the Willdeed, the daughter Smt. Dharamwati, revisionist should have been substituted. Since the regular suit is still pending before the trial Court it was necessary and mandatory on the part of the learned trial Court to have substituted somebody in place of the deceased just to get the proceedings going on keeping in view this fact, the learned trial Court substitued the legal heirs, the real daughter of the deceased Phulwati. This order will conform to the decision of the case pending before the trial Court. By substituting the name of Dharmvvati in place of her mother Smt. Phulwati, she is not going to go any right if the documentary and oral evidence are otherwise but it Phulwati was legally there and her name was recorded in the revenue records then after her death her daughter is the any heir and should be substituted in place of her mother. I think both the Courts below have passed this order keeping in view the legal as well as factual position of the case.

3.

The argument of the learned Counsel for the revisionist is that on the basis of the Will executed by the deceased the name of the revisionist should have been substituted is not correct. That Will is still disputed and final verdict has not been given by the trial Court, hence this argument cannot be sustained.

4.

Keeping in view, the arguments advaced by both the learned Counsels for the parties the present revision has no force and is dismissed accordingly.

Revision dismissed.