Tribunals and CommissionsFull Bench(2022) 08 RERA CK 0392

Sh. Manoj Garg vs Delhi Development Authority

Real Estate Regulatory Authority National Capital Territory Of Delhi · Decided on 31 August 2022

RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Comp.No.96/2021

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

31 paragraphs · 1,010 words

Facts in Brief:

1.

A complaint was filed in FORM ‘M’ on 13.09.2021 by Mr. Manoj Garg (hereinafter referred as “Complainant”) stating that in the year 2019, Plot No.134, Pocket E-4, Sector-7, Rohini measuring 120.140 sq. mts. was allotted to him vide e-auction held on 24.04.2019 by the Delhi Development Authority (hereinafter referred as “Respondents”). Subsequently, they cancelled this allotment stating that the plot was in excess of 15% area in terms of e-auction guidelines. After cancellation, the Respondents refunded the amount of Rs.4,88,73,911/- (Rupees Four Crore Eighty Eight Lakh Seventy Three Thousand Nine Hundred Eleven Only) deposited by the Complainant on 05.03.2021 without interest.

2.

The Complainant has sought following reliefs:

i.

Payment of interest on the monies deposited by him with DDA.

ii.

Refund of charges for participating in e-auction on 24.04.2019, obtaining loan etc.

iii.

Action be taken against the Respondents for not registering E-Auction Scheme with RERA, NCT of Delhi.

3.

The matter was listed initially for hearing on 11.11.2021 and notice was issued to the Respondents for reply on the same date. The Respondents filed their reply on 31.03.2022. The Authority had imposed a cost of Rs.10,000/- on Respondents on 21.02.2022 for not filing reply as directed. The Respondents till date have not deposited cost of Rs.10,000/- which was to be deposited in Bharat Kosh (Consolidated Fund of Govt. of India), as per direction in the order dated 01.06.2022.

4.

Detailed arguments from both sides were heard during several hearings. The main arguments and submissions made by the Respondents are as follows:

i.

It was made clear in the e-auction guidelines that if plot area is found in excess or short by 15 percent, then e-auction would stand cancelled and money deposited will be refunded as per the guidelines.

ii.

In this case money deposited has been refunded to the Complainant.

Analysis and consideration:

5.

The Complainant had participated in e-auction of plots in Rohini Zone on 24.04.2019 and therefore, e-auction guidelines for the year 2018-19 will be applicable in this case.

6.

We note that these guidelines do not speak of refund and interest to be paid in the cases where allocation of e-auctioned residential plot is cancelled.

7.

However, Clause no.7 of Chapter III of General Terms and Conditions of the E-Auction, talks about refund to be made by DDA in cases where allocation of e-auctioned industrial plots is cancelled. This clause reads as follows:

7.

“If the bid is not accepted, the Earnest Money (E.M) will be refunded to the bidder without any interest. If DDA has to withdraw the plot from auction (including not handing over the plot to successful bidders due to any reason like excess area or less area, etc.) then the E.M. and premium deposited will be returned to the auction purchaser without any interest up to a period of six months from the date of auction. Beyond six months period, DDA will pay an interest of 7% for the amount lying with DDA for such period.”

8.

Absence of specific clause in e-auction guidelines of 2018-2019 to deal with cases where allocation of residential plot has been cancelled shows casual approach of DDA in dealing with matters.

9.

The Authority notes the statement made by the Authorized Representative of the Respondents on 07.07.2022 that the subject scheme started in 2013 planning auction of approximately 1000 plots of which 150 still remain to be auctioned.

10.

As per Section 3 of RE (RD) Act 2016, all Real Estate Projects planned on land area of more than 500 sq mtrs. are required to be registered with the concerned RERA Authority. Further, all Real Estate Projects, including plotting, which were not completed by 01.05.2017 also require registration as ongoing project.

11.

In the instant case, DDA started project for auctioning around 1000 residential plots in Rohini area in the year 2013 and this scheme remained incomplete by 01.05.2017, the day RE(RD) Act, 2016 came into force, as more than 150 plots remained unauctioned.

12.

DDA, therefore in terms of Section 3 of RE (RD) Act 2016, was duty bound to register the subject project with RERA, NCT of Delhi before 31.07.2017. However, they not only failed to abide by the provisions of RE (RD) Act, 2016, but also continued to ignore the provisions of law. The legislature by enacting RE (RD) Act, 2016 not only wanted to protect the buyers but also make promoters including Government Agencies accountable for their actions.

13.

In this case, DDA has come out as an agency which is casual in approach and maintains a “careless” attitude towards the buyers/ allottees.

14.

Ideally, DDA should have first measured the plots and then put them to auction. This step would have obviated the inconvenience caused to Allottee and unnecessary litigation.

15.

Considering the fact that the Complainant trusting the Respondents on facts, participated in E-Auction, obtained loan for purchase of plot allotted through e-auction, made all payments to DDA before they discovered that the plot area is in excess of more than 15 percent; cannot be punished for actions of DDA.

16.

Considering the above, we order the following:

i.

DDA shall pay interest to the applicant in terms of Clause 7 of Chapter III of General Terms and Conditions of the E-Auction as applicable to industrial plots as no specific clause is there in these guidelines applicable to cancellation of residential plots.

ii.

DDA shall refund to applicant interest charged on delayed payments.

iii.

DDA shall pay to applicant all expenses incurred by the Complainant, as proved, for participating in E-Auction, and availing loan for purchasing the subject plot etc.

iv.

DDA shall register all their ongoing E-Auction schemes/projects, whether residential, commercial or industrial, where plots or flats or shops or spaces remained for auction as on 01.05.2017 within 45 days of this order.

v.

DDA shall pay a cost of Rs.10,000/- imposed on them on 21.02.2022 in Bharat Kosh (Consolidated Fund of Govt. of India) as per the order dated 01.06.2022.

17.

The case is disposed of accordingly.

18.

No orders as to costs.