High CourtsDivision Bench(2020) 03 DEL CK 0749

Sh. Jagat Singh vs Delhi Transport Corporation

Delhi High Court · Decided on 12 March 2020

HON’BLE JUDGES
Siddharth Mridul, J · Talwant Singh, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
W.P. (C) 13443/2018

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

11 paragraphs · 948 words

SIDDHARTH MRIDUL, J (OPEN COURT)

1.

Mr. Jagat Singh, is a Tyreman employed with the Delhi Transport Corporation. On the 27th April, 2015, Mr. Jagat Singh suffered retrosternal chest pain radiation to left arm with sweating and giddiness and was taken to Kalayani Hospital Private Limited, Mehrauli Road, Gurgaon, Haryana, which admittedly is a hospital empanelled by the official respondent. However, Mr. Jagat Singh was referred to the higher Centre for further management since the empanelled Kalayani Hospital was neither equipped nor able to deal with his condition.

2.

As it transpired, Mr. Jagat Singh was taken by his relatives to the Medanta Hospital in Gurgaon, where he remained under treatment till the 29th April, 2015. The Medanta Hospital diagnosed Mr. Jagat Singh to be suffering from Acute IWMI + Coronary Artery Disease and double vessel disease and consequently performed a Coronary Angiography and PTCA + stent to RCA, on Mr. Jagat Singh.

3.

Mr. Jagat Singh thereafter submitted his medical reimbursement claim, qua the treatment taken by him both at the Kalayani Hospital, as well as, the Medanta Hospital for the period from 27th April, 2015 to the 29th April, 2015, amounting to Rs.2,99,994/- (Rs.45,657/- in relation to Kalayani Hospital and Rs.2,50,000/- qua the expenses incurred for surgery and medicines at the Medanta Hospital). The Delhi Transport Corporation has by its impugned action allowed only an amount of Rs. 42,000/-, in relation to the expenditure incurred by Mr. Jagat Singh at Kalayani Hospital, which as above mentioned, is empanelled with them. Insofar as, the expenditure incurred at the Medanta Hospital is concerned, the Delhi Transport Corporation allowed the same only to the extent of an amount of Rs. 54,471/-. Mr. Jagat Singh being aggrieved by the rejection of his reimbursement of the entire amount expended by him towards his treatment, initiated an Original Application being OA No. 3995/2016, before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi. Vide the impugned judgment and Order dated 24th September, 2018, the Central Administrative Tribunal has declined the relief prayed for by Mr. Jagat Singh inter alia, in terms of the Judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Punjab and Others vs. Ram Lubhaya Bagga and Others, reported as (1998) 4 Supreme Court Cases 117.

4.

Learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. Jagat Singh assails the impugned Judgment and Order dated 24th September, 2018, principally on the ground that the relevant Circular No. Adm1-7(27)2005, dated 29th November, 2005, which admittedly governs the issue of medical reimbursement in relation to employees of the Delhi Transport Corporation, is violative of the principles enshrined in Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India and is also illogical.

5.

Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Delhi Transport Corporation on the contrary invites our attention to Clause (iii) of the said Circular dated 24th September, 2018, which he submits is attracted to the facts of the present case, to urge that, when treatment has been availed in an emergency from a non-empanelled hospital, the reimbursement therefor is thereunder required to be made strictly in accordance with the AIIMS rates, as clearly and unequivocally provided in terms of the said Office Order No. 16, dated 27th August, 1991.

6.

At the outset, we must observe that, there was no challenge to the aforesaid Circular dated 29th November, 2005, on behalf of Mr. Jagat Singh, before the Central Administrative Tribunal. Even otherwise, the question of the policy made by statutory bodies in relation to reimbursement of medical expenses is not ordinarily subject to judicial review. In this behalf, it would be profitable to extract the dictum of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ram Lubhaya Bagga (supra) and in particular, paragraph 25 of the report, which reads as follows:-

“Now we revert to the last submission, whether the new State policy is justified in not reimbursing an employee, his full medical expenses incurred on such treatment, if incurred in any hospital in India not being a government hospital in Punjab. Question is whether the new policy which is restricted by the financial constraints of the State to the rates in AIIMS would be in violation of Article 21 of the Constitution of India. So far as questioning the validity of governmental policy is concerned in our view it is not normally within the domain of any court, to weigh the pros and cons of the policy or to scrutinize it and test the degree of its beneficial or equitable disposition for the purpose of varying, modifying or annulling it, based on howsoever sound and good reasoning, except where it is arbitrary or violative of any constitutional, statutory or any other provision of law. When Government forms its policy, it is based on a number of circumstances on facts, law including constraints based on its resources. It is also based on expert opinion. It would be dangerous if court is asked to test the utility, beneficial effect of the policy or its appraisal based on facts set out on affidavits. The court would dissuade itself from entering into this realm which belongs to the executive. It is within this matrix that it is to be seen whether the new policy violates Article 21 when it restricts reimbursement on account of its financial constraints.”

7.

From a plain reading of the subject medical reimbursement policy, in our considered view, the same is neither arbitrary or whimsical, nor can it be said to violate the principles of equality.

7.

In view of the foregoing, we see no warrant to interfere with the impugned Judgment and Order dated 24th September, 2018, rendered by the Central Administrative Tribunal.

8.

The writ petition being devoid of merits is accordingly dismissed.