AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
P.Krishna Kumar, J.
The tenant, who suffered a concurrent order of eviction under Section 11(4)(ii) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (‘the Act’, for short), is the revision petitioner.
The revision petitioner was put in possession of the tenanted building, consisting of two rooms on the first floor of Visarad Complex, Attingal, in Thiruvananthapuram District, pursuant to a rent deed dated 09.12.2009, at a monthly rent of ₹1,200/-. The respondent/landlord alleges that the revision petitioner demolished the wall separating the two rooms, thereby converting them into a single room and materially and permanently reducing the value or utility of the building.
The revision petitioner contended that it was the landlord who had provided a door in the wall separating the two rooms and that he had done nothing to affect the value or utility of the building. According to him, he had merely fitted three aluminium doors, one inside each of the two outer doors and the third in the wall separating the two rooms, with a view to strengthening them.
We have heard Sri. G.S. Regunath, the learned counsel appearing for the revision petitioner.
Relying on the evidence of PW1, the landlord, and PW2, an advocate who had formerly occupied the rooms, the Rent Control Court concluded that it was the revision petitioner who had installed the door in the wall separating the two rooms, without the consent or concurrence of the landlord. Though the revision petitioner contended that the tenanted building was situated on the second floor, the Rent Control Court, on an examination of Ext.A1 rent deed, Ext.A2 notice and Ext.B11 reply notice, found that the rooms in question were situated on the first floor, excluding the basement floor. The Advocate Commissioner reported in Ext.C1 that the scheduled shop rooms could no longer be used or enjoyed as two separate rooms, as there was a door in the wall separating them. As noted by the commissioner, the demolition of a wall of a room in a multi-storied building would have an impact on the structure. On an evaluation of the entire evidence, including Ext.C1 Commission Report, the Rent Control Court concluded that the alteration made by the tenant was material and permanent in nature and had reduced the value and utility of the building. The Appellate Authority, on an independent evaluation of the evidence adduced by both sides, concurred with the said findings.
The learned counsel appearing for the revision petitioner further contended that, by installing the said doors, the tenant had only improved the value and utility of the building and, therefore, the provisions of Section 11(4)(ii) of the Act were not attracted. We are unable to accept the said proposition in view of the settled position of law that the question whether an alteration amounts to destruction or damage has to be examined from the standpoint of the landlord (Reghunathan G. v. K.V. Varghese, (2005) 7 SCC 317). Apparently, the revision petitioner has failed to dislodge the Commissioner's finding that the alteration of the wall separating the two rooms would reduce the value and utility of the building, as it would thereafter be difficult to use the rooms independently.
In the above factual circumstances, we find no illegality, irregularity or impropriety in the concurrent findings of the Rent Control Court and the Appellate Authority. In Ubaiba v. Damodaran [(1999) 5 SCC 645], the Honourable Apex Court held that the revisional jurisdiction under Section 20 of the Act is not to be exercised for reappreciating the evidence and substituting an independent conclusion in place of the findings arrived at by the Rent Control Court and the Appellate Authority. In the absence of any material indicating perversity or gross irregularity in the findings of the courts below, this Court is not expected to reconsider the correctness of concurrent findings of fact. The revision petitioner has failed to point out any such exceptional circumstance warranting interference.
We find no reason to entertain this revision petition.
In the result, the revision petition is dismissed, upholding the order of eviction. However, the revision petitioner/tenant is granted three months' time to surrender vacant possession of the petition schedule premises, subject to the following conditions:
He shall continue to pay the rent without default during the aforesaid period.
He shall file an affidavit before the execution court, within two weeks from the date of receipt of the copy of this order, undertaking to unconditionally surrender vacant possession of the premises within the period of three months granted herein.
