High CourtsSingle Bench(2012) 07 P&H CK 0070

Seema vs C.L. Mehta

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 17 July 2012

HON’BLE JUDGES
Ajay Tewari, J
CASE NUMBER
CR No. 3210 of 2012 (O and M)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

5 paragraphs · 521 words

Ajay Tewari, J.—This petition has been filed against the concurrent judgments of the Courts below allowing the ejectment application filed by the respondent on the ground of personal necessity. The case set up by the respondent was that he had two married sons who had two children each and a married abandoned daughter apart from himself and his wife and that he required the rented premises (which consist of two rooms, kitchen, verandah and open area) for his personal use. Both the Courts below on a consideration of the evidence held that the respondent wanted to settle one son who was staying with him in a separate portion of his house and also accepted the plea that one deserted daughter was dependent upon the respondent and was staying with him. In these circumstances, both the Courts below held that portion under the tenancy of the petitioner was bonafide required by the landlord.

2.

Learned counsel has firstly argued that as per Rule 4 of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent & Eviction) Rules 1976 in an application u/s 13 certain particulars are required to be given and the same have not been specifically mentioned in the eviction petition. The second argument is that admittedly one of the sons of the respondent is staying at Gujrat and the remaining portion admittedly in the possession of the respondent is enough for six members of the family who were staying with him.

3.

As regards the first argument, it may be mentioned that the particulars which allegedly have not been detailed in the eviction petition relate to the number of persons occupying the same etc. In my opinion, in the eviction petition, the respondent has mentioned that he requires the house for his two married sons as well as for the use of his married daughter and also for his deserted daughter besides his relatives and guests. In the circumstances, it cannot be said that requirement of Rule 4 of the Rules has been flagrantly violated.

4.

As regards the second argument, learned counsel has taken me through through the entire evidence as well as site plan. A perusal of the site plan reveals that house of the respondent can be stated to have three sets. One of the sets is with the petitioner, the details of which have been mentioned above; one set consists of a kitchen, veranda, courtyard and bathroom with an open passage while the third set consists of four rooms along with kitchen, water closet and bathroom. Thus, learned counsel has argued that the premises in the possession of the respondents are more than adequate for his requirement.

5.

In my opinion, the Courts below have rightly assessed the entire evidence and have come to the conclusion that the need of the respondent is bonafide, since the son, who was staying separately has also retired in interregenum. Learned counsel has not been able to persuade the Court that the findings recorded by the Courts below are not supported by any evidence or are based on such misreading of the evidence so as to justify interference by this Court. Disposed of.