High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 11 KL CK 2845

Savithri Thamban vs The State Environment Impact Assessment Authority & Ors.

High Court Of Kerala, Ernakulam · Decided on 18 November 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
G. Girish, J
CASE NUMBER
WP(C) NO. 16215 OF 2026

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

40 paragraphs · 2,411 words

The Managing Partner of a firm running granite quarry has filed this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking the following reliefs:

“i.

to issue a Writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate Writ, Order or direction to quash Exhibit P-26 and P-27;

ii.

to declare that Exhibit P-26 and P-27, have no impact on Exhibit P-1 EC and it is ultra vires;

iii.

To issue a Writ of Mandamus, other Writ, order or direction to the 1st respondent to allow the Petitioner to resume and continue mining activities as per the original approved Mining Plan and Exhibit P-1 EC pending the finalization of the modified mining plan ; and

iv.

Dispense with filing of the translation of vernacular documents produced in this case;”

2.

The facts of the case, shorn of unnecessary particulars, are as follows:

The petitioner had been conducting quarrying operations in 2.9727 hectares of land with necessary permits, licence and lease obtained from the authorities concerned. The lease period was for a period of 12 years. As per the terms of the above permits, the proposed average annual production was 152000 metric ton. The terms and conditions of the permit provided for enhancing the quantity of production and period of lease with prior permission of lessor and registration of the amended lease deed. The petitioner submitted an application for modified mining plan to the Department of Mining and Geology on 16.06.2023. After approval of the modified mining plan from the Geologist, it was submitted before the first respondent for approval. The first respondent was to re-evaluate the potential environmental risks associated with the proposed changes on the basis of the recommendations of the second respondent. In the meanwhile, the petitioner self declared an overextraction of 43961.643 MT and paid a fine of Rs.32,15,238/-. While the modified mining plan was pending consideration of the first respondent, the petitioner applied for re-appraisal of environmental clearance, and requested for Certified Compliance Report. Upon the above application, the second respondent decided to place the matter before the first respondent for seeking an inspection by the Mining and Geology Department and the State Pollution Control Board for ascertaining whether there were any violations. The Kerala State Pollution Control Board, after inspection, found no anomalies and reported that the quarrying was done inside the boundary points. But, the District Geologist who conducted the inspection on 05.11.2024, found that 4870.350 MT of rock was mined from the buffer zone and 3240 MT of rock was stocked in the yard. Thus, it was found that altogether 8110.35 MT of rock was mined excessively from the quarry. In connection with the above excessive mining, the petitioner remitted a fine of Rs.20,46,484/-. As per the 155th meeting of the first respondent held on 28.02.2025, it was decided to reject the application for re-appraisal on the ground of illegal mining in the buffer zone. The above decision of the first respondent was challenged by the petitioner in W.P(C) No.9769/2025 before this Court. Meanwhile, the additional 4th respondent filed W.P(C) No.10463/2025 to interdict the quarrying operations of the petitioner in view of serious violations noted in the joint field inspection conducted by the Geologist and the representatives of the first respondent. As per the judgment rendered on 19.06.2025 in W.P(C) No.9769/2025, this Court set aside the decision of the first respondent rejecting the application for re-appraisal, and directed the first respondent to issue show cause notice to the petitioner with a period of 15 days to explain why the application for re-appraisal shall not be rejected, and to decide the matter afresh in accordance with law. As per the judgment rendered on 26.03.2026 in W.P(C) No.10463/2025, this Court directed the first respondent herein to issue show cause notice to the petitioner on the basis of the adverse findings in the joint inspection report of the first respondent and the Geologist. The petitioner herein was also interdicted from conducting further mining activity in the premises for a period of six weeks, within which the first respondent was to decide on the application for re-appraisal of the petitioner. The petitioner challenged the aforesaid order in W.A No.836/2026. As per the judgment dated 08.04.2026, a Division Bench of this Court observed that the findings in the Joint Inspection Report showed illegal extraction, and hence any future mining activity shall be subject to an undertaking to be given by the petitioner that all environment clearance conditions shall be strictly complied with, failing which it will be open for the authorities concerned to cancel the environment clearance. It was further observed thereunder that the fact that there have been instances of past violations and offences have been compounded, cannot be a justification to cause further environmental damage and to get exonerated by payment of fine. Thereafter, the first respondent proceeded with issuance of show cause notice to the petitioner and obtained the explanation on the serious violations noted in the quarrying site. After evaluating all the relevant aspects, the first respondent in its meeting held on 25.04.2026, decided to suspend the environment clearance granted to the petitioner, pending completion of the re-appraisal proceedings and final issuance of a valid fresh environment clearance by that authority. Accordingly, Ext.P27 order was passed to cease all mining and allied activities in the project area of the petitioner until further orders, in view of the gravity of violations of environment clearance conditions. The aforesaid decision of the first respondent vide Ext.P26 and the order passed vide Ext.P27 are under challenge in this writ petition.

3.

Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the learned Government Pleader representing the respondents 1 to 3 and the learned counsel for the additional 4th respondent.

4.

At the outset, it has to be stated that the restraint imposed by the first respondent, vide Exts.P26 & P27, upon the quarrying activity of the petitioner is temporary in nature. The aforesaid aspect is writ large from the concluding portion of Ext.P26 which is extracted hereunder:

“1.

The Environmental Clearance issued by the DEIAA, Kasaragod, in respect of the Granite Building Stone Quarry Project of Smt. Savithri Thamban, M/s Sree Siva Granites, shall stand suspended pending completion of the reappraisal proceedings and final issuance of a valid fresh EC by the Authority.

2.

A proceedings to suspend the EC shall be issued forthwith, directing the Project Proponent to immediately cease all mining and allied activities in the project area until further orders of the Authority. The decision shall be provided to all respective agencies/departments for necessary action.

3.

The SEAC shall expedite consideration of the matter and furnish detailed recommendations after verifying:

•

whether any mineable mineral resources are available for further extraction within the limits prescribed in the original approved Mining Plan and Environmental Clearance conditions;

•

whether extraction has been carried out beyond the approved depth, approved quantity and permitted mining area, including the buffer zone; and

•

the extent of environmental damage caused due to the violations already noticed.

4.

The SEAC shall also specifically examine the implications of the revised Mining Plan approved on 25.08.2023 and the permissibility of any future mining operations in the light of the Office Memorandum dated 28.04.2023 issued by the MoEF&CC and the applicable provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006.

5.

The Standing Counsel shall inform the Hon’ble High Court regarding the action taken by the Authority in compliance with the interim orders passed in WP(C) No.10463/2025 and WA No.836/2026, including the issuance of the suspension of the Environmental Clearance to stop all the mining activities.”

5.

Ext.P27 order also makes it clear that the cessation of mining directed thereunder was until further orders from the first respondent. The reason for putting such a temporary curb upon the quarrying operations are narrated in Exts.P26 and P27 as follows:

(i)

The illegal activity of mining conducted by the petitioner in the buffer zone had adversely affected compensatory afforestation and caused air, water and soil pollution in the nearby areas which warranted action under the Environment Protection Act, 1986. In the above circumstances, a show-cause notice was issued by the first respondent as per the powers conferred under S.O.637(E) dated 28.02.2014 issued by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate change.

(ii)

The petitioner had admittedly indulged in illegal/excess extraction of minerals for which penalty was collected.

(iii)

The petitioner had revised the mining plan on 25.08.2023 without obtaining prior approval/consent from the first respondent despite being fully aware that the environmental clearance issued by the District Environmental Impact Assessment Authority was liable for re-apprisal before the first respondent. The petitioner had admittedly not informed the first respondent regarding the revision of mining plan, and that mining operations had already reached approximately 300 mtr AMSL which was the ultimate pit level contemplated in the original approved mining plan. The aforesaid ultimate pit level was intended to be reached only during the final years of the mining period.

(iv)

Even after the field inspection conducted in May, 2025, and despite the observations regarding violations, mining activities had continued till it was interdicted by this Court through an interim order dated 26.03.2026 in W.P.(C)No.10463/2025. Thus, presently it is not ascertainable as to whether further extraction had been carried out beyond the permissible depth and limits prescribed in the original approved mining plan and environmental clearance conditions.

(v)

The explanation offered by the petitioner to show-cause notice was found to be unsatisfactory. The petitioner failed to explain the admitted violation relating to extraction from the buffer zone, premature attainment of the ultimate pit level, revision of the mining plan without approval of the first respondent and the continued mining activities, despite the pendency of re-apprisal proceedings.

(vi)

As per condition No.36 of the Environmental Clearance, no change in mining technology and scope of working should be made without prior approval of the first respondent, and no further expansion or modification in the mine shall be carried out without prior approval of the first respondent. The petitioner violated the above legal requirements.

6.

The fact that the petitioner has resorted to excessive extraction of minerals amounting to 4870.350 metric tons from the buffer zone cannot be taken lightly by this Court. The aforesaid act of the petitioner was of such a grave nature that it could give rise to disastrous consequences to the environment leading to natural calamities. The fact that landslides due to ecological imbalances have been taking the lives and hardly earned properties of a large number of people of this State every year, cannot be ignored. In this context, the inferences/conclusions drawn by the first respondent and the Geologist in the joint inspection conducted at the mining site, require serious consideration. The aforesaid inferences are extracted hereunder for easy reference:

“Inferences

1.

The over-extraction/illegal mining conducted by the Project Proponent is as follows:

* Quantity extracted beyond the Movement Permit = 43961.643 MT

* Quantity extracted from the buffer zone = 4870.350 MT

* Illegally stacked quantity = 3240 MT

2.

The Project Proponent has remitted an amount of Rs.32,15,238/- as a penalty for the excess extraction of 43961.643 MT on 16.08.2023. An amount of Rs.20,46,484/- to compound the offence of extraction of 4870.350 MT from the buffer zone and for excess stocking of 3240 MT mineral was remitted on 07.01.2025. Altogether an amount of Rs.52,61,722/- was remitted to the Mining and Geology Department for over/illegal extraction.

3.

As per the EC and the approved mining plan, the permissible production is 1,52,000 MT per year. The Project Proponent has not exceeded this permissible limit even after the excess extraction of 43961.643 MT.

4.

The Project Proponent has violated the EC condition through the illegal extraction from the buffer zone, and for that, the environmental damage is to be assessed as decided by the Authority.

5.

The mining has reached the ultimate depth at approximately 295-300 meters AMSL. Further mining, as per the revised mining plan approved on 12.06.2023, shall be carried out only after obtaining a re-appraised Environmental Clearance (EC) from the SEIAA as per the O.M. dated 28.04.2023 of MoEFF & CC.

6.

The artificial extension of the second bench between BP6 and BP7 may be retained in its current form to improve the stability of the buffer zone.”

(underlined for emphasis)

7.

The learned Senior Counsel representing the petitioner would argue that the illegal/excessive mining made by the petitioner over the portions including buffer zone cannot be taken as a reason to impose even a temporary bar upon the mining activities of the petitioner since the aforesaid violations were compounded by the payment of penalty. It is further argued that the danger apprehended due to mining at buffer zone has been abated by the creation of benches. The argument in the above regard cannot be a justification for the flagrant violations of permit conditions committed by the petitioner with impunity and scant regard to the environmental damage caused by it. In this context, it is worth to note the observation of a Division Bench of this Court in the judgment dated 08.04.2026 in W.A.No.836/2026 (Ext.P18), which is extracted hereunder:

“7.

Prima facie, the findings in Ext.R9(a) shows certain illegal extraction. Any future mining activity shall be subject to an undertaking to be given by the writ appellant that all environment clearance conditions shall be strictly complied with, failing which it will be open for the authorities concerned to cancel the environmental clearance. The fact that there has been instances of past violations and offences have been compounded cannot be a justification to cause further environmental damage and exonerated by payment of fine.”

8.

It is to be noted that the first respondent has resorted to a temporary restraint upon the mining activities of the petitioner for valid reasons stated in Exts.P26 & P27. The permission for further extraction of minable minerals from the quarry run by the petitioner is yet to be decided by the first respondent upon completion of the procedures and formalities mentioned in Ext.P26. This Court, in exercise of its powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, is not expected to interfere with the aforesaid temporary restraint imposed by the first respondent upon the mining activities of the petitioner, since it is apparent that the petitioner had misused the permission granted for mining and resorted to blatant violations which can result in disastrous consequences. Therefore, the reliefs sought for by the petitioner in this writ petition, cannot be allowed.

In the result, the writ petition is hereby dismissed.