AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Rohit Kapoor , J.
The present batch of petitions, raise a common issue pertaining to the eligibility for appointment to the post of Civil Judge (Junior Division) in the Haryana Civil Service (Judicial Branch), arising out of the same recruitment process initiated by the Haryana Public Service Commission, (for short ‘the Commission’) and are therefore being disposed of together.
CWP-24075-2024 ‘Siddharth vs. Haryana Public Service Commission and others’ and CWP-24127-2024 ‘Sarabjot Kaur vs. State of Haryana and others’ were earlier heard along with this bunch, however, CM-11244-CWP-2026 and CM-11245-CWP-2026 were filed in the said petitions respectively, seeking re-hearing, and the said petitions were segregated vide order dated 14.07.2026, and were directed to be listed for rehearing.
Since the controversy involved is common, the facts are being taken principally from CWP-23407-2024 for the sake of brevity. However, the distinguishing features of each petition are noticed separately.
FACTUAL MATRIX
Advertisement No.1/2024 dated 01.01.2024 was published by the Commission inviting online applications for 174 posts (129 actual and 45 anticipated vacancies) of Civil Judge (Junior Division) in the Haryana Civil Service (Judicial Branch). Out of the posts advertised, 17 were reserved for Backward Classes-A (for short “BC-A”) and 03 for Backward Classes-B (for short “BC-B”). The online window was open from 05.01.2024 to 31.01.2024. The examination was to be conducted in accordance with the Punjab Civil Service (Judicial Branch) Rules, 1951, as applicable to the State of Haryana, (for short “the Rules”) and as amended vide notification No. GSR25/Const./Art.234 and 309/2023 dated 07.11.2023.
The relevant conditions of the advertisement read as under:
Clause 1. "… Their admission to all the stages of the examination will be purely provisional subject to satisfying the prescribed eligibility conditions. Mere issue of e-Admit Card to the candidate will not imply that his/her candidature has been finally cleared by the Commission. The Commission takes up verification of eligibility conditions with reference to original documents only after the candidate has qualified for Main Written Examination / Interview / Personality Test."
Note below Clause 9(A). "The candidates will have to upload the scanned documents/certificates in support of date of birth, category {viz. SC/ BCA / BCB /EWS/ ESM / DESM / DFF / PwBD} and all educational certificates at the time while applying online for the above posts. The category / caste certificates for BCA / BCB / EWS / DESM should have been issued during the year 2023-24 as per latest instructions issued by the Haryana Government in this regard. Further, these certificates should be valid for the year 2023-24. The BC-A / BC-B certificates should be issued according to Haryana Govt. Instructions dated 17.11.2021 & 22.03.2022. …"
Clause 29 (Reservation). "(i) The benefit of reservation will be given only to those SC/BC-A/BC-B/PwBD/ESM/EWS category candidates who are domicile of Haryana State. (ii) It is clarified that State Government has decided to specify the criteria for exclusion of persons within the Backward Classes as Creamy Layer, regarding reservation in Service and Admission as per notification No. 491-SW(1)2021 dated 17.11.2021. Therefore, the candidates belonging to BC-A/BC-B category of Haryana are required to attach latest/updated Certificate as per notification No. 491-SW(1)2021 dated 17-11-2021 & Govt. instructions No. 22/132/2013-1GS-III dated 22.03.2022 … issued by the Competent Authority during 2023-24 only. (iii) The women candidates seeking reservation under SC/BC-A/BC-B category are required to submit the Caste Certificate issued by the Competent Authority from Parental Side (Father's side) only. … (iv) The candidates of reserved categories of Haryana for which no post is available / reserved can apply for the posts of General category, if he / she fulfills all the eligibility conditions as meant for General category candidates, except fees. …"
Clause 30(vii). "Due care should be taken by the candidates while filling up the online application form. Incomplete or defective application form will be summarily rejected. No representation or correspondence regarding such rejection shall be entertained under any circumstances."
Clause 31, item 5. "Scanned copy of BCA & BCB certificate should be issued for the year 2023-24 as per Govt. Instructions dated 17.11.2021."
Clause 36(v). "The hard copy of application form along with all uploaded documents must be brought at the time when called upon to do so by the Commission. No document(s) which has/have not been uploaded shall be entertained."
The Government of Haryana issued notification dated 17.11.2021 under section 5(2) of the Haryana Backward Classes (Reservation in Services and Admission in Educational Institutions) Act, 2016 (for short “Act of 2016”). It specifies the criteria for excluding the creamy layer within the backward classes. Category V(Income/Wealth test) excludes the sons and daughters of parents having the gross annual income of Rs. 6 lacs or above, or possessing wealth above Rs.1 crore for a period of three consecutive years.
Instructions dated 22.03.2022 of the General Administration Department provide for issuance of caste certificate through the SARAL portal on the basis of the Parivar Pehchan Number (PPN), by the Additional Deputy Commissioner-cum-District Citizen Resources Information Officer. The provisions of those instructions that have a bearing on the present controversy read as under:
"3(xiii) Validity of a Caste Certificate.— (i) A Caste Certificate once issued (in its standard format) shall be valid for the life-time of the person so long as such caste/tribe is not removed or modified in the notifications issued by the Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes Department, Haryana. … (iii) Certificates which include income and/or assets based information like creamy layer criteria shall become invalid after the validity period prescribed on the said certificate. Such certificates shall be valid for the current financial year, i.e. till coming 31st March (included) from the date it has been issued.
3(xv)(d) Mere issuance of a Caste certificate does not entitle a person holding such certificate to any benefit that may be admissible under various Government Schemes implemented from time to time. Hence, it is important that the authority concerned examines the applicant's entitlement to any specific benefit in accordance with the instructions on the subject at any given point of time. For instance, a person from the Backward Class may not be entitled to certain benefits if he falls within the creamy layer as defined from time to time. Accordingly, the Caste Certificates shall address ONLY the caste of the certificate holder. Other eligibility criteria for a particular scheme shall be addressed separately by the authority extending any such benefit.
4.Further, it is directed that no Government Department of Haryana shall obligate any Haryana resident to submit caste related proof documents if he/she provides PPN and his/her caste and caste category is marked as verified in Family Information Data Repository (FIDR)."
It transpires that the preliminary examination was held on 03.03.2024, and its result was declared on 09.04.2024. The main written examination was held from 12.07.2024 to 14.07.2024, and on 24.08.2024, the Registrar (Recruitment) of this Court declared the result, whereby the roll numbers listed therein were declared provisionally qualified for the viva voce. On 28.08.2024, the schedule of the viva voce was published, fixing the interviews from 13.09.2024 to 29.09.2024. The Petitioners in the present petitioners, applied in the reserved categories of BC-A and BC-B, cleared the Preliminary Examination and the Main written exam, and were declared provisionally qualified for viva-voce. At the stage of scrutiny of documents, their candidature was rejected on the ground that the category certificate uploaded with the online application form had not been issued for the year 2023-2024. Certificates obtained and forwarded by them in response to the show-cause memos, were not entertained.
The petitioners took part in the viva-voce provisionally under interim orders of this Court and their results were kept in sealed cover. The recruitment has since been completed. As recorded in the order dated 22.09.2025, learned counsel for the High Court informed the Court that the selection, commenced in 2023-2024, concluded in 2025, whereafter appointments have been made.
Facts of CWP-23407-2024
The petitioner, Savita Tanwar, applied online on 09.01.2024 in BC-A category, disclosing her status as ‘married’. Along with the application, she uploaded a Backward Class certificate dated 21.10.2022, issued by the ADC Kurukshetra. While the certificate records the caste of the petitioner and that it is issued for the purposes of the Haryana Panchayati Raj (Amendment) Ordinance 2022, dated 02.09.2022, it contains no certification that the petitioner does not belong to the creamy layer.
Undisputedly, the petitioner qualified the preliminary examination and the main written examination, and her viva voce was scheduled for 14.09.2022. Vide memo dated 05.09.2024, the Commission informed her that her candidature had been found provisionally liable to rejection for the reason that her BC-A category certificate should have been issued for the year 2023-24, and from her parental side, as per the notification dated 17.11.2021 and instructions dated 22.03.2022. The petitioner responded by way of e-mails dated 05.09.2024 and 07.09.2024, as well as a representation of even date. She forwarded a backward class certificate dated 17.07.2024, which certifies her non-creamy layer status with reference to notification dated 16.07.2024, and also attached a report dated 06.09.2024 of the halqa patwari, routed through the Tehsilde, Thanesar. The report of the Patwari, which was made on her application seeking validation of her caste and non-creamy layer status for 2023-24, records that as per the Parviar Pehchan Patra, the yearly income of her family is between Rs. 3 lacs and Rs. 5 lacs. In the application, the petitioner herself stated that the 2022-23 certificate did not record anything about her belonging to the non-creamy layer. Additionally, she placed on record a Backward Class certificate dated 02.08.2006; OBC certificates dated 11.02.2022 and 05.09.2022; and a Backward Class certificate dated 01.03.2023 issued to her sister. It is pleaded that she underwent an emergency cesarian section on 17.12.2023, and that her newborn daughter required admission to the NICU on the said date, and yet again on 24.12.2023.
It is in this factual backdrop that the petitioner approached this Court. Since the Court was apprised by the counsel for the Commission that the petitioner’s candidature had been finally rejected on 12.09.2024, she sought time to amend the petition for laying challenge to the order, and in the meanwhile, was permitted to take part in the interview provisionally, and her result was directed to be kept in a sealed cover. The petitioner thereafter amended her petition and assailed the final rejection order dated 12.09.2024 (Annexure P-22). During the course of the proceedings, the sealed cover was opened in the Court on 04.11.2024, and the petitioner was found to have secured the minimum qualifying marks.
On 01.09.2025, the petitioner sought liberty to again amend the petition to incorporate the ground of migration of a reserved-category candidate, who has secured more marks than the last selected unreserved-category candidate, to the unreserved category. By CM-13696-CWP-2025, she accordingly sought to add an alternative prayer for consideration in the unreserved category.
On the observation of the Court, that the appointees who would be adversely affected, in case the petition is allowed, would have to be impleaded, the petitioner filed CM-14912-CWP-2025 under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC to implead the last two appointees of the unreserved category, Ms. Naina Jindal and Ms. Bipasha Khatana. The Petitioner has inter alia averred in the application that of the 101 unreserved posts, only 88 candidates qualified for selection, claiming that 13 unreserved posts remain unfilled. It is further averred that only 87 of the 88 candidates joined.
The Commission filed its written statement dated 19.11.2024 and, by CM-5900-CWP-2025, placed on record further facts clarifying its stand. Respondent No. 2 filed a short reply dated 20.11.2024.
Facts of CWP-23556-2024
The four petitioners in this petition applied under the BC-A category. In each case, the certificate uploaded with the application was issued between February and March, 2023. Each of the petitioners was found provisionally liable for rejection as per memo dated 05.09.2024, and their candidature was finally rejected vide order dated 12.09.2024. Fresh certificates submitted by them were issued between 25.08.2023 to 06.09.2023.
Each of the uploaded certificates makes a reference to the notification No.491-SW(1)-2021 dated 17.11.2021, as regards non-creamy layer status. The fresh certificates refer to notification No.40/13/2024-1SW dated 16.07.2024. The petitioners have also assailed the announcement dated 12.09.2024, whereby the candidature of 25 candidates, including the petitioners’, was declared to have been finally rejected.
By order dated 04.11.2024, the aggregate result of the petitioners, produced by the Recruitment Cell of this Court, was perused by the Court in a sealed envelope. Petitioner No. 1, Shubham Verma, was found to have secured the minimum qualifying marks. Petitioners No. 2 to 4, Geetanjali, Ankit and Gargee Naresh, were found not to have done so, and the petition was dismissed qua them. The petition now survives only qua petitioner No. 1.
Facts of CWP-23739-2024
The petitioner, Ramandeep Kaur, belongs to the BC-A category. She applied online on 16.01.2024, uploading the Backward Class certificate dated 04.03.2023, issued by the ADC, Kurukshetra, which certifies her non-creamy layer status as per notification dated 17.11.2021. On 05.09.2024, she forwarded a fresh certificate of even date by e-mail. The Commission issued memo No. Exam 10/2023/5882 on the same day and held the certificates not to be in order. In her representation dated 06.09.2024, the petitioner stated that the advertisement did not specify the financial year and asked that she be allowed to apply with the latest BC-A certificate as the financial year 2023-24 has already ended. Her candidature was finally rejected vide order dated 12.09.2024.
Facts of CWP-23927-2024
The petitioner, Varun, belongs to the BC-B category. He uploaded a certificate dated 20.03.2023, issued by the ADC, Bhiwani, with his application. The Commission vide memo dated 05.09.2024 raised a two-fold objection. Firstly, that the certificate should be issued for the year 2023-24, and secondly, that the domicile certificate of Haryana had not been attached. The petitioner by way of a representation dated 06.09.2024, asserted that the domicile certificate had been uploaded, as reflected in the confirmation slip dated 19.01.2024, and forwarded a fresh BC-B certificate dated 06.09.2024. A final rejection order dated 12.09.2024 was passed, maintaining both the grounds raised earlier.
SUBMISSIONS BY THE PETITIONERS
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners have, at the very outset, assailed the impugned rejection orders on the ground that the respondent authorities have failed to construe the requirements under the advertisement as well as the applicable statutory instructions, in the correct perspective. It is contended that perusal of the advertisement would show that what was required was a certificate ‘issued during the year 2023-24’, but it was not specified that the year meant financial year starting from 01.04.2023 to 31.03.2024. Submission is that the ambiguity must be resolved in favour of the candidates. While referring to paragraph 3(xiii)(i) of the instructions dated 22.03.2022, it is urged that a caste certificate is valid for life and the certificates in question carry no date of expiry.
It is further argued that membership of the backward classes outside the creamy layer, is a status. The certificate is only proof of that status, and such proof can be furnished later. Reliance is placed on Charles K. Skaria and others vs. Dr. C. Mathew and others, (1980) 2 SCC 752; Dolly Chhanda vs. Chairman, JEE and others (2005) 9 SCC 779; Ram Kumar Gijroya vs. Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board and another, (2016) 4 SCC 754; Union of India v. Rohith Nathan, (2026) 6 SCC 1; Divya Kalia vs. State of Haryana, 2025 SCC OnLine P&H 1790; and Haryana Staff Selection Commission vs. Subhash Chand and others, 2023 SCC OnLine P&H 568. It is contended that a backward class certificate is not akin to an academic qualification that must be acquired before the closing date.
It is submitted that the Commission having invited representations along with documentary proof, could not refuse to look at that proof on the ground that it was fresh. Submission is that the impugned orders/action are mechanical and perfunctory and would be hit by the doctrine of promissory estoppel. It is submitted that since roughly 70% of the recruitment process fell in the financial year 2024-25, therefore, the certificate which was current at the time of interview, should have been accepted. Citing past examples, it is urged that the Commission, in earlier recruitments has been inviting fresh forms, after the preliminary examination.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in CWP-23407-2024 has invited our attention to paragraph 4 of the instructions dated 22.03.2022, to submit that the same makes it abundantly clear that no department can insist on caste related documents from a resident whose Parivar Pehchan Number has been furnished, and whose caste is verified in the FIDR. It is contended that the petitioner had uploaded her PPP and her caste stands verified. It has been further argued that under the office memorandum dated 08.10.2015 of the Department of Personnel and Training, which is said to have been adopted by the State of Haryana, vide a letter dated 06.12.2022, the Commission was bound to accept the certificates uploaded as prima facie proof, and get them verified from the issuing authority.
It is further contended that Clause 1 of the Advertisement, authorises only the verification of original documents, and since the Commission scrutinized the forms before the Preliminary Examination, it must be taken that the petitioner’s eligibility was accepted. Her form was neither incomplete nor defective, therefore clause 36 (v) has no application. Further, the certificate dated 21.10.2022 was issued after the instructions dated 22.03.2022 and therefore satisfies the Note under Clause 9(A).
As regards the reference to the Haryana Panchayati Raj (Amendment) Ordinance, 2022, it is submitted that the same is a mistake of the office of the ADC Kurukshetra. Submission is that consequences of a mistake of the issuing authority, cannot be visited upon the Petitioner. It is pointed out that the State has, by notification dated 16.07.2024, raised the income limit for the creamy layer from Rs. 6 lakhs to Rs. 8 lakhs and the Commission, therefore could not have refused to act upon certificates issued under that notification.
It is additionally urged, that the petitioner had delivered a child by surgery on 17.12.2023, and the infant remained in the NICU for about a month. It is thus argued that compliance within the application window, was a physical impossibility, and denial of a maternity relaxation, offends Articles 14, 15(3), 16 and 21. Reliance is placed on Indian Institute of Science and Education vs. Dr. Smitha, 2021 SCC OnLine Ker 2483; Raghvendra Singh vs. Union Public Service Commission, 2025 SCC OnLine Del 9058; Dr. Rajat Ghosh vs. Tripura University, 2026 SCC OnLine Tri 197; and Indra Sawhney vs. Union of India, 1992 Supp. (3) SCC 217.
Apart from the aforementioned arguments, learned counsel appearing in CWP-23407-2024 has argued that in the alternative, the petitioner should be appointed against an unreserved vacancy. Reliance is placed on clause 11 of notification No. GSR 25/Const./Art./234 and 309/2023 dated 07.11.2023, and Chaya vs. State of Maharashtra, 2026 SCC Online SC 457, and Avinash Yadav vs. Haryana Public Service Commission, 2024 NCPHHC 38811(DB) in support of the contentions raised. It is pointed out that the Selection Committee has placed the petitioner in the unreserved category in the final list.
Lastly, an argument raised by the learned counsel appearing in CWP-23927-2024, may be noticed, who while adopting the arguments raised by the other learned counsel, has assailed the order of rejection on the ground that the same was based upon a wrong factual premise that the domicile certificate of the petitioner in the said petition, was not uploaded with the application form.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE RESPONDENTS
Per contra, learned counsels appearing on behalf of the respondents have controverted and repelled the arguments raised by the petitioners by contending that a conjoint reading of the note mentioned below clause 9(A) of the advertisement, read with instructions dated 17.11.2021 and 22.03.2022, would show that a BC-A/BC-B candidate had to upload, along with the application, a certificate issued after 01.04.2023 and before 31.01.2024, i.e. the closing date. Submission is that clause 36(v) of the advertisement bars the consideration of any document not uploaded with the application. It is further contended that the fresh certificates were in any case issued under the instructions dated 16.07.2024, which altered the creamy layer criteria and relate to 2024-25. It is stated that creamy layer status is dynamic, which is why a year-specific certificate was required. It is pointed out that the conditions of the advertisement were never challenged, and must be strictly complied with.
Elaborating the above contentions, it is submitted that a BC-A/BC-B (non-creamy layer) certificate, is issued on the basis of the income of the previous financial year and the assets of the last three financial years. A certificate issued in the year 2023-24 would thus reflect income during 01.04.2022 to 31.03.2023, whereas a certificate issued in the year 2024-2025, would reflect income during 01.04.2023 to 31.03.2024. The notification dated 16.07.2024, has raised the income limit for the creamy layer from Rs. 6 lakhs to Rs. 8 lakhs for a period of three consecutive years and provides that income from salaries and agricultural land shall not be clubbed. Submission is that a certificate issued under the said notification is materially different from the one issued under the notification dated 17.11.2021.
Our attention has been invited to the certificate uploaded by the petitioner in CWP-23407-2024, alongwith her application and it is submitted that the same does not specify exclusion from creamy layer. As regards the OBC certificates brought on record by the said petitioner, it is contended that there is no reservation for “OBC” in the recruitment. It is further pointed out that central OBC certificates, are issued under the instructions of the Government of India, and were in any case not uploaded. It is argued that there was sufficient time to obtain the stipulated certificate and as regards the plea of health condition, it is submitted that no such ground was raised in the representation nor there is any provision for making such relaxation.
While adverting to the certificates of petitioner no. 1 in CWP-23556-2024, and the petitioners in CWP-23739-2024 and CWP-23927-2024, it is submitted that although the same were issued under the instructions of 17.11.2021, however, they pertained to the period 01.04.2021 to 31.3.2022, besides the fact that their validity was only till 31.03.2023.
Learned Senior Counsel and learned Counsel representing the High Court, have additionally contended that under the advertisement, the eligibility of the candidates is to be decided by the Commission and that since the impugned orders have also been passed by the Commission, the petitioners have no grievance against the High Court, and the petitions are therefore not maintainable against it.
POINTS OF DETERMINATION:-
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the material available on record, with their able assistance. Upon consideration of the rival contentions of the parties, the following issues fall for our consideration:-
Whether the requirement that a BC-A/BC-B certificate should have been issued during the year 2023-24 and should be valid for the said period, was satisfied by the petitioners by the cut-off date of 31.01.2024?
Whether the said requirement is that of eligibility, or merely one of proof that could be supplied after the closing date?; and was the Commission bound to act upon the certificates furnished in response to the memos dated 05.09.2024?
Do the additional grounds urged in CWP-23407-2024 with regard to the PPN/FIDR mechanism, the office memorandum dated 08.10.2015, the maternity circumstances, and the stage at which the process stood, make out a case for interference?
What is the effect of rejection of the claim to reservation on the said petitioner’s candidature as a whole, including the alternative claim to an unreserved post?
ANALYSIS
At the outset, it is necessary to take note of the decision passed by this Bench in the case of Haryana Public Service Commission vs. Pardeep Kumar, LPA-1397-2025 and other connected appeals, decided on 03.11.2025, 2025 NCPHHC 150786, whereby a similar controversy stands decided. In the facts of the said case, the advertisement issued by the Commission, carried a materially identical stipulation requiring BC-A/BC-B certificates issued for the year 2024-25, in terms of the notification and instructions dated 17.11.2021 and 22.03.2022. The candidates in the said petitions had similarly been issued provisional rejection notices and had in response furnished fresh certificates with their representations, which were finally rejected. While allowing the appeals filed by the Commission, this Court inter alia observed as under:-
“54.The facts of the present LPAs are analyzed, and we find that the advertisement clearly required the candidates to submit BC(A)/BC(B) certificate. The advertisement was issued in June 2024 i.e. 21.06.2024. The candidates, who claimed reservation for BC(A)and BC(B), were required to belong to Non-Creamy Layer. The determination of Non-Creamy Layer is with reference to the income and assets of a candidate. Certificate of BC(A)/BC(B) are, therefore, based on changing financial status of the applicant and therefore, it becomes necessary for the appellant-Commission to require the candidate to submit the certificate issued before the cut-off date. xxx
57.It is undisputed that all the respondents-writ petitioners claimed reservation in BC(A)/BC(B) or EWS category but had not submitted their respective caste certificate of the relevant period. In the leading case, the respondent No.1-Pradeep Kumar submitted the BC(A) certificate dated 31.12.2019. Similarly, BC(A)/BC(B) certificates of all other candidates/respondents were not of the relevant period as per the advertisement. The candidates were required to be possessed of the certificates on the last date of making of application i.e. 12.07.2024. The certificates annexed by them since were not in terms of the advertisement, therefore, they were rightly ignored. xxx
63.Similarly, the action of the appellant-Commission in inviting of representation could not have been construed as an act of extending the last date fixed for submission of application forms. What was intended by the appellant-Commission, as is apparent from its notice, was to give an opportunity to the candidates to explain their position as to the proposed ground of rejection. The intent was only to give an opportunity to clarify any factual error in the proposed ground for rejection, the number of applications being large. The perusal of the notice rather fortifies that the parameters on which the entitlement/eligibility for reservation were to be adjudged, was to be done strictly as per the provisions of the advertisement.”
The Special Leave Petitions against the said judgment were dismissed by the Supreme Court on 16.12.2025 in Naveen Kumar vs. Haryana Public Service Commission, SLP(C) Nos. 35944-35968 of 2025.
Point (i)- The meaning of the requirement, and whether it was met.
The expression ‘2023-24’ is not a calendar year. It is the conventional description of a financial year, and the advertisement does not leave this to inference. The note below clause 9(a) requires the certificate both to ‘have been issued during the year 2023-24’ and ‘to be valid for the year 2023-24’. It also directs that BC certificates be issued according to the instructions dated 17.11.2021 and 22.03.2022. Paragraph 3(xiii)(iii) of the latter makes every certificate that carries creamy-layer information valid only for the current financial year, i.e. till 31st March from the date it has been issued. Read together, these clauses can be construed in only one manner. A BC-A/BC-B certificate would meet the requirements under the advertisement only if it was issued within the financial year 2023-24, and was in possession of the candidate on the closing date i.e. 31st January, 2024. 39. The plea of ambiguity would not be available to the petitioners, for two reasons. Firstly, none of them sought any clarification before applying, and all of them took part in the process on their own reading of the clause. In such circumstances, as held in Mohit Kumar vs. State of U.P., 2025 SCC Online SC 1125, the courts should lean in favour of the recruiting authority's understanding of the term. Para 19 of the judgement is relevant and is extracted as under:
“It is no longer res integra that terms of an advertisement issued in connection with the selection process are normally not open to challenge, unless the challenge is founded on the ground of breach of article 16 of the constitution or, for that matter, Article 14. Once an advertisement is issued inviting applications for public employment, it is the responsibility, nay duty, of an aspirant to read and note the terms and understand what its requirements are. If any aspirant finds any of the terms ambiguous and there is scope for an inquiry inbuilt in the advertisement or is provided by any rule/regulation, an effort ought to be first made to obtain clarity for understanding the requirements accurately. If no such scope is available, nothing prevents the aspirant from seeking clarity by making a representation. Should such clarity be not provided, the aspirant may participate in the process without prejudice to his rights and may question the term even after he is not selected. However, if the aspirant does not make any such effort and takes a calculated chance of selection based on his own understanding of the disputed term in the advertisement and later, he emerges unsuccessful, ordinarily, it would not be open to him to challenge the selection on the ground that the disputed term is capable of being understood differently. In such cases, the courts should be loath to entertain such plea of ambiguity while preferring to accept the recruiting authorities understanding of the said term. This is for the simple reason that the recruitment authority is the best judge of what its requirements are and it is such understanding of the recruiting authority that would matter more in cases brought up before the courts; hence, after commencement of the process wherein aspirants have participated without raising any demur as to what a particular term means, even if any of the terms be ambiguous, the courts should lean in favour of the recruiting authority.”
Secondly, the question is academic for the certificates in issue. The certificates dated 21.10.2022 (Savita Tanwar), 15.02.2023 (Shubham Verma), 04.03.2023 (Ramandeep Kaur) and 20.03.2023 (Varun) were all issued, in the financial year 2022-23. By force of paragraph 3(xiii)(iii), each of them ceased to be valid on 31.03.2023, nine months before the advertisement was even issued. Whatever reading is given to "2023-24", none of these certificates was a valid non-creamy-layer certificate on 31.01.2024.
The reliance on paragraph 3(xiii)(i), which makes a caste certificate valid for life, overlooks the distinction drawn in the instructions themselves. A certificate of caste alone does not lapse. A certificate that speaks of income or assets lapses at the end of the financial year. Membership of the Nai, Kumhar, Khati, Labana or Saini caste is not in question. What is in question is whether each petitioner stood outside the creamy layer, and that is an income- and asset-based determination which the instructions confine to the financial year of issue. That is why this bench in Pardeep Kumar (supra) described these certificates as "based on changing financial status of the applicant".
The Supreme Court has held that a certificate relating to a financial year other than the one stipulated is not a mere irregularity. In Union Public Service Commission v. Gaurav Singh, (2024) 2 SCC 605, the Court said:
"18.A technical irregularity in a certificate issued by the competent authority in respect of the correct financial year cannot be equated with an Income and Asset Certificate in respect of a different financial year when the income and assets for the particular financial year prior to the year of submission of the application, goes to the root of eligibility of a candidate to qualify in the EWS category."
In Poonam Dwivedi v. State of U.P., 2026 SCC OnLine SC 577, the Supreme Court applied Gaurav Singh and Divya v. Union of India, (2024) 1 SCC 448. It answered an argument similar to the one now raised by noticing that the certificates relied on had been obtained even before the advertisement was published, and that "those candidates could have applied for fresh certificates in terms of the advertisement if their earlier certificates were not in conformity with the advertisement". That observation applies squarely to every petitioner before us. The advertisement was published on 01.01.2024 and the online window remained open till 31.01.2024. Certificates under the instructions dated 22.03.2022 are issued through the SARAL portal. Nothing prevented the petitioners from obtaining a certificate in terms of the advertisement, within that window.
Point (i) is answered accordingly. None of the certificates uploaded by the petitioners with their applications satisfied the requirement of the advertisement on the closing date.
Point (ii): eligibility or proof
The petitioners' principal argument rests on the distinction between eligibility and proof of eligibility, drawn in Charles K. Skaria and Dolly Chhanda. In Charles K. Skaria, the Court held that what is essential is the possession of the diploma before the given date, while "what is ancillary is the safe mode of proof of the qualification". In Dolly Chhanda, the Court, after reiterating the general rule that eligibility must be possessed on the last date fixed, observed that "depending upon the facts of a case, there can be some relaxation in the matter of submission of proof".
The Supreme Court has thereafter explained the limits of that line of cases in the specific context of income- and asset-based category certificates. In Divya v. Union of India, (supra), it held that "the eligibility for being categorized as EWS candidate crystallizes only when the I&AC is issued and, in this case, as required under the rules, it was to be issued and possessed by the candidate before 22.02.2022". That, the Court said, "is the fundamental distinction between the Charles J. Skaria (supra) line of cases and the cases at hand". It added that in the absence of a rule or a date prescribed in the advertisement, "there is a judicial chorus holding that it would be the last date for submission of the application". Divya also held Ram Kumar Gijroya to be distinguishable, noting that its correctness had been doubted and referred to a larger Bench.
A Bench of three Judges in Sakshi Arha v. Rajasthan High Court, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 757 then dealt with OBC/MBC non-creamy-layer certificates in a recruitment of Civil Judges, which is the precise subject before us. The Court held:
"34.Moreover, the decisions of this Court have cleared the air of any doubt that the claim made by a candidate while filling his or her application as per the concerned advertisement are to hold good as on the date of his or her application or as per the last date of submission of applications prescribed by the concerned advertisement. xxx
36.xxx … No relaxation can be granted in the given facts and circumstances of the case nor can it be claimed as a matter of right in the absence of any such discretionary clause in the Advertisement/Rules/Instructions."
The principles enunciated in Sakshi Arha (supra), hold good in the present case also. No petitioner applied for a 2023-24 certificate before the closing date. Every fresh certificate was applied for, and issued, after the memos of 05.09.2024, or shortly before them, and in each case months after the closing date.
This bench in Pardeep Kumar reached the same conclusion on Dolly Chhanda and Charles K. Skaria. In the said cases, the candidate held the qualification on the relevant date and the authority had erred in certifying it. Divorced from those facts, the cases do not dispense with proof of eligibility by the cut-off date. A Division Bench of this Court in Yoshika Verma v. Union of India, 2022 SCC OnLine P&H 3760 declined relief to a candidate who had uploaded an OBC-NCL certificate of an earlier year in breach of a requirement that it be issued on or after a specified date. The special leave petition against the said decision was dismissed.
In Mohit Kumar (supra), the Supreme Court further held that the status claimed by an aspirant "is per se not decisive" and has to be certified by the competent authority. It also held that "once a process of recruitment is set in motion, all aspirants are entitled in law to equal treatment. There cannot be different yardsticks for different sets of aspirants." The force of that observation is evident here. The Announcement dated 12.09.2024 shows that the petitioners were not alone. Other candidates, and those who did not apply at all for want of a current certificate, stand on the same footing. To admit certificates obtained in September 2024 for these petitioners alone would be to extend the closing date for them alone.
The decisions relied upon by the petitioners do not assist them, as the same are based upon distinct facts. Divya Kalia(supra) concerned a Scheduled Caste certificate, which under paragraph 3(xiii)(i) is valid for life. The only defect was the absence of a registration number and date, which was attributable solely to the issuing authority, and the issuing authority vouched for the certificate. In Subhash Chand (supra), the relief turned on the circumstance that the Commission had, without informing the candidates, withheld the very reservation under which the candidate had applied. The Bench held that the Commission could not then hold the candidate to the cut-off date for claiming another category. There is no comparable conduct on the part of the Commission here.
Union of India v. Rohith Nathan, (supra) concerns the substantive criteria for determining the creamy layer among OBC candidates. It has no bearing on the date by which a certificate attesting non-creamy-layer status must be held.
In Dr. Rajat Ghosh (supra), the Tripura High Court upheld the acceptance of a later OBC-NCL certificate in a recruitment by a Central University, to which the Office Memoranda of the Department of Personnel and Training dated 08.10.2015 and 29.03.2023 applied of their own force. The Division Bench expressly recognised that Sakshi Arha "specifically deals with OBC-NCL Certificate and holds that it cannot be produced by a candidate beyond the cut-off date". It held that those Office Memoranda "do not apply to the post of Civil Judge cadre" recruited under State judicial service rules.
As to the fresh certificates, they could not have been acted upon in any event. Clause 36(v) of the advertisement stippulates in no uncertain terms and that any document, not uploaded shall not be entertained. The certificates were issued, according to their own recitals, with reference to notification No. 40/13/2024-1SW dated 16.07.2024. That notification raised the income limit from Rs. 6,00,000 to Rs. 8,00,000 and excluded income from salaries and agricultural land from the computation. According to the Commission, a certificate of 2024-25 also assesses income of a later period (01.04.2023 to 31.03.2024) than a certificate of 2023-24 would (01.04.2022 to 31.03.2023). A certificate so issued certifies a different thing, under different criteria, for a different period. It cannot establish that the holder satisfied the criteria of the notification dated 17.11.2021 for the year 2023-24, which is what the advertisement required.
The plea that the Commission, was bound to give effect to the enhanced limit misconceives the position. The eligibility of candidates in a recruitment is determined by the conditions in force on the closing date. A change in the criteria, made by the State some six months after that date, cannot be applied to this recruitment alone, and selectively, in favour of those who did not hold the required certificate. The Patwari's report dated 06.09.2024 placed on record in CWP-23407-2024 suffers from the further infirmity that it is not a certificate of the competent authority under paragraph 3(xii) of the instructions dated 22.03.2022.
The argument that the memos dated 05.09.2024 be read as an invitation to cure the deficiency, is wholly misconceived and as held in Pardeep Kumar, an opportunity to explain a proposed ground of rejection, is not an extension of the closing date. The final orders are brief, but the ground on which they rest is clear and is correct in law. The plea of promissory estoppel fails for want of any representation by the Commission on which the petitioners acted to their detriment.
Point (ii) is answered against the petitioners. The requirement of a valid non-creamy-layer certificate issued in 2023-24, held on the closing date, is a condition of the claim to reservation itself. The Commission was neither bound nor entitled to act upon certificates obtained thereafter.
Point (iii): the additional grounds urged in CWP-23407-2024
The petitioner in the said case stands on a weaker ground than the others. The certificate she uploaded was not issued under the instructions dated 17.11.2021 at all. It was issued "for the purposes of the Haryana Panchayati Raj (Amendment) Ordinance, 2022" and certifies nothing about the creamy layer. Her own application to the Tehsildar dated 06.09.2024 acknowledges as much. The certificate thus failed the requirement of the advertisement on two counts. It was not of the year 2023-24, and it was not a non-creamy-layer certificate at all. The central OBC certificates dated 11.02.2022 and 05.09.2022 were issued under the instructions of the Government of India for other purposes, were themselves of the financial year 2021-22 and 2022-23, and admittedly were not uploaded with the application. The certificate dated 02.08.2006 is of no avail for the same reasons.
The reliance by the said petitioners on paragraph 4 of the instructions dated 22.03.2022, also does not come to her rescue. It relieves a resident of the need to submit "caste related proof documents" where the Parivar Pehchan Number is furnished and the caste and caste category are marked as verified in the FIDR. Paragraph 3(xv)(d) of the same instructions makes it clear that a caste certificate addresses only the caste of the holder. Entitlement to a benefit that depends on the creamy-layer criteria is a separate question, to be addressed "separately by the authority extending any such benefit". Verification of caste in the FIDR is not a determination that the holder stands outside the creamy layer. The Parivar Pehchan Patra printout placed on record in CWP-23739-2024 itself carries a disclaimer that it is not proof of verified information. Besides, the advertisement expressly required a BC certificate of the year 2023-24, and that condition was never questioned.
Paragraph 4 of the Office Memorandum of the Department of Personnel and Training dated 08.10.2015 is noticed in Dr. Rajat Ghosh (supra). It provides that where a Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe or Other Backward Class candidate "is unable to produce a certificate from any of the prescribed authorities", he or she may be appointed provisionally on whatever prima facie proof is produced, subject to furnishing the prescribed certificate within a reasonable time. Where there is genuine difficulty in obtaining a certificate, the appointing authority may itself verify the claim through the District Magistrate. The petitioner says that the State of Haryana has adopted the Memorandum by letter dated 06.12.2022 (Annexure P-26). The letter dated 06.12.2022 (Annexure P-26), however, is issued under the subject "Timely verification of Caste/Community Certificates". It forwards a communication of the Government of India dated 21.10.2022 and asks all concerned to adhere to the instructions on "timely completion of the process of caste verification of the employees". It is concerned with the verification of the certificates of persons already in employment. It does not make paragraph 4 of the Memorandum a condition of recruitment by the Commission, and it says nothing about the period of validity of non-creamy-layer certificates. The plea therefore fails for the reason that it is an executive instruction which does not govern recruitment of Civil Judges. It cannot over ride a specific condition of the advertisement, and because the petitioner chose to upload a certificate, which said nothing about her non-creamy-layer status for 2023-24.
We have given our anxious consideration to the circumstances in which the petitioner found herself in December 2023 and January 2024. Her account of a surgical delivery and of a new-born in intensive care is not disputed, and it commands sympathy. However, sympathy cannot supply what the law does not permit, for several reasons:
The financial year 2023-24 began on 01.04.2023, more than eight months before the delivery, and a non-creamy-layer certificate is issued online through the SARAL portal.
The petitioner did not ask the Commission for time before the closing date, and her representations against the provisional rejection, dated 05.09.2024 and 07.09.2024, did not mention her health.
The deficiency was not of timing alone. The certificate she chose to upload was not a non-creamy-layer certificate at all.
The condition applies alike to every candidate, man or woman, and cannot be said to penalise motherhood. Neither the Rules nor the advertisement provide for relaxation.
In State of Tamil Nadu v. G. Hemalathaa, (2020) 19 SCC 430, also a case of recruitment of Civil Judges, the Supreme Court set aside relief granted on humanitarian grounds. It held that instructions issued by the Commission "are mandatory, having the force of law" and that the High Court under Article 226 "cannot modify/relax" them. The decision of the Kerala High Court in Dr. Smitha V.S., on which the petitioner places particular reliance, turned on the terms of that recruitment notification. Clause 10 of the notification adopted the norms of the Union Government, and those norms, issued on 17.08.2017 with the concurrence of the Department of Personnel and Training, had expressly relaxed the insistence on OBC certificates issued within the cut-off dates. The candidate's pregnancy was noticed as an additional circumstance, not as the foundation of the relief. There is no corresponding norm here. On the contrary, the advertisement forbids the entertaining of documents not uploaded. The decision also precedes Divya and Sakshi Arha.
The plea that the reference in the certificate to the Haryana Panchayati Raj (Amendment) Ordinance, 2022 was a mistake of the issuing office, can also not be countenanced, as nothing has been placed on record from the office of the Additional Deputy Commissioner acknowledging any mistake, nor is there anything to show that the petitioner applied in 2022 for a non-creamy-layer certificate under the instructions dated 17.11.2021. The petitioner held the certificate for more than fifteen months before uploading it, and she chose to upload it as it stood. More importantly, the asserted mistake makes no difference. Even if the certificate dated 21.10.2022 had been a non-creamy-layer certificate in the standard form, it would have been a certificate of the financial year 2022-23. By paragraph 3(xiii)(iii) it would have lapsed on 31.03.2023, like the certificates of the other petitioners.
For the same reason, the submission that the certificate satisfies the Note below Clause 9(A) because it was issued after 22.03.2022 cannot be accepted. The Note requires a certificate issued during, and valid for, the year 2023-24, not merely one issued after the date of the instructions.
Paragraph 3(xv)(e) of the instructions dated 22.03.2022 requires Government organisations to accept a caste certificate in its standard format. The Commission has not doubted that the petitioner belongs to the Nai caste. The certificate has been accepted for what it certifies, namely caste. As paragraph 3(xv)(d) of the same instructions makes clear, a caste certificate addresses only the caste of the holder. It does not address the creamy layer.
The contention of the petitioner that her representation dated 07.09.2024 was not considered, even if taken to be correct, would be of no consequence as the certificate dated 17.07.2024 and the Patwari's report were obtained after the closing date.
The plea that most of the process fell in 2024-25, and therefore a 2024-25 certificate should have sufficed, runs directly against the settled rule that a claim must hold good on the closing date (see Sakshi Arha(supra) and Divya(supra) ). Further, a 2024-25- certificate pertains to income in a later year. As for the alleged practice of inviting fresh forms after the Preliminary Examination, no material has been placed to show such a practice in this recruitment. In any case, no parity can be claimed in breach of the terms of the advertisement (see paragraph 65 of Pardeep Kumar(supra)).
Point (iii) is answered against the petitioner.
Point (iv): the alternative claim to an unreserved post
The petitioner in CWP-23407-2024 seeks, in the alternative, appointment against an unreserved vacancy. That relief was sought by CM-13696-CWP-2025. She relies on paragraph 11 of the notification dated 07.11.2023 and asserts that the Selection Committee has placed her in the unreserved category in the final result. Paragraph 11 of the Rules, as substituted by the notification dated 07.11.2023 (Annexure P-23), reads:
"11.Candidates shall be selected for appointment strictly in the order in which they have been placed by the Selection Committee: Provided that in the case of candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes, Selection Committee shall have a right to select in order of merit a candidate who has merely qualified irrespective of the position obtained by him in the examination: Provided further that the selection of candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes in the order of merit inter-se shall be made against the vacancies reserved for them and in the manner to be adopted by the Selection Committee."
The main part of paragraph 11 requires selection strictly in order of merit. The provisos concern candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes, which is the very status the petitioner has failed to establish in terms of the advertisement. The paragraph does not, by itself, entitle a candidate whose claim to a reserved category has failed, to be placed in the unreserved category on reserved-category standards.
The second proviso to paragraph 9 of the Rules, as substituted by the notification dated 07.11.2023 (Annexure P-23), reads:
"Provided further that only those candidates shall be eligible to be recruited as Civil Judges/Judicial Magistrates who secure fifty percent or more marks (forty-five percent for the Scheduled Caste, Backward Classes, Physically Handicapped and Ex-Serviceman candidates only but not dependents of ESM candidates) in aggregate of the marks secured in the main written examination and the viva-voce."
The Main Written Examination carries 900 marks and the viva-voce 200, an aggregate of 1100. A General category candidate must therefore secure at least 550 marks to be eligible for recruitment. A Backward Classes candidate needs 495. Record reveals that the petitioner secured 507.40 marks in the aggregate of the Main Written Examination and the viva-voce, that is, 46.13%. That is what the order dated 04.11.2024 recorded as "minimum qualifying marks". It is the minimum prescribed for the Backward Classes, not the minimum prescribed for the General category.
Since the petitioner does not secure the 50% required of a General category candidate, she is not eligible to be recruited in that category. It follows that the number of unfilled unreserved posts is immaterial to her claim. The question whether she stands above the last selected unreserved candidate does not arise, since that candidate must himself or herself have secured at least 550 marks, and paragraph 11 does not help her. It’s proviso’s operate only in favour of candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes, and only against the vacancies reserved for them, and the petitioner has not established that status in terms of the advertisement.
The ratio laid down in Chaya(supra) does not assist her either. That decision treats a concession at a qualifying stage as one that "merely enables entry of a candidate into the zone of consideration" without affecting merit, which is determined by the main examination and the interview. The 50% standard in paragraph 9 is not such a concession. It is the final standard of eligibility for recruitment, applied to the very aggregate that determines merit. Under Chaya itself, a candidate who does not meet the essential eligibility criteria, cannot migrate to open category. Avinash Yadav, which concerns the stage at which migration is to be examined, is also not attracted, for the same reason.
In this view, it is unnecessary to examine the averment in CM-14912-CWP-2025 that 13 unreserved posts remain unfilled. It is equally unnecessary to decide whether the last two appointees of the unreserved category should be impleaded, since no relief that could affect them is called for.
The domicile ground in CWP-23927-2024
In view of the discussion made hereinabove which on its own is sufficient to sustain the rejection of the petitioner's claim to the BC-B category, it is unnecessary to examine the second ground, that the domicile certificate was not uploaded. Even otherwise, the application form and the confirmation slip dated 19.01.2024 ,on which the petitioner relies, are not on record.
CONCLUSION
As a sequel to the findings and reasons recorded above, we hold as under:-
The requirement of the advertisement that a BC-A/BC-B certificate is required to be issued during the Financial Year 2023-24 and should also be valid for the said financial year, and that the same was required to be uploaded with the application by the cut-off date of 31.01.2024, was lawful and binding. Undisputedly, none of the petitioners satisfied the said mandatory condition.
The certificates obtained after the closing date, could not be acted upon. The Commission committed no illegality in declining to rely upon the same.
The memos dated 05.09.2024, the final rejection orders dated 12.09.2024 and the announcement dated 12.09.2024, do not call for any interference.
Accordingly, all four petitions are dismissed with no order as to costs.
Pending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of accordingly.
