Satyabhama Choudhary vs State Of Madhya Pradesh & Others

Extracted from the

order of learned

Collector",Learned Commissioner,"Extracted from the order of

the District Programme

Officer

(R/1)

ewy vfHkys[k ,oa

mRrjoknh dks tkjh chih,y

jk'ku dkMZ ds laca/k esa

izdj.k ds lkFk layXu

nLrkostksa dk voyksdu

fd;k x;kA ftyk

Lrjh; lfefr }kjk vihykFkhZ

}kjk yxkbZ xbZ vkifRr ds

laca/k esa fnukad

18@11@15 dks Li""V :i ls","izdj.k esa okn fcUnq ek=

;g gS fd D;k vihykFkhZ

n~okjk izLrqr ch0ih0,y0

dkMZ QthZ gSAd ysDVj

flouh ,oa ifj;kstuk vf/kdkjh

ds ewy vfHkys[kksa dk

voyksdu ds voyksdu ls Li""V

gS fd vihykFkhZ n~okjk

ifj;kstuk vf/kdkjh ds le{k

vkosnu ds","dk;kZy; ftyk dk;Zdze

vf/kdkjh] ,dhd`r cky fodkl

lsok] ftyk&flouh

dzekad@2901@dk;ZdrkZ]fu;qf

Dr@2016Â Â Â Â flouh]

fnukad

15@02@2016

izfr]

ifj;kstuk vf/kdkjh]

,dhd`r cky fodkl

fu.kZ; fn;k x;k Fkk fd

^^lgk;d lapkyd tkap dj

izfrosnu izLrqr djsaA

ifj;kstuk vf/kdkjh cj?

kkV fu;qfDr ls lacaf/kr

le Lr vfHkys[k lgk;d

lapkyd dks mifLFkr

djkos^^ ftyk Lrjh; lfefr

ds fu.kZ; ds ikyu esa lgk;d

lapkyd lhih- tk;loky ds }kjk

tkap izfrosnu dzekad 2901

fnukad 15@2@16 dks

tkap djrs gq, izfrosnu

ifj;kstuk vf/kdkjh cj?kkV

dks izLrqr fd;k x;kA izLrqr

fd;s x;s tkap izfrosnu esa

izeq[k :i ls ;g ys[k fd;k x;k

gS fd ^^¼1½ eq[;

dk;Zikyu vf/kdkjh tuin","lkFk izLrqr ch0,y0 jk'ku

dkMZ dh Nk;k izfr ds

voyksdu ls Li""V gS fd

vihykFkhZ ds ifr jhiflag dks

rglhynkj ,oa lfpo ds gLrk{kj

ls fnukad @2015 dks jk'ku

dkMZ tkjh fd;k x;k gSA

rglhynkj cj?kkV ds i=

dzekad D;w fnukad

29@9@2015 dks vkosnd

jhiflag firk dkSMwyky iaokj

dks 14 vad iznku djrsgq,

eq[; dk;Zikyu vf/kdkjh tuin

iapk;r cj?kV dks xjhch js[kk

dk ik= crkrs gq, ch0ih0,y0

lwph esa uke tksMs tkus ds

funsZ'k fn, x, FksA ijUrq

vihykFkhZ n~okjk izLrqr

ch0ih0,y0 dkMZ dkMZ

rglhynkj n~okjk tkjhi= ds

iwoZ dk cuk izLrqr fd;k x;k

gSA tks fu%lans'k dwV

jfpr nLrkostksa dh Js.kh

esa vkrk gSA vr% izdj.k

esa dysDVj flouh

n~okjkfy;k x;k fopkj.k fof/k

vuqdwy gksus ls mlesa fdlh

izdkj ds gLr{ksi dh vko';drk

ugha gksus ls fLFkj j[ks

tkus ;ksX; gSA

      Â

 mijksDr foospkuqlkj

dysDVj flouh n~okjk izdj.k

dzekad vkj0lh0,e0,l0

0010@2015&16 esa ikfjr

vk fnukad 20@09@2016

fof/k vuq:i gksus ls fLFkj

j[kk tkrk gSA vihykFkhZ

n~okjk izLrqr vihy lkjghu

gksus ls

[kkfjt dh tkrh gSA","ifj;kstuk] cj?kkV]

ftyk&flouhA fo""k;%&

vkaxuokM+h dsUnz

vks>kVksyk ds fu;qfDr ls

lacaf/kr nLrkost miyC/k

djkus ds laca/k esaA

lanHkZ%& 01&ftyk dk;Zdze

vf/kdkjh] ,dhd`r cky fodkl lsok]

flouh dk i= dza-

@2120@fnukad 14-12-15

02&Â Â Â Â Â Â

vkidk      i=

dzekad@524@fu;qfDr@fnuka

d 04-01-2016Â Â Â Â Â Â Â

&&00&&Â Â Â Â Â Â

fo""k;karxZr xzke iapk;r vjh ds

rgr feuh vkaxuokMh dsUnz

vks>kVksyk esa dk;ZdrkZ

fu;qfDr ds laca/k esa lanfHkZr

i= dzekad&02 ls izkIr

funsZ'kkuqlkj oLrfLFkfr

tkudkjh yh xbZ gSA ftldh

fcUnqokj fLFkfr fuEukuqlkj gS

% & 01& ftyk dk;Zdze

vf/kdkjh] ,dhd`r cky fodkl lsok]

flouh dk i=

dzekad@2828@fnukad 20-

012016 }kjk rglhynkj cj?kkV

ftyk&flouh ls Jh jhiflag firk Jh

dkSnwyky fuoklh xzke iapk;r

vjh ds xzke vjh fuoklh dks tkjh

ch-ih-,ydkMZ dzekad 89669 ds

lca/k esa ,oa dk;kZy; rglhynkj

cj?kkV ds i=

dzekad@D;w@fnukad 28-

092015 ds i= dh iqf""V djus i=

fy[kk x;k

FkkAÂ Â Â Â Â Â Â

rglhynkj cj?kkV } kjk vkt

iapk;r cj?kkV }kjk,,

lacaf/kr dks chih,y losZ",,

dzekad tkjh ugh fd;kÂ,,

x;k gSA  ¼2½Â,,

 lfpo xzke iapk;r vjh,,

} k j k dk;kZy; xzke,,

iapk;r vjh esa tkjh,,

chih,y dkMZ ls lacaf/kr",,

iath ds vafre iUus dh,,

Nk;k izfr ds lkFk jftLVj,,

esa jhiflag firk,,

dkSnwyky ds uke ij,,

chih,y dkMZ tkjh djus",,

dk mYYks[k ugh Â,,

gSA ¼3½ chih,y",,

jk'ku dkMZ tkjh djus,,

esa iw.kZ izfdz;k dk,,

ikyu ugh fd;k x;kA lgk;d

lapkyd ds mijksDr tkap

izfrosnu ds izLrqr djus ds

mijkar Hkh ftyk Lrjh; lfefr

}kjk fnukad 3@4@16 dh

cSBd esa mRrjoknh

dzekad ds chih,y dkMZ ds

tkap izfrosnu dh vuns[kh

djrs gq, mls 10 vad chih,y

dks oS/k ekurs gq, izFke

ojh;rk iznku djus dk fu.kZ;

nsrs gq, fu;qfDr vkns'k

tkjh dj fn;k x;kA ^^izdj.k

esa layXu nLrkostks ,oa

mRrjoknh } kjk izLrqr

chih,y dkMZ dh Nk;k

izfr ds voyksdu ls ik;k

tkrk gS fd mRrjoknh ds

ifr jhiflag dks rglhynkj

,oa lfpo",,

,,fnukad rd fdlh Hkh izdkj dh ch-

,,"ih-,y- dkMZ ,oa muds }kjk tkjh

,,"i= fnukad 28-09-2015 dh iqf""V

,,"ugha dh xbZ gSA

02& Jherh lR;Hkkek ifr Jh

jhiflag }kjk feuh dk;ZdrkZ

HkrhZ esa izLrqr ch-ih-,y-

dkMZ ds laca/k esaA ftyk

dk;Zdze vf/kdkjh] ,dhd`r cky

fodkl lsok] flouh ds i=

dzekad@2674@LFkk-

d s gLrk{kj ls fnukad

15@5@15 dks gLrk{kj",,"@tkap@2016 fnukad 25-

012016 lfpo xzke iapk;r vkjh

dks i= fy[kdj xzke iapk;r

fjdkMZ vuqlkj mDr ch-ih-

,ydkMZ ds laca/k esa tkudkjh

pkgh xbZA

      lfpo xzke iapk;r

vjh }kjk i= dzekad

496@fnukad 12-02-2016 }kjk

dj jk'ku dkMZ tkjh fd;k,,

x;k gSA ;gka ;g Hkh

mys[kuh; gS fd rglhynkj

cj?kkV }kjk muds i=

dzekad D;w fnukad

29@9@15 dks vkosnd",,

jhiflag dkSMwyky iaokj,,

dks 14 vad iznku djrs,,fyf[kr esa fn;k x;k fd] lacaf/kr

gq, eq[; dk;Zikyu

vf/kdkjh tuin iapk;r cj?

kkV dks xjhchjs[kk dk

ik= crkrs gq, chih,y dh

lwph esa uke tksMs

tkus ds funsZ'k fn;s x;s

FksA^^ mijksDr rF;ksa ls

bl ckr dh iqf""V gksrh gS fd

mRrjoknh dzekad&1

lR;Hkkek pkS/kjh } kjk

feuh vkaxuckM+h dsUnz

esa feuh vkaxuckMh

dk;ZdrkZ dk in izkIr djus

dh ea'kk ls dwVjfpr izfdz;k

ls ifr dk chih,y esa uke

tksMs tkus dk vkns'kk",,"ch-ih-,y- jk'kudkMZ rRdkyhu

,,"lfpo ds

gLrk{kj ,oa rglhynkj ds gh

,,gLrk{kj ls tkjh fd;k x;k gSA

,,"lkFk gh muds fjdkMZ esa

miyC/k i= tks rRdkyhu

mi&rglhynkj xaxs:vk }kjk eq[;

dk;Zikyu vf/kdkjh] tuin iapk;r

cj?kkV dks 47 ch-ih-,y- gsrq

vkosnu drkZvksa ds uke dh

,,lwph Hkh nh xbZ mlds ljy

,,dzekad 42 esa Jh

,,jhiflag@dkSnwyky ds laca/k

,,"esa ch-ih-,y- dk;Zokgh iw.kZ

,,"djus fy[kk x;k fn;k x;k gSA

      eq[;d k;Zikyu

vf/kdkjh] tuin iapk;r cj? kkV

}kjk lacaf/kr dks ch-ih-,ylosZ

dzekad tkjh ugha fd;k x;kA

03& lfpo xzke iapk;r vjh }kjk

dk;kZy; xzke iapk;r vjh esa tkjh

ch-ih-,ydkMZ ls lacaf/kr ita h

ds vafre iUus dh Nk;kizfr ds

djkus ds iwoZ gh rglhynkj,,

,oa lfpo ls chih,y dk dkMZ",,

cuokdj mlds QthZ rjhds ls

iz'kklu dks xqejkg djrs gq,

10 vad izkIr dj dqy 71 vad

ikrs gq, izFke ojh;rk izkIr

dh xbZ gS mijksDr ftyk

Lrjh; lfefr vkSj ifj;kstuk

vf/kdkjh cj?kkV }kjk

'kklu }kjk fu/kkZfjr

fu;qfDr izfdz;k dks nwf""kr

djrs gq, mRrjoknh

lR;Hkkek pkS/kjh dh

fu;qfDr dj nh xbZA

mijksDr foosfpr rF;ksa ds

vk/kkj ij mRrjoknh dzekad

&1 lR;Hkkek pkS/kjh }kjk

izLrqr fd;k x;k chih,y jk'ku

dkMZ dwVjfpr rjhds ls ,oa

in dk ykHk vftZr djus dh

ea'kk ls rS;kj fd;k tkuk ik;k

tkrk gSA",,

,,lkFk jftLVj esa Jh

,,"jhiflag@dkSnwyky ds uke ij ch-

ih-,y- dkMZ tkjh djus dk

mYys[k ugha gSA

fu""d""kZ %& ch-ih-,yjk'kudkMZ

tkjh djus esa iw.kZ izfdz;k dk

ikyu ugha fd;k x;k] fdUrq iwjs

izdj.k ds voyksdu esa ik;k x;k

f d J h jhiflag@dkSnwyky dks

tkjh ch-ih-,y- jk'kudkMZ

,,dzekad 89669 esa rRdkyhu lfpo

,,"xzke iapk;r vjh ds ,oa rRdkyhu

,,rglhynkj rglhynkj ds gh gLrk{kj

,,"ls

tkjh fd;k x;k gSA

,,"layXu %& mijksDrkuqlkj iw.kZ

izdj.k ,oa lfpo xzke iapk;r vjh ls

izkIr nLrkostA

¼lh-ih- tk;loky½

lgk;d lapkyd]

  ,dhd`r cky fodkl lsok]

ftyk&flouh i`0

dzekad@2902@dk;ZdrkZ

fu;qfDr@2016Â Â Â Â flouh]

fnukad 15@02@2016

Secretary of Gram Panchayat; (iii) The list of 47 candidates claiming BPL card was supplied to the CEO, Janpad Panchayat. Â",,

The learned Collector has passed the order solely on the report of Assistant Director dated 15.02.2016. The basic reason assigned for disturbing,,

the petitioner’s appointment is that the ration card was issued by Tahasildar on 15.05.2015 whereas the benefit of BPL marks was given to the,,

petitioner prior to it. I am unable to accept this finding. As per the report dated 15.02.2016, it is clear that the BPL ration card was issued with the",,

signature of Tahasildar and Secretary, Gram Panchayat. A specific finding was given that the said BPL card was signed by Panchayat Secretary",,

on 15.05.2015. The additional marks of BPL were directed to be given on 29.09.2015. Thus, the finding of learned Collector is contrary to the",,

record that before including the name in BPL, a forged BPL card was prepared and 10 additional marks were obtained. Such finding runs contrary",,

to the report dated 15.02.2016 on which the entire order of Collector is founded upon.,,

The impugned order of Additional Commissioner is nothing but reiteration of the order of Collector in a different language. Since in the report dated,,

05.02.2016 it is admitted that ration card was issued by the signature of concerned Secretary and Tahasildar, it cannot be disputed that petitioner’s",,

husband possesses a valid BPL card and marks were rightly given to her. In this view of the matter, the impugned order of learned Collector and",,

Commissioner cannot sustain judicial scrutiny. The orders dated 05.04.2016 (Annexure-P/1) and 20.09.2016 (Annexure-P/5) are set aside.Â,,

This petition is allowed.,,