High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 11 SHI CK 2455

Satya Devi vs Roop Singh & Ors.

High Court Of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla · Decided on 16 November 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Rakesh Kainthla, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
RSA No. 495 of 2011

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

16 paragraphs · 1,149 words

Rakesh Kainthla, Judge

The appellant has filed the present appeal against the judgment and decree dated 15.07.2011 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur, H.P., vide which the judgment and decree passed by the learned Civil Judge, Junior Division Court No. 1, Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur, H.P. dated 30.03.2010 were upheld.

2.

The appellant had not filed the certified copy of the judgment and decree of the learned Trial Court. He filed an application seeking exemption from filing the certified copy of the judgment and decree, which was registered as CMP No. 988 of 2011 and was dismissed on 14.11.2011. It was directed that the certified copy be filed within 3 weeks. The certified copy of the judgment and decree was again not filed, and it was ordered on 12.12.2011 that the certified copy of the judgment of the learned trial Court be filed within a week. The certified copy of the judgment and decree of the learned Trial Court was not filed despite the directions of the Court.

3.

The matter was listed for hearing on 27.10.2026, and the learned counsel for the appellant made a prayer that time be granted to file the certified copy of the judgment and decree of the learned Trial Court.

4.

Chapter 1 of Volume V of the Rules and Orders of the Punjab High Court as applicable to the State of HP reads as follows: —

PART A. Paragraph 2(b):

2.

Every memorandum of appeal shall be accompanied by copies of the decree and judgment, as prescribed by Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code. In the case of Second Appeals, in addition to the documents prescribed by Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Code, the memorandum shall be accompanied by a copy of the judgment of the Court of First Instance unless the appellate court dispenses therewith.

5.

Rule 2 was added to Order 41 CPC by the Punjab High Court, which reads as follows: —

“R. 2. In addition to the copies specified in 0.41 R-1, the memorandum of appeal shall be accompanied by a copy of the judgment of the Court of first instance, unless the Appellate Court dispenses therewith.”

6.

The record shows that the appeal was filed before this Court without the certified copy of the judgment and decree of the learned Trial Court, which is required as per the Punjab High Court Rules and Order applicable to the State of HP. The time was granted to file the certified copy of the judgment and decree but it was not filed.

7.

The effect of not filing the certified copy of the judgment and decree of the learned Trial Court is that an incompetent appeal was filed before this Court, which was accepted subject to filing of the certified copy within the time granted by the Court. When the certified copy was not filed, the exemption stood withdrawn, and the appeal became non-existent. Dealing with almost a similar situation wherein the printed copy as required under the rules was not filed, it was laid down by the Kerala High Court in Vediyeri Chandroth Reghunathan Nambiar v. Alora Janu, 1995 SCC OnLine Ker 97: AIR 1995 Ker 334 that the appeal is not competent in the absence of the printed copy of the judgment and if the printed copy is not filed within the time provided by the Court, the appeal is non-existent. It was observed at page 335:

4.

As held by this court in Muthukaruppan v. Chellayi, 1973 KLJ 265 the acceptance of the earlier appeal A.S. 80 of 1991 filed along with the certified copy of the judgment of the trial court was only a provisional acceptance in terms of R. 258 of the Civil Rules of Practice and the plaintiff was obliged to produce the printed copy of the judgment of the trial court within the time granted by the appellate Court for that purpose or within any extended time that may be obtained for that purpose. The plaintiff did not produce the printed copy of the judgment, and consequently the dismissal of A.S. 80 of 1991 for non-production of the printed copy of the judgment was clearly justified…..

5.

Under Order 41, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, a Memorandum of Appeal has to be accompanied by a copy of the decree appealed from and a copy of the judgment on which it is founded unless, of course, the appellate Court dispenses with the production of the judgment. Rule 258 of the Civil Rules of Practice insists that when a copy of the judgment is applied for, for the purpose of appeal, the copy shall be printed if the length of the judgment exceeds 700 words. Rule 258(2) provides that in a case where the party who is bound to produce a printed copy of the judgment files an appeal without production of the printed copy, he is obliged to file a petition for the provisional acceptance of the manuscript or typed copy of the judgment he produced with the appeal, particularly stating that he had applied for a printed copy of the judgment but had not received the same. It is therefore clear that the acceptance of the appeal A.S. 80 of 1991 filed in the first instance by the plaintiff was only a provisional acceptance of that appeal and the dismissal of that appeal on the ground that the plaintiff did not produce the printed copy of the judgment within time was perfectly justified in terms of the provisions noticed above. But the dismissal of that appeal for non-production of the printed copy of the judgment cannot be treated as a final adjudication of the appeal in view of the fact that the appeal itself had not been finally accepted but had only been provisionally accepted in terms of R. 258(2) of the Civil Rules of Practice. When an appeal is dismissed for default for non-production of the printed copy of the judgment, it can only mean that the appellate Court has withdrawn the provisional permission given by it to the appellant to appeal against the decree of the trial court without producing the printed copy of the judgment along with the Memorandum of Appeal…….

8.

In the present case, also, the appeal was not competent on the date of its presentation without the certified copy of the judgment and decree. The Court had granted time, but the order was not complied with, which means that the appeal remained incompetent and there is no legally constituted appeal before this Court. Therefore, it is impermissible to grant time at this stage after the lapse of more than 15 years to file the certified copy of the judgment and decree.

9.

In view of the above, the present appeal is dismissed as incompetent.

10.

The appeal stands disposed of, so also the pending application(s), if any.