High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 11 BOM CK 1960

Satish s/o Shankar Raut vs Assistant Commissioner (Backlog Cell) & Ors.

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 5 November 2026

RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Writ Petition No. 1469 of 2025

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

72 paragraphs · 3,671 words

[Per : URMILA JOSHI-PHALKE, J.]

1.

Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with the consent of the learned counsel for the petitioner, learned AGP for the State and learned counsel for the respondent No.4.

2.

By this writ petition, the petitioner is seeking quashing and setting aside the impugned roster approval dated 04.01.2024 to the extent filling the vacant post of Supervisor through direct recruitment as approved by the respondent No.1 - Assistant Commissioner, Backlog Cell, Amravati and also direction to the respondent No.1 - Assistant Commissioner Backlog Cell, Amravati to call a revised proposal for approval of roster by calling relevant documents of nature of appointment of Ramesh Devkate and Kiran Keshav Chavan, issued by APMC and to declare that vacant post of Supervisor is to be filled by promotion.

3.

The petitioner was appointed as Junior Clerk and working with the Agricultural Produce Market Committee (hereinafter referred to as “APMC”), Arni since 01.07.2009. As per the contention of the petitioner, since the initial appointment his service is quite clean, unblemished and there are no complaints against him. He was entitled for the time-bound promotion when he has completed 12 years of service on a particular post. He raised the grievance that though he is placed at Serial No. 1 in the seniority list of Junior Clerks among six employees in the respondent No.4 - APMC. The respondent APMC, through a Notification dated 28.01.2023, published the seniority list for the posts of Senior Clerk, Statistical Inspector and Supervisor, which disclosed that Shri K. K. Chavan and R. D. Devkate were appointed by nomination, whereas, Shri. S. K. Wankheke and Shri. J. H. Khan were promoted. The respondent No.4 - APMC is under obligation to seek approval of the roster for its staff every three years, however, the APMC has not obtained the approval since 2012. It was only for initiating the appointment process that the respondent APMC, by providing incorrect information regarding the status of the appointments, sought and procured approval for filling the vacant post of Supervisor through direct recruitment. It is contention of the petitioner that post of Inspector/Supervisor/Statistical/Senior Clerk is part of a single cadre with a sanctioned strength of four posts. Out of these, three posts were already filled and one post remained vacant due to recent retirement of Shri J. H. Khan. Despite the seniority list reflecting that the promoted employees occupied three posts, the respondent APMC misrepresented that two of these employees Shri K. K. Chavan and Shri R. D. Devkate, were promoted. Based on this misrepresentation, the respondent APMC secured approval for filling the fourth post through direct recruitment. On 04.01.2024, the respondent No.1 - Assistant Commissioner, Backlog Cell, Amravati, approved the roster based on this incorrect information and certified that the vacant post of Supervisor was to be filled through direct recruitment instead of promotion. It is contention of the petitioner that upon the retirement of Shri J. H. Khan on 30.04.2023, the post of Supervisor fell vacant. The petitioner despite having served as a Junior Clerk since 01.07.2009, has neither been considered for the promotional post of Supervisor nor has he received the higher pay scale benefits under the time-bound promotion scheme after completing 12 years of service. Therefore, he filed ULP No. 233 of 2023 before the Industrial Court on 17.10.2023, seeking directions for the said benefits and promotion to the vacant post of Supervisor. It is further contention of the petitioner that he has made several representations to the Registrar Co-operative, Arni mentioning all above these facts, but it was not considered and, therefore, petitioner approached this Court for the said directions.

4.

Heard learned counsel Shri. Saboo, for the petitioner. He reiterated the said contentions and submitted that the petitioner is at Serial No. 1 in seniority list of Junior Clerks among six employees in the APMC. The said seniority list is already published. Despite it was mandatory on the part of the APMC to seek an approval of the roster, but the respondent No. 4 has not obtained the roster. On the basis of incorrect information, the approval was obtained. He submitted that despite Shri. K. K. Chavan and R. D. Devkate were shown to be appointed by way of direct recruitment, but they were shown to be promoted. He invited our attention towards the seniority list, which shows that Shri K. K. Chavan and Shri. R. D. Devkate were appointed as Senior Clerk and Inspector through direct recruitment on 27.12.2011 and 28.12.2011, however, while seeking an approval, they were shown to be promoted and approval was sought. He invited our attention towards the reply filed by the respondent No.4 and submitted that, in the said reply, the respondent No.4 has specifically stated that respondent No.2 - Director of Marketing vide Circular dated 07.04.2022 directed all the Market Committees that while recruiting/promoting employees in the Market Committee 75% posts should be filled through promotion and the remaining 25% are to be directly recruited. In compliance of this Circular, the Market Committee had forwarded the proposal to respondent No.1 Backlog Cell for approval. Based on the Government Resolutions and Circulars issued by the Director Marketing, the details were forwarded. The reply further shows that when in 2012 the roster was approved, Shri. Ramesh Devkate and Shri. Kiran Chavan have been shown as promoted employees and in the approved roster they have been continued to be shown as a promoted employees. Hence, the request of the petitioner seeking resolution of the Market Committee promoting these employees has been rejected by the Assistant Registrar. He submitted that this contention is contrary to the order dated 01.01.2023 issued by the Administrator of APMC. Thus, he submitted that this fact itself is sufficient to establish that by misrepresenting the approval was obtained and therefore, the direction be given to the respondent No.1 - Assistant Commissioner, Backlog Cell, Amravati, to call revised proposal for approval of roster by calling relevant documents of nature of appointment of Ramesh Devkate and Kiran Keshav Chavan issued by the APMC.

5.

Per contra, learned counsel Shri. Paliwal for the respondent No. 4, vehemently submitted that the petitioner has questioned the roster approved by the respondent No. 1 dated 04.01.2024 stating that based on the incorrect information provided by the Market Committee, the Assistant Commissioner has certified that the vacant post of Supervisor is fulfilled through direct recruitment instead of promotion. The roster has been approved from time to time by respondent No. 1. The Market Committee had communicated with the respondent No. 1 about reservation in the appointments of the Market Committee. Based on the communication of the respondent No. 1 department, the Secretary of the Market Committee had provided the necessary information to the respondent No. 1 and based on that the respondent No. 1 had approved the roster. The Secretary of the Market Committee again addressed the communication on 05.10.2015 to respondent No. 1 requesting him to scrutinize the employees category classification of the Market Committee. The relevant details of employees working with the Market Committee and the post of their recruitment were all provided to respondent No.1, who then approved the roster on 31.12.2015. The Market Committee thereafter on 26.07.2019, again addressed to the respondent No. 1 requesting him to scrutinize the employees category classification of the Market Committee. Thereafter, on 28.08.2023 again the Secretary of the Market Committee addressed a communication to the respondent No.1 to scrutinize the roster of the Market Committee. The respondent No.2 - Director of Marketing vide Circular dated 07.04.2022 directed all the market committees that while recruiting/promoting employees in the Market Committee 75% posts should be filled through promotion and remaining 25% are to be directly recruited. In compliance of this circular, the Market Committee had forwarded the proposal to respondent No. 1 - Backlog Cell for approval and accordingly, it was approved. Therefore, the petition being devoid of merits and liable to be dismissed.

6.

Before entering into the merits, Rule 46 of the Market Committee Employees (Service) Rules requires to be reproduced, which reads as under:

“४६. बढती : बाजार समितीतील रिकाम्या झालेल्या किंवा निर्माण केलेल्या पदावर करावयाची कर्मचा-याची नियुक्ती ही शक्यतोवर बाजार समितीचे सेवेत असलेल्या कर्मचा-यासच बढती देउन करण्यात यावी. या कामी बाजार समिती, कर्मचा-याच्या वर्गवारीप्रमाणे म्हणजेच अधिकारी, वरिष्ठ कर्मचारी व कनिष्ठ कर्मचारी याप्रमाणे वेगवेगळी ज्येष्ठता सूची तयार करील व त्या त्या वर्गातील कर्मचा-यांच्या सेवा ज्येष्ठतेनुसार बढती देण्यात येईल. मात्र अपवादात्मक बाबतीत कारणे नमूद करून, कोणत्याही कर्मचा-यास कोणत्याही वर्गातील पदावर बाजार समिती बढती देउ शकेल. अशी बढती दिलेल्या कर्मचा-यांचा पगार नवीन वेतन श्रेणीतील पुढील टप्प्यावर निश्चित करून एक वेतनवाढ देण्यात येईल. महाराष्ट्र कृषी उत्पन्न खरेदी-विक्री ( नियमन ) नियम, १९६७ यातील नियम १०२ मध्ये नमूद केलेल्या शास्तीपैकी कोणत्याही प्रकारची शास्ती झालेल्या कर्मचा-याचा, तो ज्येष्ठ असला तरी, ज्येष्ठता सूचीतील कम शेवटचा असेल.”

7.

The true translation of the above Rule 46 is as under:

“46.

Promotion : The appointments of employees to be made on the posts fallen vacant in Market Committee shall, as far as possible, be made by promoting the employee in service of the Market Committee only. For this purpose, the Market Committee will prepare separate seniority list as per categories of employees i.e. Officers, Senior employees and junior employees and promotions will be given as per seniority of the employees in the respective class. However, in exceptional cases, the Market Committee can promote employee from any class to any post by giving reasons. The pay of such promoted employee shall be fixed on the next stage in the new pay-scale and one increment will be given. The employee who has been awarded penalties as per Rule 102 of the Maharashtra Agricultural Produce Marketing (Development & Regulation) Rules, 1977, though happens to be senior, shall be placed at the end of the seniority list.”

8.

It is not in dispute that by invoking the said provision, the promotions are to be done. It is true that those Rules are issued by the Executive Instructions, but nevertheless approved by the State Government at the concerned Department level. In that view of the matter, the claim of the petitioner requires to be considered. On 28.01.2023, the Administrator APMC, respondent No. 4 issued an advertisement which reads as under:

राज्यीय निर्णय, सामान्य प्रशासन विभाग, क्रमांक एसआरव्ही-२०११/प्र क्र २८४/१२दि. २१/१०/२०११

ज.स.स.आ.आ/३/५६/ज्येष्ठा वादी व.सी./नि.आ.सी./२०२३ कार्यालय क्र.स.आ.आ/वि.क.८/०१/२०२३

आदेश

कृषी उत्पन्न बाजार समिती आर्गीतील " वरिष्ठ लौकिक, निरीक्षक, सा.लौकिक, पर्यवेक्षक, " या संवर्गीय क्षेत्र केंद्र एस ०८ २५,५००-८१,१०० मधील कर्मचार्‍यांची दिनांक १ जानें, २०२३ ची लागुती सेवाभेद्यता यादी प्रसिद्ध करण्यात येत आहे. संवर्गीय कर्मचार्‍यांच्या सदर सेवाभेद्यवेबाबत काही आदेश व हाकती असल्यास त्या संवर्गीय कार्यालय प्रमुखामार्फत सदरची लागुता सेवाभेद्यता कृषी प्रसिद्ध झाल्याच्या दिनांकपत्रात ०३ ( तीन ) दिवसाच्या आत सादर करण्यात येईल. ही बाब कार्यालय प्रमुखाची त्यांच्या अधिकार असलेल्या सर्व संबंधितांच्या निदर्शनास आणून घ्यावी. विहित मुदतीनंतर अथवा उर्वरित प्राप्त झालेल्या सेवाभेद्यवेबाबत आदेश व हाकती विचारात घेतल्या जाणार नाही.

सदर लेखता यादी सर्व संवर्गीय कर्मचार्‍यांचे निदर्शनास आणून एका प्रतीक त्यांच्या स्वाक्षराचा चेंडून स्वाक्षराची प्रत कार्यालयास सादर करावी. तसेच प्रतिमान पुढील पदावर पदोन्नती / वरील वेतनवेणी व इतर आल्यापत्र विषयक फायदे देणारा " ज्येष्ठा वादी मध्ये निदर्शनास आणी नाही " असा आदेश घेतल्यास व त्यामुळे पदोन्नती पासून संवर्गीय कर्मचारी वर्गात राहिल्यास त्याची जबाबदारी सचिव यांची राहिल याची नोंद घ्यावी.

प्रशासक कृषी उत्पन्न बाजार समिती आर्गी.

प्रतिलिपि :- १) मा. प्रधान संचालक, म.प्र.पुणे, यांना माहितीपत्रे सविस्तर सादर. २) मा. जिल्हा उपनिवेशक, सहकारी संस्था, पवनगाड यांना माहितीपत्रे सविस्तर सादर. ३) मा. सहायक निवेशक सहकारी संस्था, आर्गी यांना माहितीपत्रे सविस्तर सादर. ४) संबंधित कर्मचारी. १) बी.जे.के.भवाण, वरिष्ठ लौकिक - १) बी.आर.टी.देवको, निरीक्षक - १) डी.एस.के.बाबखडे, माहितीपत्रे लौकिक - १) बी.जे.एच.खान, पर्यवेक्षक -

प्रशासक कृषी उत्पन्न बाजार समिती आर्गी.

प्रशासक

9.

It reveals that by referring Government Resolution dated 21.10.2011 states that the seniority list of Senior Clerk, Inspector, Accountant and Supervisor was prepared on 01.01.2023, which is reproduced as under:

शासन निर्णय, सामान्य प्रशासन विभाग, क्रमांक एसआरडी-२०११/प्र.क्र.२८४/१२दि.२१/१०/२०११ वरिष्ठ लिपीक, निरीक्षक, सांख्यिकीय लिपीक, पर्यवेक्षक या संवर्गाची दिनांक ०१/०१/२०२३ रोजीची अंतीम ज्येष्ठतासुची दिनांक ०१/०१/२०२३ ते दिनांक ३१/१२/२०२३ या कालावधीत नियमित नियुक्त झालेल्या अधिकारी/कर्मचाऱ्यांची अंतीम ज्येष्ठतासुची (वरिष्ठ लिपीक, निरीक्षक, सांख्यिकीय लिपीक, पर्यवेक्षक) ज्येष्ठता क्रमांकनावप्रवर्ग (नियुक्तीला प्रवर्ग बदलत असल्यास त्याचा दिनांक)जन्मतिथीनियुक्ती दिनांकनियुक्तीचा मार्ग (सदस्य/सर्वदलीय विभागीय परीक्षेसाठी नियुक्त उमेदवारांचा पुरस्कार क्रमांक व परीक्षेचे वर्ष)ज्येष्ठता दिनांक/ ज्येष्ठतेचा नामी दिनांकसेवानिवृत्तीचा दिनांकशैक्षणिक अंतीमअभिप्राय 1डॉ. जे.के. वाडारवरिष्ठ लिपीकदि. ३१/०१/१९८३दि. ३०/१२/२०११सदस्यदि. ०१/१२/२०११मे-२०२१एम.ए. स्वाती, राज्यशास्त्र, समाजशास्त्र वि.वह. वि.व.अं. ( समाजशास्त्र ) एम.एस.सी.आय.टी. कॉम्पुट- 2डॉ. आर.डी. देवकलेनिरीक्षकदि. २४/०१/१९९८दि. २८/१२/२०११सदस्यदि. ०१/१२/२०११जुलै-२०२१वि.वह.वि.व.व.एम.एस. कॉम्पुट- 3डॉ. एम.के. सरस्वतीसांख्यिकीय लिपीकदि. ११/१०/१९९२दि. २४/०१/१९९७पदेस्त्री दि. ३१/०१/२०१२दि. २४/१२/१९९७ऑक्टो-२०२०एम.एस.सी- 4डॉ. जे.एन. खानपर्यवेक्षकदि. ०६/०१/१९९५दि. १६/०६/१९९७पदेस्त्री दि. ०६/०१/२०१६दि. १६/०६/१९९७एप्रिल २०२३एम.एस.सी-

10.

The above seniority list shows that one Shri. K. K. Chavan and R. D. Devkate, were appointed on 27.12.2011 and 28.12.2011 by direct recruitment. Similarly, the seniority list of Junior Clerks were also prepared on 31.12.2023, wherein the present petitioner was shown at Serial No.1. On 28.08.2023, Secretary of the Market Committee addressed a communication to the respondent No.1 to scrutinize the roster of the Market Committee for the approval, wherein the four vacancies were shown against Inspector/Supervisor/Accountant/Lipik/Senior Clerk, out of which three were shown to be filled up and one was shown to be vacant. The document Annexure A placed on record by the respondent No.4 also shows that one Ramesh Dhondu Devkate was appointed by the direct recruitment as a Senior Clerk. The Government Resolution dated 07.04.2022 issued by the Panan Sanchanalaya, Maharashtra State, Pune. The subject of the said resolution reads as under:

“महाराष्ट्र राज्यातील कृषी उत्पन्न बाजार समितीच्या आस्थापनेवरील रिक्त पदे सरळ सेवेद्वारे भरती करणे बाबत.”

11.

The said Government Resolution is produced as under:

ANNEXURE - R.4

महाराष्ट्र राज्यातील कृषि उत्पन्न बाजार समितीच्या आस्थापनेवरील रिक्त पदे सरळ सेवेबारे भरती करणे बाबत.

पणन संचालनालय, महाराष्ट्र राज्य, पुणे.

३ रा मजला, नवीन मध्यवर्ती इमारत, पुणे- ४११००१

पीबीएक्स- ०२०-२६१२६६२८/२६१२६७८५/२६११४०६४ फॅक्स- ०२०-२६१२७००४/२६१३२४०१

website :- www.mabapanan.maharashtra.gov.in

जा.क्र. पणन-५/कुउवास/नोकरभरती/निर्देश/२०२२ | १५२७ |

दि. ०७ एप्रिल, २०२२

विषय :- कृषि उत्पन्न बाजार समितीच्या आस्थापनेवरील रिक्त पदे भरती करणेबाबत.

संदर्भ :- १. या कार्यालयाचे निर्देश जा.क्र. पणन-५/कुउवास/नोकरभरती/निर्देश/५९४७/सन २०१९ दि. २८.११.२०१९.

२. या कार्यालयाचे निर्देश जा.क्र. सम दि. १९.०७.२०२१.

३. सामान्य प्रशासन विभागाकडील क्र. आरटीआर.२०१४/प्र.क्र.३५५/१२ दि. ०६ जून २०१७ रोजीची अधिसूचना.

प्रस्तावना:-

मा. उच्च न्यायालय, खंडपीठ औरंगाबाद यांचेकडील रिट पिटीशन क्र. ६१४३/२०१८ व इतर संलग्न रिट पिटीशनमध्ये दिलेल्या निर्देशानुसार राज्यातील सर्व कृषि उत्पन्न बाजार समितीच्या त्यांच्या आस्थापनेवरील रिक्त असलेली पदे सरळसेवेने भरती करणेबाबत तसेच कृषि उत्पन्न बाजार समितीमध्ये जास्त काम असलेल्या हंगामात गरज पडल्यास रोजंदारी कर्मचारी भरती करण्याची आवश्यकता असल्यास करावयाच्या कार्यवाहीबाबत पणन संचालनालयाकडून उपरोक्त संदर्भ क्र. १ अन्वये निर्देश जारी करण्यात आलेले आहेत. तसेच उपरोक्त संदर्भ क्र. २ अन्वये अधिकारी, वरिष्ठ कर्मचारी आणि कनिष्ठ कर्मचाऱ्यांचे बाबतीत वयोमर्यादेबाबत सुधारित निर्देश जारी करण्यात आले आहेत.

महाराष्ट्र कृषि उत्पन्न खरेदी विक्री (विकास व विनियमन) नियम, १९६७ चे नियम १०० मध्ये बाजार समितीचे अधिकारी व कर्मचारी यांचे वर्गीकरण नमूद केलेले आहे. त्यानुसार सचिव, सहसचिव, उपसचिव, सहायक सचिव व लेखाधिकारी यांचा अधिकारी म्हणून, कोषपाल, लिपिक, पर्यवेक्षक, निरीक्षक, मुख्य लिपिक, वरिष्ठ लिपिक, ग्रेडर यांचा वरिष्ठ सेवक म्हणून तर चपराशी, पहारेकरी, पाणीवाला, वाहनचालक, नाईक, गेटमन, माळी आणि इतर कर्मचारी यांचे कनिष्ठ सेवक म्हणून वर्गीकरण केलेले आहे.

उपरोक्त संदर्भित निर्देश क्र. १ च्या परिच्छेद ५ मध्ये अधिकारी, वरिष्ठ कर्मचारी व कनिष्ठ कर्मचारी यांच्या प्रथम नियुक्तीसाठीची किमान अर्हता निश्चित करून देण्यात आलेली आहे. सदरची अर्हता ही बाजार समितीच्या प्रचलित पोटनियम/सेवानियमातील तरतुदीनुसार करण्यात आली होती. सदर अर्हतेमध्ये कालानुरूप बदल करणे आवश्यक असल्याने सुधारित अर्हता निश्चित करणे आवश्यक आहे.

तसेच, परिच्छेद क्र. ७ मध्ये बाजार समितीच्या आस्थापनेवर रिक्त असलेल्या कनिष्ठ कर्मचाऱ्यांची पदे १०० टक्के सरळसेवा पद्धतीने व वरिष्ठ कर्मचाऱ्यांची पदे भरताना ७५ टक्के पदोन्नतीने व २५ टक्के सरळसेवा पद्धतीने भरती करणे नमूद केले आहे. तथापि, सामान्य प्रशासन विभागाकडील उपरोक्त संदर्भ क्र. ३ चे अधिसूचनेच्यचे बृहन्मुंबईबाहेरील शासकीय कार्यालयातील 'लिपिक- टंकलेखक', गट- क या पदावरील सेवा प्रवेशाची विनियमन करणेसाठी नियम केलेले आहेत. त्यानुसार या अधिसूचनेमध्ये “लिपिक- टंकलेखक”, गट- क या पदाकरिता पदोन्नतीने, अनुकंपा तत्वावरील नियुक्तीसह नामनिर्देशनाने व वाहनचालकामधुन कायमस्वरूपी बदलीने करावयाची नियुक्ती यांचे प्रमाण ४०:५०:१०असे राहिल, असे स्पष्ट करण्यात आलेले आहे. त्यानुसार उपरोक्त संदर्भ क्र.१ अन्वये देण्यात आलेल्या निर्देशामध्ये अनुरूप बदल करणे आवश्यक आहे.

त्यानुसार उपरोक्त संदर्भ क्र. १ अन्वये जारी करण्यात आलेल्या निर्देशामधील मुद्दा क्र. ५ व ७ बाबत खालीलप्रमाणे सुधारित निर्देश देण्यात येत आहेत.

निर्देश

महाराष्ट्र कृषि उत्पन्न खरेदी विक्री (विकास व विनियमन) अधिनियम १९६३ चे कलम ४० ई अन्वये मला प्राप्त असलेल्या अधिकारानुसार, मी, सुनिल पवार, पणन संचालक, महाराष्ट्र राज्य, पुणे, राज्यातील सर्व कृषि उत्पन्न बाजार समित्यांना उपरोक्त संदर्भ क्र. १ अन्वये देण्यात आलेल्या निर्देशामधील मुद्दा क्र.५ व ७ बाबत खालीलप्रमाणे सुधारित निर्देश निर्गमित करीत आहे.

५. बाजार समितीने त्यांच्या मंजूर अनुसूचीतील पदांचे महाराष्ट्र कृषि उत्पन्न खरेदी विक्री (विकास व विनियमन) नियम, १९६७ चे नियम १०० (१) मधील तरतुदीनुसार खालीलप्रमाणे वर्गीकरण करावे. तसेच नियम १००(२) मध्ये नमूद केलेल्या अधिकारी, नियम १००(३) मध्ये नमूद केलेले वरिष्ठ सेवक व नियम १००(४) मध्ये नमूद केलेल्या कनिष्ठ सेवक यांच्या प्रथम नियुक्तीसाठी किमान अर्हता पुढील प्रमाणे असेल:-

(अ) अधिकारी:- संविधिक विद्यापीठाची कोणत्याही शाखेतील पदवी किंवा शासनाने त्याच्याशी समतुल्य म्हणून घोषित केलेली अन्य कोणतीही अर्हता.

(ब) वरिष्ठ सेवक:- संविधिक विद्यापीठाची कोणत्याही शाखेतील पदवी किंवा शासनाने त्याच्याशी समतुल्य म्हणून घोषित केलेली अन्य कोणतीही अर्हता. तसेच संबंधित पदाचे कामकाजाकरीता आवश्यक असणारे मान्यताप्राप्त संस्थेकडून मिळविलेले संगणकीय/व्यावसायिक/तांत्रिक अर्हता प्रमाणपत्र.

(क) कनिष्ठ सेवक:- एस.एस.सी. किंवा समतुल्य परीक्षा.

७. बाजार समितीने सरळसेवेने व पदोन्नतीने भरावयाच्या पदांबाबत खालीलप्रमाणे कार्यवाही करावी.

(अ) बाजार समितीच्या आस्थापनेवर रिक्त असलेल्या कनिष्ठ सेवकांची पदे १००% सरळ सेवा पद्धतीने भरण्यात यावीत. तथापि, कनिष्ठ सेवकांमधून कनिष्ठ सेवकांमध्येच पदोन्नती देताना १००% पदोन्नती द्यावी.

(ब) वरिष्ठ सेवक संवर्गातील लिपिक टंकलेखक या पदासाठी उपरोक्त नमूद ५ (ब) मध्ये नमूद केलेली अर्हता प्राप्त करणाऱ्या कनिष्ठ सेवकांमधून ५०% पदोन्नतीने व अनुकंपा तत्वावरील नियुक्तीसह सरळसेवेने ५०% असे प्रमाण राहिल.

(क) वरिष्ठ सेवक संवर्गातील कनिष्ठ लिपिक पदाव्यतिरिक्त इतर पदे व अधिकारी संवर्गातील सचिव पदाव्यतिरिक्त इतर पदे भरताना ७५% पदोन्नतीने व २५% सरळ सेवा पद्धतीने भरण्यात यावीत.

तसेच, पणन संचालनालयाकडून उपरोक्त संदर्भ क्र. १, क्र. २ अन्वये निर्गमित केलेल्या निर्देशास अनुसरून आणि उपरोक्त निर्देशास अनुसरून राज्यातील सर्व बाजार समित्यांनी त्यांच्या उपविधी व सेवानिवृत्तीमध्ये आवश्यक त्या तरतुदी करून त्यास सक्षम अधिकाऱ्याची मान्यता घेण्यात यावी. सदरचे निर्देश या निर्देशाच्या दिनांकापासून तात्काळ प्रभावाने अंमलात येतील.

दिनांक:- ०४/०९/२०२२ ठिकाण:- पुणे

(सुजित पवार) पणन संचालक, महाराष्ट्र राज्य, पुणे.

प्रति:-

सभापती /प्रशासक/ सचिव, कृषि उत्पन्न बाजार समिती, (सर्व)

प्रत :-

1.

विभागीय सहनिर्बंधक, सहकारी संस्था, (सर्व)

2.

जिल्हा उपनिर्बंधक, सहकारी संस्था, (सर्व)

3.

सरव्यवस्थापक, महाराष्ट्र राज्य कृषि पणन मंडळ, गुलटेकडी, मार्केट यार्ड, पुणे.

4.

कार्यकारी संचालक, कृषि उत्पन्न बाजार समिती संघ, गुलटेकडी, मार्केट यार्ड, पुणे.

प्रत महितीस्तव सविनय सादर:-

मा. अपर मुख्य सचिव, (सहकार व पणन) सहकार, पणन व वस्त्रोद्योग विभाग, मंत्रालय, मुंबई -३२.

12.

Thus, from the documents on record, it reveals that despite the said Kiran Chavan and Ramesh Devkate though directly appointed as a Senior Clerks, they were shown to be promoted in the roster and the said roster was approved on 12.06.2012. Though, it was contended by the Assistant Registrar that as per the Circular Shri. Ramesh Dhondu Devkate and Kiran Keshavrao Chavan were shown in the promoted list as per the Government Circular dated 07.04.2022. However, it is apparent that the appointment of these two persons on 27.12.2011 and 28.12.2011 and they were shown to be promoted, however, they were directly recruited on the post of the Senior Clerk and, therefore, the communication issued by the Assistant Registrar Co-operative stating that they have shown these two names, in view of Government Circular regarding the filling of the post by promotions is incorrect. Therefore, there is a substance in the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that three posts were already filled and one post remained vacant due to recent retirement of Shri J. H. Khan. It is apparent that Shri K. K. Chavan and Shri. R. D. Devkate were directly recruited, however, they were shown as promoted and on the basis of the said misrepresentation, the respondent APMC secured approval for filling the four posts through direct recruitment, which is erroneous. Even these fact is substantiated from the reply filed by the respondent No.4. The respondent No. 4 has stated in the reply that Market Committee on 26.07.2019 addressed respondent No.1 requesting him to scrutinize the employee category classification of the Market Committee. The relevant details of the employees working with the Market Committee and the post of the recruitment were all provided to respondent No. 1, but thereafter due to COVID-19, the approval the proposal was pending with respondent No.1. On 28.08.2023, the Secretary of the Market Committee addressed the communication to respondent No. 1 to scrutinize the roster of the Market Committee. It reveals that the relevant details along with the previous communication were provided showing these two persons Devkate and Chavan shown to be as promoted when they were recruited by way of a direct recruitment. Thus, it is contrary to the condition in the Circular dated 07.04.2022, which shows that all the market committees while recruiting promoting employees in the Market Committee 75% post should be filled through promotion and remaining 25% are to be directly recruited. The respondent No.4 has not complied with this Circular and shown that the persons i.e. Shri. Chavan and Devkate as a promoted employees when they were directly recruited. Thus, it is apparent that on the basis of incorrect information, the respondent No.1 has approved the roster and as per the approved roster, the employees of the Market Committee are working on the post of Assistant Secretary, Clerk, Supervisor, Statistical Clerk, Inspector and Senior Clerk. The same roster was approved in future also. It is further apparent that the Market Committee approved the roster on 12.06.2012, wherein Ramesh Devkate and Kiran Chavan are shown as promoted employees when they were recruited directly and the said roster was approved contrary to the Government Resolution and, therefore, there is a substance in the contention of the petitioner. In the result, the petitioner is partly succeed.

13.

The Writ Petition is partly allowed, in terms of prayer clause (ii).

14.

The impugned order dated 04.01.2024 passed by respondent No.1 granting approval to the roster is hereby quashed and set aside.

15.

We direct the respondent No.1 - Assistant Commissioner, Backlog Cell, Amravati to call revised proposal for approval of the roster by calling relevant documents relating to the nature of appointment of Ramesh Devkate and Kiran Keshav Chavan issued by APMC and examine the issue regarding filling of the vacant posts by way of promotion.

16.

With these directions, the petition is disposed of.

17.

Rule accordingly.