AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Puja Chopra, J.
CRM-8122-2018
This is an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, seeking condonation of delay of 63 days in filing the accompanying appeal. For the reasons mentioned in the application, which is duly supported by an affidavit, the same is allowed. The delay of 63 days in filing the present appeal is condoned.
CRM-A-561-MA-2018(O&M)
The present appeal is directed against the judgement dated 13.10.2017 passed by learned Additional Sessions, Judge, Karnal, whereby accused Manoj was acquitted of the charges framed against him.
Section 384(2) Cr.P.C. gives discretion to this Court to call for records of the case in appropriate cases. In Dharmendrakumar v. State of Maharashtra and another, 2019 SCC Online Bom 343, the Hon’ble Bombay High Court has held:
“16.xxx When an appeal is frivolous or is without any merit, the Court need not be burdened by mechanically admitting the same and keeping it pending for final hearing. The object is to get rid of such appeals from the system which do not deserve final hearing.”
On 28.04.2012, an FIR was registered under Sections 279, 307, 34 IPC at Police Station Gharaunda at the instance of complainant Satpal Singh. After investigation, the investigating agency found accused Manoj not to be present at the spot and was, in fact, found to be present at his duty and thus untraced report was filed by the investigating agency. Dissatisfied with the investigation, complainant filed protest petition before learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Karnal, whereupon accused Manoj was summoned to face trial.
After appreciating the evidence led by parties and hearing the arguments of both sides, learned Additional Sessions Judge, Karnal (hereinafter referred to as, ‘learned trial Court’) acquitted the accused, giving him benefit of doubt, hence the present application before this court.
The brief facts of the case are that information regarding admission of injured Jagpal Singh son of Jaibir Singh, resident of Arianpura, Police station, Gharaunda was received from Parveen Hospital, Karnal regarding injuries suffered in a roadside accident, whereupon ASI Chander Pal along with Constable Yoginder reached Parveen Hospital, where the Doctor opined the injured unfit to make statement. Again on 28.04.2012, ASI Chander Pal, along with Constable Sunil reached Parveen Hospital, Karnal and sought opinion of the Doctor, who again opined the injured unfit to make statement. Thus, on 28.04.2012, statement of complainant Satpal (cousin brother of injured Jagpal) was recorded to the effect that he and his cousin brother Jagpal used to go for morning walk from Village Arainpura to Village Chaura. On 27.04.2012, when the complainant and his cousin brother Jagpal had started from their residence at about 5:30 am for morning walk and were going towards village Chaura on pakka road at about 5:35 am and when they reached near Geeta Niketan Senior Secondary School Chaura, he heard the sound of a vehicle coming from the side of village Arianpura and when he turned back, he saw that the driver was driving the said vehicle at a very high speed towards Chaura and on coming near, he saw that the vehicle was a white coloured Tavera without any number plate on its front, which was being driven by accused Manoj, who was resident of their village. Another person was sitting on his side whom he can identify if brought before him. The accused Manoj turned his aforesaid vehicle towards them at about 15 meters from them, and thereafter straight-way collided with them with an intention to kill them. He was on the left side of the road and Jagpal Singh was on his right side, and he pulled Jagpal on his side in order to save him, but still, Manoj got his vehicle turned towards them and collided with them, complainant was saved by chance, and Jagpal jumped in the air for 7-8 feet due to impact of vehicle and fell down in the field. The accused Manoj ran away from the spot along with his vehicle. When the complainant raised hue and cry, Chowkidar of the school came running, but the vehicle had gone far by that time. The complainant and some passers by picked up injured Jagpal and he informed about the incident to his family and also called police by dialing number 100. Then, he and younger brother of Jagpal, namely, Anangpal Singh took Jagpal to Civil Hospital Gharaunda for treatment. From there, Jagpal was referred to Civil Hospital, Karnal. Jagpal was got x-rayed in Civil Hospital Karnal, whereafter in view of his serious condition Jagpal was taken to Shri Hospital, Karnal and later on, he was admitted to Parveen Hospital Karnal. The accused Manoj had prepared a forged affidavit of his aunt Premwati, for which they had lost the case, and since they were pursuing the case of Premwati, Manoj etc. used to threaten to kill them. Accused Manoj had caused the accident with them in order to kill them due to the grudge of land. There was something pasted on the backside number plate of vehicle.
As aforesaid, the investigating agency filed untraced report claiming that the accused Manoj Kumar was found present at his job at the time of accident and the vehicle which caused the accident and the driver of accidental vehicle could not be traced.
Upon protest petition filed by complainant, accused Manoj Kumar was summoned to face trial and upon his appearance, the case was committed to the learned Sessions Court vide commitment order dated 28.02.2017. Charge was framed against the accused under Sections 279 and 307 IPC to which accused pleaded, not guilty and claimed trial.
The prosecution examined as many as seven witnesses and also produced and proved documentary evidence on record. In his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C, the accused pleaded innocence and false implication, and also examined three witnesses in defence.
SI Chander Pal appeared as PW4 in the witness box being the Investigating Officer and also appeared as DW1. PW4 was present in Police Station Gharaunda as Investigating Officer and case FIR No.132 dated 28.04.2012 (Ex P-1) was registered in Police Station, Gharaunda. The said case was investigated by him and the final report (Ex.P2) was submitted by the then Inspector Vijay Malik. As DW1, he deposed that during investigation, he collected the relevant record regarding accused Manoj being posted with Soma company, Toll Plaza, Nilokheri. He collected the relevant record of corridor attendance register dated 26.04.2012 (Ex.D5) wherein at Sr. No.12, there was entry regarding accused Manoj being present on duty. Photocopy of AMB report register as Ex.D6 in which relevant entries are dated 26.04.2012, photocopy of control room punching register as Ex.D7, copy of performance register as Ex.D8, payslip as Ex.D9, entry of performance register from 26.04.2012 to 27.04.2012 as Ex.D10 were also taken.
As per the aforesaid record and according to enquiry conducted by DW1, accused Manoj was present at Toll Plaza Nilo Kheri on duty at the time of alleged accident. DW5 had also examined the CCTV footage of Soma company and had also obtained call detail record of mobile numbers, 9458509570 and 9760259422 of complainant Satpal and also mobile number 9813476762 of accused Manoj. The location of mobile phone of Manoj at the time of occurrence was also not found at the spot. DW3 Suresh Kumar Junior officer deposed that on the relevant date, i.e. with effect from 20.04.2012 to 28.04.2012 accused Manoj Kumar was posted as Petrol driver with Soma Isolux NH-1 Toll Way at Nilokheri. Ex.D8 and Ex.D10 bore his signatures and were handed over by him to the police. As per Ex.D8, accused Manoj Kumar started duty on 26.04.2012 at 22:27 till 7.00 AM on 27.04.2012, and remained present on his duty.
Motive is a double edged sword. PW3 Satpal (complainant) stated in his cross-examination that he is known to Premwati who belongs to his family and no land was sold by Premwati, Suresh and Sher Singh, and as per his knowledge no agreement to sell was ever executed between Premwati on one side and Suresh and Sher Singh on the other side. He also admitted that the land, which was subject matter of civil appeal titled as “Sher Singh and Suresh v. Prem Singh and others”, was purchased by him in name of his wife as well as wife of Jagpal (injured) and one Parvesh w/o Karam Singh (Ex D3). PW3 denied knowledge that vide order Ex.D4 the aforesaid sale deed No.2519/1 and mutation on basis thereof were set aside though he stated that the litigation was pending before the High Court. However, PW3 admitted it as correct that Manoj was a witness to agreement to sell which took place between Premwati and Suresh Kumar and Sher Singh.
PW5 Jagpal (injured witness) stated in cross-examination that “whether any litigation between Satpal and Manoj is pending or not” is to be disclosed by Satpal. There is enmity between him and accused Manoj with respect to dispute of Premwati and Manoj and Suresh Kumar etc. He also admitted that Satpal is a property dealer by profession. Thus, there is a motive to falsely implicate the accused which has to be viewed viz a viz delay in registration of FIR
The accident in the present case took place on 27.04.2012, at about 5:00/5:30 am. However, FIR was registered on 28.04.2012 at about 10.53 pm (ruqa was sent after 1.20 pm on 27.04.2012). The argument raised by learned counsel for the appellant that the FIR was delayed as injured Jagpal was unfit to make statement on 27.04.2012, 28.04.2012, 01.05.2012 and 02.05.2012, has been rightly rejected by learned trial Court.
In the background of previous litigation and enmity, delay in registration of FIR is fatal to prosecution as delay gives time for fabrications and embellishments to complainant who has an axe to grind against the accused. Thus, learned trial Court has held, “Due to the above said dispute,
there may be chance to falsely involvement of the accused in the present case, therefore, the courts should always view the allegations with suspicious look for satisfactory explanation. If no such satisfaction is found, the delay is treated as fatal to the case of the prosecution.”
In Thulia Kali v. State of T.N., (1972) 3 SCC 393, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held:
“12.... First information report in a criminal case is an extremely vital and valuable piece of evidence for the purpose of corroborating the oral evidence adduced at the trial. The importance of the above report can hardly be overestimated from the standpoint of the accused. The object of insisting upon prompt lodging of the report to the police in respect of commission of an offence is to obtain early information regarding the circumstances in which the crime was committed, the names of the actual culprits and the part played by them as well as the names of eyewitnesses present at the scene of occurrence. Delay in lodging the first information report quite often results in embellishment which is a creature of afterthought. On account of delay, the report not only gets bereft of the advantage of spontaneity, danger creeps in of the introduction of coloured version, exaggerated account or concocted story as a result of deliberation and consultation. It is, therefore, essential that the delay in the lodging of the first information report should be satisfactorily explained…”
Furthermore, after the accident took place, injured Jagpal was taken to PHC Gharaunda at about 6.15 am on 27.04.2012, where it was clearly mentioned that it was a case of Road Side Accident (RSA). The injured was referred to Govt Hospital Karnal but instead he was taken to Shri Hari Hospital Karnal and then at about 1.20 PM, the injured was taken to Dr. Parveen Garg Hospital. No record of Shri Hari Hospital, Karnal is forthcoming and this fact only came during the course of evidence. Even the discharge summary of Dr. Parveen Garg Hospital mentioned that it was a road side accident with Hemorrhage i.e. shock and hemorrhage, with injury on right hip with fracture of pelvis with CAD. As per PW3 (complainant Satpal), the offending vehicle had no number plate on its front and something was pasted on the back side number plate of vehicle. Thus, a feeble attempt was made to connect the accused Manoj to accident by PW3 and PW5 who stated that Manoj was driving the vehicle Tavera with other person sitting on his side. The identity of such other person has not been established at all.
Coming to the nature of injuries, PW6, Dr. Lalit Saini deposed that on 27.04.2012 he was posted as Medical Officer in PHC Gharaunda, Karnal and he medico-legally examined injured Jagpal. On examination, he found two injuries on the person of injured. Injury no.1 was blunt in nature while injury no.2 was simple blunt. Patient was referred to General Hospital, Karnal. He advised Ortho Opinion as well as x-ray to be conducted with regard to the injury no.1. Injury no.1 was caused by blunt weapon while injury no.2 was simple in nature. He proved the copy of MLR as Ex.PW6/A.
PW7 Dr. Parveen Garg (Parveen Hospital Pvt. Ltd. Karnal) deposed that on 27.04.2012 patient Jagpal son of Jaiveer, resident of Arainpura aged 53 years was admitted in the hospital with the alleged history of road side accident around 5.30 am on 27.04.2012. The patient was taken to PHC, Gharaunda, then to Shri Hospital, Karnal and then brought to my hospital in gasping condition with blood pressure and pulse not readable. The patient was diagnosed as haemorrhagic shock. On examination, he found the following condition: 1. Patient intubated and put on ventilator by Dr. Tarun Singla, Four IV lines placed with 1st norade drip, 2nd. Blood, 3rd. Haemaccel, 4th.normal saline. 2. Exploratory laparotmy done with ligation of mesenteric bleed with control of R.P. (Retroperitoneal Haematoma) with P.L. Condition. Afebrile, Accepting only, Abdomen-Soft, No Haematuria. He proved the discharge summary Ex.PW7/B, police information Ex.PW7/D and discharge summary Ex.PW7/E.
Perusal of MLR (Ex PW6/A) reveals that there were two injuries i.e. one injury on the lower back and second injury on head. But Dr. Parveen Garg has operated the abdomen of the injured Satpal only to make an offence under Section 307 of IPC.
Learned trial Court appreciated the medical evidence and held as under:
“PW6 Dr. Lalit Saini has stated in his cross-examination that it is correct that there was no visible injury on the person of injured, except the complaint of pain. He has not mentioned duration of the injuries in above MLR. It is correct that in the MLR he has mentioned incident being 'RSA'. It is correct that the opinion of RSA was proved by injured and the person, who was giving company to the injured. Injured was conscious and well oriented. He did not send rukka to the police regarding the admission of injured. Voluntarily stated that the injured was not admitted rather he was referred to General Hospital, Karnal. He has mentioned in MLR that the injured was referred to General Hospital, Karnal and this endorsement is against a proper column. He did not see any X-ray or any other report for giving opinion regarding the nature of injury i.e. injury no.1. PW7 Dr. Parveen Garg has stated in his cross-examination that he has not prepared any MLR of the injured in this case. MLR was already prepared when patient was earlier taken to CHC, Gharaunda. Copy of MLR is in his record. Patient attendant told him that after injury patient was taken to PHC Gharaunda, MLR prepared and referred to Karnal. After that patient was taken to Shri Hari Hospital and then brought to his hospital. Patient was never taken to Civil Hospital, Karnal, so refer of patient from Civil Hospital does not arise at all. There is no document pertaining to referring of the patient by Shri Hari Hospital, on the judicial file. Voluntarily stated that referral letter of Shri Hari Hospital is in his record. There is no document on the judicial file, which could show that who accompanied the patient to the hospital. Voluntarily stated that patient was accompanied by Jitender, Yogesh Kumar and one another person. In Ex.PW7/B, he has mentioned the alleged history of road side accident. He has written the above said fact at the asking of the attendants of the patient. Name of attendant is not mentioned in this document, who had told about this fact. No visible injury has been there in the MLR Ex.PW6/A. It is correct that in MLR although there was no visible injuries, but two complaint of pain were described by the doctor is only regarding right thigh and head. It is correct that he has operated the abdomen of the patient. There was no visible injury on the abdomen. Patient had fracture pelvis (hip) for which treatment was given. It is correct that at the time of discharge, he has also mentioned the alleged history of road side accident. It is incorrect to suggest that he prepared false medical record documents Ex.PW7/B to Ex.PW7/E at the asking of patient as well as his attendants. Ex.PW7/C is opinion regarding the fitness/unfitness for statement.”
The evidence of prosecution has been dealt with by learned trial Court, who also formed its opinion regarding credibility of witnesses and no perversity has been pointed out before this Court by learned counsel for the appellant. The learned trial Court is often the best Judge of credibility of witnesses, as it has the chance and occasion to notice the demeanour of witnesses. Further, in case of acquittal by learned trial Court, the scope of interference in appeal is limited.
In H.D. Sundara and others v. State of Karnataka, 2023(9) SCC 581, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:-
“9.Normally, when an appellate court exercises appellate jurisdiction, the duty of the appellate court is to find out whether the verdict which is under challenge is correct or incorrect in law and on facts. The appellate court normally ascertains whether the decision under challenge is legal or illegal. But while dealing with an appeal against acquittal, the appellate court cannot examine the impugned judgment only to find out whether the view taken was correct or incorrect. After reappreciating the oral and documentary evidence, the appellate court must first decide whether the trial court's view was a possible view. The appellate court cannot overturn acquittal only on the ground that after reappreciating evidence, it is of the view that the guilt of the accused was established beyond a reasonable doubt. Only by recording such a conclusion an order of acquittal cannot be reversed unless the appellate court also concludes that it was the only possible conclusion. Thus, the appellate court must see whether the view taken by the trial court while acquitting an accused can be reasonably taken on the basis of the evidence on record. If the view taken by the trial court is a possible view, the appellate court cannot interfere with the order of acquittal on the ground that another view could have been taken.”
Another interesting fact which emerges from the testimony of PW7 Dr. Parveen Garg is that the patient was accompanied by Jitender, Yogesh and another person. However, name of attendant who gave the history of RSA (Road Side Accident) was not mentioned. Furthermore, there was no visible injury in the MLR (Ex.PW6/A). Only 2 complaints of pain were described by Doctor regarding right thigh and head. However, PW6 had still operated the abdomen of the patient and there was no visible injury on the abdomen. Learned trial Court has disbelieved the opinion of PW7 Dr. Parveen Garg who had declared the injury dangerous to life by relying on Rang Bahadur Singh v. State of U.P, 2000(3) SCC 454.
Though the private doctor can be believed if the medical treatment accorded to the patient is in consonance with the prosecution case. In case of contradictions between oral testimonies and medical evidence/record, the latter is liable to be disbelieved.
Weighing the facts and circumstances of the present case on the anvil of settled law and after going through the memorandum of appeal, judgment passed by learned trial Court and hearing the arguments of learned counsel for the parties, this Court finds no perversity in the order passed by learned trial Court and hence records are not necessary in the case.
In view of the aforesaid, no case for interference is made out. Consequently, the present application filed by the applicant under Section 378(3) Cr.P.C. [Section 419(3) BNSS, 2023] seeking leave to file appeal, is hereby dismissed.
