AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Sathish Ninan, J.
The suit for partition was dismissed by the trial court against which the plaintiffs are in appeal.
The 1st defendant is the mother of plaintiffs and defendants 2 to 5. The property sought to be partitioned stood in the name of the mother as per Ext.A2 Sale Deed dated 23.04.1974. It was the contention of the plaintiffs that the property was purchased for and on behalf of the family.
Defendants 1, 2, 4 and 5 filed a joint written statement, denying the plaint allegation. It was contended that it is the separate property of the mother. In the joint written statement, it was further contended that the 1st defendant mother has executed settlement deeds in the year 2012 in favour of defendants 2 and 5, conveying the property in question in their favour. The 3rd defendant did not contest the suit.
The 1st defendant mother died pending the suit, after filing the written statement.
On the day of trial, the defendants' counsel reported no instructions and they were set ex parte. The plaintiffs filed proof affidavit in tune with the plaint averments. The trial court proceeded to dismiss the suit holding that there is no evidence to show that the acquisition under Ext.A2 is for and on behalf of the family.
I have heard the learned counsel on both sides.
The point that arises for determination is;
“Was the trial court right in having dismissed the suit in the absence of any evidence to controvert the evidence of PW1 and also in the absence of any materials to evidence any settlement by the 1st defendant in favour of defendants 2 and 5?
As noticed above, the 1st defendant mother died pending the suit. Though there is a contention that the mother had conveyed the property in favour of defendants 2 and 5 there is no material before the Court to hold so. Unless it is proved that there are such conveyances, even assuming that the property in question belonged to the mother, the property devolves on all the children including plaintiffs. Therefore, in the absence of any evidence of conveyance by the 1st defendant-mother in favour of defendants 2 and 5, the plaintiffs would also be entitled to a share. Therefore, the suit for partition could not have dismissed.
Now coming to the question as to whether the acquisition under Ext.A2 was the self acquisition or for and on behalf of the family, it is the plaintiffs' case that the property that stood in the name of the father under Ext.A1 was sold by him and the proceeds thereof were utilised for purchase of Ext.A2 property. It is argued that there are recitals in Ext.A1 that the sale is being effected since the property is situated far away and the inconvenience in looking after the property. This probabilises the contention that the purchase under Ext.A2 is on behalf of the family, it is contended.
In the light of the facts as above, it is only deemed appropriate that the trial court disposes of the suit afresh, after affording opportunity to both sides to adduce evidence.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed. The decree and judgment of the trial court are set aside. The suit is remanded back to the trial court for disposal de novo. The parties shall appear before the trial court on 05.01.2024. It is clarified that all contentions of both sides are left open.
