High CourtsDivision Bench(2018) 04 CHH CK 0304

Sanjar Ansari vs Chief Engineer

Chhattisgarh High Court · Decided on 25 April 2018

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
WPPIL No. 21, 28 of 2018

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

240 paragraphs · 4,370 words

,,,,,

1.

In these two Public Interest Litigations (PILs), the petitioners, claiming themselves to be the public spirited persons, one of them namely; Sant"

Kumar Netam, being a tribal, have prayed for quashment of the entire tender process of first and second round of sale of tendu patta for the collection"

year 2018 undertaken by the respondent-Chhattisgarh State Minor Forest Produce (Trading & Development) Cooperative Federation Limited

(hereinafter referred to as ‘the Federation’) and consequently direct for fresh tender. Petitioners have also prayed for a criminal investigation

by an independent agency like Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in respect of corruption and scam in allotment of lots/units to the successful

bidders. Prayer has also been made to direct the respondent State to make good the loss of livelihood likely to be caused to the tribal tendu patta

plucking families.,,,,,

2.

Facts of the matter, as projected in the writ petition, are that tendu patta is one of the principal minor forest produce generating revenue for the"

State and the tribals, as tendu patta is available mainly in tribal dominated areas and the pluckers are mostly tribals. Tendu Patta being a natural"

resource is a State largesse, which is sold/allotted/ disposed of by the Federation by inviting tenders. According to the petitioner, the revenue earned"

by sale of tendu patta to bidders is firstly utilized for payment of wages to the pluckers at the rate of Rs.2,500/- per standard bag and, thereafter, out"

of the profit, 80% is distributed to the plucker families and 5% each to the Federation, the District Union and the Primary Societies. The remaining 5%"

is used to compensate loss making primary societies. The amount so paid to the tribals is, thus, their main source of livelihood and most of them are"

Below Poverty Line (BPL) families, therefore, in case of substantial loss or decrease in the amount of revenue earned by sale of tendu patta, the"

livelihood of the tribal families is severely affected.,,,,,

3.

For the collection year 2018, the Federation issued the Notice Inviting Tender (hereinafter referred to as ‘the e-Tender’) on 28-11-2017 for"

disposal of tendu leaves of 951 lots. The interested bidders submitted their bids via e-mode and in the first round, the bids were received for as many"

as 650 lots, out of which 549 were approved while the remaining were rejected. The Federation has accepted the bids which are ranging from above"

(+) 15% to (-) 51% compared to last year’s rates and, as such, whopping loss is caused to the Federation, as the accepted bids are shockingly"

low.,,,,,

4.

According to the petitioner, the tender of first round has caused loss to the tune of Rs.200 crores to the State, which smells of deep rooted"

corruption on account of cartelization to play fraud on the exchequer and the tribals. The Federation, thereafter, proceeded to invite second round of"

bids in respect of the remaining 451 lots and again bids have been accepted in the same manner causing further loss to the tune of Rs.81 crores to the

exchequer. In this round, the tender committee has approved the bids below up to 51%. In the second round, 153 lots were finalized and 72 were"

rejected, therefore, now almost 250 lots are remaining for disposal in the third round of tender."

5.

The petitioners would state that by virtue of public trust doctrine, the natural resources belong to the people of this country of which the"

Government is only a trustee, therefore, the State is bound to protect the interest of the exchequer and the tribals. In earlier years, the irregular and"

arbitrary bids were cancelled in 2007 & 2008 to protect the interest of the tribals, but in this year the Federation has not acted fairly raising serious"

doubt and suspicion of foul play and corruption on account of cartelizing. Petitioners would further state that in the first round itself the Federation has

accepted the bid of a bidder who were as low as 19th or 20th in terms of bid amount.

6.

Petitioners would further plead that the tender process is undertaken by the Federation on the basis of standard terms and conditions which have

been prevailing since long. After submission of bids in e-form, the same are opened on-line and the results are placed for finalization of the tender"

committee of the Federation. As per the recommendation of the committee, the Federation, acting through the Managing Director, issues the final"

allotment order and a formal contract and agreement called as 'purchaser's agreement' is executed between the Federation and the successful bidder.

In the year 2017, the rates quoted by the bidders were on higher side, therefore, it earned enhanced profit to the Federation to be passed on to the"

tribals as enhanced bonus. Petitioners would also state that collection of tendu patta takes place between April — June of every year, therefore, the"

Federation floats tender for sale of tendu patta as advance sale. In the e-tender itself, it is mentioned that the lots were to be advertised as many as in"

three rounds in case the Federation does not receive the satisfactory bids or/and until all lots/units are sold and as a matter of practice, tenders are"

called for selling the lots even after three rounds and those lots which remained to be sold on completion of the tender process are managed by the

Federation.,,,,,

7.

In para 8.31 of WP PIL No.21 of 2018 filed by Sant Kumar Netam, it is pleaded that on-line tender process requires very few days to be"

completed, the season of tendu leaves is yet to commence from April, therefore, the tenders are required to be cancelled & rejected for inviting fresh"

tenders to get better rates.,,,,,

8.

On the strength of above pleadings, Shri Sunil Otwani, Shri Sudiep Shrivastava and Shri Sanjay Kumar, learned counsels appearing for the"

petitioners, would submit that the Federation has accepted bids at a shockingly low price causing whopping loss to the exchequer, which would"

ultimately affect the earning of the tribals by way of distribution of bonus. They would submit that in the first round itself the Federation has accepted

bids of such bidders who are down below up to 19th position in the descending order of the value of their bids. The Federation should have called

fresh bids after all H-1 bids were either accepted or rejected due to exhaustion of their purchasing capacity. By not inviting bids de novo for the

remaining lots, which have not been allotted to H-1 bidders, the respondent authority has caused loss to the exchequer and has promoted cartelization"

of tendu patta traders.,,,,,

9.

Learned counsel would strenuously urge that the officials of the Federation and the concerned Department of the State Government have indulged

in corruption of scam proportion which needs to be investigated by the CBI, as it amounts to amassing of illegal wealth, which is punishable under the"

provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Learned counsel would next argue that under Section 2 (i) of the Scheduled Tribes and Other

Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 read with Section 3 (1)(c), the tribals have been conferred with the forest rights,"

therefore, acceptance of bids at an enormously low rate affects the rights of the tribals vitiating the tender process."

10.

Learned counsels would refer to the documents (Annexure — P/9 in WP PIL No.21 of 2018) to highlight acceptance of bids as low as 20th in

the order of bidding price. They have cited the tender process adopted by the State of Madhya Pradesh, which accepts only H-1 bidder."

11.

To buttress their contentions, learned counsels for the petitioners would place reliance upon the decisions rendered by the Surpeme Court in State"

of West Bengal and Others v Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights, West Bengal and Others1, Narmada Bai v State of Gujarat and"

others2, Centre for Public Interest Litigation and others v Union of India and others3, Natural Resources Allocation, In Re. Special Reference No.1 of"

(2010) 3 SCC 571,,,,,

2 (2011) 5 SCC 79,,,,,

3 (2012) 3 SCC 1,,,,,

20124, Bhubaneswar Development Authority and another v Adikanda Biswal and others5, Ram Kishun and others v State of Uttar Pradesh and"

others6, Master Marine Services (P) Ltd. v Metcalfe & Hodgkinson (P) Ltd. and Another7, Institute of Law and others v Neeraj Sharma and others8,"

decisions rendered by the High Court of Chhattisgarh in Ajit Pramod Kumar Jogi v High Power Certification Scrutiny Committee and Another9, M/s"

Bhawna Enterprises v State of Chhattisgarh & Anr.10 and the decision of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Aman Traders v State of M.P. and

Another11.,,,,,

12.

Shri J.K. Gilda, learned Advocate General appearing for the State, Shri R.N. Singh, learned senior counsel, Shri A.S. Kachhawaha & Shri"

Apoorva Kurup, learned counsels appearing for the Federation, would argue, per contra, that the petitioners may be the public spirited persons, but the"

present petitions do not involve any element of public interest. They would submit that the petitions have been preferred with an oblique motive to

frustrate the entire tender process, which would benefit none. In the eventuality of the petitions being allowed, at this juncture, the tribals shall suffer"

loss, as there would be uncertainty in respect of plucking, storing and disposal of tendu leaves. Learned counsels would further submit that the entire"

e-tendering process for disposal/sale of tendu leaves,,,,,

4 (2012) 10 SCC 1,,,,,

5 (2012) 11 SCC 731,,,,,

6 (2012) 11 SCC 511,,,,,

7 (2005) 6 SCC 138,,,,,

8 2014 AIR SCW 6357,,,,,

9 WPC 2104 of 2017 (decided on 30-1-2018( (DB) 10 AIR 2007 Chhattisgarh 74,,,,,

11 2013 (1) MPLJ 699,,,,,

is time tested and has withstood scrutiny by the High Court on various occasions, therefore, branding the same as arbitrary, improper or irrational"

process, is entirely misplaced.",,,,,

13.

Shri J.K. Gilda, learned Advocate General appearing for the State and Shri A.S. Kachhawaha, learned counsel appearing for the Federation have"

taken this Court through the entire tender process to demonstrate the inbuilt fairness through a very rational and logical bidding process. Referring to

the history of collection of tendu patta and the corresponding revenue generated for the last so many years, they have tried to demonstrate that the"

present year is a lean year for the business of tendu patta, therefore, it has not generated desired revenue for which the State or the Federation cannot"

be blamed. According to them, produce of tendu patta in a particular year and the price which it would fetch in the market is not completely within the"

control of the State as host of market factors govern such complicated price fixation. They would submit that price fixation of any commodity being a

market dependant phenomenon, generation of reduced revenue cannot be a foundation for presumption of any corruption. They would also"

vehemently submit that there is absolutely no factual foundation set out in the petitions to, prima facie, point out any element of corruption. Mere"

rhetoric and oral submission of corruption is not sufficient to smell corruption and direct an enquiry.

14.

To substantiate their contentions, Shri J.K. Gilda, learned Advocate General and Shri R.N. Singh, learned senior counsel would place reliance upon"

the decisions rendered by the Supreme Court in State of Uttar Pradesh and Others v Vijay Bahadur Singh and Others12, Center for Public Interest"

Litigation and Another v Union of India and Others13, Raunaq International Ltd. v I.V.R. Construction Ltd. and Others14, Union of India v Rajasthan"

High Court and Others15 and the decisions of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Hari Om v State of M.P. and another16, H.N. Sundresh v State"

of M.P. and others17 and Mukesh and Co. Tobacco Products (P.) Ltd. v Madhya Pradesh Rajya Laghu Vanopaj (Vyapar Evam Vikas) Sahakari

Sangh Limited and others18.,,,,,

15.

Shri Kishore Bhaduri, learned counsel appearing for the CBI, would submit that for the present the CBI has no role to play in the contest between"

the petitioners and the State or the Federation.,,,,,

16.

Shri K.A. Ansari, learned senior counsel, Shri Prateek Sharma, Ms. Sharmila Singhai, Shri Vipin Singh, Shri Devesh Kela, Shri Anup Mazumdar,"

Shri Basant Dewangan, Shri Pritam Tiwari, Shri Ali Asgar, Shri Akshay Pawar, Shri Abhishek Agrawal, Shri K. Rohan, Shri Parag Kotecha, Shri"

Sanjay Agrawal, Shri Chandresh Shrivastava and Shri Pawan Kesharwani, learned counsels appearing for the respective respondents would support"

the submission raised by the State and the Federation.,,,,,

12 (1982) 2 SCC 365,,,,,

13 (2000) 8 SCC 606,,,,,

14 (1999) 1 SCC 492,,,,,

15 (2017) 2 SCC 599,,,,,

16 1987 SCC Online MP 23 : AIR 1987 MP 212,,,,,

17 MANU/MP/0422/1989,,,,,

18 (1990) MPLJ 694,,,,,

17.

To appreciate and dwell on the rival contentions, it would be necessary for us to understand the entire tender process, which is set out infra."

18.

It is not in dispute between the parties that the on-line tender process of the Federation for disposal/sale of tendu leaves is invoked since 2013.

According to the State, the computerised bidding process started as early as 1989-90. The Federation issued on-line e-tender notice for advance sale"

of tendu leaves for collection season 2018 on 28-11-2017 for three rounds of bidding. The tenderers/bidders were informed to download the tender

notice by a particular date mentioned against the three rounds with corresponding dates for submission of on-line tender and the date of on-line

opening of tender for each of the round. The tenderer is required to submit the Earnest Money Deposit (EMD) based on his own calculation of his

Collection year,"Average Sale Rate Obtained (In

Rs. Per Standard Bag)","Rise or Fall in Percentage w.r.t.

Previous Year",,,

2004,787.00,-17.68,,,

2005,906.00,15.12,,,

2006,951.00,4.97,,,

2007,1895.00,4.97,,,

2008,1434.00,-24.33,,,

2009,1748.00,21.90,,,

2010,2170.00,24.14,,,

2011,2619.00,20.69,,,

2012,3772.00,44.02,,,

2013,2461.00,-34.76,,,

Year,"Total no. of

bidders in 1 st

round","Purchase

capacity of all

bidders in 1st

round of tender in

Rs. Crores","Actual collection

of tendu leaves in

lac SB","Total sale value

obtained in that

year in Rs.Crore",Market Condition

2012,392,1213.14,17.15,646.90,Excellent

2013,149,387.29,14.71,362.13,Slump

2014,104,300.76,14.27,334.75,Slump

2015,161,605.11,13.01,345.50,Improved Market

2016,291,1318.65,13.61,638.89,Excellent

2017,302,2412.92,17.10,1358.65,Outstanding

2018,138,710.92,NA,900*,Slump

32.

Learned counsel appearing for both the parties have referred to the synopsis/proposal submitted before the IDC to strengthen their respective

submissions. IDC is a high power committee chaired by the Forest Minister, along with 8 other senior officers of the rank of Principal Secretary of"

Forest, Finance, Commerce & Industry, Tribal Development, Principal Chief Conservator of Forest, Managing Director of the Federation. The"

documents concerning the proposal for fixation of cut off price for the year 2018 and its acceptance by the IDC would demonstrate that the

IDC/Federation has considered the average sale price and average cut off price of the previous year along with the rate of tendu patta in other tendu

patta producing States. It nowhere suggests that relevant factors have been ignored and irrelevant or extraneous matters have been considered while

fixing the minimum and maximum cut off price. The e-tender document particularly clause 8 (ii) confers right to the Federation to fix different cut off

levels/upset prices for different lots or class of lots or lots of different areas in deciding allotment of lots to different tenderers. Thus, fixation of cut off"

or upset price is a part of tender process made known to all tenderers in the tender document itself and the acceptance of tender has taken place only

after the fixation of cut off/up set price.,,,,,

33.

It has been argued by the petitioners that the Awarodh Moolya would mean cut off price and not upset price, therefore, no upset price has been"

fixed before acceptance of tender, therefore, the entire process is illegal, however, the tender document itself has not provided for any date on which"

cut off price/upset price would be fixed. Tender document speaks of the cut off/upset price at the same place and the expression is interchangeable in

the context of the present tender.,,,,,

34.

It is well known that when the Government disposes/sales a commodity, the object is to achieve better rates, therefore, non-disclosure of cut off"

price/upset price while selling tendu patta would generate more competition amongst bidders, therefore, non-disclosure or cut off price is not arbitrary."

35.

In Mukesh and Co. Tobacco Products (P.) Ltd. (supra), the Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, while dealing with the similar"

tender process and similar challenge, would observe thus at para 6 :",,,,,

‘6…It, therefore, cannot be inferred that merely because a lower offer has been accepted in respect of a given lot, the respondent has"

committed any illegality because it may as well be that by the time the tenderer's priority in respect of a given lot comes for consideration, his"

purchasing capacity may either be exhausted or reduced so as to disentitle him to purchase that particular lot. In this process, no fault could be pointed"

out by the learned counsel for the petitioners. True it is that while working out the aforesaid method in selecting purchasers in respect of different lots,"

mistakes may be committed and it was not denied by the respondents that some mistakes were committed in process of selecting purchasers and in

accepting their offers. It was, however, submitted that those mistakes have been corrected. No better method of ascertaining the best purchaser for a"

given lot was suggested by either of the petitioners. That being so, the respondents did well to apply the process mentioned above in accepting the"

offers of the various tenderers in respect of different lots. The criticism levelled by the learned counsel for the petitioners that due weight has not been

given to the priorities in selecting purchasers in respect of different lots of Bidi leaves is not sound and must be rejected.

36.

Petitioners have also referred to the provisions contained in Sections 5 & 6 of the Chhattisgarh Tendu Patta (Vyapar Viniyaman) Adhiniyam, 1964"

(hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act, 1964’) to argue that the Government should have formed advisory committee and the price at which the"

tendu leaves are to be sold should have been fixed in consultation with the said committee but the same having not been done there is statutory

violation in fixation of price and, as such, the entire tender process should be quashed."

37.

A bare reading of the provisions contained in Sections 6 & 7 of the Act, 1964 would manifest that constitution of advisory committee and"

consultation by the State Government with the committee is for purchase of tendu leaves and not for sale of tendu leaves. There is no question of

fixing any price for sale of tendu leaves because effort of the Government is to earn maximum sale price. The trade in tendu leaves including sale or

disposal of tendu leaves has been left to be undertaken by the agents to be appointed by the State under the powers conferred under Section 4 of the

Act, 1964. The argument with reference to Sections 6 & 7 of the Act, 1964 has no substance and it deserves to be rejected."

38.

Invocation of public trust doctrine, fixation of upset price, corruption, etc., by learned counsel for the petitioners, on the strength of judgments of"

the Supreme Court in Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights, West Bengal (supra), Narmada Bai (supra), Centre for Public Interest"

Litigation (2012) 3 SCC 1 (supra), Natural Resources Allocation (supra), Bhubaneswar Development Authority (supra) and Ram Kishun (supra), may"

not detain this Court for the reason that on comparison of rates of tendu patta for 2018 season in different tendu patta producing States, history of the"

rates in the State of Chhattisgarh for the last more than 10 years, the phenomenon of slump year and bumper year as has been considered in the"

preceding paragraphs has impressed us to hold that there is no, prima facie, evidence of illegal or arbitrary act based on corruption or nefarious design"

to benefit any particular tenderer. The public trust doctrine can be invoked only when there is proof of misuse of public funds or arbitrary disposal of

State largesse on a throwaway price, which is not the case here."

39.

The foundation for calling in question the entire tender process is on the allegation of the Federation having accepted lower bids upto level 19 or

20, however, the prevailing e-tendering system for sale of tendu leaves permits such process. The price quoted by the purchaser/bidder is the price"

which he considers it to be appropriate and suitable to him for various reasons. It also depends on elimination of tenderers due to exhaustion of the

bidding capacity. If a bidder is not fit for consideration as it has exhausted its capacity the price fixation depends on the rates quoted by the bidders

who is next in line. Such method of bidding has been found valid by the Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Mukesh and Co.

Tobacco Products (P.) Ltd. (supra),",,,,,

40.

In respect of price fixation the Supreme Court in Centre for Public Interest Litigation (2010) 8 SCC 606 (supra) has held thus at paras 16 & 20 :

16.

The price fixation in a contract of the nature with which we are concerned, is a highly technical and complex procedure. It will be extremely"

difficult for a court to decide whether a particular price agreed to be paid under the contract is fair and reasonable or not in a contract of this nature.

More so, because the fixation of price for crude to be purchased by the GOI depends upon various variable factors. We are not satisfied with the"

argument of the appellants that the nation has suffered a huge financial loss by virtue of this arbitrary fixation of crude price. As a matter of fact, the"

figure mentioned by the appellants of Rs.3,000 crores as a loss under this head of pricing is based on incorrect fact that the consortium is charging $ 4"

per barrel as premium. It is because of this factual error that the appellants came to the conclusion that under the contract the GOI had agreed to

purchase the crude from the consortium at an inflated price. We also take note of the fact that under the agreement the respondents are bound to give

a discount of $ 0.10 per barrel on the price of the crude fixed on the basis of the international market rate which, prima facie shows that the fixation of"

price is reasonable since under all given circumstances the said will be less than the international market price for Brent crude.

xxx xxx xxx,,,,,

xxx xxx xxx,,,,,

xxx xxx xxx,,,,,

20.

It is clear from the above observations of this Court that it will be very difficult for the courts to visualise the various factors like commercial/

technical aspects of the contract, prevailing market conditions both national and international and immediate needs of the country etc. which will have"

to be taken note of while accepting the bid offer. In such a case, unless the court is satisfied that the allegations levelled are unassailable and there"

could be no doubt as to the unreasonableness, mala fide, collateral considerations alleged, it will not be possible for the courts to come to the"

conclusion that such a contract can be prima facie or otherwise held to be vitiated so as to call for an independent investigation, as prayed for by the"

appellants. Therefore, the above contention of the appellants also fails.",,,,,

41.

Similarly, in Raunaq International Ltd. (supra) the Supreme Court observed thus at para 16 :"

16.

It is also necessary to remember that price may not always be the sole criterion for awarding a contract. Often when an evaluation committee of

experts is appointed to evaluate offers, the expert committee's special knowledge plays a decisive role in deciding which is the best offer. Price"

offered is only one of the criteria. The past record of the tenderers, the quality of the goods or services which are offered, assessing such quality on"

the basis of the past performance of the tenderer, its market reputation and so on, all play an important role in deciding to whom the contract should be"

awarded. At times, a higher price for a much better quality of work, can be legitimately paid in order to secure proper performance of the contract"

and good quality of work-which is as much in public interest as a low price. The court should not substitute its own decision for the decision of an

expert evaluation committee.,,,,,

42.

Having considered the whole gamut of the pleadings/allegations, the e-tender process undertaken by the Federation, the history of quantity and"

rate of tendu patta generated for the last many years, the nature of trade of tendu patta and the market forces, which govern the price fixation of"

tendu patta in a particular year and the comparable price in other States, we have no hesitation in concluding that the fall in price of tendu patta for the"

year 2018 is not on account of any illegality or corruption of the Federation or its officers nor as a result of cartelization, but is purely based on market"

condition or market forces.,,,,,

43.

Price fixation is essentially a job of the expert, which should be left to the body, who is well versed with the trade in question and the Court should"

not venture into the territory as it is the beyond the scope of judicial review as held by the Supreme Court in Center for Public Interest Litigation,"

(2000) 8 SCC 606 (supra) and Raunaq International Ltd. (supra).,,,,,

44.

In course of hearing, we confronted learned counsel appearing for the petitioners that if the whole or any part of the tender process is quashed and"

re-tender is ordered, but the Federation fails to generate more revenue than it has earned for the concerned lot and resultantly it runs into losses, who"

will compensate the Federation or the tribals, who are the ultimate beneficiaries, learned counsel would submit that the petitioners have no means to"

compensate the Federation and the tribals.,,,,,

45.

As an upshot, for the above stated reasons, we find no substance in both the writ petitions (PILs). Accordingly, both the petitions are liable to be"

and are hereby dismissed and the interim order stands vacated. The parties shall bear their respective costs.