Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2025) 10 NCLAT CK 1694

Samson T. George vs Bejo Thomas & Ors.

National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, CHENNAI Bench · Decided on 29 October 2025

CASE NUMBER
Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 546/2025 (IA Nos. 1530 & 1531/2025)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

28 paragraphs · 1,544 words

O R D E R

Oral Judgment : Justice Sharad Kumar Sharma, Member (Judicial):

1.

The entire controversy germinates from an Application, which was preferred by the Respondents / Applicants, under Section 60(5) of I & B Code, 2016, before the Ld. NCLT, Kochi Bench, praying for the directions, as it was contained therein for directing the Liquidator and the Respondents therein i.e. the Appellants, to execute the Sale Deed in relation to the subject property.

2.

While this Application was being considered, the Tribunal considered it to be necessary to call to produce certain documents and accordingly passed an order on 25.04.2025, directing the Appellant to produce the said documents, as mentioned therein in the aforesaid order, for the purposes of facilitating the Tribunal to decide on the aforesaid application. Relevant part of the directions contained in the order of 25.04.2025 is extracted hereunder:-

“This is a batch of cases filed by the Home Buyers/applicants for seeking various reliefs regarding execution of sale deeds in their favour. The applicants have entered into Sale Agreements and construction agreements in these batch of cases starting from the year 2007 and in some cases in subsequent years from 2007 to 2015. R3 to R5 (land owners (majority shareholders of the Corporate Debtor)) have entered into a joint development agreement with Corporate Debtor in respect of land measuring 53 cents for construction of building named as “Jade Heights 1”. The Corporate Debtor and the land owners though earlier sailing on the same boat and induced the applicants/homebuyers to purchase respective flats, now in this litigation they have taken contradictory stance. As it may be, this Tribunal vide its order dated 25.04.2025 directed the land owners (majority shareholders of the Corporate Debtor) to produce some documents and information. That documents and information are required for judicious adjudication of this case. To their convenience, ample time was given. However today, Counsel appearing for R3 to R5 sought at least one month’s time to comply with the said order. The relevant extracts of the said order is reproduced below for ready reference: -

“Heard. The Tribunal has directed the Counsel to specify the documents intended to be produced. In response, the Counsel has identified the following documents:

i.

Copy of pleadings of all Civil litigations

ii.

orders passed by civil courts.

iii.

Copies of two Joint Venture Agreements.

iv.

Orders passed by Hon'ble High Court in Writ Appeal.

v.

Agreements executed between CD and home Buyers.

vi.

Notice issued by Municipality to the Land Owners.

vii.

Complaints filed before the Police Authority.

The land owners may produce above-mentioned documents, but apart from the above-mentioned documents no other documents would be permissible. Counsel appearing for the landowners (majority shareholders of CD) should also place before this Tribunal Certified Copies of all Passports since 2005 till date; and details/particulars of all representations made by the land owners and majority shareholders of CD to various statutory authorities, details of income tax returns, details of their bank accounts, details of all documents executed by them from 2005 regarding their immovable properties whether said properties are part of the project or not, details of all general or specific power of attorneys executed by them.

At the request and to the convenience of counsel for the landowners (majority shareholders of CD), thirty days' time is granted to file the above-mentioned documents. It is made clear that thereafter no document would be taken on record. However, the concerned litigant would be under obligation to produce all those documents for which this Tribunal has given separate directions. Counsel for the land owners and majority shareholders of CD would be able to raise all legal objections available to them in accordance with law at the time of hearing.”

3.

The directions contained in the order of 25.04.2025, was not complied within the time frame prescribed therein, therefore the Tribunal passed a fresh order on 12.06.2025, reiterating the directions that, was given in the order of 25.04.2025. The relevant directions given in the order of 12.06.2025 is almost verbatim to the order of 25.04.2025 as extracted above.

4.

These orders were not complied with. Subsequently, when the proceedings were taken up before the Ld. Tribunal on 26.06.2025 and thereafter on 03.07.2025, the Appellant had given an assurance by way of an undertaking, as recorded therein that he will be producing the documents in compliance of the earlier order passed on 25.04.2025 and 12.06.2025. When the same was not followed, the necessity arose for the Tribunal to pass the impugned order which is being challenged in the instant Appeal.

5.

The grievance as agitated by the Appellant at this stage is, that the directions given by the Tribunal by the impugned order of 26.09.2025, as it was rendered in IA(IBC)/375/KOB/2023 in IBA/11/KOB/2020 were erroneous as the said documents as called for, would not be relevant for the purposes of deciding the Interlocutory Application preferred before the Ld. NCLT.

6.

What relevance would those documents carry which were directed to be produced by the orders of 25.04.2025 and 12.06.2025 for the purposes of deciding the Interlocutory Application, would not be a subject matter for consideration by this Appellate Tribunal and at this stage we will confine ourselves to considering the propriety of the impugned order of 26.09.2025, whereby there happens to be a simpliciter direction for the Appellant to comply, with the direction given on 25.04.2025 which was later reiterated by the order of 12.06.2025.

7.

The impugned order dated 26.09.2025 cannot be read in isolation or in exclusion of the earlier two orders i.e. 25.04.2025 and 12.06.2025, which the Appellant has undertaken to comply with by supplying the documents, during subsequent proceedings of Ld. NCLT.

8.

The present direction given in the impugned order dated 26.09.2025 is not an independent order in itself. In that eventuality, the earlier orders of 25.04.2025 and 12.06.2025, would be treated to be the orders that have attained finality qua the Appellant because he has not challenged the same and instead, has subsequently affirmed the same and assured that he will be supplying the documents in compliance thereto of the earlier orders.

9.

By the proceedings, which were held on 24.09.2025 the date when impugned order was rendered, the endeavour made by the Appellant was to qualify the directions as it were given by the earlier orders, by modifying the arguments, and interpreting the same to the extent that, he will be supplying the documents as directed earlier in a sealed envelope. This cannot be a condition, which could now be imposed by the Appellant, in the light of the provisions contained under Rule 43 of the NCLT Rules, which vests with Ld. NCLT the exclusive prerogative to direct the parties to produce documents as required by it for deciding the cases before it.

10.

So far as the necessity of those documents to be produced on record is concerned, it is to be decided so by Ld. Tribunal, in the context of the interlocutory application filed before it and the said decision falls within the exclusive domain of Ld. Tribunal and it is not open for a party to the proceedings to dispute the same.

11.

The observation, which has been made by the Tribunal while passing the impugned order dated 26.09.2025, observing thereof that there has been an apparent dereliction on part of the Appellant, in not complying the earlier directions is quite apparent from the order itself, where it is recorded that the Appellant has not produced the documents as directed.

12.

Owing to the fact that, the determination as to whether the documents will be relevant for the purposes of deciding the application and by how much, is the exclusive prerogative of the Tribunal, which was decided on 25.04.2025 and 12.06.2025 and which were not challenged by the Appellant, we are not required to go into the matter of determining the necessity of documents which is being prayed for by the Ld. Counsel for the Appellant because, that may create a cloud over the proceedings when the application itself is to be decided on merits.

13.

In these eventualities, we hold that the observation, which has been made by the Tribunal in the impugned order, that the conditions attempted to be imposed and introduced by the Appellant in the proceedings of 26.09.2025 were uncalled for and were rather beyond the scope of the order of 25.04.2025 and 12.06.2025, was correct and that, Ld. Tribunal is right in declining the contentions of the Appellant while directing the Appellant to comply with the earlier orders and to produce the documents called for by its earlier orders because, the Appellant is bound under the earlier orders which he failed to challenge and because the impugned order is nothing but an order in continuation of the earlier orders asking the Appellant to comply the directions to produce the required documents as called for.

14.

However, so far as the aspect of imposition of costs of Rs. 5.00 lakh to be deposited into National Defence Fund is concerned, taking a pragmatic view, we direct that part of the order alone to be withdrawn.

15.

Subject to the aforesaid, the Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (INS) No. 546 / 2025, would stand dismissed. All Interlocutory Applications, would stand closed.