AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Rakesh Kumar Jain, J.—The question of law involved in this appeal is as to "whether as per Rule 18(2) of the Government Employee's (Conduct) Rules, 1966, it is incumbent upon the government servant to obtain sanction or only intimation is required to be given to the prescribed authority before purchasing immovable property"? The plaintiff has come up in appeal against the judgment and decree of the lower Appellate Court by which he has been held entitled to a decree of recovery of Rs. 20,000/- as damages from the defendant with future interest @ 6% per annum from the date of decree of the Trial Court dated 31.10.1992 till realization. He has also been held entitled to proportionate cost of this amount throughout.
The case set up by the plaintiff is that he along with his brother Randhir Singh, Rajbir Singh and Rajesh Kumar entered into an agreement to sell dated 22.07.1986 of the land measuring 19 Kanals 05 Marlas, situated in village Murad Nagar, at the rate of Rs. 27,500/- per acre. The said land was already mortgaged with the plaintiff and his brothers for a sum of Rs. 36,000/-. The defendant obtained a sum of Rs. 10,000/- at the time of agreement and the balance amount was to be paid at the time of execution and registration of the sale deed on 11.06.1987.
In the written statement filed by the defendant, the agreement was denied. He objected to the agreement on the ground that it was against the public policy in view of Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 because the plaintiff was employed in Deputy Commissioner's office and could not have purchased the property in dispute without prior permission.
Replication was filed. Ultimately, the following issues were framed by the Trial Court:-
Whether the impugned agreement to sell dated 22.07.1986 was validly executed by the defendant in favour of plaintiff, on payment of Rs. 10,000/- as earnest money? OPP.
1-A. If issue No. 1 is proved, whether the alleged agreement to sell dt. 22.7.1986 is not enforceable on the grounds mentioned in paragraph No. 8 of the preliminary objections in the written statement? OPP.
Whether the plaintiff was in possession of the land in dispute prior to the date of execution of the alleged agreement to sell as mortgagee? OPP.
If issue No. 1. is proved, whether the plaintiff was ready and willing and is still ready and willing to get the sale deed executed and the sale could not be executed in time due to the faults of defendant? OPP.
Whether the plaintiff is estopped from filing the present suit by his own act and conduct? OPD.
Whether the suit is not properly valued for the purposes of court fee and jurisdiction? OPD.
Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties? OPD.
Whether the land in dispute was a joint Hindu family property and defendant was not competent to execute the alleged agreement to sell? OPD.
Whether the suit is time barred? OPD.
Relief.
It was found by the Trial Court that the agreement was duly executed between the parties and the plaintiff was ready and willing to perform his part of contract but the suit was dismissed in view of the finding recorded on issue No. 1-A.
In appeal also, the case of Jagir Singh and another v. Chanchal Singh died and represented by his legal heirs namely Jasjit Singh and others, 1984 S.L.J. (P&H) 471 is relied upon in which it was held that as per Rule 9 of the Government Servant Conduct Rules, 1955 (for short "1955 Rules"), no government servant shall directly or indirectly acquire any immovable property except with the previous sanction of the Government.
The lower Appellate Court dealt with Rule 18(2) of the Government Employees (Conduct) Rules, 1966 (for short "1966 Rules"), which provides that no government employee shall, except with the previous knowledge of the prescribed authority, acquire or dispose of any immovable property by lease, mortgage, purchase, sale, gift or otherwise either in his own name or in the name of any member of his family. It was admitted that sanction Ex.P11 was granted on 16.12.1991 but still it was held that it cannot validate the actions of the plaintiff, without seeking prior permission and it was held that the plaintiff is only entitled to the earnest money as well as damages but not the specific performance of the agreement by execution of sale deed.
Counsel for the appellant has referred to the statement of the plaintiff, who appeared as PW2, in which he has categorically stated that information about the agreement was provided to the relevant authority, therefore, it was already in the knowledge of the prescribed authority that the plaintiff was to acquire immovable property by way of purchase. It is further submitted that Rule 9 of the 1955 Rules, interpreted in Jagir Singh's case (supra), is not applicable because in that Rule, the word used is "previous sanction", whereas in Rule 18(2) of the 1966 Rules, the word is "previous knowledge" of the prescribed authority and since the 1966 Rules are in vogue, therefore, are applicable to him.
Counsel for the appellant has relied upon a judgment of this Court in the case of Tara Chand Vs. Parkash, in which, while referring to the judgment in Jagir Singh's case (supra), it has been held that in view of Rule 18(2) and 14.23 of 1966 Rules, no previous sanction is required as only prior intimation is to be given by the purchaser to the department. He has also relied upon another judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Vishwa Nath Sharma v. Shyam Shankar Goela and another, in which it has been held that the vendor can sell his property and execute sale deed even though sale was prohibited without prior sanction of authority, which can be obtained subsequently.
On the other hand, counsel for the respondent has submitted that in Rule 18(3) of the 1966 Rules, the provision talks of the deal through a regular or reputed dealer but since, in the present case, there is no evidence that the deal was through a regular or reputed dealer, therefore, previous sanction was required to be obtained. In this regard, it would be relevant to reproduce Rule 18(3) of the 1966 Rules, which reads as under:-
Where a Government employee enters into a transaction in respect of movable property either in his own name or in the name of a member of his family, he shall within one month from the date of such transaction, report the same to the prescribed authority, if the value of such property exceeds Rs. 10,000/-.
Provided that the previous sanction of the prescribed authority shall be obtained if any such transaction is
(1) with a person having official dealings with the Government employee; or
(2) otherwise than through a regular or reputed dealer.
It may be pertinent to mention that Rule 18(2) of the 1966 Rules deals with immovable property, whereas Rule 18(3) deals with the movable property. As per Rule 18(2), only requirement is that the government servant has to bring it to the notice of the prescribed authority of his intention to acquire immovable property by way of purchase etc. but as per Rule 18(3), previous sanction is required in respect of movable property and as the proviso is attached to Rule 18(3), it cannot be read with Rule 18(2). In view of the aforesaid discussion, the question of law framed in this appeal is hereby answered in favour of the appellant in affirmative and the appeal is thus allowed.
