High CourtsSingle Bench(2023) 11 KL CK 0055

Sajeev M.A vs Johnson

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 2 November 2023

HON’BLE JUDGES
C. Jayachandran, J
RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Original Petition (C) No. 2335 Of 2023

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

9 paragraphs · 718 words

C. Jayachandran, J

1.

The defendant in OS No.155/23 of the Munsiff Court, Kothamangalam is the petitioner herein. He is claiming under an agreement to conduct quarry operations in the property of the plaintiffs in the suit, who are the respondents herein. The plaintiffs would maintain that the agreement with the defendant (petitioner herein) has been terminated, wherefore, the plaintiffs have sought for an injunction restraining the defendant (petitioner herein) from trespassing into the plaint scheduled property, as also, from doing anything interfering with the possession of the plaintiffs.

2.

The interim injunction sought for by the plaintiffs had been granted by the learned Munsiff. The defendant, upon entering appearance, have filed an injunction application seeking to prevent the plaintiffs from obstructing the defendant in conducting quarrying operations in the plaint scheduled property on the strength of the agreement in question.

3.

The present urgency for this Original Petition is on account of an inspection of the property scheduled to be conducted by State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA) which is scheduled tomorrow, ie. 03.11.2023. Upon receipt of notice of this inspection, the petitioner moved the Munsiff Court by filing I.A No.9/23 apprehending obstruction on the part of the plaintiffs who are the respondents herein. The said application is pending and is not disposed of. Since the inspection is scheduled tomorrow, this Original Petition was filed before this Court invoking the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

4.

Heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as also the respondents. Perused the records.

5.

The prayer in this Original Petition was seriously opposed by the learned counsel for the respondents/plaintiffs. It was pointed out that inasmuch as the agreement in favour of the petitioner herein has been cancelled/terminated, the petitioner has no surviving rights over the plaint scheduled property and that therefore no useful purpose is to be served by conducting the inspection by SEIAA. Nor does the petitioner/defendant has a right to insist on such inspection being conducted, in the nature of the contentions urged by the plaintiffs in respect of the plaint scheduled property, of which the plaintiffs are the absolute owners undisputedly.

6.

Per contra, the learned counsel for the petitioner/defendant would submit that conduct of an inspection by SEIAA would not cause any prejudice or harm to the plaintiffs in the suit, as also, to their contentions. It was pointed out that the petitioner/defendant was pursuing the matter for long and after considerable efforts only, they got an appointment for inspection by the state agency, SEIAA. Once the opportunity is lost it will be very difficult to obtain another appointment for inspection of the property.

7.

Having heard the learned counsel appearing on both sides and in view of the urgency espoused on account of the fact that the inspection is scheduled tomorrow, this Court is of the opinion that the limited prayer of the petitioner/defendant to get the inspection done by SEIAA, without any obstruction from any quarters, can be considered favourably. The inspection by SEIAA is only a procedural/statutory requirement for issuance of licence to the petitioner/defendant for quarrying, whose application is pending before the competent authority under the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2015. The inspection by SEIAA would not and cannot impact in any manner the case and contentions put forward by the plaintiffs (respondents herein) in the subject suit. Clarifying the above aspect that the plaintiffs can not be put to any prejudice on account of such inspection by SEIAA and further clarifying that irrespective of the outcome of such inspection by SEIAA, the matter will be decided by the learned Munsiff on the relative merits of the parties based on the pleadings, there will be an order restraining the plaintiffs (respondents herein) from causing any obstruction to the inspection, which is scheduled to be conducted in the plaint schedule property tomorrow by SEIAA. Original Petition is disposed of with the above observations.

In view of the second prayer of the petitioner in this Original Petition, the learned Munsiff will take all pending Interlocutory Applications preferred by the petitioner herein (defendant) and will pass orders in accordance with law. It is also directed that if the suit is ripe for trial, the learned Munsiff will proceed with the matter by listing the suit for trial expeditiously.