AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Abdul Quddhose, J
This writ petition has been filed challenging the impugned relieving order dated 05.01.2022, issued by the respondent – Institute, relieving the petitioner from service, based on the alleged resignation letter said to have been submitted by the petitioner.
The grievance of the petitioner is that arbitrarily, the respondent issued the impugned relieving order relieving him from service. According to the petitioner, he was working as an Attender in the respondent – Institute and due to family circumstances, on account of depression, and due to the compulsion of the officials of the respondent – Institute, he was forced to submit a resignation letter on 05.01.2022. But, on the very same date, his resignation has been accepted by the respondent and the impugned relieving order dated 05.01.2022 came to be issued. According to the petitioner, immediately thereafter, on 06.01.2022, he has sent a letter to the respondent – Institute requesting them to cancel the impugned relieving order as he has withdrawn his resignation.
Learned counsel for the petitioner drew the attention of this Court to the Service Rules applicable to the respondent – Institute and would submit that as per Clause 18(1) of the Service Rules, an employee may resign his / her post by giving three months notice in writing to the Director. He would also submit that as per the Clause 18(3), the resignation of an employee shall not be accepted, if it has been withdrawn by him / her before the orders accepting the resignation are actually issued. Contrary to the same, the respondent has issued the impugned relieving order relieving the petitioner from service on the very same day of the petitioner's resignation and therefore, the impugned relieving order is arbitrary and illegal.
A counter affidavit has been filed by the respondent denying the contentions of the petitioner. In the counter affidavit, the respondent would submit as follows:
(a) Having tendered resignation and the respondent having issued the impugned relieving order, the question of withdrawing the resignation thereafter does not arise.
(b) The petitioner has tendered resignation only voluntarily in his own handwriting expressing his willingness to resign from the services of the respondent - Institute and requesting the respondent to accept the same forthwith. There was no coercion of the respondent on the petitioner to compel him to submit his resignation.
(c) The resignation or voluntary retirement once accepted by the Management / employer, the same cannot be withdrawn thereafter by the employee.
The following are the undisputed facts:
(a) The impugned relieving order relieving the petitioner from service was issued on the same date, when the petitioner tendered his resignation.
(b) The petitioner was working only as an Attender and he is having only 10th Standard qualification and he was not holding any senior position in the respondent – Institute.
(c) Under the Service Rules of the respondent – Institute, before an employee resigns from the services of the respondent – Institute, three months notice will have to be given. In the case on hand, three months notice was not given either by the petitioner or by the respondent (employer). The petitioner has sent a letter dated 06.01.2022 to the respondent – Institute stating that he is withdrawing his resignation. The impugned relieving order relieving the petitioner from the services of the respondent – Institute was issued on 05.01.2022 pursuant to the resignation letter submitted by the petitioner on the same date.
(d) The respondent – Institute also accepts that the petitioner had sent a letter to them stating that he is withdrawing his resignation. Though the petitioner contends that the said letter was sent on 06.01.2022, the respondent – Institute states that the same was received by them only on 10.01.2022.
The petitioner is a ministerial staff and is not a highly educated person and is not holding any senior position in the respondent – Institute to know the consequences of sending a letter to the respondent – Institute stating that he is resigning from the services of the respondent – Institute. In the letter placed on record by the respondent – Institute, which is said to have been sent by the petitioner on 05.01.2022, which is the resignation letter, the phrase “from that date” (தேதியில் இருந்து) has been struck off. The petitioner claims that he did not strike off the said phrase. But, it is only the respondent, who had struck off the said phrase to suit to their advantage. The letter alleged to have been sent by the petitioner on 05.01.2022 to the respondent – Institute, which, according to the respondent – Institute, is the resignation letter submitted by the petitioner, is reproduced hereunder:
“நான் கடந்த 10.10.2017 தேதியில் இருந்து
அட்டெண்டர் ஆக நமது நிறுவனத்தில் பணிபுரிந்து
வருகின்றேன். எனது குடும்ப சூழ்நிலையில் மற்றும தனிப்பட்ட காரணங்களினால் எனது வேலையை தொடர்ந்து
செய்ய முடியாத காரணத்தினால் எனது வேலையினை
தேதியில் இருந்து ராஜினாமா செய்ய விரும்புகிறேன்.
எனவே தையவு கூர்ந்து என்னை (05.01.2022) தேதியில்
இருந்து விடுவிக்கும்படி தாழ்மையுடன் கேட்டுக் கொள்கிறேன்.”
However, in the letter dated 05.01.2022 annexed in the typed set of documents filed by the petitioner before this Court, the phrase “from that date” (Njjpapy; ,Ue;J)has not been struck off and the same is also re-produced hereunder:
“அம்மா நான் இந்நிறுவனத்தில் 10.10.2017 முதல்
நிரந்தர பணியாளராக பணியாற்றி வருகிறேன். எனது குடும்ப
சூழ்நிலை காரணமாக எனது பணியை (05.01.2022) முதல்
ராஜினாமா செய்கிறேன்.”
In the case on hand, it is not a case where the employee after a long period has withdrawn his resignation. The respondent also does not dispute the fact that the petitioner had withdrawn his resignation, though the date of receipt of the said letter sent by the petitioner seeking withdrawal of his resignation is disputed by the respondent. The petitioner claims that immediately on the very next day after submitting his resignation i.e., on 06.01.2022, the petitioner had withdrawn his resignation. However, the respondent states that though the letter is dated 06.01.2022, the same was received by them only on 10.01.2022. Assuming the date of receipt of the letter by the respondent is only on 10.01.2022, even the said date will not amount to an inordinate delay on the part of the petitioner to seek for withdrawal of his resignation, as he admittedly submitted his resignation letter only on 05.01.2022. Immediately, on the date of the resignation letter, without following the Rules applicable to the respondent – Institute, the respondent has issued the impugned relieving order also dated 05.01.2022 relieving the petitioner from service of the respondent – Institute. The petitioner has been working in the respondent – University from 2017 onwards as a permanent employee.
This Court, after giving due consideration to the aforementioned undisputed facts, is of the considered view that the impugned relieving order dated 05.01.2022 is arbitrary and illegal and in violation of the Service Rules applicable to the respondent – University. Being an Attender and being a ministerial staff, the respondent ought to have been more careful even if there was a misconduct committed by the petitioner while being employed as an Attender in the respondent – Institute.
In the counter affidavit filed before this Court, the respondent has stated that the petitioner was having some extra-marital affairs with another temporary lady faculty of the respondent – University in the office campus. However, the said reason is not found in the impugned relieving order. Only for the first time, through the counter affidavit filed by the respondent before this Court, the said allegation has been levelled against the petitioner, which is also denied by the petitioner as seen from the submissions made by the learned counsel of the petitioner. If the petitioner had committed any misconduct, the respondent – Institute can only proceed against the petitioner through disciplinary proceedings. But, without holding any enquiry and without initiating any disciplinary proceedings, based on the petitioner's letter dated 05.01.2022, the respondent ought not to have issued the impugned relieving order on the very same date, without following the procedure contemplated under the Service Rules of the respondent – Institute. Since the Service Rules of the respondent – Institute are not followed and the impugned relieving order has been passed on the very same date of the resignation letter submitted by the petitioner, which has been subsequently withdrawn by the petitioner on 06.01.2022, though the respondent may contend that the said letter was received by them only on 10.01.2022, this Court is of the considered view that the impugned relieving order issued by the respondent is arbitrary and illegal and has to be quashed.
Accordingly, this writ petition is allowed and the impugned relieving order dated 05.01.2022, issued by the respondent, is hereby quashed and the respondent is directed to reinstate the petitioner into service with all attended monetary benefits with continuity of service, within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. Liberty is also granted to the respondent - Institute, in case if the petitioner has committed any misconduct, to initiate disciplinary proceedings against him. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
