AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard Shri Amit Kumar Rai, learned Amicus Curiae appearing on behalf of the appellant and Shri Shyam Narayan Rai, learned AGA for the State.
The present criminal appeal has been preferred by the appellant Rohtash against the judgment and order dated 10.11.1986 passed by the 5th Additional District and Sessions Judge, Moradabad, in Sessions Trial No. 725 of 1985 (State v. Rohtash), arising out of Case Crime No.179 of 1985, Police Station-Hasanpur, District- Moradabad, whereby the appellant has been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 396 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of ten years along with a fine of Rs.5,000/-, with a further direction to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year in default of payment of fine.
The prosecution case, in brief, is that in the intervening night of 21/22.06.1985, at about 1:45 A.M., the complainant Abdul Ali (P.W.-1), his father Sana Ulla, his brother Mahmood Ali and other members of the family were sleeping on the roof of their house situated at Mohalla Kayasthan, Town Hasanpur, District Moradabad. At the aforesaid time, they woke up on hearing the barking of dogs and noticed that approximately six or seven dacoits had entered their roof from the adjoining roof of Fazal Mohammad. The dacoits were allegedly armed with firearms.
According to the prosecution, when Sana Ulla, father of the complainant, got up from his cot, one of the dacoits fired a shot at him, as a result of which he sustained firearm injuries and fell down. Other members of the family also sustained injuries during the occurrence. The dacoits allegedly entered the house, threatened the inmates and started looting the property. On hearing the commotion and firing, certain persons of the locality, including Shamsuddin (P.W.-3), Dal Chand and others, reached near the place of occurrence. The villagers also raised an alarm and threw bricks towards the dacoits. Meanwhile, an announcement regarding the occurrence was made through the loudspeaker installed at the nearby mosque. On hearing the announcement, the dacoits fled away before the police party could reach the spot.
It is further alleged that Mahmood Ali, who had also sustained injuries during the occurrence, was being taken to the hospital by his family members, but he succumbed to his injuries on the way. Thus, two persons, namely Sana Ulla and Mahmood Ali, lost their lives in the incident. The injured witnesses were subsequently medically examined.
The complainant Abdul Ali lodged the written report at Police Station Hasanpur during the same night, at about 2:15 A.M. on 22.06.1985. On the basis of the said report, a criminal case was registered and its investigation was entrusted to Sri Sriniwas Chaturvedi (P.W.-12). The initial report was against six or seven unknown miscreants. The prosecution further alleged that there was electric lighting in the house and a burning bulb at the mosque, in the light of which the complainant and other witnesses had an opportunity to see the faces of the dacoits. It was also stated that the accused persons were not previously known to the complainant and the witnesses, but they could identify them if produced before them.
During investigation, the Investigating Officer visited the place of occurrence and prepared the site plan. The inquest proceedings in respect of the deceased Sana Ulla were conducted by Sub-Inspector Sanwal Singh (P.W.-11), and the relevant inquest papers and other documents were prepared. The dead bodies of Sana Ulla and Mahmood Ali were thereafter sent for post-mortem examination. Dr. R.A. Gupta, Medical Officer, District Hospital, Moradabad, conducted the post-mortem examinations and prepared the corresponding reports. The Investigating Officer also collected simple and blood-stained earth from the roof of the complainant’s house and prepared the relevant recovery memo.
During inspection of the place of occurrence, three empty cartridges were allegedly found on the roof of the complainant’s house, one behind the house and two in the adjoining field. The Investigating Officer prepared the relevant recovery memo and sealed the cartridges. He also recovered approximately thirty pellets from the place of occurrence and prepared the necessary recovery documents. The injury reports of the injured witnesses Dal Chand and Maqsood, who had been medically examined at P.H.C., Hasanpur, were also collected. The injuries recorded in the medical examination of Dal Chand were simple in nature and were attributed to friction against a rough surface, whereas the injury sustained by Maqsood was also described as simple in nature.
The prosecution further alleged that on 26.06.1985, Sub-Inspector D.K. Khan, accompanied by Constable Sohan Singh (P.W.-10) of Police Station Bachhraun, was on patrol duty. When they reached near village Belkheda, they noticed the accused-appellant and suspected him to be involved in the crime. The appellant was arrested and, upon his personal search, an allegedly country-made pistol was recovered from his possession. It was further alleged that the appellant confessed his involvement in the dacoity committed at Hasanpur. He was thereafter kept ba-parda at the police station and subsequently produced before the Magistrate.
The Investigating Officer moved an application before the Executive Magistrate for conducting an identification parade. Accordingly, an identification parade of the accused-appellant Rohtash was conducted by Sri M.A. Khan, Executive Magistrate, Moradabad, in District Jail, Moradabad, on 25.07.1985. As recorded in the trial court judgment, witnesses Maqsood, Mohammad Zafar, Kurban and Shamsuddin correctly identified the appellant during the identification proceedings. After completing the investigation, the Investigating Officer submitted a charge-sheet against the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 396 IPC.
The case was committed to the Court of Sessions and the accused-appellant was charged with the offence punishable under Section 396 IPC. The appellant denied the charge and claimed to be tried.
In order to establish its case, the prosecution examined the complainant Abdul Ali (P.W.-1), other witnesses of the occurrence, police personnel associated with the investigation and the Investigating Officer Sriniwas Chaturvedi (P.W.-12). The prosecution also relied upon documentary evidence, including the written report, chik FIR, general diary entry, inquest reports, post-mortem reports, injury reports, site plan, recovery memos, identification memo and charge-sheet etc.
After conclusion of the prosecution evidence, the statement of the accused-appellant was recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., wherein he denied the prosecution allegations and claimed to be innocent.
The grounds of the appeal, in brief, are that the impugned judgment and order of conviction and sentence passed against the appellant is against the weight of evidence on record, suffers from manifest illegality and is bad in the eyes of law. The sentence awarded to the appellant is also too severe and excessive.
Learned Amicus Curiae appearing on behalf of the appellant submits that the appellant was not named in the FIR and was admittedly unknown to the complainant and other witnesses. The alleged incident took place during the night, but the prosecution failed to establish the existence and adequacy of the sources of light at the place of occurrence, as neither the alleged torch was recovered nor the electric pole was shown in the site plan. The test identification parade, which was conducted after more than one month of the incident, cannot by itself form the basis of conviction, particularly when the identification of the appellant before the Court is also doubtful. It is further submitted that no looted article was recovered from the possession or at the instance of the appellant and the alleged recovery of a country-made pistol has not been connected with the crime through any ballistic or forensic evidence. The arrest and recovery are also doubtful in the absence of any independent public witness. Thus, the prosecution has failed to establish the identity and participation of the appellant in the alleged dacoity beyond reasonable doubt, and he is entitled to acquittal. Learned Amicus Curiae places reliance upon Wakil Singh and others v. State of Bihar, AIR 1981 SC 1392; Govind v. State of U.P., 1995 LawSuit (All) 142; State of U.P. v. Ram Saroop and Hokar, 1997 LawSuit (All) 660; and Kaushal Kishore son of Gobardhan v. State of U.P., 2005 LawSuit (All) 295, wherein it has been held that identification of accused persons who were previously unknown to the witnesses requires careful scrutiny. The test identification parade is only corroborative in nature, and its reliability depends upon the opportunity of identification, promptness of proceedings and observance of prescribed safeguards. In the absence of reliable identification and corroborative evidence connecting the accused with the crime, conviction cannot safely be sustained.
Per contra, learned AGA appearing for the State opposes the appeal and submits that the prosecution has successfully established the occurrence of dacoity in which two persons lost their lives and other persons sustained injuries. The complainant and other witnesses have supported the prosecution version and have identified the appellant during the test identification parade as well as before the trial court. Their presence at and around the place of occurrence is natural and their testimony cannot be discarded merely on account of minor discrepancies. It is further submitted that the appellant was arrested during investigation and a country-made pistol was recovered from his possession. The trial court, after proper appreciation of the evidence on record, has rightly convicted the appellant under Section 396 IPC, and no interference with the impugned judgment is warranted.
Before proceeding to examine the evidence relating to identification, it would be appropriate to notice that the initial prosecution case was against six or seven unknown miscreants. The appellant was not named in the FIR and his identity was subsequently sought to be established during investigation, principally through the alleged test identification parade and the circumstances of his arrest and recovery.
So far as the alleged confessional statement of the appellant before the police is concerned, it is settled that a confession made to a police officer is inadmissible in evidence in view of Sections 25 and 26 of the Indian Evidence Act, except to the limited extent permitted under Section 27 thereof. The prosecution has alleged that the appellant disclosed the involvement of certain other persons, namely Hari Om, Noori, Vijay Gurjar, Makhan, Gujar, Tirath Jatav, Munshi and some others in the alleged dacoity. However, mere disclosure of the names of such persons during police interrogation cannot be treated as substantive evidence of their participation in the crime. In the absence of any legally admissible discovery pursuant to such statement, the alleged confession cannot independently furnish the foundation for recording conviction against the appellant.
Another significant circumstance is that no looted property or article allegedly belonging to the complainant or the deceased persons was recovered from the possession or at the instance of the appellant. There is no recovery of stolen jewellery, cash, household articles or any other property allegedly taken away during the dacoity. Although absence of recovery of looted property may not, by itself, be sufficient to discard an otherwise trustworthy prosecution case, in the present case it assumes significance while examining the cumulative circumstances relied upon by the prosecution to establish the appellant’s participation.
The prosecution version regarding the arrest of the appellant is that he was apprehended by police personnel while they were on patrol duty near village Belkheda on 26.06.1985. The alleged arrest and personal search were conducted at a public place. However, no independent witness from the locality or any other person available near the place of arrest was associated with the proceedings. The prosecution has also not offered any convincing explanation as to why no independent witness was procured to attest the alleged recovery memo.
It is true that merely because the witnesses to arrest and recovery are police personnel, their testimony cannot be discarded solely on that ground. Nevertheless, where the alleged arrest and recovery constitute an important link in the chain of circumstances relied upon by the prosecution, the Court is required to scrutinise such evidence with due care and caution. In the present case, the absence of independent corroboration, coupled with the non-recovery of any looted property or article connecting the appellant with the occurrence, requires careful examination of the reliability and evidentiary value of the police version.
So far as the alleged recovery of a country-made pistol from the personal possession of the appellant is concerned, the mere recovery of a firearm, even if accepted, does not automatically establish that the said weapon was used in the commission of the particular dacoity or that the person possessing it was one of the participants in the occurrence. The prosecution has not brought on record any reliable forensic or ballistic evidence connecting the recovered firearm with the empty cartridges allegedly collected from the place of occurrence. Nor is there any reliable evidence demonstrating that the recovered firearm was used for causing the fatal firearm injuries sustained by the deceased persons.
It is further noticeable that no satisfactory material has been brought on record to establish whether a separate criminal case under the Arms Act was registered against the appellant in respect of the alleged recovery, whether any charge-sheet was submitted in that regard or whether any trial was initiated against him. Although registration or pendency of a separate Arms Act case is not an essential ingredient for determining liability under Section 396 IPC, the alleged recovery, in the absence of any established connection with the present occurrence, cannot independently establish the appellant’s participation in the dacoity accompanied by murder.
Upon careful examination of the prosecution evidence, it transpires that the entire prosecution case, so far as the identity and participation of the appellant Rohtash is concerned, substantially rests upon the test identification parade (T.I.P.) conducted during investigation. Admittedly, the FIR was lodged against six or seven unknown miscreants and the appellant was not previously known to the complainant or any of the alleged eyewitnesses. The alleged occurrence took place during the intervening night of 21/22.06.1985 at about 1:45 A.M. The prosecution sought to establish the identity of the appellant principally through the identification parade conducted in District Jail, Moradabad, on 25.07.1985, in which P.W.-2 Maqsood Ahmad, P.W.-3 Shamsuddin and P.W.-4 Kurban Ahmad are stated to have identified him.
It is noteworthy that the aforesaid witnesses, in their depositions before the trial court, claimed that they had seen the dacoits, including the appellant, in the light of a torch as well as an electric bulb situated near the place of occurrence. According to the prosecution, the availability of such light enabled the witnesses to observe the faces of the miscreants. However, the existence, location and adequacy of the alleged sources of light assume considerable significance, particularly when the occurrence took place at an odd hour of the night and the appellant was admittedly a stranger to the witnesses.
The prosecution has not produced any recovery memo relating to the alleged torch said to have been used by the witnesses for identifying the miscreants during the occurrence. More significantly, the Investigating Officer, P.W.-12 Sri Sriniwas Chaturvedi, admitted in his deposition that he had neither prepared any memo regarding the existence of an electric pole or electric bulb at the relevant place nor shown the alleged source of electric illumination in the site plan, Exhibit Ka-18. Thus, the alleged availability of sufficient light at the place of occurrence, which constitutes a material circumstance for establishing the identity of the unknown assailants, has not been satisfactorily established through investigation.
The Investigating Officer was expected to ascertain and properly indicate the relevant sources of light in the site plan, particularly when the prosecution case itself depended substantially upon the ability of the witnesses to recognise unknown miscreants during night hours. The omission to investigate and establish this material circumstance assumes importance and creates reasonable doubt regarding the opportunity available to the witnesses to observe the facial features of the appellant.
It is also difficult to accept the identification of a particular accused during night hours merely on the basis of a general assertion regarding availability of light, unless the prosecution establishes the nature, location and adequacy of such illumination. The prosecution has not brought on record any satisfactory explanation regarding the duration of observation, distance from which the appellant was allegedly seen, intensity of illumination and particular circumstances under which the witnesses could recognise his face. These factors assume greater significance because the witnesses were not previously acquainted with the appellant.
It is a settled principle of criminal jurisprudence that a test identification parade is not substantive evidence. Its primary object is to test the memory and capacity of a witness to identify a person whom he had allegedly seen at the time of occurrence but was not previously acquainted with. Identification made during the test identification parade is only corroborative in nature and its evidentiary value depends upon the reliability of the identification made by the witness before the Court. Therefore, the mere fact that the appellant was identified during the test identification parade cannot, by itself, be treated as conclusive proof of his participation in the alleged offence.
It is also necessary that the test identification parade should be conducted in a fair and proper manner, ensuring that the accused is mixed with persons having reasonably similar physical features, including height, age, complexion and body structure, so that the witnesses are not afforded any opportunity to identify the accused merely on account of his distinguishable appearance. The purpose of such precautions is to eliminate the possibility of suggestion, unfair advantage or mistaken identification. The mere preparation of an identification memo cannot dispense with the requirement of establishing the fairness and reliability of the identification proceedings.
In Uttar Pradesh, the procedure for a Test Identification Parade (TIP) conducted in jail is governed principally by Paragraph 116 of the U.P. Police Regulations and Paragraph 416 of the U.P. Jail Manual, 2022 dealing with undertrial prisoners who are to be identified by witnesses. The object of a TIP is not to constitute substantive evidence, but to test the memory and veracity of a witness who claims to have seen an unknown offender. The substantive evidence is the witness’s identification of the accused during trial before the Court. Step-by-step procedure regarding identification parade are:
“(a)When the accused is sent to judicial custody, the Investigating Officer moves an application before the Magistrate requesting a Test Identification Parade.
(b)Normally, the parade should be held inside the jail, not at the police station.
(c)The Superintendent of Police or an officer not below the rank of Inspector informs the Jail Superintendent in writing that the prisoner is to be put up for identification. This information should be given at the time of admission or as soon thereafter as possible.
(d)After receiving such intimation, the Jail Superintendent must ensure that: the accused does not shave or grow a beard contrary to his appearance at arrest; hair style and moustache remain unchanged; no disguise is permitted; the accused wears the same or similar type of clothing as at the time of arrest.
(e)The Investigating Officer must ensure from the beginning of the investigation that: witnesses do not see the accused before the parade; police avoid showing the accused to witnesses; unnecessary production before witnesses is avoided. This is one of the most important safeguards because prior exposure substantially weakens the evidentiary value of the TIP.
(f)The TIP should ordinarily be conducted by a Judicial Magistrate. Police officers should not participate in the actual proceedings. A jail officer remains present only to comply with directions of the Magistrate.
(g)The accused is mixed with several persons of similar: age, height, complexion, build, dress, general appearance. The object is to ensure fairness and eliminate suggestive identification. Prisoners who themselves have to be identified in other cases should not be used as dummies.
(h)Each witness is brought individually. Witnesses are kept separate. They are not permitted to communicate with each other. Each witness identifies independently.
(i)Normally, after each witness: the accused is allowed to change his position in the line; the Magistrate records whether such change was requested or made. This prevents identification merely by remembering the position.
(j)The Magistrate records: names of persons mixed with the accused; objections raised by the accused; whether position was changed; exact words and conduct of each witness. whether identification was immediate, hesitant or mistaken. The proceedings are signed by the Magistrate.
(k)The U.P. Jail Manual provides that before the proceedings begin, the prosecuting inspector and the defence counsel (if present) may satisfy themselves that the prescribed safeguards have been observed. However, they do not participate in the actual identification process, which remains under the exclusive control of the Magistrate. In this case at hand, the test identification parade has not been conducted properly as per existing rule and procedure, thus the accused persons are liable to provide the benefit of the material omissions and procedural lapses committed by the prosecution in this regard.”
In Malkhansingh vs. State of M.P., (2003) 5 SCC 746, Hon’ble Supreme Court held in paras 7 and 16 as under:-
“7.It is trite to say that the substantive evidence is the evidence of identification in court. Apart from the clear provisions of Section 9 of the Evidence Act, the position in law is well settled by a catena of decisions of this Court. The facts, which establish the identity of the accused persons, are relevant under Section 9 of the Evidence Act. As a general rule, the substantive evidence of a witness is the statement made in court. The evidence of mere identification of the accused person at the trial for the first time is from its very nature inherently of a weak character. The purpose of a prior test identification, therefore, is to test and strengthen the trustworthiness of that evidence. It is accordingly considered a safe rule of prudence to generally look for corroboration of the sworn testimony of witnesses in court as to the identity of the accused who are strangers to them, in the form of earlier identification proceedings. This rule of prudence, however, is subject to exceptions, when, for example, the court is impressed by a particular witness on whose testimony it can safely rely, without such or other corroboration. The identification parades belong to the stage of investigation, and there is no provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure which obliges the investigating agency to hold, or confers a right upon the accused to claim a test identification parade. They do not constitute substantive evidence and these parades are essentially governed by Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Failure to hold a test identification parade would not make inadmissible the evidence of identification in court. The weight to be attached to such identification should be a matter for the courts of fact. In appropriate cases it may accept the evidence of identification even without insisting on corroboration.
16.It is well settled that the substantive evidence is the evidence of identification in court and the test identification parade provides corroboration to the identification of the witness in court, if required. However, what weight must be attached to the evidence of identification in court, which is not preceded by a test identification parade, is a matter for the courts of fact to examine.…………..”
Further in State of H.P. vs. Lekh Raj, (2000) 1 SCC 247, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para 3 as under:
“3…...During the investigation of a crime the police agency is required to hold identification parade for the purposes of enabling the witness to identify the person alleged to have committed the offence particularly when such person was not previously known to the witness or the informant. The absence of test identification may not be fatal if the accused is known or sufficiently described in the complaint leaving no doubt in the mind of the court regarding his involvement. Identification parade may also not be necessary in a case where the accused persons are arrested at the spot. The evidence of identifying the accused person at the trial for the first time is, from its very nature, inherently of a weak character. This Court in Budhsen v. State of U.P. [(1970) 2 SCC 128 : 1970 SCC (Cri) 343] held that the evidence in order to carry conviction should ordinarily clarify as to how and under what circumstances the complainant or the witness came to pick out the particular accused person and the details of the part which he allegedly played in the crime in question with reasonable particularity. In such cases test identification is considered a safe rule of prudence to generally look for corroboration of the sworn testimony of witnesses in court as to the identity of the accused who are strangers to them.” (emphasis added)
The settled law of the Supreme Court in Budhsen (supra), Malkhansingh (supra) and Lekh Raj (supra) is that TIP is only corroborative evidence under Section 9 of the Evidence Act. Failure to hold TIP is not invariably fatal, especially where the accused was previously known to the witness. Where the accused was unknown and is identified for the first time in court without an earlier TIP, such dock identification is generally considered weak unless supported by other evidence. In the present case, TIP has not been conducted as per the prescribed guidelines as discussed above.
Upon careful scrutiny of the testimony of P.W.-1 Abdul Ali, the informant, certain material inconsistencies emerge which cannot be overlooked. In his examination-in-chief, P.W.-1 stated that he had furnished the list of looted articles on 22.06.1985 and proved the same as Exhibit Ka-2. However, Exhibit Ka-2 is, in fact, a copy of Nakal Rapat No.20, recorded at 14:30 hours on 26.06.1985. Thus, there is an apparent discrepancy regarding the date and nature of the document sought to be relied upon by the prosecution.
Furthermore, in his cross-examination, P.W.-1 stated that all the accused persons, except one, had entered the house for committing the loot and that he had identified them in the light of an electric pole. However, he subsequently admitted that he had seen the accused persons from their backside while they were running towards the western direction. This admission assumes significance because the opportunity to observe the faces of the fleeing miscreants appears to have been considerably limited. The aforesaid circumstances create uncertainty regarding the reliability of his identification of the appellant.
The testimony of P.W.-2 Maqsood Ahmad also requires careful examination. He stated that he had identified the accused persons in the light of an electric pole and a torch, although he was not previously acquainted with any of them. In his cross-examination, he further admitted that the witnesses came after the departure of the dacoits. He also stated that he had participated in the test identification parade in jail after approximately two months of the incident. However, the identification memo, Exhibit Ka-29, indicates that the test identification parade was actually conducted on 25.07.1985, i.e., approximately one month after the incident. This discrepancy regarding the time of identification, coupled with the fact that P.W.-2 had no previous acquaintance with the appellant, assumes importance in assessing the evidentiary value of the identification proceedings.
P.W.-3, Shamsuddin and P.W.-4, Kurban Ahmad, who are stated to be neighbours of the informant, have also supported the prosecution case regarding the occurrence. According to them, the incident took place inside the informant’s house, where all the accused persons, except one, were allegedly engaged in committing the loot. Both witnesses claimed to have been present on the road near the place of occurrence and to have identified the accused persons in the light of a torch and an electric pole.
However, the prosecution has failed to establish through cogent and reliable evidence the actual availability and adequacy of the alleged sources of light. No torch allegedly used by these witnesses was produced or proved before the trial court, nor was any recovery memo prepared in respect thereof. Equally significant is the fact that the alleged electric pole, projected as an important source of illumination, has not been shown in the site plan. In the absence of satisfactory evidence regarding the existence, location and intensity of the alleged sources of light, the claim of the witnesses that they could identify unfamiliar persons during the occurrence becomes doubtful. These omissions assume greater significance when the identity of the appellant substantially rests upon such identification.
In Iqbal and another vs. State of U.P., (2015) 6 SCC 623, the Apex Court held in paras 14, 15 and 17 as under:
“14.Even though the complainant PW 1 and other witnesses have denied the defence plea, in the light of the fact that the incident occurred in the pitch of darkness, the identification of the appellants by the witnesses has to be viewed with caution and the Court is to look for corroboration strengthening the identification.
15.The evidence of identification of the miscreants in the test identification parade is not a substantive evidence. Conviction cannot be based solely on the identity of the dacoits by the witnesses in the test identification parade. The prosecution has to adduce substantive evidence by establishing incriminating evidence connecting the accused with the crime, like recovery of articles which are the subject-matter of dacoity and the alleged weapons used in the commission of the offence.
17.In order to bring home the guilt of the accused persons, it is the duty of the prosecution to prove that the stolen property was in the possession of the accused persons or that the accused had knowledge that the property was a stolen property or the accused persons had converted the stolen property. No such recovery was made to connect the appellants and other non-appealing accused persons with the crime.”
Thus, while examining the reliability of identification evidence and the circumstances in which witnesses claim to have recognised unknown assailants. The identification evidence must be assessed in the light of the actual opportunity available to the witnesses to see and recognise the accused.
In the present case, the alleged incident is stated to have taken place at about 1:30 A.M., during the night, when there was darkness, thereby making the identification of the assailants by the witnesses a matter requiring careful scrutiny. In such circumstances, the identification of the appellant by the witnesses, even if supported by the test identification parade, cannot be treated as sufficient by itself to establish his involvement in the crime, particularly when the identification in the test identification parade is not substantive evidence. The prosecution has failed to produce any reliable independent or corroborative evidence connecting the appellant with the alleged offence. No looted articles or any other incriminating material allegedly connected with the commission of the offence were recovered from the possession of the appellant. Thus, in the absence of any reliable substantive evidence corroborating the identification made during the test identification parade, the prosecution case against the appellant does not inspire confidence, and the possibility of mistaken identification, particularly in view of the darkness prevailing at the time of the incident, cannot be ruled out.
Another circumstance which creates doubt regarding the prosecution version is that, although six or seven persons allegedly participated in the dacoity, only one accused-appellant, namely Rohtash, could ultimately be identified and brought to trial, whereas the remaining alleged participants were neither arrested nor charge-sheeted. Admittedly, the identifying witnesses were not previously acquainted with the accused persons. In such circumstances, the prosecution was required to establish through convincing evidence the circumstances in which the witnesses could distinguish and identify the appellant amongst several unknown persons during the occurrence.
The incident allegedly took place inside the house, whereas the witnesses claim to have identified the miscreants from the road in the light of an electric pole and torches, the existence and adequacy of which have not been satisfactorily established. The test identification parade was also conducted approximately more than one month after the incident. When these circumstances are considered cumulatively, the possibility of mistaken identification cannot safely be excluded.
It is further noticeable that, apart from the evidence relating to the test identification parade, the prosecution has not produced any independent and reliable connecting evidence against the appellant. No looted article has been recovered from his possession or at his instance. The alleged recovery of a country-made pistol has also not been connected with the commission of the present offence through any reliable forensic or ballistic evidence. No independent public witness to the alleged arrest and recovery has been examined to lend assurance to the prosecution version. Thus, no satisfactory independent documentary or circumstantial reliable evidence connecting the appellant with the alleged looted property or commission of dacoity has been collected and duly proved before the trial court.
It is well settled that absence of recovery, by itself, may not be sufficient to discard otherwise trustworthy ocular evidence. However, where the very identity of the accused is doubtful, the absence of any independent corroborative circumstance assumes considerable significance. The prosecution cannot seek to establish the identity of the appellant merely through doubtful identification evidence, particularly when no other reliable circumstance connects him with the alleged occurrence.
There is no dispute regarding the gravity of the occurrence in question. The prosecution evidence establishes that two persons lost their lives and certain other persons sustained injuries during the alleged dacoity. The unfortunate loss of human lives and the injuries sustained by the victims undoubtedly establish the seriousness of the occurrence. However, the seriousness of the crime cannot dispense with the fundamental requirement of proving the identity and participation of each accused through legally admissible and reliable evidence. The fact that murders were committed during the occurrence does not, by itself, establish that the appellant Rohtash was one of the participants in the dacoity.
The liability of an accused under Section 396 IPC arises when five or more persons conjointly commit dacoity and murder is committed in the course of such dacoity. Therefore, before fastening criminal liability upon the appellant under the aforesaid provision, the prosecution was required to establish beyond reasonable doubt that he was one of the persons conjointly committing the dacoity in which the murders were committed. The commission of murder during the alleged occurrence and the participation of the appellant therein are two distinct aspects requiring independent appreciation of evidence. The former cannot automatically establish the latter.
Upon an overall appreciation of the prosecution evidence, this Court finds that the prosecution has failed to establish the identity of accused-appellant Rohtash through wholly reliable and convincing evidence. The material discrepancies in the testimonies of P.W.-1 to P.W.-4, the uncertainty regarding the sources of light, the admitted unfamiliarity of the identifying witnesses with the appellant, the delay in conducting the test identification parade and the absence of recovery of looted articles or other independent connecting evidence cumulatively create ‘reasonable doubt’ regarding his participation in the alleged dacoity.
It is true that a test identification parade is ordinarily intended to lend assurance to the substantive evidence of identification given before the Court and is not substantive evidence by itself. However, where the substantive identification evidence is itself rendered doubtful by the surrounding circumstances, the test identification parade cannot independently cure such deficiencies. The prosecution has also failed to establish any other reliable circumstance connecting the appellant with the commission of the alleged offence beyond reasonable doubt.
In the facts and circumstances of the present case, this Court is of the considered view that the prosecution has failed to discharge its burden of proving the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt. The benefit of doubt must, therefore, go to the appellant. Consequently, the conviction of the appellant under Section 396 IPC cannot be sustained.
In view of the foregoing discussion and findings recorded hereinabove, this criminal appeal deserves to be allowed and is accordingly allowed.
The impugned judgment and order dated 10.11.1986 passed by the 5th Additional District and Sessions Judge, Moradabad, in Sessions Trial No. 725 of 1985 (State v. Rohtash), convicting and sentencing the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 396 IPC, is hereby set aside.
The appellant Rohtash is acquitted of the charge levelled against him by extending the benefit of doubt.
It is brought to the notice of this Court that the appellant Rohtash is presently in judicial custody in compliance with the non-bailable warrant issued against him. Accordingly, it is directed that he shall be released from custody forthwith, if not wanted in connection with any other criminal case.
The appellant shall stand discharged from the liability of his bail bonds and sureties, if any, furnished by him, and the same shall stand cancelled, if not already cancelled.
Let a copy of this judgment be transmitted within a week to the trial court concerned along with trial court record for compliance.
The Registrar (Compliance) is also directed to send a copy of this order by FAX/e-mail to the concerned court through District & Sessions Judge concerned within 48 hours for information and necessary compliance.
Let Shri Amit Kumar Rai, learned Amicus Curiae, be paid her remuneration as fixed by this Court vide order dated 27.05.2026, within a period of two weeks from today.
