High CourtsSingle Bench(2011) 02 DEL CK 0234

Rohtash vs State

Delhi High Court · Decided on 15 February 2011 · Citation: (2011) 3 AD 73 : (2011) 2 ILR Delhi 679 : (2011) 1 JCC 526

HON’BLE JUDGES
Mukta Gupta, J
RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
Criminal A. 359 of 1999

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

9 paragraphs · 1,417 words

Mukta Gupta, J.—By the present appeal the Appellant challenged his conviction for offence punishable u/s 307 IPC and sentence of Rigorous Imprisonment for a period of five years and a fine of `5,000/- and in default of payment of fine to further undergo Simple Imprisonment for five months.

2.

Briefly the prosecution case is that one Samay Singh admitted in the Safdarjang Hospital gave the statement that he has two brothers of which one Ram Kishan lives with his father and he along with the other brother Rohtas lives in Jhuggi at Mehram Nagar. Rohtas, the Appellant wanted to get the Jhuggi vacated from him and thus, used to quarrel a number of times. At about 2.30 a.m. when Samay Singh was sleeping in his Jhuggi his brother Rohtas poured kerosene oil over him. He woke up and asked his brother as to what he was doing on which Rohtas said that today he would die and set him ablaze by lighting a match stick. On his raising an alarm some tenants came and extinguished the fire. Samay Singh/Complainant then went to PS Palam Airport and lodged a report from where he was removed to Safdarjung Hospital by the police. On the statement of the Complainant case FIR No. 95/1996 u/s 307 IPC was registered at PS Delhi Cantt. After completion of investigation a charge sheet was filed. After recording the prosecution evidence and statement of the Appellant, he was convicted as above.

3.

Learned Counsel for the Appellant challenging the conviction contends that the statement of PW1 Samay Singh, the complainant suffers from contradictions. After putting himself on fire and extinguishing the same the Complainant/Samay Singh went on his own to the police station and the said information given by him was recorded as DD No. 6 vide Ex.PW4/A. In the said statement the complainant/Samay Singh has attributed no reason for setting him ablaze by his brother Rohtas. As per the said statement the complainant only came to know when his body started burning. Though he stated that the neighbours extinguished the fire, nobody from the neighbourhood was examined except PW2 Mithlesh Kumar who turned hostile and has not supported the prosecution case. The doctor Mahesh Vyas PW6 in his testimony has stated that the injury on the Complainant could be self inflicted. Thus, in view of the contradictions in the statement of the complainant before the Court and his initial statement, the Appellant is entitled to be acquitted by giving him the benefit of doubt.

4.

Learned APP for the State on the other hand contends that the incident took place around 2.30 a.m. at night. PW1 Samay Singh in his statement has clearly stated that while he was sleeping the Appellant poured kerosene oil over him. Even as per the suggestion given on behalf of the Appellant his presence on the spot is proved. In the MLC the Appellant has been named. The material witnesses have not been cross-examined and thus, by the testimony of PW1 duly corroborated by the testimony of PW6 the doctor, it has been proved beyond reasonable doubt that the Appellant committed the offence punishable u/s 307 IPC.

5.

I have heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the record. The prosecution case is based on the sole testimony of PW1 Samay Singh. He has stated in his testimony that about 2.00-2.30 a.m. while he was sleeping the Appellant poured kerosene oil upon him and set him ablaze. PW1 Samay Singh had two Jhuggis and the Appellant had put him on fire because he was not agreeing to give him one Jhuggi. After he was put on fire he became unconscious and on regaining conscious he went to the police station and thereafter he was shifted to the hospital by the police officials. He remained in the hospital for about 20-22 days and he has exhibited his complaint Ex.PW1/A made by him to the police on 22nd February, 1996. PW1 in his cross-examination has been confronted with his earlier statements and it is also suggested to him that at that day he was over drunk and made nuisance which was resented by the neighbours and it is under the influence of liquor that he poured kerosene oil upon himself and put on fire to threaten the accused and his family members. PW2 Mithlesh Kumar a neighbour has not supported the prosecution case. PW4 Constable Ombir Singh is the officer to whom PW1 Samay Singh first went on 22nd February, 1996 at about 9.05 a.m. and gave his statement Ex.PW4/A. According to PW4 in the said statement the complainant/Samay Singh stated that he was burnt by his brother Rohtas without any reason when he was sleeping and he had recorded his statement vide DD No. 6. A perusal of the Ex.PW4/A would show that though PW1 had named his brother however, the version given in it is totally contrary to his statement in EX.PW1/A and made in the court. As per him there was no reason why he poured kerosene oil and burnt him and secondly, he got to know only after his body was burnt. On confrontation it is clear that each statement made by PW1 in the court except naming the Appellant, is contrary to his previous statements.

6.

PW6 Dr. Mahesh Vyas is yet another material witness. He has stated that this witness was admitted in the Hospital vide MLC Ex.PW6/A and he had received 30% deep burns. In the cross-examination he has stated that the history given was as told by the injured and the duration of injuries sustained was not more than 24 hours. According to the PW6 Dr. Mahesh Vyas if a person pours kerosene oil on himself he can sustain injuries as mentioned by him in the MLC.

7.

The most material aspect in the present case is that the incident took place at 2.30 A.M. in the thickly polluted area, however, nobody brought the injured PW1 Samay Singh to the hospital nor informed the police. PW1 at 9.05 a.m. himself goes to the police station when his statement which is the first statement Ex. PW4/A was recorded and thereafter he was taken to the hospital by the police. Thus, there was enough time from 2.30 A.M. to 9.A.M. for PW1 to reflect on the statement to be made particularly in the light of the fact that if the case of the defence is true then PW1 inflicted burn injuries upon himself and he would have been liable for an offence punishable u/s 309 IPC. Thus, in order to avoid himself from prosecution the fact that he would have implicated his brother who was admittedly objecting to his drunken behavior as he was creating nuisance with the neighbours cannot be ruled out. This defence of the Appellant is further fortified by the statement of PW6 Dr. Mahesh Vyas who in cross examination has stated that if a person pours kerosene oil upon himself he can sustain injuries as mentioned by him in the MLC. The finding of the learned trial court that the defence version that PW1 was overdrunk and made nuisance which was resented by the neighbours and the Appellant and so he poured kerosene oil upon himself and set ablaze under the influence of liquor cannot be believed as the MLC did not observe smell of alcohol is erroneous. The MLC did not even observe smell of kerosene though the admitted case of both the sides is that PW1 suffered burn injuries after pouring of kerosene oil. The injured reached the hospital at about 11.30 a.m. and by that time the smell of alcohol, which he would have consumed would have been washed out and thus gone unnoticed at the time of preparation of MLC. It is for this reason the fact that nobody informed the police, nor extinguished fire and PW1 went to the police station on his own after nearly 61/2 hours assumes importance.

8.

In view of the material contradictions in the testimony of PW1 which is not corroborated by any independent witness and in view of the evidence of PW6 that the injury could have been caused if a person pours kerosene oil on himself, thus proving the defence of the Appellant by preponderance of probability, I am of the opinion that the Appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt.

9.

Accordingly the appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment of conviction and order on sentence are set aside. Bail bond and the surety bond are discharged.