AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER SHRI M BALAGANESH, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER:
The appeal in ITA No.4717/Del/2025 for AY 2010-11, arises out of the order of the Id National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi [hereinafter referred to as 'Id. CIT(A)', in short] dated 25.06.2025 against the order of assessment passed u/s 148/143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') dated 26.12.2017 by the Assessing Officer, Income Tax Officer, Ward-21(3), Delhi (hereinafter referred to as 'Id. AO').
The first issue to be decided in this appeal is as to whether the learned AO was justified in validly assuming jurisdiction under section 147 of the Act in the facts and circumstances of the instant case. The interconnected issue involved therein on merits is as to whether the learned CITA was justified in confirming the action of the learned AO in making the addition of Rs 62,86,000 in group company of G J Holding Private Limited as unexplained investment in the facts and circumstances of the instant case.
We have heard the rival submissions and perused the materials available on record. The assessee company was engaged in the business of trading in loose milk, investment and real estate. The return of income for the assessment year 2010-11 was filed by the assessee on 26-09-2010 declaring total income of Rs 33,742. Based on the information received from the investigation wing, the learned AO issued notice under section 148 of the Act. The reasons recorded for reopening the assessment are as under:-
“The assessee filed return of income for the A.Y. 2010-11 on 26.09.2010 declaring income of Rs.33,742/-. The return was processed u/s 143(1) on 25.11.2010.
In this case, information was received from the O/o ACIT, Central Circle-II, Ludhiana vide letter in F.No.ACIT/CC-II/Ldh./2016-17/2076 dated 25.11.2016 that a survey u/s.133A was carried out at the premises of M/s.Jain Monga and Associates, 1304, Padma Tower-1, Rajendra Palace, New Delhi in connection with search and seizure operation in the case of M/s.G.S Auto Group, Ludhiana. Shri. Satish Monga was the Chartered Accountant of the various concerns who have allegedly provided accommodation entries towards share capital/premium to G.S Group of cases through many Bogus companies. During the course of survey it came to the notice that the ässessee company is involved in the business of providing accommodation entries alongwith other group companies controlled by Sh. Satish Monga.
As per the information received from the Investigation wing(Enclosed as Annexure B), M/s. Ritu Mercantile Pvt.Ltd. has invested Rs.62.86 lakhs in the F.Y 2009-10 in the group company of G.J Holding Pvt.Ltd. which receives huge share capital/share application money and transfer the same to other group companies. Further, on perusal of the Return of Income of M/s. Ritu Mercantile Pvt.Ltd., it was found that the returned income of the assessee is abysmally low ie., Rs.33,742/-.
Further, as per the appraisal report of the Investigation wing, the summons u/s.131 issued to M/s. Ritu Mercantile (P) Ltd. was received back with remarks 'No such Company' indicating that it is bogus non existent company operated by Sh.Satish Monga to provide accommodation entries. Accordingly, I have reason to believe that an amount of Rs.62.86 lakhs has escaped assessment and in order to protect the interest of Revenue the assessment of the company for the AY 2010-11 is to be made by issuing notice u/s. 148.
Since, the assessment/re-assessment proceedings in this case for A”Y 2010-11 pertain to period beyond four years but before the expiry of six years from the date of issue of notice, necessary sanction has to be obtained from Pr. Commissioner Income Tax in view of the amended provision of section 151 w.e.f 01.06.2015. The necessary sanction in this regard is being obtained separately from Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-07, Delhi before the issue of notice u/s. 148. "
The aforesaid reasons suggest the following:-
A survey under section 133A of the Act was conducted at the premises of M/s Jain Monga and Associates in connection with search and seizure operation in the case of M/s G S Auto Group, Ludhiana.
Shri Satish Monga was found to be the Chartered Accountant of various concerns which had allegedly provided certain accommodation entries to G S Group of cases
The assessee company is involved in the business of providing accommodation entries along with other group companies controlled by Shri Satish Monga.
The assessee company had invested Rs 62.86 lakhs in the group company of G J Holding Pvt Ltd which receives huge share capital/ share application money. Hence it pertains to behavior of group company of G J Holding Pvt Ltd.
The summons issued by investigation wing under section 131 of the Act to assessee company was received back with remarks “No such company” indicating that it is bogus non existent company operated by Shri Satish Monga to provide accommodation entries. Accordingly, the learned AO has reason to believe that income of the asssesee company to the extent of Rs 62.86 lakhs has escaped assessment warranting reopening of assessment.
Reopening is being made beyond four years from the end of the relevant assessment year based on the information received from investigation wing. Hence it is a case of borrowed satisfaction by the learned AO.
It is pertinent to note that assessee had indeed made investment of Rs 62,86,000 in the group company of G J Holding Pvt. Ltd and the said investment is already disclosed in the books of accounts of the assessee. The said information which is already disclosed in the balance sheet is now sought to be treated as an accommodation entry provided by the assessee by the Learned AO in the reassessment proceedings based on information received from Investigation Wing. Though the information received from Investigation Wing would constitute tangible material for the purpose of reopening, the Learned AO had not carried out any independent verification on his part by independently applying his mind to the information received from the Investigation Wing. The Learned AO is duty bound to make independent enquiries by independent application of mind and then come to a conscious conclusion that assessee is engaged in providing accommodation entries to the group company of G J Holding Pvt. Ltd. No such examination was even sought to be carried out by the Learned AO as is evident from the recording of recently reproduced supra. Hence, the facts of the case squarely fall within the ratio decidendi of Hon’ble Jurisdictional Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT vs Meenakshi Overseas Pvt. Ltd. reported in 395 ITR 677 (Del). The relevant operative portion of the aforesaid judgment is reproduced below:-
“36.In the present case, as already noticed, the reasons to believe contain not the reasons, but the conclusions of the AO one after the other. There is no independent application of mind by the AO to the tangible material, which forms the basis of the reasons to believe that income has escaped assessment. The conclusions of the AO are at best a reproduction of the conclusion in the investigation report. Indeed, it is a ‘borrowed satisfaction’. The reasons fail to demonstrate the link between the tangible material and the formation of the reason to believe that income has escaped assessment.
37.For the aforementioned reasons, the Court is satisfied that in the facts and circumstances of the case, no error has been committed by the ITAT in the impugned order in concluding that the initiation of the proceedings under section 147/148 of the Act to reopen the assessments for the AYs in question does not satisfy the requirement of law.”
Similar view was rendered by the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT vs G and G Pharma India Ltd. reported in 384 ITR 147 (Del).
We find that it is not the case of the revenue that investment of Rs 62.86 lakhs has been made by the assessee company out of undisclosed sources. We find that addition has been made by the learned AO in the instant case by applying the provisions of section 69 of the Act. But we find that the provisions of section 69 of the Act could be applied only for the investments which are not recorded in the books of accounts and for which sources are not explained by the assessee. In the instant case, the investment of Rs 62.86 lakhs has already been recorded in the books of accounts by the assessee company. As stated earlier, it is not the case of the revenue that the said investment has been made out of undisclosed sources or the assessee was not able to satisfactorily explain the sources for making such investment. Hence, in our considered opinion, the provisions of section 69 of the Act per se could not be applied at all. Further, the assessee on its part had furnished the bank statements, copy of ITR together with the computation of total income, audited financial statements and copy of memorandum and articles of association of G J Holdings Private Limited together with the copy of share certificate for investment made by the assessee.
In view of the aforesaid observations, the assumption of jurisdiction under section 147 of the Act is based on borrowed satisfaction, which is totally flawed and becomes fatal to the entire reassessment proceedings and reassessment proceedings deserve to be quashed as void ab initio. Even on merits, the assessee has furnished all the relevant details before the Learned AO and there cannot be any applicability of provisions of section 69 of the Act for making the impugned addition in view of the aforementioned reasons. Hence, the reassessment is quashed and the addition is also deleted on merits. The grounds raised by the assessee are allowed.
In the result, the appeal of the assessee is allowed.
