AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
1.,"Medical expenditure including medical bills, attendant charges, special diet, transportation charges:","Rs.1,76,000/-
2.,Pain and agony:,"Rs.1,50,000/-
3.,Loss of future income:,"Rs.12,96,000/-
4.,Loss of amenities:,"Rs.2,50,000/-
5.,Loss of marriage prospects:,"Rs.1,50,000/-
6.,"Future medical expenses including expenses of artificial limb:","Rs.2,50,000/-
7.,Total:,"Rs.22,72,800/-
refers to the residuary incapacity or loss of use of some part of the body, found existing at the end of the period of treatment and recuperation, after" achieving the maximum bodily improvement or recovery which is likely to remain for the remainder life of the injured. Temporary disability refers to the incapacity or loss of use of some part of the body on account of the injury, which will cease to exist at the end of the period of treatment and" recuperation. Permanent disability can be either partial or total. Partial permanent disability refers to a person's inability to perform all the duties and bodily functions that he could perform before the accident, though he is able to perform some of them and is still able to engage in some gainful" activity. Total permanent disability refers to a person's inability to perform any avocation or employment related activities as a result of the accident.
The permanent disabilities that may arise from motor accident injuries, are of a much wider range when compared to the physical disabilities which" are enumerated in the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 (“the Disabilities Act”," for short). But if any of the disabilities enumerated in Section 2(i) of the Disabilities Act are the result of injuries sustained in a motor accident, they" can be permanent disabilities for the purpose of claiming compensation.
The percentage of permanent disability is expressed by the doctors with reference to the whole body, or more often than not, with reference to a" particular limb. When a disability certificate states that the injured has suffered permanent disability to an extent of 45% of the left lower limb, it is not" the same as 45% permanent disability with reference to the whole body. The extent of disability of a limb (or part of the body) expressed in terms of a percentage of the total functions of that limb, obviously cannot be assumed to be the extent of disability of the whole body. If there is 60% permanent" disability of the right hand and 80% permanent disability of left leg, it does not mean that the extent of permanent disability with reference to the whole" body is 140% (that is 80% plus 60%). If different parts of the body have suffered different percentages of disabilities, the sum total thereof expressed" in terms of the permanent disability with reference to the whole body cannot obviously exceed 100%.
Where the claimant suffers a permanent disability as a result of injuries, the assessment of compensation under the head of loss of future earnings" would depend upon the effect and impact of such permanent disability on his earning capacity. The Tribunal should not mechanically apply the percentage of permanent disability as the percentage of economic loss or loss of earning capacity. In most of the cases, the percentage of economic" loss, that is, the percentage of loss of earning capacity, arising from a permanent disability will be different from the percentage of permanent" disability. Some Tribunals wrongly assume that in all cases, a particular extent (percentage) of permanent disability would result in a corresponding" loss of earning capacity, and consequently, if the evidence produced show 45% as the permanent disability, will hold that there is 45% loss of future" earning capacity. In most of the cases, equating the extent (percentage) of loss of earning capacity to the extent (percentage) of permanent disability" will result in award of either too low or too high a compensation.
What requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is the effect of the permanent disability on the earning capacity of the injured; and after assessing the loss of earning capacity in terms of a percentage of the income, it has to be quantified in terms of money, to arrive at the future loss of earnings" (by applying the standard multiplier method used to determine loss of dependency). We may however note that in some cases, on appreciation of" evidence and assessment, the Tribunal may find that the percentage of loss of earning capacity as a result of the permanent disability, is approximately" the same as the percentage of permanent disability in which case, of course, the Tribunal will adopt the said percentage for determination of" compensation.”
Adverting to the facts of the present case, the claimant/appellant had examined PW3, Dr. Sudesh Pebam and who had deposed that the claimant" had been admitted in PGI (Emergency Ward) on 10.06.2013 with history of roadside accident and had suffered crushed injury of the right foot," fracture of femur of right side and injuries on right forearm. Claimant was operated on 11.06.2013 for fracture femur with nail and for crushed injuries below knee, amputation was done. An operation was conducted on 19.06.2013 for amputation of right leg and he was discharged on 03.07.2013. As" per deposition of PW3, the kind of injuries suffered by the claimant would require high protein diet and the patient would require the service of an" attendant and the recovery period would be almost 9 months. PW3, Dr. Sudesh Pebam further deposed that the claimant had been examined for" assessment of permanent physical disability on 22.11.2013 and which was assessed to be 70% in relation to right lower limb. Furthermore, the" disability element was opined to be permanent and functional in nature and not likely to improve with passage of time. In cross examination, the doctor" deposed that after fitting an artificial limb, the claimant can perform routine household work and can do sitting job."
The Tribunal has taken note of the factual position that the claimant had qualified 10+2 examination and was in the process of proceeding abroad for higher studies and that he was 19 years of age at the time of accident. A notional income of Rs.8000/- per month has been assessed and 50% increase in income has been granted towards future prospects. Keeping in view the deposition of PW3, Dr. Sudesh Pebam and the disability" certificate, Ex.P40 reflecting a permanent disability of 70% of the right lower limb, the Tribunal has taken a view that the claimant would still be able" to pursue his studies and can do a desk job and has assessed his functional disability at 50%. A multiplier of 18 has been applied. The amount has been calculated as Rs.12,000 x 12 x 18 = 25,92,000/- and 50% of which come to Rs.12,96,000/-. As such, claimant has been held entitled to a sum of" Rs.12,96,000/- on account of loss of future income after assessing a functional disability of 50% due to amputation of leg. In addition, Tribunal has" awarded the claimant a sum of Rs.1.50 lakhs towards loss of amenities and sum of Rs.2 lakhs on account of loss of marriage prospects. A total sum of Rs.2.50 lakhs has been awarded towards expenses of artificial limb and for future medical expenses.
That apart, claimant has been held entitled to Rs.86,800/- on account of medicines/hospital treatment on the basis of medical bills, Ex. P-37 and P-" 48 to P-52 that had been duly proved on record. Claimant has further been held entitled to a sum of Rs.1.50 lakhs on account of pain and agony, a" sum of Rs.35,000/- towards special diet, Rs.45,000/- for availing the services of an attendant and further sum of Rs.10,000/- on account of transport" expenses.
In the considered view of this Court and as per dictum laid down in Raj Kumar's case (supra), it was imperative upon the Tribunal to have" assessed the affect of permanent disability on the earning capacity of the injured and after assessing the loss of earning capacity in terms of percentage of the income, it had to be quantified in terms of money to arrive at the rate of future loss of earning by applying the standard multiplier" method used to determine loss of dependency. In the present case, the competent Authority has assessed the permanent disability of the" claimant/appellant as 70% in relation to the right leg. In the deposition recorded of the doctor as PW3, it has come forth that the appellant would be" able to undertake routine household chores after fitment of an artificial leg and may be able to pursue a desk job. The Tribunal has assessed the functional disability, as such, to be 50%. No intervention in this regard would be required. Be that as it may, while assessing the loss of earning" capacity, the notional income per month assessed by the Tribunal as Rs.8000/- is slightly on the lower side. The Apex Court in V. Mekala Vs. M."
Malathi & another, 2014 (2) SCC 178, wherein the victim was a student and bones of her both legs were fractured in the motor vehicle accident and" had assessed her monthly notional income as Rs.10,000/- and awarded 50% towards future prospects. In the present case, appellant was stated to be" 19 years of age on the date of accident and had qualified the 10+2 examination as also IELTS examination and was preparing to proceed abroad for future studies. It can well be presumed that the petitioner had a bright future and it is only on account of the accident and the disability suffered that his studies have been disrupted and avenues of employment/job have become restricted. The notional monthly income of the appellant as such is assessed at Rs.10,000/-. By awarding an addition in income @ 50% towards future prospects, the same would come to Rs.15,000/-. Keeping in view" the age bracket and as per guidelines in Sarla Verma & others Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & another, 2009 (3) RCR (Civil) 77, multiplier of 18 is" to be applied. As such, the total amount would work out to be Rs.15,000 x 12 x 18 = 32,40,000/-. 50% of such amount would be Rs.16,20,000/-. The" appellant, as such, is held entitled to a sum of Rs.16,20,000/- under the head of loss of future income on account of his functional disability having been"
Sr. No.,Computation/Heads,Revised calculations
1.,"Loss of future income i.e. 50% of the total
income assessed.","15,000 x 12 x 18 = 32,40,000/-
32,40,000 — 16,20,000 =
Rs.16,20,000/-
2.,"Future medical expenses including expenses of
artificial limb",Rs.5.50 lakhs
3.,Medical expenditure towards medical bills etc.,"Rs.86,800/-
4.,Pain and agony,Rs.2 lakhs
5.,Special die,"Rs.35,000/-
6.,Services of an attendant,Rs. 1 lakh
7,Loss of amenities,Rs.2 lakhs
8.,Loss of marriage prospects,Rs.1.50 lakhs
9.,Transportation expenses,"Rs.10,000/-
10.,Total,"Rs.29,51,800/-
