AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Sathish Ninan, J
The plaintiff in a suit for money under a construction contract, is the appellant. The defendant raised a counter claim for recovery of excess amounts paid. The trial court dismissed the suit and decreed the counter claim.
On 26.07.2008, Ext.A1 construction contract was entered into between the plaintiff (builder) and the defendant (owner) for construction of a commercial building for the defendant. As per Ext.A1, the cost of construction is 775 per sq. ft. for the built-up area of 3856 sq. ft. The total amount for construction is ₹29,88,400/-. The amount was to be paid in various stages as specified in Ext.A1. According to the plaintiff, in the course of the construction work, the defendant required execution of additional construction. The additional construction thus carried out is 346.4 sq. ft. The same was neither endorsed on the agreement nor a separate agreement executed. It was done by an oral agreement. Though 97% of the works are completed, the payments due have not been made. The plaintiff claims that an amount of ₹1,38,400/- is outstanding in terms of the original agreement and an amount of ₹4,83,860/- for the additional work. Thus, the suit is filed for realisation of a total amount of ₹ 6,22,260/-with interest.
The defendant though admitted the Ext.A1 agreement, contended that page 3 of Ext.A1 is fabricated one. The said page contains the specifications with regard to construction. The original of page 3 was replaced with a fabricated one and produced before the court. As per the agreement the work to be done includes electrification, plumbing, flooring etc. The said works were not done by the plaintiff. The construction carried out by the plaintiff is not as per the specifications contained in the agreement. The materials used and the workmanship are of inferior quality. The claim of the plaintiff that 97% of the construction is over was denied and it was contended that only 60% of the work has been completed. The defendant claimed that he has paid an amount of approximately ₹9 lakhs in excess of the actual amount due to the plaintiff. The defendant raised a counter claim limiting the amount to ₹8 lakhs.
The plaintiff filed a written statement to the counter claim denying the averments and the claim in the written statement.
The trial court held that the construction carried out by the plaintiff was not in accordance with the specifications. It was held that the rate of ₹ 775/-per sq.ft could not be for construction of the structure alone. The Court adopted the PWD rate towards the cost of construction of the structure, and held that the total cost of construction is ₹16,18,925/-. Admittedly the plaintiff was paid an amount of ₹ 28,50,000/-. Accordingly, the counter claim was decreed for return of ₹8 lakhs as claimed by the defendant and the plaint claim was dismissed.
I have heard Sri.Santheep Ankarath on behalf of the appellant-plaintiff and Sri.J.Julian Xavier, the learned counsel for the respondent-defendant.
According to the plaintiff, by the time disputes arose between the parties, 97% of the construction was completed. However, according to the defendant only 60% of the work was completed. The state of the construction obtaining at that time was reported by a Commissioner with the assistance of an expert who were deputed in another suit that was filed by the plaintiff as OS 228/2010, before the Munsiff's Court, Pala. That was a suit filed by the plaintiff for prohibitory injunction to restrain the defendant from entrusting the work to others. Therein, the Commissioner originally filed a report stating the value of construction at ₹16 lakhs (approximately). The Commissioner's report was set aside and the very same commission was reissued. Thereafter, the Commissioner submitted a report, marked as Ext.A8 in the present suit, wherein the cost of construction at the rate as specified in Ext.A1 agreement was reported as, ₹36,53,149/-.
The main dispute between the parties is, whether the rate fixed in Ext.A1 agreement includes the electrical, plumbing and other works, or is it only for the structure. In Ext.A1 agreement, the rate fixed for construction is ₹775/- per sq. ft. for the built-up area. According to the defendant, the rate includes expenses for electrification, plumbing, flooring etc. According to the plaintiff, the rate is only for the structure of the building to be completed in terms of the specifications in the agreement and the plan. The plans are marked as Exts.B1 and B2.
Clause 1 of Ext.A1 agreement provide that, the work will be executed in accordance with the plan, specification attached to the agreement and the rates mutually agreed by the parties. The specifications were contained at page 3 of Ext.A1. Going by page 3 in Ext.A1, electrical, plumbing and wood work are not included. The genuineness of page 3 of Ext.A1 is stoutly disputed by the defendant, including his signature therein. It is his case that the original of page 3 has been replaced by the plaintiff with a fabricated one. The trial court found that, in spite of the specific denial, the plaintiff did not take any steps to prove the genuineness of the disputed signature. Further, on a perusal of the signatures, the court noticed the differences at page 3 with the signatures at the other pages. The court has observed the details of such differences. On a perusal of page 3 of Ext.A1, it is seen that the observations of the trial court with regard to the signatures found at the disputed page are justified. The trial court was right in having refused to consider page 3 of Ext.A1.
Though the genuineness of page 3 of Ext.A1 agreement is disputed, the defendant has not produced a copy of the authentic Ext.A1 agreement. In the replication filed by the plaintiff at paragraph 4, it is contended that a copy of Ext.A1 was given to the defendant. As DW1, the defendant would deny the same. However, it is not probable that he would not have retained even a copy of the agreement. Though in the written statement the defendant contended that the original page of Ext.A1 was replaced with a fabricated one, as DW1, he would in cross-examination say that the original did not contain the specification. His deposition reads thus :-
“Exhibit A1 ð hmZn ]dªn«m H¸n . sI«nS ]Wnbp sS IcmÀ BtWm F a\Ênem¡nbmtWm H (Q). AsX, hmZn ]dª A\pkcn¨m H (A). H¸n«¸w specification Dïmbncptóm (Q). Cñmbn cpóp. ]nóo AhÀ Hsc®w Xóp. (A)”
Claiming to be the detailed specification with regard to the construction as given by the plaintiff, the defendant produced Ext.B3. According to the plaintiff, Ext.B3 happened to be issued as claimed by the defendant to enable availing of a loan from Bank. When PW1 is cross-examined, a suggestion is made by the learned counsel for the defendant with regard to availing of loan from the Bank. That Ext.B3 was not prepared along with Ext.A1 agreement and Exts.B1 and B2 plan is evident for the reason, Ext.B3 contains provisions for “handrails” for balcony whereas going by Exts.B1 and B2 plan what is provided for is “parapet”. Therefore, the case of the plaintiff that Ext.B3 does not reflect the specifications agreed between the parties cannot be brushed aside. Relying on Ext.B3, the trial court concluded that the rate agreed to between the parties under Ext.A1 agreement was for the works of the building to be made in a ‘ready to occupy’ condition. Here it is to be noticed that, at the undisputed pages of Ext.A1 agreement what is provided for is “for the construction of structure of the building”. At pages 1 and 2 it has been repeatedly mentioned as “construction of structure” of the building. At the opening part of the agreement it is recited thus “Agreement entered into on this ... as one part (….. the contractor) and ... as second part (….. the owner) by entering into an agreement with the following conditions for construction of structure of the building for the owner …”. The terms mentioned at clause 4, page 2 of Ext.A1 agreement reads thus: -
“Payments will be strictly in accordance with the stages mentioned below.
Total amount of construction of the Structure @ 775/- (Seven Hundred and Seventy Five Only) per square feet of the built up area i.e. 3856 x 775 = 29,88,400.00
a. Advance 10% of the total construction cost mutually agreed by both the parties i.e. Rs.2,98,840.00
b. 10% of the total amount after the completion of plinth level i.e. Rs.2,98,840.00
c. 20% of the total amount after the completion of ground floor columns i.e. Rs.5,97,680.00
d. 15% of the total amount after Floor Concrete i.e. Rs.4,48,260.00”
e. 15% of the total amount after the completion of first floor columns i.e. Rs.4,48,260.00
f. 10% of the total amount after Roof Concrete i.e. Rs.2,98,840.00
g. 10% of the total amount after hollow blocks masonry i.e. Rs.2,98,840.00
h. 5% of the total amount after plastering i.e. Rs.1,49,420.00
i. 5% of the total amount after the completion i.e. Rs.1,49,420.00
j. Rate for the construction of structure of the commercial building as per the plan specification in this agreement is Rs.775/-”
Noticeably, at clause (4) what is stated is total amount for construction of the “structure”. Clause-(j) provides the rate of construction of the structure of the commercial building as per the plan specification. Sub-clauses (a) to (i) in clause No.4 above refers to the stage-wise payments. The stages mentioned are only “plinth level” “completion of ground floor columns”, “floor concrete”, “completion of first floor columns”, “completion of roof concrete”, “hollow blocks”, “masonry and plastering”. The stage-wise payment of the total amount as above does not make any reference to electrical, plumbing, sanitary works etc. There is nothing to indicate that other works like sanitation, plumbing, electrical etc. are included in the stages mentioned therein. Therefore, the disputed document Ext.B3, alone cannot made the basis to find that the rate mentioned in Ext.A1 agreement included the cost of electrical, sanitary and other works. On the other hand, pages 1 and 2 of Ext.A1 which are undisputed, suggest that the rate agreed is only for the structure of the building.
Deliberating on the rate of construction, the trial court has proceeded observing that “nobody will agree to construct structures at the rate of ₹775/- per sq.ft.” There was no material before the Court, oral or documentary, to arrive at the said conclusion. There was no plea for the defendant that the rate, ₹775/- per sq.ft. for construction of the structure was an exorbitant rate which was not prevalent at that time. No evidence was adduced by the defendant that such rate for structure was exorbitant during that period. If the rate was so excessive, then evidence regarding the same could have been adduced. It is pertinent to note that, even when the expert was examined as PW3 or when the Advocate Commissioner was examined as CW1, not even a suggestion is made to them that the rate of ₹775/- per sq. ft. for structure alone is an exorbitant rate and that under normal circumstances a contract would not be entered into at that rate for the construction of structural works alone. In the absence of any such evidence, the conclusions arrived at by the trial court that, the rate agreed to between the parties was inclusive of all works to make the building in a ready to occupy condition, including electrical, sanitary and other works, cannot be sustained.
Thus, I find that the rate of ₹775/- per sq. ft. agreed to in Ext.A1 is only for construction of the structure, for a built-up area of 3856 sq. ft.
Though the plaintiff would allege that the construction carried out by the defendant was using low quality materials and that the foundation does not conform to the required specifications, such aspects were not ascertained by the defendant through the expert Commissioner. He having not been asked to report regarding the same, it could only be found that the said allegations have no substance. There is no claim for damages alleging that the defendant had to do any extra work to make the committed work in accordance with the standards.
It is the case of the defendant that the extra/additional works were done by the plaintiff on an agreement that it will be in lieu of the cost of the wood work which had to be replaced at the cost of the defendant since the work done by the plaintiff was found to be of inferior quality. However, but for such a contention to be subsist there is no evidence regarding the same. Hence such contention is only to be negatived. The plaintiff is thus entitled to the value of extra/additional works also.
The stage up to which the plaintiff carried out construction is evident from Ext.A8 the Commissioner's Report prepared in OS 228/2010. The Commissioner was examined as CW1 and the expert who accompanied the Commissioner was examined as PW3. There is no dispute with regard to the stage of construction as reported therein. The value/cost of such construction based on the rate as agreed in Ext.A1 viz. ₹775/- per sq.ft., has been reported to be ₹36,53,149/-. The value of such construction at the PWD rate has been assessed and reported by the very same Commissioner and expert, who were deputed in the present case, through Ext.C1 and C1(a) as ₹16,18,925/-. Incidentally it is also to be noted that, though the difference is ₹20,34,224/-, and even the defendant does not have a case that he has paid so much excess amount. According to him the excess payment made is only ₹9 lakhs (approximately).
Having found that the agreed rate for construction is ₹775/- per sq. ft., the plaintiff is entitled to get ₹36,53,149/- towards the work carried out by him. It is not in dispute that only an amount of ₹28,50,000/- was paid to him. Therefore, he is entitled for the balance amount of ` 6,22,260/-. The claim of the defendant that he has paid amounts in excess of that due to the plaintiff, is thus incorrect. The finding of the trial court to the contrary is thus liable to be interfered with and I do so.
With regard to the entitlement of interest, considering the conduct of the plaintiff in having tampered with page 3 of Ext.A1 agreement, I deem it appropriate to decline interest till the date of decree and also the costs. From the date of decree the plaintiff shall be entitled for interest at the rate of 6% per annum.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed. The decree and judgment of the trial court are set aside. The suit is decreed allowing the plaintiff to realise an amount of ₹6,22,260/- with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of decree till realisation, from the defendant and his assets. Costs disallowed.
