AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Per: Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain (Oral)
13.05.2025: This appeal has arisen from the order dated 20.11.2023 passed by the National Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai Bench, Court-IV by which Appeal-(IBC)/50 (MB) 2023, filed by the appellant under Section 42 of the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (in short ‘Code’) has been dismissed.
Shorn of unnecessary details, the liquidation proceedings were initiated against the Corporate Debtor, namely, Independent TV Limited (ITV) on 17.03.2023. Liquidator made the public announcement for inviting claims on 22.03.2023 which were to be submitted latest by 16.04.2023. It is an admitted fact that the appellant filed its claim with the Liquidator on Form-C in respect of their outstanding dues against the Corporate Debtor for a sum of Rs.21,83,14,789/-. The said claim of the appellant was rejected by the Liquidator on 23.08.2023 by way of an email on the ground that the claim has been filed belatedly after a delay of 102 days which was not within the statutory timelines prescribed under the Code and the Liquidation Regulations.
Aggrieved against the order of the Liquidator dated 23.08.2023, the appellant preferred the appeal under Section 42 of the Code on 05.09.2023 in which it was prayed that the delay because of which the claim of the appellant has been rejected may be condoned and the Liquidator may be directed to verify and admit the said claim.
However, as per the appellant, the appeal dated 05.09.2023 bearing (IBC)/50 (MB) 2023, was dismissed on 20.11.2023.
According to the appellant, the Ld. Tribunal, relying upon an order of the Ld. NCLT, Hyderabad Bench, rendered in IA-168/2022 IN CP. No. 369/10/HDB/2019 titled as ‘Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Limited vs. Priyadarsini Limited Rep by Liquidator, Mr. Krishna Mohan Gollamudi’ decided on 17.07.2023 [2023 SCC Online NCLT 314] has dismissed the appeal filed under Section 42 of the Code on the ground that the delay in filing of the appeal has not been appropriately explained. Therefore, according to the appellant the Ld. Tribunal has infact dismissed the appeal on the ground of the limitation which was though filed within the statutory period.
In the alternative, it is submitted that even if it is presumed for the sake of the argument that the Ld. Tribunal has dismissed the appeal while not condoning the delay yet the said order is totally non-speaking as the issue raised by the appellant in his appeal, including jurisdiction of the Liquidator for considering the belated claim that as to whether it is directory and not mandatory has not been considered.
In the light of the aforesaid argument, he has thus submitted that since the impugned order is not clear as to whether it has decided the appeal filed under Section 42 of the Code or refused to condone the delay made in the appeal, therefore, the impugned order dated 20.11.2023 may be set aside and the matter may be remanded back to the Ld. Tribunal to decide the appeal filed by the appellant under Section 42 of the Code afresh after taking into consideration all the facts and circumstances and the law.
On the other hand, Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate appearing on behalf of Liquidator has vehemently opposed the appeal filed by the appellant and submitted that the impugned order does not deserve to be set aside and do not call for a remand because the Ld. Tribunal has rightly taken into consideration the appeal filed by the appellant in which there is a prayer made by the appellant for condonation of delay which has not found in favour with the Tribunal.
We have heard counsel for the parties and after perusal of record, are of the considered opinion that the impugned order is not clear as to whether it has decided the appeal filed by the appellant on the merit or on the issue of limitation because in paragraph No. 5 of the impugned order, the Ld. Tribunal has relied upon a decision of the Hyderabad Bench of the NCLT for refusing to condone the delay which was a case pertaining to an appeal filed by the appellant therein under Section 42 of the Code seeking condonation of delay in filing of the appeal under Section 42 of the Code. The Ld. Tribunal, in the penultimate paragraph No. 6 has categorically recorded that: “In view of the above and perused the material available on record, this bench finds that, the reasons for delay is not properly given in the application” which means that the Tribunal has taken into consideration the decision in the case of Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Limited vs. Priyadarsini Limited Rep by Liquidator, Mr. Krishna Mohan Gollamudi (supra) which was on the issue of condonation of delay in filing of the appeal under Section 42 of the Code and not the condonation of delay in filing the claim before the Liquidator.
Moreover, though counsel for the respondent has vehemently argued that in the entire application of the appellant there is hardly any averment as to how the delay of 102 has been explained yet we have found that the appellant has also raised a legal issue that the consideration of the claim is directory and not mandatory for which the claim of the appellant which is running into more than 21 crores, that too towards the rental dues since 2018 has been rejected. Counsel for the respondent has submitted that in this regard the appellant had already filed an application bearing I.A. No. 1342 of 2025 for the said amount.
Be that as it may, keeping in view the aforesaid discussion, we have reached to a conclusion in this case that the impugned order is totally confusing as to whether it has decided the appeal or rejected the claim of the appellant and also the impugned order is totally non-speaking, therefore, the impugned order deserves to be set aside and the matter deserves to be remanded back to the Ld. Tribunal to decide the issue raised by the appellant and contested by the respondent afresh.
Consequently, the appeal is allowed. The impugned order passed in Appeal-(IBC)/50 (MB) 2023 is set aside. The Appeal-(IBC)/50 (MB) 2023 is hereby restored. The matter is remanded back to the Ld. Tribunal seized of the Liquidation Proceedings, to decide the aforesaid appeal No. (IBC)/50 (MB) 2023 in accordance with law.
While parting with this order, we pertinently mention that while allowing this appeal, we have not touched the merits of the matter and have left everything open for the Ld. Tribunal to decide in the appeal. The parties are directed to appear before the Tribunal on 30.05.2025. Pending I.As, if any, are hereby closed. The parties shall bear their own cost.
We request the Ld. Tribunal to decide this appeal of the appellant expeditiously by giving short dates.
