AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
VIRINDER AGGARWAL, J. (Oral)
The present revision petition has been preferred under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, invoking the supervisory jurisdiction of this Court, seeking setting aside of the impugned order dated 18.07.2025 (Annexure P-2), passed by the Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kapurthala, whereby the defence of petitioner-defendants No. 1 to 4 was struck off, as well as the subsequent order dated 18.05.2026 (Annexure P-4), whereby the Trial Court dismissed their application seeking review of the aforesaid order. Both orders are assailed as being legally unsustainable, arbitrary and contrary to the settled principles governing the exercise of judicial discretion.
As per the averments set out in the revision petition, the respondent-plaintiffs instituted a suit for permanent injunction seeking to restrain the petitioner-defendant No.2 from forcibly dispossessing them from the suit property, demolishing any specific portion thereof or otherwise interfering with their possession. Petitioner-defendant No.2 entered appearance through counsel on 03.10.2024. However, on account of non-filing of the written statement within the prescribed period, the defence of petitioner-defendants No. 1 to 4 was struck off vide order dated 18.07.2025 (Annexure P-2).
The petitioner asserts that they remained unaware of the passing of the aforesaid order, as the clerk of their counsel had informed them that the matter had merely been adjourned to 22.08.2025 for filing of the written statement. It was only upon subsequently checking the case status online that they discovered that their defence had already been struck off. Consequently, they moved an application seeking review of the order on the very same day. The said application, however, came to be dismissed by the Trial Court vide order dated 18.05.2026 (Annexure P-4). Both orders have been assailed as being legally unsustainable, arbitrary and contrary to the principles of fairness and substantial justice.
The petitioner further contends that the Trial Court failed to appreciate that the default in filing the written statement was attributable to an inadvertent communication lapse on the part of the clerk of their counsel and was neither deliberate nor willful. It is urged that a litigant ought not to be made to suffer on account of an inadvertent mistake or omission attributable to counsel or his clerk, particularly when the petitioner was under the bona fide impression that the matter had been adjourned to 22.08.2025 for filing of the written statement. The Trial Court, according to the petitioner, committed a material error in dismissing the review application without duly appreciating the explanation furnished for the default and the circumstances leading to the delay. It is, therefore, prayed that the impugned orders be set aside and the petitioner be afforded one effective opportunity to file their written statement, subject to such terms as this Court may deem appropriate, so that the lis may be adjudicated on its merits rather than being foreclosed on account of a procedural lapse.
Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner and, with his able assistance, having meticulously scrutinised the paper-book and the impugned orders, this Court finds no merit in the present revision petition. A perusal of the order sheets and the history of the proceedings reveals that defendant Nos. 1 and 2 entered appearance through Mr. M.R. Kalia, Advocate, whereas defendant Nos. 3 and 4 appeared through Ms. Deepti Marwaha, Advocate, on 03.10.2024. Thereafter, the matter was repeatedly adjourned to enable the defendants to file their written statement, initially to 12.11.2024 and subsequently to 07.01.2025, 13.02.2025, 13.03.2025, 17.04.2025, 06.05.2025 and, lastly, to 18.07.2025, subject to payment of costs of `100/-. While granting the final adjournment, the Trial Court had categorically indicated that no further opportunity would be afforded. However, even on 18.07.2025, the written statement remained unfiled and the costs imposed on the previous occasion had also not been deposited. Taking note of the fact that more than 90 days had elapsed and that no plausible explanation had been furnished for the continued default, the Trial Court struck off the defence of the petitioner-defendant No.2. Subsequently, the application seeking review of the said order was dismissed vide the impugned order dated 18.05.2026, on the ground that no reasonable or sufficient cause had been disclosed for their failure to file the written statement either on 18.07.2025 or on any of the preceding dates.
The significant aspect of the matter is that, even before this Court, the petitioner has failed to furnish any cogent explanation for not filing the written statement within the prescribed period of 30 days from the date of service, as contemplated under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC. It is true that the provision is directory in nature and that the Court retains discretion to extend the time for filing the written statement even beyond the outer period of 90 days. However, such discretion is neither unfettered nor intended to permit an indefinite extension of time in the absence of exceptional circumstances or a satisfactory explanation for the delay. The indulgence contemplated by the provision must be exercised judiciously and upon the defendant demonstrating circumstances which genuinely prevented compliance within the prescribed period, particularly where such circumstances were beyond the defendant's control.
The legal position in this regard stands authoritatively elucidated by the Supreme Court in Kailash vs. Nanhku and Others, 2005(4) SCC 480, wherein it has been held that, in exceptional circumstances, the Court may permit the filing of a written statement beyond the prescribed period, provided sufficient justification is forthcoming and the exercise of such discretion is supported by reasons. The directory character of Order VIII Rule 1 CPC, however, cannot be construed as conferring an unrestricted licence upon a defendant(s) to prolong the proceedings indefinitely or to disregard the timelines prescribed by the statute.
Tested on the touchstone of the aforesaid principles, the conduct of the petitioner does not warrant any further indulgence. In the present case, the Trial Court had already been magnanimous in affording the petitioners repeated opportunities over a period spanning nearly nine months, i.e. approximately 270 days, to file their written statement. Despite such repeated indulgence, they neither filed the written statement nor complied with the direction regarding payment of costs. More significantly, no circumstance has been pleaded, much less substantiated, to demonstrate that any factor beyond their control incapacitated them from complying with the directions of the Trial Court. The explanation sought to be advanced on the basis of an alleged communication lapse on the part of the counsel's clerk also remains unsupported by any cogent material and does not satisfactorily account for the prolonged and repeated defaults. Even in the present revision petition, the petitioner has not disclosed any plausible reason for their failure to file the written statement on 18.07.2025 or on any of the earlier dates fixed for that purpose.
In these circumstances, the petitioner cannot claim an equitable indulgence from this Court in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. Procedural timelines are intended to secure the orderly and expeditious adjudication of civil disputes, and the discretion of the Court cannot be invoked to perpetuate delay in the absence of a bona fide and convincing explanation. A litigant who, despite repeated opportunities, fails to avail the same without demonstrating sufficient cause cannot seek to attribute the consequences of such persistent default to mere procedural technicalities. This Court, therefore, finds no illegality, perversity or material infirmity in the impugned orders warranting interference in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction.
Consequently, the present revision petition, being devoid of merit, is dismissed with exemplary costs of `10,000/-, to be deposited by the petitioner with the Poor Patients Fund, PGIMER, Chandigarh.
It is clarified that the observations made herein are confined strictly to the adjudication of the present proceedings and shall not be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the underlying dispute or prejudice the rights, claims or contentions of either party in any other proceedings.
In view of the final disposal of the principal matter, all pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of. No further orders are warranted.
