High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 10 P&H CK 5854

Ramneek Rai vs Sanjay Kumar

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 16 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Vikas Suri, J
RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
CR-7773-2026 (O&M)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

27 paragraphs · 2,498 words

VIKAS SURI, J. (Oral)

1.

The petitioner-tenant (Sanjay Kumar), through the present revision petition under Section 15(5) of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent & Eviction) Act, 1973 (for short, ‘Haryana Rent Act’), has assailed order dated 25.09.2026 passed by learned Rent Controller, whereby evidence on behalf of the petitioner, was closed by order of the Court.

2.

Briefly stated, respondent-landlord (Ramneek Rai) filed a rent petition under Section 13 of the Haryana Rent Act, seeking ejectment of the petitioner-tenant from the demised premises being Shop No.12, situated near Jat College, Het Ram Park, Hisar, on the ground that petitioner-tenant has not paid rent @ Rs.8,000/- per month, excluding house tax w.e.f. 01.03.2021 despite repeated requests, and the shop in question is required to be demolished by landlord for personal use and occupation for his only son for the purpose of constructing a big showroom adjacent to the showroom of brother of the petitioner, namely Amit Kumar, who is running the business of Electrical goods, Electronic goods, Mobiles, Mobile equipments, Accessories, computer goods etc., for the last many years. It was further averred in the rent petition that the landlord or his son (Tushar Singal) has not vacated any building after the commencement of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 as well as the Haryana Rent Act, without sufficient cause.

2.1

Upon notice of rent petition, the same was opposed by the petitioner-tenant by filing written statement. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that it was contended that the ejectment petition is frivolous and vexatious and has been filed to put pressure upon the tenant to increase the rent from Rs.8,000/- per month to Rs.20,000/- per month or vacate the shop. On merits, the grounds raised in para 3 of the rent petition were denied.

2.2

The issues were framed and the respondent-landlord led his evidence, which was closed in the affirmative, by suffering separate statement, on 08.09.2025. Thereafter, petitioner-tenant was granted opportunity to lead his evidence, which stands closed by the Court, vide impugned order dated 25.09.2026.

2.3

Aggrieved by aforesaid, petitioner-tenant has assailed the impugned order dated 25.09.2026 by way of present petition.

3.

Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that learned Rent Controller has acted with material irregularity while curtailing the opportunity of the petitioner-tenant to lead his evidence. It is further submitted that instead of enforcing the attendance of the summoned witness, i.e. concerned Clerk from the Municipal Corporation along with relevant record, learned Rent Controller observed that the respondent-landlord, who was present in the Court, has admitted his ownership/occupation of the portion of the properties shown in the Naksha (site plan) produced by the tenant, therefore, summoning of the witnesses from Municipal Corporation will amount to a roving enquiry. Observing as aforesaid, evidence on behalf of the petitioner-tenant has been erroneously closed by order of the Court. The same is not sustainable in law. It is further contended that the Rent Controller had no authority to close the evidence of the petitioner-tenant as such. Such a procedure is not contemplated under Order XVIII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, ‘the CPC’). It is still further contended that the petitioner-tenant has not been granted adequate and equal number of opportunities to adduce his evidence, as were granted to the respondent-landlord. It is, thus, contended that the cost imposed vide order dated 05.08.2026 for affording further opportunity to lead evidence at own responsibility was not warranted and is unfair. During the course of hearing, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has produced a compilation of the interlocutory orders passed by learned Rent Controller in the rent petition since 15.02.2023.

4.

I have heard learned senior counsel for the petitioner and with his able assistance perused the record.

5.

Admittedly, the respondent-landlord closed his evidence in affirmative by suffering a statement, as recorded in order dated 08.09.2025. The matter was thereafter adjourned to 19.11.2025 for evidence of the petitioner-tenant, at own responsibility. Learned senior counsel has produced a copy of application dated 24.03.2026 moved by the petitioner-tenant for summoning of witnesses. The said application is shown to have been allowed on the same day and the requisite process fee and diet money, as assessed by the Rent Controller, is shown to have been deposited on 25.03.2026. Three witnesses sought to be summoned are detailed therein. The witness in question, who finds mention and has been discussed in the impugned order, has been described in the application for summoning of witnesses, is as under:-

(iii)

Concerned Clerk of house tax branch Municipal corporation, Hisar along with Municipal House Tax assessment register from the year 2000 till date in respect of the property owned by shri Rattan Kumar s/o Shri Anjani Kumar and after his death owned by his son Sh. Sanjay Kumar.”

6.

It has been recorded in the impugned order that the summoned witness was duly served and has asked for being provided the property ID details to bring the house tax report before the Court. Thereafter, learned Rent Controller has proceeded to examine the evidentiary value of the evidence sought to be brought on record by the respondent-tenant in the rent petition, by putting question to the landlord and the tenant, who are recorded to be present in Court. Further, relying upon the response of the landlord, it has been recorded in the impugned order that the landlord has admitted his ownership/occupation in the portion of the property shown in the Naksha produced by the tenant qua which the witness was summoned from the Municipal Corporation. The aforesaid procedure is unknown to law and cannot be sustained for the reasons recorded hereinafter.

7.

It is trite that the Court is not required to examine the evidentiary value of the evidence at the stage of summoning witnesses or at the time of recording evidence. The said exercise is required to be done at the stage of final arguments and immediately preceding delivery of judgment in the matter. Even in cases, wherein an objection is raised regarding admissibility of any material at the stage of recording evidence, it was laid down in Bipin Shantilal Panchal vs. State of Gujarat and another, (2001) 2 SCC 1, that the course to be followed by the Court is to make notice of such objection and decide at the last stage of the final judgment. The said procedure has to be followed except where the objection relates to deficiency of stamp duty of a document. The reason given by their Lordships of the Apex Court, reads as under:-

“12.

As pointed out earlier, on different occasions the trial judge has chosen to decide questions of admissibility of documents or other items of evidence, as and when objections thereto were raised and then detailed orders were passed either upholding or overruling such objections. The worse part is that after passing the orders the trial court waited for days and weeks for the concerned parties to go before the higher courts for the purpose of challenging such interlocutory orders.

13.

It is an archaic practice that during the evidence collecting stage, whenever any objection is raised regarding admissibility of any material in evidence the court does not proceed further without passing order on such objection. But the fall out of the above practice is this: Suppose the trial court, in a case, upholds a particular objection and excludes the material from being admitted in evidence and then proceeds with the trial and disposes of the case finally. If the appellate or revisional court, when the same question is re-canvassed, could take a different view on the admissibility of that material in such cases the appellate court would be deprived of the benefit of that evidence, because that was not put on record by the trial court. In such a situation the higher court may have to send the case back to the trial court for recording that evidence and then to dispose of the case afresh. Why should the trial prolong like that unnecessarily on account of practices created by ourselves. Such practices, when realised through the course of long period to be hindrances which impede steady and swift progress of trial proceedings, must be recast or re-moulded to give way for better substitutes which would help acceleration of trial proceedings.

14.

When so recast, the practice which can be a better substitute is this: Whenever an objection is raised during evidence taking stage regarding the admissibility of any material or item of oral evidence the trial court can make a note of such objection and mark the objected document tentatively as an exhibit in the case (or record the objected part of the oral evidence) subject to such objections to be decided at the last stage in the final judgment. If the court finds at the final stage that the objection so raised is sustainable the judge or magistrate can keep such evidence excluded from consideration. In our view there is no illegality in adopting such a course. (However, we make it clear that if the objection relates to deficiency of stamp duty of a document the court has to decide the objection before proceeding further. For all other objections the procedure suggested above can be followed.)

15.

The above procedure, if followed, will have two advantages. First is that the time in the trial court, during evidence taking stage, would not be wasted on account of raising such objections and the court can continue to examine the witnesses. The witnesses need not wait for long hours, if not days. Second is that the superior court, when the same objection is re-canvassed and reconsidered in appeal or revision against the final judgment of the trial court, can determine the correctness of the view taken by the trial court regarding that objection, without bothering to remit the case to the trial court again for fresh disposal. We may also point out that this measure would not cause any prejudice to the parties to the litigation and would not add to their misery or expenses.

16.

We, therefore, make the above as a procedure to be followed by the trial courts whenever an objection is raised regarding the admissibility of any material or any item of oral evidence.”

8.

It is also noteworthy that the alleged admission of ownership and occupation by the landlord in Court, is a statement by a party which has not been suffered under oath and thus, the same cannot be read into evidence. Therefore, closing the right of a party to summon witness in support of its claim in the absence of any legal or justifiable ground, would result in shutting out evidence on the basis of an alleged admission, which cannot be read into evidence. Such a procedure is not sustainable in law. Moreover, it was not open for the Rent Controller to examine the aforesaid aspect at the stage of summoning of witnesses.

9.

Considering the primary argument raised by learned senior counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner-tenant has not been granted equal opportunities to lead his evidence, is being examined on the basis of the interlocutory orders produced during the course of hearing.

10.

A perusal thereof would show that the first opportunity to lead evidence was provided to the respondent-landlord for 15.03.2023 and upto closing of his evidence on 08.09.2025, as many as 16 hearings have taken place, and out of said hearings, two hearings have been such, which were not before the regular Court, having been recorded to be on casual/child care leave. Moreover, on more than three occasions, the matter was adjourned at the request of petitioner-tenant to cross-examine the landlord or his witnesses. It is also borne out from the record that two hearings were also consumed to explore the possibility of a mutual settlement between the parties, which did not fructify. Thus, out of 16 opportunities granted to the respondent herein, only 10 opportunities can be considered to be effective opportunities.

11.

The interlocutory orders, when considered in the aforesaid perspective, make it evident that an equal number of opportunities have been afforded to the petitioner-tenant as well. The petitioner-tenant is shown to have availed at least six last opportunities and one of which was subject to payment of cost. It has not been shown from the record as to the total number of witnesses that petitioner-tenant intended to produce to prove his case. The remaining tenant’s witnesses, if any, have also not been disclosed in the revision petition or during the course of hearing before this Court. However, a perusal of the application for summoning of witnesses moved by the petitioner-tenant, shows them to be three only. From the said cited witnesses, petitioner-tenant has asserted to examine the witness mentioned at Sr. No.iii in the said application. The said witness having been summoned through the process of Court, ought to have been examined by ensuring his presence.

12.

The last argument raised on behalf of the petitioner-tenant that evidence could not have been closed under Order XVIII CPC, also does not find favour with this Court. It is settled law that procedure contained in CPC is not strictly applicable to the proceedings under the rent legislation, which prescribes its own procedure, though the principles of CPC are broadly applicable, but not strictly. Even otherwise, it is the inherent jurisdiction of the Courts/Tribunals/persona designata to grant sufficient opportunity to both the sides to lead their evidence and make submissions in support of their case. It cannot be left open to the whims and fancies of any party to avail endless opportunities to lead evidence. Hence, the argument raised cannot be accepted.

13.

In the case at hand, it is noteworthy that the petitioner-tenant had sought assistance of the Court to summon three witnesses only and despite having availed nine opportunities, has not brought any other witness before the Rent Controller, to be examined.

14.

As a consequence of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered opinion that the impugned order dated 25.09.2026 cannot be sustained in law and is, accordingly, set aside. Resultantly, upon furnishing of property details/property IDs, the petitioner-tenant may seek assistance of the Court to summon the concerned Clerk of house tax branch, Municipal Corporation, Hisar, along with the summoned record, as noticed hereinbefore and for the said purpose, one effective opportunity is to be afforded to the petitioner. It is made clear that as the matter is being deferred for the aforesaid purpose, the petitioner-tenant may also examine other remaining witness(es), as permissible in law, at his own responsibility. However, any further or separate opportunity would not be granted for the said purpose.

15.

As the present revision petition is being disposed of in the absence of the respondent-landlord, liberty is granted to him to seek recall of this order, if valid grounds for the same are made out.

16.

The revision petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.

17.

Pending applications, if any, shall stand closed.