AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER SHRI M BALAGANESH, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER:
The appeal in ITA No.6711/Del/2025 for AY 2012-13, arises out of the order of the Id National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi [hereinafter referred to as 'Id. CIT(A)', in short] dated 06.10.2025 against the order of assessment passed u/s 147 r.w.s. 144 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') dated 26.12.2019 by the Assessing Officer, ITO, Ward-36(5), Delhi (hereinafter referred to as 'Id. AO').
At the outset, the revenue preferred an adjournment in this matter on the ground that report is awaited from the learned AO. But we find that assessee had challenged the validity of assumption of jurisdiction under section 147 of the Act. The entire details relevant for its adjudication are already placed on the paper book and hence the revenue’s adjournment is rejected and the case is taken up for hearing.
The preliminary issue to be decided in this appeal is as to whether the learned AO had validly assumed jurisdiction to reopen the case for the year under consideration in the facts and circumstances of the instant case. This goes to the root of the matter and hence we proceed to take the same first for adjudication.
We have heard the rival submissions and perused the materials available on record. The assessee filed his return of income for the assessment year 2012-13 on 25-09-2012 declaring total income of Rs 12,01,406. The original assessment was completed under section 143(3) of the Act dated 18-03-2015 determining the total income of the assessee at Rs 13,14,930.
The case of the assessee was sought to be reopened by the Learned AO vide issuance of notice under section 148 of the Act dated 31-03-2019. The reasons recorded for reopening the assessment are enclosed in pages 16 to 19 of the paper book. For the sake of convenience, the reasons recorded for reopening the assessment are reproduced below:-
Name of the Assessee Sh. Ramesh Kumar Bansal Prop. Arushi Exports,
Address the of Assessee A-29, 1st Floor, Group Indl. Area, Wazirpur-Delhi-110052
PAN ADJPB9470H
Assessment Year 2012-13
Details of the Assessing Officer having Income Tax Officer, Ward 36(2), jurisdiction over the Assessee New Delhi
Reasons for reopening of assessment in the case of Ramesh Kumar Bansal Prop. Arushi Exports, A.Y. 2012-13 u/s 147 of Income Tax Act, 1961
In this case, the assessee has filed return of income for the year under consideration declaring income of Rs. 12,01,406/- on 25.09.2012.
In this case, an information has been disseminated from the O/o the Investigation Wing, Delhi vide letter No. 6845 dated 19.03.2019 mentioning that there were transfer receipts of funds to multiple accounts within branch, amount of cash remittances value of which is just below threshold limit of Rs. 10 Lac in an apparent attempt to avoid reporting firm doing business in the same address with common signatory with different line of activity and transfer of funds to accounts with other banks are all suspicious in nature AML. Reported bank account statement alongwith KYC details were obtained. Also summons were issued to proprietor seeking relevant details. Summons were issued and sent to the address of the assessee given in the information at F-5/55, Sector 15, Rohini, Delhi and remain undelivered. Further address was found from the database query and summons were sent to all these addresses as per details below:-
Principal officer Address as per PAN Postal remarks 1. Ajay Shrivastava F-5/55, Sector 15, Rohini, Delhi Left and other no such person Ajay Shrivastava S/o Sh. Dilip Shrivastava House no. 61-62, Sector-22, Rohini, Delhi No such person Thus the absence of any entity, absence of any proprietor, no response to summons and financials of the entity prove that the entity is merely a paper entity and was used to provide accommodation entry. On the basis of the analysis bank account; it was found that many other bank accounts in the name of Sh. Ajay Shrivastava were opened in the name of various entries and all these were used for providing the accommodation entries, The list of the bank account details is given below:-
Bank name Bank address Account no. Proprietor Debit credit Oriental Bank of Commerce Sector 3, Rohini, Delhi 52082191006415 Ajay Shrivastava 187863 188664 Oriental Bank of Sector 3, Rohini, 52081131000919 Ajay Shrivastava 302574433 329118371 Commerce Delhi Oriental Bank of Commerce Sector 3, Rohini, Delhi 52081131000353 Ajay Shrivastava 89985536 89985346 Dhanlakshmi Plot No. 04, Ground floor, Sector-8, Rohini, Delhi 19406200001019 Ajay Shrivastava 70565679 70999112 Dhanlakshmi Plot No. 04, Ground floor, Sector-8, Rohini, Delhi 19406700000101 Ajay Shrivastava 143187078 143187078 Dhanlakshmi Plot No. 04, Ground floor, Sector-8, Rohini, Delhi 19406700000156 Ajay Shrivastava 183501160 156360995 Dhanlakshmi Plot No. 04, Ground floor, Sector-8, Rohini, Delhi 19406700000414 Ajay Shrivastava 15070281 164886 Dhanlakshmi Plot No. 04, Ground floor, Sector-8, Rohini, Delhi 19406700000113 Ajay Shrivastava 21977731 21987976 Dhanlakshmi Plot No. 04, Ground floor, Sector-8, 19406200002102 Ajay Shrivastava 50542123 78144979 Rohini, Delhi
On analysis of these bank accounts, the parties from whom funds were received by operators were identified. Also the ITR profile of these entities were examined. These have been termed as credit beneficiaries. Further entities were found who have received substantial funds from these accounts. The ITR profile of these entities were examined. These have been termed as debit beneficiaries. Among them one of the entities was M/s Arushi Exports which has received fund from as well as transfer funds to these operators entities. The details of the transaction found with the above mentioned operator entities during F.Y. 2011-12 is as follows:-
Operator entities Received from Operator entities Transfer to operator entity Krishna sales Corporation 10,34,05,918/- - North Delhi developer - 31,00,00/- North Delhi developer - 1,49,61,000/- Prem trading company 1,47,61,000/- - TOTAL 11,81,66,918/- 1,80,61,000/- Since the identity and creditworthiness of all operators entities has not established. The fund received and transfer out by M/s Arushi Exports remained unexplained and could be bogus purchases/investment to the tune of Rs. 13,62,27,918/-.
2 In view of the information that the assessee has entered into the bogus purchases/investment and the assessee's case is clearly covered by the clause (b) of Explanation 2 of Section 147 of the I.T. Act, 1961. Hence, it is a case where it shall be deemed to the case where income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment.
3.In this case the assessee has made bogus purchases/investment to the tune of Rs. 13,62,27,918/- and assessee has filed return of income for the year under consideration declaring income of Rs. 12,01,406/- on 25.09.2012 and the bogus purchases/investment to the tune of Rs. 13,62,27,918/- remained unexplained, therefore, the only requirement to initiate proceedings u/s 147 is reason to believe which has been recorded above.
4.Consequently, considering the facts of the case, I am satisfied and have reasons to believe that the income of Rs. 13,62,27,918/- chargeable to tax has escaped assessment for which notice u/s 148 is required to be issued within the meaning of the section 147 of the I.T. Act, 1961 in the case of the above mentioned assessee for A.Y. 2012-13.
5.It is pertinent to mention here that in this case the assessee has concealed income for the year under assessment although the total income of the assessee had exceeded the maximum amount which is not chargeable to tax as discussed in paragraph 4 above and the assessee was assessable under the Act. In view of the above, provisions of clause (b) of Explanation 2 to section 147 are applicable to the facts of this case and the assessment year under consideration is deemed to be a case where income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment.
In this case, more than 4 years have elapsed from the end of assessment year under consideration. Hence necessary sanction to issue the notice u/s 148 is solicited from the Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi-12, New Delhi as per the provisions of section 151 of the Act.
Encl: Case record
(Kulvir Singh)
(Income Tax Officer)
Ward 36(2), New Delhi”
From the perusal of the aforesaid reasons, it could be seen that the Learned AO had sought to reopen the assessment of the assessee beyond 4 years from the end of the relevant assessment year and since the original assessment was completed under section 143(3) of the Act, there is a mandatory requirement (as per first proviso to section 147 of the Act) on the part of the Learned AO to mention the failure committed by the assessee by not making full and true disclosure of all material facts relevant for the purpose of assessment in the original assessment proceedings. This aspect is conspicuously absent in the reasons recorded by the Learned AO. Further, the Learned AR also placed on record the proforma for seeking approval in terms of section 151 of the Act from the competent authority in pages 14 to 15 of the paper book which were admittedly obtained by the assessee under Right to Information Act 2005. On perusal of the said proforma for seeking approval under section 151 of the Act from the competent authority, it is noted that the Learned PCIT, being the competent authority, had neither signed the approval nor mentioned the date of sanctioning approval, if any. Hence, this is a clear case of undated and unsigned approval granted by the Learned PCIT under section 151 of the Act which vitiates the entire assumption of jurisdiction for reopening the assessment. Hence, the reassessment is hereby quashed for more than one reason.
Since the reassessment is quashed on the legal issue, the adjudication of other factual grounds raised by the assessee become academic in nature and they are left open.
In the result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed.
