AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
(PER: SHIVKUMAR DIGE, J.)
This appeal is directed against the judgment and order passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Gadchiroli, whereby the appellant has been convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, “IPC”) and sentenced to suffer imprisonment for life and to pay fine of Rs.15,000/-, in default, to suffer rigorous imprisonment for six months.
It is the prosecution’s case that on 25.07.2019, at around 08:00 to 08:30 am, Kiran Atram (P.W. 7), daughter of deceased, was cooking food at her house. Her father, Zuru Atram (deceased) informed her that he was going to the shop of “Bangali” and left the house, after half an hour. Sudha Bishwas (P.W. 5), wife of the shop owner - Naresh Bishwas, called P.W. 7 and told that the appellant killed her father by assaulting him with an axe and ran away. On hearing news, she rushed to the place of the incident and found her father sitting on a chair with his neck tilted to one side. His neck was bleeding and his clothes were soaked in blood. He was motionless. 15 to 20 other people were gathered at the incident spot. P.W. 7 called her cousin Roshan and asked him to call the police. They arrived at the incident spot and Zuru was shifted to Rural Hospital, Bhamragad, where he was declared dead. P.W. 7 Kiran lodged report against the appellant at Bhamragad Police Station.
During investigation, the appellant was arrested. The axe used in the crime was recovered at his instance. After completion of investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the appellant. Upon appreciating the oral and documentary evidence on record, the learned Sessions Judge has convicted the appellant as stated above.
It is contention of learned counsel for the appellant that the appellant has been falsely implicated in this case. No one witnessed the incident. As per deposition of P.W. 5 – Sudha Bishwas, she was inside her house when the incident occurred. Therefore, she could not have seen the appellant murdering the deceased with an axe. She further deposed that Naxalites had killed people during strike week and it had created fear among the villagers. She also stated that due to this reason, her shop remains closed during the said week.
As per the deposition of P.W. 4 – Danu Atram, who was present at the incident spot at the time of offence, the appellant dealt another blow with an axe on the neck of the deceased. However, the post-mortem report at Exh.-34 indicates that deceased had sustained only one injury on the back of his neck, which contradicts the evidence of this witness. This witness further stated that village Tadgaon is a naxal affected area and naxalites had killed people around or outside the village and indulge in violent activities. Learned counsel further submitted that the deceased may have been killed as a result of naxal activities during the ongoing naxal saptah (week). The prosecution has failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt, but these facts are not considered by the learned Sessions Judge, and requested to allow the appeal.
Per contra, it is contention of learned APP that there is direct evidence that the appellant murdered the deceased on the ground of suspicion that deceased had illicit relations with his wife. There are eyewitnesses to the incident namely Danu Atram (P.W. 4) and Sudha Bishwas (P.W. 5), in whose presence, the appellant murdered the deceased. The axe used in the crime was recovered at the instance of the appellant in presence of panchas. The death of deceased was homicidal. There is no reason for the prosecution witnesses to falsely implicate the appellant. The prosecution has proved the case beyond reasonable doubt. The learned Sessions Judge has passed a well-reasoned order, no interference is warranted, and requested to dismiss the appeal.
Heard rival submissions. Perused impugned judgment and order and evidence produced on record.
To prove its case, the prosecution has examined nine witnesses in all. As per the prosecution’s case, Danu Atram (P.W. 4) and Sudha Bishwas (P.W. 5) were present at the incident spot at the time of offence and were eyewitnesses to the said incident. P.W. 4 – Danu Atram, who was Sarpanch of the village Tadgaon from 2005-2010 stated that Zuru Atram (deceased) was a teacher at Zilla Parishad School in Tadgaon. The appellant suspected that the deceased was having illicit relations with his wife and a village meeting was held to make him understand that the deceased was not of such a nature and he should not suspect the deceased, but it had no effect on the appellant. This witness further stated that he was present at the incident spot along with the deceased on the day of the incident. On hearing some noise, he turned around and saw the deceased bleeding from his neck and the appellant standing behind him holding an axe. Subsequently, the appellant gave another blow with an axe on the neck of the deceased and ran away.
P.W. 5 – Sudha Bishwas in her deposition stated that she was inside her shop at the time of incident and saw the deceased trembling. She saw the appellant giving a blow of axe on the neck of the deceased. Thereafter, she immediately called the daughter of the deceased to inform her about the incident. It was sought to be brought on record that deceased may have been killed by the Naxalites, but this defence is manifestly absurd as P.W.4 and P.W.5, who are independent witnesses categorically stated that appellant assaulted the deceased. From evidence of P.W. 4, it proves that motive behind the assault was that the appellant suspected the deceased of having illicit relations with his wife. Homicidal death of the deceased is not disputed by the defence.
P.W. 8 – Mangesh Gawade (Medical Officer) who performed an autopsy on the dead body of the deceased has stated that cause of death was sudden neurogenic shock due to deep, incised, penetrating grievous wound/injury. The appellant produced the axe used in the crime and clothes worn at the time of incident in presence of panch witness, P.W. 3 - Umesh Madavi. The panchanama is at Exhibit 24 and Articles are at B, C, and D.
Chemical Analysis Report (Exh.10) indicates that human blood was found on the blade of axe as well as clothes of appellant.
P.W. 7 - Kiran Atram is the first informant and daughter of the deceased. She has stated that after coming to know about the incident, she reached the spot and lodged the report (Exh.30) against the appellant. During cross-examination, she admitted that meetings were held once or twice regarding the quarrel between the family of appellant and her family. She admitted that she had not witnessed the incident personally. The FIR is at Exhibit 31.
P.W. 6 - Tejaswini Bishwas has stated that on the day of incident, she saw the appellant riding a bicycle at a high speed. Upon her return, she saw the dead body of the deceased at some distance.
P.W. 1 - Nilkantha Nimsarkar acted as a panch witness to the inquest panchanama (Exhibit 18) and the panchanama of seizure of clothes on the dead body (Exhibit 19). P.W. 2 - Rajanand Meshram is a panch witness to the spot panchanama, which is at Exhibit 21.
The evidence produced on record clearly establishes that the appellant murdered the deceased by inflicting axe blows on the back of his neck resulting in his death. The appellant had a motive to kill the deceased, as he suspected that the deceased had ilicit relations with his wife. The prosecution has proved the case beyond reasonable doubt. The learned Sessions Judge has passed a well-reasoned order. No interference is required in it. Hence, we pass the following order:-
The appeal is dismissed.
Fees of the appointed counsel be quantified as per rules.
