AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
J.C. Mishra, J.—This application u/s 482, Cr. P.C. has been filed for quashing the charge-sheet submitted in Case No. 1286 of 1987, pending in the Court of A.C.J.M. IV, Faizabad (Case Crime No. 504 of 1996 under Sections 379/406/408/420, I.P.C., P.S. Tarun, district Faizabad).
The prosecution case as disclosed in the first information report lodged by Mitrasen Yadav, Manager, Kisan Uchchatar Madhyamik Vidyalaya, Bankata, Faizabad, on 31.12.1996, is that while inspecting the school along with Gyanendra Prasad Yadunandan and other teachers he found that the applicant-accused Ram Pratap Yadav was absent. On inquiry he was informed by other teachers that the accused frequently absented from the school and some time he did not attend the school for a month. The Manager then tried to inspect the office but he was informed that the accused has stealthily shifted the record to his house. On inspection he detected that by-laws, registration certificate, agenda register, scholar register, cash book and character roll register etc., pass book, cheque book and other documents were missing. He was informed that the accused appended his signatures in the attendance register at his house, without attending the school and made false entries in documents and registers.
The police registered a case. During investigation the Investigating Officer recorded the statements of Mitrasen Yadav, Manager, Subedar Yadav, lecturer, Ram Naresh Maurya, Vice-Principal, Tilakdhari, teacher in junior section, Hari Om, head clerk, Ram Bharat Yadav, head clerk, Gajraj Yadav, teacher, Gyanender Yadav and Yadunath Yadav. On the basis of the statements recorded during investigation the police submitted charge-sheet.
The accused has approached this Court for invoking the inherent powers to quash the charge-sheet and the criminal case.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant contended that no direct evidence was collected during the investigation to indicate that the accused committed any crime. Mitrasen Yadav who had inspected the institution and the office had no personal knowledge and had lodged the report on the information furnished by the police.
The teachers Subedar Yadav, Ram Naresh Maurya, Hari Om Yadav stated that the accused did not attend the school regularly and the Principal Ram Pratap Yadav kept most of the registers at his residence. They further stated that at the time of inspection by the Manager neither the Principal nor head clerk was available.
Tilakdhari Yadav is brother of Principal Ram Pratap Yadav. He stated that he came to meet his brother but was informed that he had gone to city with the Manager. Ram Bharat Yadav stated that he has not received any register in his charge. He stated that he has heard that the record of the school have been deposited in the office of District Inspector of Schools and are available with the clerk Latif. Lallo Yadav stated that he has not received his salary on account of some controversy regarding appointment of teachers and clerks. Yadunandan has stated that the Principal Ram Pratap kept registers at his residence and he issued fictitious certificates. He however, and Gyanendra Yadav used their knowledge on the information furnished by others. They had no personal knowledge about the facts stated.
A perusal of the statements, which have been filed, does not indicate that these witnesses had personal knowledge regarding the alleged theft. The learned A.G.A. could not show that the Principal was not entitled to the custody of the registers and other documents or he had committed theft of the said registers and documents. The allegations regarding forgery was based on hearsay evidence and is mere in the nature of opinion than of any direct evidence. None of the witnesses has indicated the documents, which were allegedly forged or in which forgeries were committed.
In the counter-affidavit as well no incriminating evidence has been disclosed. It has only been stated that in view of the evidence offence is made out.
After having gone through the records, statements of the witnesses and having considered the submission made by the learned Counsel for the applicant and learned A.G.A., I find that the evidence collected during investigation is insufficient to prove even prima facie that any offence is made out. In absence of any incriminating evidence to support the accusation the charge-sheet and criminal case are liable to be quashed.
The application is allowed. The proceeding in State v. Ram Pratap Yadav Criminal Case No. 1286 of 1997 pending in the Court of A.C.J.M., Faizabad, is quashed.
